Summary: "Crime Junkie" Episode - MISSING: Brian Worley from Atlanta

Introduction

In this compelling episode of Crime Junkie, hosts Ashley Flowers and Brit Prawat explore the unsettling disappearance of Brian Worley from Atlanta, Georgia. Released on November 28, 2024, the episode meticulously unpacks the timeline of Brian's vanishing, highlights critical investigative oversights, and delves into the relentless efforts of his family to uncover the truth.

Background of the Disappearance

On the morning of September 24, 2009, Brian Worley, a 39-year-old man from Atlanta, failed to appear for a scheduled probate court hearing in Carrollton, Georgia. Brian was in town to handle essential legal matters for his mother, who suffers from Alzheimer's and neurocognitive disorder. His sister, Anita Gay, received a troubling call from a courthouse friend informing her that Brian did not show up for court as expected.

"It's like probate court and he was only supposed to be there to just turn in some receipts and sign a document." — Ashley Flowers [02:46]

Despite the urgency, Brian had recently endured a challenging four-hour drive through severe flooding to attend the court hearing, underscoring his commitment to his responsibilities.

Initial Investigation and Red Flags

Anita’s immediate concern led her to contact Brian’s close associates, including his partner Jeff and niece Amanda. Amanda recounted Brian's last conversation, where he mentioned meeting "interesting people" and considering alternative routes due to the flooded roads.

"He had just finished up some yard work at his parents' house... he might try to get his hands on a topographic map." — Amanda [05:15]

Upon searching Brian’s family home, Anita discovered unsettling signs: Brian’s bed was only partially made, his essential belongings—including medications—were left untouched, and his wallet was missing.

"There's no way that this dude is leaving with all of his medications left behind unless he planned to come back." — Ashley Flowers [09:37]

These observations raised immediate suspicions about the nature of his disappearance.

Flaws in the Police Investigation

When Jeff contacted the Carrollton Police Department, he was initially told to wait 72 hours before filing a missing person report—a standard procedure that felt inadequate given Brian’s medical conditions.

"Law enforcement agencies are not required to wait to take a missing person's report, even if that person is an adult. Totally file that report." — Brit Prawat [10:32]

Eventually, a report was filed, but numerous inconsistencies plagued the investigation. Police records were incomplete, with many entries lacking dates or times, and Brian's information was not promptly entered into state and national databases.

"There’s so much stuff that just was never documented by the original investigators." — Ashley Flowers [06:38]

Additionally, Detective Tony Johnson initially misclassified Jeff as Brian’s roommate, hinting at unfounded personal issues between them.

"We have zero interest in pursuing charges for car theft. We just want to follow that trail back to Brian." — Ashley Flowers [35:56]

Key Investigative Developments

1. Discovery of Brian's Car in Tennessee: In December 2009, Brian’s car was found in Chattanooga, Tennessee, with the license plate removed. A witness described seeing a young black man driving the car, leading to dead ends due to lack of matching descriptions.

   "The Tennessee tag that the cop just ran doesn't match the car that the plate is on now." — Ashley Flowers [32:59]

2. Canine and Psychic Searches: In 2015, Sergeant Meredith Browning collaborated with a psychic and canine specialist to search Brian’s family property. Dogs signaled the boathouse area, but no human remains were found, leading to expanded searches on the now-drained lake.

   "Her dogs are trained to smell human remains. So you could be talking blood, tissue, cadaver fluids, bones, teeth." — Ashley Flowers [44:51]

3. License Plate Alert Oversight: In July 2018, it was discovered that Brian’s license plate had been flagged in Coweta County weeks after his disappearance, but this information was not properly communicated to Carrollton authorities.

   "Brian's license plate was on a vehicle in Coweta County, 45 minutes away from Carrollton." — Ashley Flowers [47:57]

Possible Bias and Missed Leads

Friends and family speculated that Brian's sexual orientation might have impacted the seriousness with which his case was initially handled. Robert, a friend, suggested potential homophobia within the Carrollton Police could have influenced the investigation's delays.

"Brian never made any bones about the fact that he was gay. My impression was that rubbed a lot of people wrong, and it may even have rubbed the police force in Carrollton wrong." — Robert [39:58]

Despite claims from investigators that there was no malicious intent, the mishandling of evidence and delayed responses fueled distrust among Brian’s loved ones.

Family's Ongoing Efforts and Advocacy

Brian's partner, Jeff, continued to seek answers vigorously until his untimely death from a heart attack in 2017. The family has remained active, utilizing social media, flyers, and a GoFundMe campaign to fund billboards aimed at generating new leads.

"The lack of answers is just the worst part." — Brit Prawat [50:10]

The podcast encourages listeners to support the family by sharing information and contributing to their advocacy efforts.

Current Status and Conclusion

As of the latest updates, Brian’s case remains unresolved. Despite extensive efforts, including revisiting old leads and exploring new theories, there has been no substantial progress. Detective Johnson continues to express hope that answers lie in the Chattanooga findings, while the family's perseverance highlights the enduring pain of unresolved disappearances.

"Detective Johnson thinks there are answers in Chattanooga because someone there knows something about the Buick." — Ashley Flowers [37:13]

Notable Quotes

• "There's so much stuff that just was never documented by the original investigators." — Ashley Flowers [06:38]
• "There's no way that this dude is leaving with all of his medications left behind unless he planned to come back." — Ashley Flowers [09:37]
• "Brian never made any bones about the fact that he was gay. My impression was that rubbed a lot of people wrong, and it may even have rubbed the police force in Carrollton wrong." — Robert [39:58]
• "Detective Johnson thinks there are answers in Chattanooga because someone there knows something about the Buick." — Ashley Flowers [37:13]

Call to Action

The episode concludes with a heartfelt plea for listeners to assist in locating Brian by reaching out to the Carrollton Police Department with any relevant information.

"If you have any information about Brian's disappearance or the car or anything related to the case, contact the Carrollton Police Department at 770-834-4451." — Ashley Flowers [53:26]

Additionally, the podcast provides resources and links for those who may need guidance on handling similar missing person situations, emphasizing community support and active participation in seeking justice.

Final Thoughts

This episode of Crime Junkie not only sheds light on the tragic case of Brian Worley but also underscores broader issues within law enforcement investigations. It serves as a poignant reminder of the enduring impact of unresolved disappearances on families and communities, advocating for greater diligence and sensitivity in handling such cases.