Vanessa Richardson (35:24)
On September 12, 1943. David Bacon's up and coming career came to an end that day. The 29 year old crashed his car into a bean field and died after being stabbed in the back. Police assumed he'd been attacked by a passenger, but they didn't find a murder weapon in the car or any fingerprints. The only clue they did find was a small crew neck sweater and a mysterious key. But before continuing the investigation, they had to tell David's pregnant wife, Greta, what had happened that day. September 12th. Detectives went to David and Greta's house in the Hollywood Hills. Greta was devastated by the news. Despite her grief, she did everything she could to help the detectives with their investigation. When they showed her the key, she recognized it right away. Greta explained that David had rented a studio apartment a few weeks ago for their gardener. This was the key. She also gave the police David's diary, which they hoped might point them to a potential suspect. Later, Greta revealed the diary was full of information about David's personal life, including his sexual preferences. But at the time, there was a problem. He'd written the entire thing in some kind of code, and despite their best efforts, detectives couldn't crack it. As a closeted gay man, there were a lot of things David wanted to keep secret. And Greta wasn't about to out a dead man, so she didn't tell the police about his sexual orientation. Greta's loyalty was well intentioned and understandable, but it also hurt the investigation. Because police assumed David had been straight, they likely missed a whole slew of possible suspects, mainly the men he he'd had intimate relationships with. But that wasn't the only secret Greta was keeping for David. When police went over to the apartment that David had rented, they realized he and Greta didn't have a gardener at all. The apartment was located at 8481 Kirkwood Avenue in Laurel Canyon, about a mile away from Greta and David's house. It was owned by a local doctor named Charles Hendrix, and David had started renting it on August 31, a little less than two weeks before he was murdered. When police went inside, they found dirty dishes, coffee, canned spaghetti, and a few books. According to Dr. Hendricks, David told him he was renting the apartment for a friend who police initially assumed was a mistress. Hendrick said he saw the friend, who turned out to be a man man. When he came to collect rent on September 10, two days before David's murder. Hendricks said the man had a slight build, was foreign looking, and had a red face like he was angry. David didn't introduce the man. And the man didn't offer any information about himself either. Police circulated the man's description and issued statements to local newspapers asking him to get in touch. But nobody, nobody matching this description ever came forward. Looking back on the situation, it seems likely that David wasn't renting the apartment for someone else. He was renting it for himself as a discreet place to carry out his affairs. Maybe the man who Dr. Hendricks saw was one of David's partners. Maybe he was angry because they were having a fight. And maybe over the next two days, that quarrel escalated until he stabbed David in his car. Since the police didn't know about David's sexuality at the time, they didn't consider this possibility. But before long, detectives realized this mystery man wasn't their only suspect. While searching through one of David's notepads, police found the phone number for a 20 year old man named Glenn Irwin Shmiel. When police tracked Glenn down, he didn't match the description of the angry man seen with David at the apartment. But other things about Glenn made the police suspicious. For one, it looked like he could fit into the sweater found in David's car. Investigators had determined the sweater was a navy issue garment and Glenn was a Navy deserter. According to Glenn, David had put an ad in the paper looking for a garment gardener. The ad stated that the position came with an apartment. It seems like Glenn replied because in early September, David picked him up and drove him to the apartment to discuss the position. In his interview with the police, Glenn said David initially gave him the gardener job, then rescinded the offer days before his death. Based on that information, police wondered if Glenn was angry at David for withdrawing the job offer and killed him in revenge. Another possibility that police didn't consider was that Glenn was lying about the Gardner job to hide the fact that he was in a relationship with David that eventually went sour. In any case, Glenn had an alibi. According to his wife, she'd been with Glenn all day on September 12th. Several other witnesses confirmed this. Whatever the real nature of Glenn and David's relationship, he wasn't the killer. As the investigation dragged on, LA newspapers reported on every new twist and turn in the case. The mysterious killing of a handsome movie star was big news and lots of people wanted to be a part of the story. Nine days after the murder, a 22 year old man named Blakely Patterson told the Los Angeles examiner that he was one of David's his best friends and he knew who'd killed him. Blakely said that on the morning of the murder, David had called him in a panic. Apparently someone was blackmailing him, though Blakely didn't say about what. Then, later that day, David turned up dead. For police, this seemed like a real possibility. There was just one problem. None of it was true. When they interviewed Blakely, it became clear he'd never, never even met David. Under questioning, Blakeley admitted he'd made the whole thing up to get his name in the press. He was arrested and charged with filing a false report, and a judge ordered him to go back to his hometown in Minnesota. As the weeks dragged by without any major breaks, the media circus moved on. Every lead the police chased down led them to a dead end. And before long, the investigation into David Bacon's murder had gone cold. Decades later, we still don't know the truth. Today, the case remains open, but as of 2019, the LAPD officially had no comment on the investigation. While the whole town of Hollywood was wrapped up in what happened, the person who suffered the most was his wife, Greta Keller. Although their marriage was one of convenience, they still cared for each other deeply. Just two weeks after he died, Greta went into labor prematurely and delivered a stillborn baby. She never remarried. Despite the tragic loss of her husband and their child, Greta went on to have a long career as a cabaret singer in both the US and Europe until her death in 1977. As they say, the show must go on. The Masked Marvel made its big screen debut on November 6, 1943, less than two months after the unsolved murder of its leading man. The series was a hit at the box office and critics called it one of Republic Pictures best serials. Unfortunately, David Bacon was wasn't able to enjoy the success of his big debut as a leading man. Today, his film career is just a footnote in the mystery of who stabbed him in the back on that hot Sunday in September. Looking back at this week in crime history, we can see that time is the real villain. The people who killed Roger Atkinson, Rose Burkert and D. David Bacon were not criminal masterminds who pulled off the perfect crime. They were just lucky enough to escape. Evidence is fragile and memories are fleeting as weeks turned into months and months turned to years. The trail went cold and these killers went free. Foreign thanks so much for listening. I'm Vanessa Richardson and this is True Crime. This week part of Crime House Daily. Crime House Daily is a Crime House original. Powered by Pave Studios At Crime House, we want to express our gratitude to you, our community, for making this possible. Please, please support us by rating, reviewing and following us on Crime House Daily. Wherever you get your podcasts, your feedback truly matters. And for ad free and early access to Crime House Daily plus exciting bonus content, subscribe to Crime House plus on Apple Podcasts. We'll be back tomorrow. True Crime this Week is hosted by me, Vanessa Richardson and is a Crime House original. Powered by Pave Studios, this episode was brought to life by the True Crime this Week Team Max Cutler, Ron Shapiro, Alex Benedon, Natalie Pertovsky, Lori Marinelli, Sarah Camp, Truman Capps, Sarah Tardif, and Michael Langsner. Thank you for listening.