wavePod

Get Wave AI

MISSING: The Thompson Family - Crime Junkie | Wave AI Podcast Notes

Back to Crime Junkie

MISSING: The Thompson Family

Crime Junkie

Thu Oct 30 2025

Summary

Crime Junkie: MISSING — The Thompson Family

Host: Ashley Flowers (with Britt Prawat)
Date: October 30, 2025
Episode Theme:
A multi-generational Black family vanishes in Chicago, 1996. The episode investigates the systemic failures, missed opportunities, and the chilling evidence all pointing to one main suspect: Lydia Thompson’s brother, Kenneth, recently released from prison. Through interviews and court records, Ashley and Britt piece together how neglect and bias allowed a probable family annihilation to go unresolved, with the case closing only after the key suspect’s suicide.

1. Overview

The episode unpacks the 1996 disappearance of Everett and Lydia Thompson and their two sons, Everett Jr. (11) and Andrew (8). It highlights the obstacles their family faced—skepticism, delayed police action, and institutional indifference—especially as a family of color. Ashley and Britt reconstruct the timeline, zeroing in on Lydia’s brother, Kenneth, as details and damning evidence emerge.

2. Key Discussion Points & Insights

Timeline of Disappearance & Police Response

July 5, 1996:
- Everett Thompson calls his father, interrupted by Lydia who locks herself and the kids in a closet, fearing Kenneth, her brother, who’s threatening them with an axe. Everett hangs up to rush home. [03:46]
- “...Lydia has locked herself and their two boys in the closet because her brother is there at their house, threatening them with an axe..." — Ashley [03:37]
Next Day:
- No contact from the family; Everett’s father, Herman, tries to report them missing, but the Chicago PD won’t take an out-of-state report. [05:14]
- Instead, a welfare check is done, but police only speak to Kenneth, who claims the family left for Philadelphia. [05:55]
Over a week later:
- With no word, the family drives from Philly to Chicago, confirms with Everett’s manager he hasn’t been seen since July 5, finds the Thompson home eerily empty. [07:54]
- The house is void of all furniture, only leaving garbage bags with clothes. Kenneth is also gone. [08:22]
Delayed Investigation:
- It takes weeks before the missing persons report is accepted; significant police follow-up is absent, reflecting a pattern of neglect in missing Black families. [10:29]
- Chicago's Black community is overrepresented in missing persons statistics but routinely underserved by authorities. [11:00]

Suspicions around Kenneth

Inconsistent Stories:
- Kenneth first tells police the family drove to Philadelphia; later, he claims to have dropped Everett at a bus station. [09:49]
Neighbors’ Observations:
- Witness sees someone not recognizable as Thompson family removing a rolled-up carpet to the van, prompting suspicion. [09:09]
Van and Home Sale Moves:
- Kenneth is seen with Everett’s van hours after the last sighting of Everett, despite Everett telling his manager:
  - “If you ever see Kenny driving my car, you’ll know that I’m dead.” — Recalls Everett’s warning [14:13]
- Kenneth obtains dubious power of attorney and proceeds to sell the Thompson house and van, depositing Lydia’s share himself with a forged signature. [21:11]
Home’s Forensic Compromise:
- When police finally search the house, extensive renovations have occurred — floors are ripped out, a bathroom is painted red, erasing potential evidence. [23:18]

Missed Red Flags & Systemic Issues

Prior Violence:
- Just two days prior, Lydia had called police reporting Kenneth threatened her with an axe; the police response was cursory and insufficient. [13:33]
Family Animosity and Motive:
- Kenneth felt cheated out of inheritance by Lydia, threatened to kill her in letters per the family, expressing long-standing rage. [18:47]
Obstruction & Evasion:
- Kenneth leaves town, sells the family’s assets, and starts a pattern of wild, conflicting stories about their disappearance:
  - “He told a random cashier… his sister and her family moved to Hawaii… Everett took Lydia and the children to escape the IRS or drug debts…” [25:20]

The Breakthrough (Too Late)

Physical Evidence:
- In Kenneth’s trailer, police eventually recover blood-stained sneakers and a child’s blood-soaked sock, later confirmed as human blood—potentially one of the boys’. [26:46-27:19]
Legal Action:
- With no bodies or forensic evidence from the original scene, murder charges aren’t possible. Kenneth is prosecuted for bank fraud (forging Lydia’s signature on house sale documents) and is confronted with the suspicion of murder as the motive for fraud in an unprecedented affidavit. [27:50-28:15]
Kenneth’s Death:
- Shocked at the public allegation, Kenneth takes his own life in jail the next day. He leaves a message for his sister:
  - “I did a really bad thing. You may not be hearing from me again.” [29:21]

Aftermath & Remaining Mysteries

Unanswered Questions:
- Even with subsequent searches of Kenneth’s trailer and possible bone fragments uncovered, lack of accessible records leaves the family’s final whereabouts a mystery. [29:57]
Impact:
- The episode emphasizes the compounded trauma—from Kenneth’s actions, police inaction, and the enduring pain for surviving relatives. The case is functionally closed due to the suspect’s death and evidence now lost to time.

3. Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

“If you ever see Kenny driving my car, you’ll know that I’m dead.” — Recalls Everett to his manager (Ashley, 14:13)
“Did anyone check the bus depot? I bet the family bought no tickets.” — Ashley [10:33]
“One of the bathrooms in the house had the toilet and the tub painted red.” — Ashley [23:18]
“He told a random cashier as he was cashing checks that his sister and her family moved to Hawaii…” — Ashley [25:20]
“They have diddly squat when it comes to forensic evidence.” — Ashley [23:46]
“I did a really bad thing. You may not be hearing from me again.” — Kenneth’s final message (Ashley, 29:21)

4. Timestamps for Important Segments

[03:46] — The family’s last documented phone call, Lydia’s panic, and Kenneth’s threats.
[05:14] — Herman’s attempts to get police help; the initial brush-off by Chicago PD.
[07:54] — Family arrives in Chicago, finds house emptied.
[09:09] — Neighbor’s sighting of suspicious carpet removal.
[13:33] — Everett’s manager recounts last events; Kenneth seen with Everett’s van.
[14:13] — “If you ever see Kenny driving my car, you’ll know that I’m dead.”
[18:47] — History of animosity, inheritance, and threats from Kenneth.
[21:11] — Kenneth forges documents to sell the house and van.
[23:18] — Discovery of the home’s altered state; possible cover-up.
[26:46-27:19] — Physical evidence found in Kenneth’s trailer: bloody shoes, child’s sock.
[27:50-28:15] — Bank fraud charge links directly to murder motive.
[29:21] — Kenneth’s suicide and final correspondence.
[29:57] — Ongoing pleas for information; lingering questions for the family.

5. Final Notes

The episode delivers a powerful indictment of systemic neglect and the unique vulnerabilities faced by missing persons in marginalized communities. Through chilling interviews, abandoned leads, and failed institutions, listeners are left with a haunting portrait of four lives erased and the tragic, unfinished search for justice.

If you have information about the Thompson case, contact Chicago PD Missing Persons at 312-745-5020.

Source: crimejunkie.com
Instagram: @crimejunkiepodcast

Loading summary...

Transcript

Yvette Gentile (0:01)

Every mystery has an answer, but some have way more than one possibility. I'm Yvette Gentile and I'm her sister Racha Pecorero. Every week on our podcast so Supernatural, we invite you to explore the unknown and to consider the many theories behind each unsolved mystery. We'll guide you as you question the world you think you know through investigations into spine chilling hauntings, unexplainable encounters, strange disappearances, and so much more. So if you're ready to be haunted by stories of the unsolved and of the unknown, listen if you dare to so Supernatural every Friday wherever you get your podcasts.

Ashley Flowers (0:49)

Making decisions shouldn't feel mysterious. With the State Farm Personal Price Plan, you can personalize your plan to help create an affordable price for you so you can continue cracking all of life's big cases. Talk to a State Farm agent to uncover how you can choose to bundle and save like a good neighbor. State Farm is there. Prices are based on rating plans that vary by state. Coverage options are selected by the customer, availability, amount of discounts and savings and eligibility vary by state.

Sponsor/Ad Voice (1:20)

IXL helps kids stay confident and ahead of the curve. IXL is an award winning online learning platform that helps kids truly understand what they're learning and it's used in 96 of the top 100 school districts in the U.S. we've used IXL for years both in and out of the classroom and of course through the summer to keep their minds engaged. Make an impact on your child's learning. Get IXL now and Crime Junkie listeners can get an exclusive 20% off IXL membership when they sign up today at ixl.com crimejunkie.be Visit ixl.com crimejunKie to get the most effective learning program out there at the best price.

Ashley Flowers (1:58)

Saks Fifth Avenue makes it easy to holiday your way. Saks is where you can find everything from the perfect Chloe bag for your hard to shop for sister to a Prada jacket for a fancy holiday dinner. And if you don't know where to start, Saks.com is customized to your personal style so you can save time shopping and spend more time just enjoying the holidays. Make shopping fun and easy this season and find gifts and inspiration to suit your holiday style at Saks Fifth Avenue. Hi Crime Junkies, I'm your host Ashley Flowers and I'm Britt and man, the story I have for you today, I'm going to warn you, it is going to have you yelling at your phone or whatever you're listening on because the answers to this case were out in the open the entire time. When a family disappears into thin air, it is glaringly obvious that all roads point to one person, and the answer literally starts at home. But police at the time jumped on the investigation too little, too late, Leaving the family of the victims frustrated with the lack of police response for this family of color, something that is still all too common in marginalized communities. But we talked to an attorney in this case, and she gave us the real details on. On why the investigation unfolded the way it did and why no charges were ever brought in what looks like an open and shut murder case. This is the story of the Thompson family. It's Friday, July 5, 1996, when Herman Thompson calls his son Everett at the restaurant Everett owned. He wants to know exactly when he can expect Everett and his young family to get into town for the holiday weekend. The plan was for them to drive from Chicago to Philly sometime after Everett got off work. But, you know, when you're the owner operator, that's always a little tbd. So before they can hash out all the details over the phone, Everett tells his dad, okay, listen, hang on. My wife, Lydia, she's on the other line. He's only off the phone for a second before he clicks back over and he tells his dad he's gotta go. Lydia has locked herself and their two boys in the closet because her brother is there at their house, three threatening them with an axe, and Everett's got to get home, like, click. Now, based on reporting from the Chicago Tribune, Herman expects Everett to call him back at any point, right?

Ashley Flowers (14:31)

Literally. Yeah, I don't know the context for that. Also, Kenneth was there with a story that must have made her put her guard down. I guess he came into the restaurant and walked right up to her and said that Everett had gotten in an accident and was arrested after he got in an argument with a Chicago police officer. Now, this makes zero sense to the manager because that's not like Everett at all. But for some reason, she accepts this even when she looks down at Kenneth's feet and notices what looks like blood on his white sneakers. And not that I even have to say this, but just in case, there was never any arrest records for Everett in Chicago or anywhere else. Now, what does the detective do with this bombshell revelation? Wish I could tell you. The Chicago Tribune reports that in October 1996, Chicago PD's Special Investigation Unit takes on the Thompsons case. And they've gotta attempt to retrace all the family's steps from like three months before. They are so behind. But they start by going to the boys school and they talk to the principal who says that the boys hadn't attended since early summer of 1996. So seemingly when the school year ended in June and there were no other transfer requests or anything, so, like, poof, they're just gone. And it's discovered that medical appointments have been missed. No one has shown backup at the restaurant. And even their mailperson noticed that none of the Thompsons were getting any of their mail and they had left the family cat behind. It was just Kenneth and this cat at the house. So it is seeming more and more clear that something happened to this family on or around July 5th, and all eyes are finally on Kenneth. And guess what was in their records all along that maybe they knew about but did nothing with or they never looked hard enough into to find. Just two days before the family went missing, Lydia had called police on Kenneth for the same exact thing that she called her husband for on the 5th. Court records show that on July 3rd, 3rd of 1996, Lydia called police to say that Kenneth was chasing her around the house with an ax. Now, the court documents aren't actually for that case. It's just like a note made for another case involving something else. So it doesn't get into any details about the police's response or lack thereof, because I know based on the records that they didn't arrest Kenneth for that. Now, we found some reporting from the Chicago Tribune that says police noted the scene was correct, quiet and calm and no ongoing trouble. Nothing that stood out. But that doesn't make it clear to me. Like, was Kenneth gone? Was he there, but everything had cooled down? Yeah, I wish I had more details. I mean, again, the court records just say that the responding officer checked out each room, didn't see anything strange, but, like, they clearly didn't do enough because Instead of calling 911 on the 5th, two days later, Lydia calls her husband for help. Like she called the police the first time, and nothing happened. Right now, as you might be picking up on, Kenneth is a real piece of work. Like I said, he had just recently gotten out of jail. He was a convicted sexual predator who was threatening to murder his sister. Now, for why, you might ask. Best guesses only here. But he and Lydia had a history of animosity. According to court docs, detectives learned from their aunt that things had gotten pretty bad between the year before in 1995, after their dad passed away. Their mom had already died in 89, but when their dad passed away, this is when the kids. So Kenneth, Lydia and their other sister Phyllis, they got an inheritance. Now, this came while Kenneth was still in prison for criminal sexual assault. So Lydia sent him his portion while he was still in prison. But when he received $11,000 from Lydia, he was pissed because he told their aunt that each of them were allotted $15,000. So basically, he thought that Lydia was holding out on him, and he accused her of getting rid of his personal belongings while he was locked up. And he's saying all of this via letters to his aunt that, of course, the aunt ended up not being able to find for us, which is like a real shame because she says that in these letters, Kenneth allegedly wrote that he was going to kill Lydia when he got out of prison. Like, very damning letters.

Ashley Flowers (27:30)

Yeah. Yeah. And, like, circumstantially, this case is really building. And Kenneth must feel the walls closing in on him because the FBI gets word from his other sister, the one out of state, Phyllis, who says that Kenneth tried getting her to tell Chicago PD that she'd talked to Lydia sometime in early October of 96, even though she hadn't. And, like, Kenneth also knew she hadn't talked to Lydia since, like, around July 4th. But anyway, so it's building. And Jacqueline tells us that sometime In December of 97, Kenneth gets charged with bank fraud for that. Forged signature, but still not murder. But what's so interesting is that they use this as a chance to set the record straight. And I've never seen anything like this before. Not saying it hasn't happened, but, like, it was just so interesting to everyone on the team who worked on this episode. Basically, they said that Kenneth committed fraud that was motivated by murdering all four Thompson family members. And they use that affidavit to spell out what they think happened. It says that Kenneth was so mad at his sister for how she handled the inheritance and their parents house after they passed, that he basically wanted her out of the picture so that he could get the home, he could get the money. And his rage led him to attack Lydia and her kids. And Everett were just unfortunately there, like collateral damage in his mind. Now, Jacqueline was there in court on the 24th and told us that Kenneth seemed shocked. Like he knew his charge was bank fraud, but when they brought up the murder allegations, like, I guess his head, like, flew back in surprise. And the next day, the very next day, he took his own life in his prison cell. According to the Chicago Tribune, he didn't leave a note, but Jacqueline told us that he did send one final message to his sister Phyllis, saying something along the lines of, I did a really bad thing. You may not be hearing from me again. And any potential answers about the Thompson family's whereabouts probably died with Kenneth. I mean, according to the Daily Chronicle, investigators do go back to Kenneth's trailer after his death to search for clues. And they do find some bone, like fragments that might be human, along with fibers and fabrics found underneath it. And that was like, June of 98. They even bring out cadaver dogs to, like, sniff around the area. Now, I know that those items were sent off to the FBI crime lab in D.C. but there's no telling what the analysis showed. And again, we couldn't get the records. Back in 1998, police did put out a plea to anyone, cellmate or otherwise, that knew Kenneth that might have information from him about where he put the family. Like, they're begging people to come forward. And that is what still stands today. This case is essentially closed. I mean, the main suspect has passed, and so have Everett's mom and dad. But Everett's siblings are still here, and so is Lydia's sister. So if anyone listening has information about this case, please contact the Chicago PD Missing Persons Division at 312-745-5020. You can find all the source material for this episode on our website site.