Crime Junkie Podcast Episode Summary: "MURDERED: Nathaniel Jones"

Presented by audiochuck Media Company

Introduction

In the gripping episode titled "MURDERED: Nathaniel Jones," Ashley Flowers, host of Crime Junkie, delves deep into a haunting true crime case that has lingered unanswered for over two decades. Partnering with investigative journalist Delia D'Ambra, the episode unravels the mysterious circumstances surrounding the untimely death of Nathaniel Jones in Winston Salem, North Carolina.

Background on Nathaniel Jones

Nathaniel Frederick Jones, a 61-year-old widower and pillar of the Winston Salem community, owned and operated Jones Chevron, an auto service station situated at the bustling intersection of New Walkertown Road and Carver School Road. Notably, Jones was the first African American man to own and run his own service station in the city—a testament to his entrepreneurial spirit and commitment to his community.

Chuck Byram (Retired Police Detective): "Mr. Jones was well liked and revered in the black community."
(14:17)

Jones was not only a business owner but also a dedicated church member and a beloved grandfather to local sports star Chris Paul. His establishment was a communal hub, frequented by residents and respected by local law enforcement alike.

The Day of the Murder

On the evening of November 15, 2002, Nathaniel Jones met a tragic end. After a day of running errands with his nephew, Terrence Jones, Nathaniel was last seen alive at approximately 6:17 PM near his Lincoln Town Car in the parking lot of Terrence's apartment complex. Despite extensive efforts, Nathaniel never returned home to meet the scheduled painting contractors, Claude Walker and his fiancée, Gloria.

By 7:40 PM, Calvin Scriven, a close friend of Nathaniel, arrived at his residence following failed attempts to contact him. Accompanied by Ms. Gloria, Calvin discovered Nathaniel's lifeless body in the carport—bound, gagged, and displaying signs of a violent encounter.

Delia D'Ambra (Narrator): "Violent crime came for both of us, and it did what only it can do. It changed everything."
(07:15)

Discovery and Initial Investigation

Upon arrival, emergency responders found Nathaniel face down with black tape securing his hands and mouth. Despite efforts to revive him, he succumbed to a fatal cardiac arrest caused by the immense stress of the assault.

Key observations at the scene included:

• Broken Motion Sensor Light: Tampered to remain non-functional, suggesting premeditated efforts to avoid detection.
• Partial Shoe Prints: Two faint impressions found on the hood of the Lincoln Town Car, indicating the potential number of assailants.
• Missing Wallet: Despite significant cash found on Nathaniel, his wallet was absent, hinting at possible robbery motives.

Calvin Scriven (Witness): "He was laying between the car and the house. His mouth was duct taped and his hands were duct taped."
(23:10)

Witnesses and Evidence

Several key witnesses provided critical insights:

• Calvin Scriven: Confirmed arriving at the scene post-assault and described Nathaniel's state.
• Claude Walker and Gloria: The painting contractors who had arrived to meet Nathaniel for the scheduled job but were diverted by his sudden unavailability.
• Brian Lindsey: A neighbor who reported no unusual activity prior to the incident.

Forensic evidence collected included:

• Groceries Inside the Home: Indicated Nathaniel was ambushed shortly after returning from errands.
• Cash on Nathaniel: $1,416 found in his pockets and more in the trunk, suggesting a possible motive tied to robbery.
• Shoe Prints: Suggested one or more assailants involved in the crime.

Marshall Griffin (Lead Detective): "It appeared someone had used the hood to boost themselves up to reach the light and disable it, most likely so that they could commit the crime without being seen."
(41:35)

Police Investigation and Findings

The Winston Salem Police Department (WSPD) pursued the robbery theory, focusing on the economic aspect as a potential motive. Despite thorough investigations, several questions remained unanswered:

• Number of Assailants: Unclear whether the crime was perpetrated by a single individual or a group.
• Motive Beyond Robbery: The absence of Nathaniel's wallet suggested either negligence by the assailants or a more complex motive.
• Surveillance Footage and Alibis: Limited due to the time period and technological constraints, hindering the identification of suspects.

Delia D'Ambra: "The absence of his wallet pointed to a possible motive of robbery gone wrong."
(39:43)

Theories and Unanswered Questions

Despite the evidence pointing towards robbery, inconsistencies and missing elements left room for alternative theories:

• Personal Vendetta: Was Nathaniel targeted due to personal conflicts or grudges?
• Inside Involvement: Any indication of internal betrayal or acquaintances within the community being involved?
• Technological Gaps: Lack of advanced forensic technology at the time may have impeded the investigation.

Delia D'Ambra emphasizes the complexity of the case, urging listeners to consider the multifaceted nature of violent crimes and the profound impact they have on victims and their communities.

Delia D'Ambra: "There are layers upon layers to this case and it is one that holds so many players, stories, and perspectives."
(07:15)

Community Impact

Nathaniel Jones was more than just a victim; he was a cornerstone of the Winston Salem community. His untimely death sent shockwaves through the neighborhood, leaving residents grappling with the loss of a trusted friend and mentor. The case highlighted underlying issues within the community, including economic disparities and the challenges faced by minority business owners.

Chris Paul (Friend): "He was a community grandfather, I guess you could say. The store that he ran was always busy."
(14:45)

Conclusion and Continuing Mystery

Even after 22 years, the murder of Nathaniel Jones remains a haunting mystery. While the Crime Junkie team and Delia D'Ambra have unearthed numerous leads and testimonies, definitive answers still elude law enforcement. The episode serves as a poignant reminder of the enduring quest for justice and the importance of community in seeking truth.

Delia D'Ambra: "How did the suspect or suspects do that without Mr. Jones seeing them? It's pretty risky jumping up on the hood of a car."
(43:24)

Listeners are left contemplating the unresolved aspects of the case, pondering over the true motives and identities of those responsible for Nathaniel Jones's tragic demise.

Delia D'Ambra: "It's dark by the time emergency responders pulled up to the scene, and they realized they needed to let the first officer take over."
(31:06)

As the investigation continues, Crime Junkie encourages the community and true crime enthusiasts alike to remain vigilant and proactive in seeking justice for those who can no longer speak for themselves.

Join the Community

Whether you're a seasoned true crime aficionado or new to the genre, "MURDERED: Nathaniel Jones" offers a compelling exploration into a case that continues to resonate. Follow Crime Junkie every Monday for more untold stories and theories.

This summary captures the essence of the "MURDERED: Nathaniel Jones" episode, highlighting key discussions, testimonies, and investigative insights while maintaining a natural flow for new listeners.