Loading summary
Progressive Insurance Narrator
Insurance isn't one size fits all, and shopping for it shouldn't feel like squeezing into something that just doesn't fit. That's why drivers have enjoyed Progressive's name
Shopify Narrator
your price tool for years.
Progressive Insurance Narrator
With the name your price tool, you tell them what you want to pay and they show you options that fit your budget enough. Hunting for discounts, trying to calculate rates, and tinkering with coverages. Maybe you're picking out your very first policy, or maybe you're just looking for something that works better for you and your family. Either way, they make it simple to see your options. No guesswork, no surprises. Ready to see how easy and fun shopping for car insurance can be? Visit progressive.com and give the name your price tool a try. Take the stress out of shopping and find coverage that fits your life on your terms. Progressive Casualty Insurance Company and affiliates Price and coverage match limited by state law
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
what they did to your family. You're lucky to make it out alive. Streaming on Peacock Men are going to come after me. Taking them out.
Progressive Insurance Narrator
It's my only chance.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Put a bullet in her head from
Ozark Promo Voice
the co Creator of Ozark.
Woodbine Podcast Narrator
Looks like a family was running drugs execution style. Killing it's rare for the Keys.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Any leads on who they might have been running for?
Progressive Insurance Narrator
The cartel killed my family.
Woodbine Podcast Narrator
I'm gonna kill them.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
All of them.
Ozark Promo Voice
Mia streaming now only on Peacock.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Zootopia 2 has come home to Disney Plus.
I Think Not Podcast Host Joey Taranto
Let's go get ready for a new case.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
We're gonna crack this case and prove we're victorious. Partners of all friends, you are Gary the Snake and your last name the
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
Snake Dream Team Hidden New Habitats Zootopia
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
has a secret reptile population. You can watch the record breaking phenomenon at home. You're clearly working at Zootopia 2, now available on Disney Plus. Rated PG. Egg Harbor Township in South Jersey isn't the glitzy boardwalk of Atlantic City, but it's close enough to see the neon glow on a humid summer night. It sits on the edge of the sprawling New Jersey Pine Barrens, a landscape filled with dense scrub pines, sandy soil and winding back roads. And it's beautiful, but it's also a place where it's very easy to disappear. There are quiet residential pockets like Bargain Town or Sculleyville, side by side with bustling commercial corridors and the FAA Tech Center. It's a town of commuters, casino workers and families that have been there for generations. In May, the air starts to get heavy with a specific South Jersey humidity, a mix of salt spray from the ocean and the scent of damp pine needles from the barrens, and it's the sweet spot where locals feel like they own the town. Before the summer crowds descend. People are opening up their windows, getting the patio furniture out, and maybe heading over to storybook land or hitting the local ball fields.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
The boardwalks in Atlantic City are testing their lights and the marinas in Egg harbor are buzzing with people. They're getting their boats ready for the great Egg Harbor Bay. It's supposed to be the beginning of the good times.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
The specifically in 2012, Egg harbor saw a warm early spring. It was a clear, bright Thursday morning when the 911 call came in and it changed the whole community in Atlanta county for years. This is the story of April Christine Kaufman. I'm Ashley, I'm Ricky and you are listening to Crime. April Christine was born on October 27, 1964 in Atlantic City and she was a lifelong shore resident deeply rooted in South Jersey and known by many. According to the Press of Atlantic City, she was the oldest of five children and the only one her mother did not place into the foster care system. So in 1973, at the age of nine, she watched a social worker take her four siblings away from her Absecan home and it took her 23 years. But in 1996 she found all of them again, scattered across New Jersey, California and West Virginia. She was raised by her grandmother and even from that childhood, April built a life that kept her constantly connected to people. She wasn't someone who just stayed in the background, but was instead someone who was outspoken, driven and very, very much a presence in her community. One of the ways that April made herself known in her community was through her entrepreneurial spirit, her ownership of Artistic Salon in Northfield, Hair Salon, which was a central hub for local information and also community connection. It served as a base for April's many social and professional networks. She also ran Jack Purveyor's catering company. In 2010, according to Atlantic City Weekly, she expanded her food business by opening Cherry Cafe and Catering in Northfield. She specialized in high quality catering for local events, corporate lunches and private parties, using her social abilities to welcome local political and charitable functions.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
And with just those businesses, anyone could see that April was a pillar in her community.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
And if that wasn't enough, what really set April apart was her voice.
Moms and Mysteries Hosts Melissa and Mandy
Literally.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
She became a well known radio personality on W O N D 1400am, hosting a weekly talk show where she shared her opinions, spoke on community issues and connected with listeners across the region. She wasn't afraid to say exactly what she thought and people respected her for it. She wasn't trying to please everyone. She had strong opinions and she stood by them. And in a small community like that, that kind of personality makes you memorable. But she was also deeply compassionate and kind. As her childhood friends described, April could definitely piss people off, and she had a knack for telling people to go to hell and make them look forward to the trip. Somehow that honestly didn't push them away, but drew them in. The radio show became the top of the funnel for her other businesses, since people who heard her on the radio would visit her salon or hire her for her catering company because they felt like they knew her personally. From these ventures, April experienced great success. She was busy, had her hands in everything and was a connector. She had a pulse on every corner of Egg Harbor Township and Northfield. She was connecting to women in the community through her salon and she was feeding local events through her catering company. And W O N D let her reach the entire county through her bold personality. She was heavily involved with the Wounded Warrior Project, which focused on the transition of veterans returning from Iraq, specifically those dealing with invisible wounds like PTSD and traumatic brain injuries. On her show, she would frequently interview veterans, giving them a space to share their stories, using her jersey grit to demand better services for them, often putting local politicians on the spot to support WWP initiatives. She even hosted events at Artistic Salon, where a portion of the day's proceeds would go directly to the wwp. April also created programs to support those who had served. One of those efforts was the Vet and Vets program. It was tied to the National Corvette Museum in Bowling Green, Kentucky, which, according to her obituary in the Press of Atlantic City, April was responsible for establishing it, brought Corvette owners together to raise money for veteran causes and helped launch Wounded Warrior events at the museum. And she also opened her home during those holidays, hosting Thanksgiving dinners for Coast Guard recruits from the Cape May Training center through a program called Operation Fireside, making sure that even those far from home had somewhere to go for the holidays. And on top of that, she served on the board for the Southern New Jersey chapter of the American Red Cross for blood drives and and emergency relief fundraisers. And she also worked with Toys for Kids, a local effort to make sure that no child in Atlanta county went without a gift during the holiday season.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
Her impact was significant enough that on May 8th of 2012, then Governor Chris Christie presented her with the New Jersey Governor's Jefferson Award for Public Service, an honor sometimes described as the Nobel Prize for Public Service. It recognized April's ability to mobilize thousands of others to step up for their community. That award was presented just two days before she was killed.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
April was, according to friends and family, a princess, but also a bulldog. She had beautiful eyes, blonde hair and a sweet smile, but she also drove a cherry red Corvette and rode a black Harley, things that matched her bold personality and and she had a family who she was close to, including her daughter Kimberly, her two grandsons, and her husband, Dr. James Kaufman. April met Jim through her work with veterans, with James telling stories about serving as a Green Beret during the Vietnam War, and the two connected over their shared passions for supporting military members. Jim became her third husband and according to ABC News and the book Dr. Dealer, they were married on Valentine's Day in 2003 and together they built a life in Lynwood, New Jersey which is where people move to escape the tourist noise but stay close enough to the shore.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
It's a town of manicured lawns, colonial style homes, and a legendary bike path. It consistently ranks as one of the best and most expensive places to live in New Jersey. It was a perfect place for a successful business owner in a high performing endocrinologist like Dr. Kaufman. From the outside, they were like a power couple in their community. A strong, outspoken woman, a respected doctor,
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
both involved and by early 2012, April was at the height of her life, recognized for her service, surrounded by family and deeply embedded in her community. But behind that public image, there were layers to her life that most people didn't see. And In May of 2012, everything came to a sudden and violent end inside the home that she shared with her husband. Your bed sheets. Yes, the ones that you're probably sitting on right now or laying under can hold more bacteria than a toilet seat. But now that we both know, we have to do something about it. Miracle made Sheets. And yes, that name sounds like something Ricky would make up to avoid doing laundry. But it is a real company and these sheets are genuinely incredible. Here's the deal. Miracle Made bedding is inspired by NASA technology and the fabric is infused with silver, which actually prevents up to 99.7% of bacterial growth. Which means the sheets stay cleaner and fresher up to three times longer than regular sheets. Fewer odors, fewer wash cycles, way less laundry. I cannot get over this part. Less laundry is a love language to they also regulate your body temperature. So if you're the type of person who wakes up at three in the morning either soaked in sweat or shivering under a pile of blankets, they're going to change your life. Hot Sleeper Cold sleeper. The weirdly specific sleeper who runs hot on one side and cold on the other. These sheets, they figure it out for you while you're sleeping. And these sheets are like luxury hotel quality without the really expensive hotel price tag. And because all of that bacteria in your old sheets can clog your pores, cause breakouts, your skin is about to get a little upgrade too. So here's what you can do. Go to try Miracle.com Crimesalad that's T R Y Miracle.com Crimesalad you are going to save over 40% and when you use the promo code CRIMESALAD at checkout, you get an extra 20% off plus a free three piece towel set. They make a really great gift and there's a 30 day money back guarantee so there's zero risk. One more time. That's trymiracle.com Crimesalad promo code CRIMESALAD Big thank you to Miracle made for sponsoring this episode.
Shopify Narrator
Starting or growing your own business can be intimidating and lonely at times. Your to do list may feel endless with new tasks and lists can easily begin to overrun your life. So finding the right tool that not only helps you out, but simplifies everything as a built in business partner can be a game changer for millions of businesses. That tool is Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses around the world and 10% of all e commerce in the US from household names like Gymshark, Rare Beauty and Heinz to brands just getting started. Shopify has hundreds of ready to use
Progressive Insurance Narrator
templates that can help you build a
Shopify Narrator
beautiful online store that matches your brand's style. And you can tackle all the important tasks in one place from inventory to payments to analytics and more. No need to save multiple websites or try to figure out what platform is hosting the tool that you need. And if people haven't heard about your brand, you can get the word out. Like you have a marketing team behind you with easy to run email and social media campaigns to reach customers wherever they're scrolling or strolling. Start your business today with the industry's best business partner, Shopify and start hearing. Sign up for your $1 per month trial today at shopify.com realm. Go to shopify.com realm that's shopify.com realm
Ryan Reynolds (Mint Mobile Ad)
Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile with a message for everyone paying Big Wireless way too much. Please, for the love of everything good in this world, stop with Mint. You can get premium wireless for just $15 a month. Of course, if you enjoy overpaying no judgments, but that's weird. Okay, one judgment anyway. Give it a try@mintmobile.com Switch upfront payment
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
of $45 for three month plan equivalent to $15 per month required Intro rate first three months only, then full price plan options available.
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
Taxes and fees extra.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
See full terms@mintmobile.com the morning of May 10th started like any other morning in Linwood, New Jersey. The neighborhoods were calm and nothing like this was supposed to happen. But inside the Kaufman home on Woodstock Drive, something had already gone terribly wrong. Late that morning, a 911 call came into the local police station. On the other end of the line was the Kaufman's handyman, who had reportedly helped April care for her collection of exotic birds. And he urgently was trying to make sense of what he was seeing, saying that his boss was on the floor of her bedroom, unresponsive. She had been shot twice, lying face down on the floor, and the door had been left unlocked. One of the bullets shattered her elbow and the other tore through her side, passing through a lung, her heart and then her other lung. According to the book doctor Dealer, the medical examiner believed April may have initially survived the shooting, speculating that she struggled out of the bed after being shot before ultimately collapsing onto the floor. And when first responders arrived at the scene, they quickly confirmed that April Christine had tragically died in her bedroom, shot twice. This completely shocked the affluent neighborhood that she came from, where a murder was unheard of and also devastated the ones that she had such a positive impact on. There was no sign of forced entry. Nothing had been stolen. There were no fingerprints or shell casings or any clear indication of how someone got in or got out. And it was as if whoever had done this had vanished without a trace, leaving everyone wondering what happened and who could have done this. Because of that, detectives did what they always do first. They look at the person closest to her and was with her that morning, her husband, prominent endocrinologist Dr. James Kaufman. But almost immediately, Jim was ruled out. He told investigators that he had left early that morning for work and completed his normal morning routine, according to reporting from the Press of Atlantic City. He stopped at a nearby Wawa like he always does, and he arrived at work at his normal time. And when detectives checked on this storyline, his story held up. There was surveillance footage placing him at the Wawa and at his office, and phone records confirmed his movements throughout the day. His alibi was solid and he could securely be ruled out.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
At the time, Jim was perceived as a recognizable, upstanding figure. He was a physician who specialized in treating patients with diabetes, often speaking publicly about health, diet and lifestyle. And he was known for presenting himself well, as polished together and confident. He owned multiple properties, including his home in Lynwood and a vacation home in Arizona. He enjoyed hobbies like motorcycle riding and shooting, and spent time at firing ranges and skeet shooting. At the time April's death, she was 47 years old while he was 62. Their relationship stood out, with April described as a vibrant, striking blonde presence that contrasted with Jim's more reserved professional image, and they connected over their interests and respect for service members.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Meanwhile, news of April's death spread quickly through the community. For those who knew her, it was almost impossible to process. Her fellow radio host Harry Hurley told the press of Atlantic City that April did the work of 100 people. It cannot be replaced, and he could not think of anyone who would want to do her harm because all she had ever done was help people. It left an emptiness that reflected just how much April meant to the people around her. US Senator Robert Menendez released a statement praising her tireless work on behalf of veterans and the difference she made in so many lives. Even though April pressured government officials to act, no one could deny the positive impact she had in every aspect of her life. It left everyone wondering who would want April dead? Someone who was publicly recognized for doing good, someone who people truly cared about. And to answer that question, Jim, April's husband, offered something unexpected, suggesting that investigators should look into the Pagans motorcycle club. He told them that April may have crossed paths with members of the group through her work with veterans who may have had connections inside the group, which was immediately alarming. The FBI and Department of justice have long classified the Pagans as one of the major outlaw motorcycle gangs operating on the east coast, alongside groups like the Hells Angels, the Outlaws and the Bandidos. According to Department of Justice reporting, the Pagans have been tied to organized crime involving methamphetamine, cocaine and PCP distribution, as well as racketeering, extortion and violence for hire.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
Racketeering is the act of operating an illegal business or using a legitimate business to commit crimes. So using a restaurant as a way to buy and sell drugs, for example. Extortion is basically getting money, property or anything else by intimidating someone through threats of violence, property damage or social ruin. And contract violence is violence for hire, paying someone or being paid to commit violence against someone or worse.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Many have described this gang as one of the toughest and most violent groups on the east coast. So if April became involved with them, Somehow, through her work with veterans, it would have been a huge problem. According to law enforcement accounts, women have not traditionally been viewed as equals inside clubs like this. So because of that, detectives had to consider the possibility that April, who was outspoken and unafraid to challenge people, may have said something to the wrong person. This introduced the early theory that instead of this being random, it was retaliation. In the days following April's murder, the community didn't stay quiet. They organized candlelight vigils, events, and her colleagues at the radio station pushed authorities to stay focused on the case. Local newspapers continued to cover her story again and again, hoping that detectives would give some kind of update or a swift arrest to solve the case. But despite all of that, nothing seemed to move forward as police remained extremely private about their investigation. Months passed, and still no rest or answers surfaced in the case. And By May of 2013, nearly a year had passed since April Christine was tragically murdered with no justice in sight. Despite the public pressure, the media coverage, and the community demanding answers, the case had gone cold. There were no arrest, clear suspects, or any indication that an indictment was coming. But for April's daughter, Kimberly, standing still wasn't an option. She believed that she knew exactly who was responsible, and she was determined to prove it. So she walked into a law office, Darcy Johnson Day, looking for help. She had already been turned away by a major Philadelphia firm, and she knew that even though it wouldn't be easy, she refused. When she sat down with the attorneys, she didn't hesitate. She believed her stepfather murdered her mother, and she needed help proving it. She had been suspicious of Jim from the very start, even though on the outside, their marriage had been seemingly like a power couple, and even Kimberly would agree that they had some really fun times. There were warning signs, according to Kimberly, speaking later to the Oxygen series. Killer motive. Everything that the public saw wasn't always what was going on behind the scenes. There was an incident where Jim had actually pushed April down the stairs.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
On top of that, according to killer motive, Jim missed a community vigil a month after April's murder, soon brought up dating again, and then sold all of April's possessions without telling Kimberly.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
So when Kimberly was notified that Jim was eligible for April's $600,000 life insurance policy, she immediately considered it a possible motive and wanted to contest the payout. The attorneys were hesitant at first. Jim Kaufman was a respected doctor in the community, and it wasn't an accusation that people would take lightly. But after hearing her out, reviewing what she had to say, and with the support of their firm. They decided to take the case. And their approach was strategic, since at that point, the criminal investigation wasn't moving forward. Instead, they turned to civil court. The prosecutor's office appeared to be at a standstill, with no sign that charges were coming. And since Jim had sought life insurance money following April's death, that opened the door for litigation. Even though April had named James as the beneficiary, Transamerica Life Insurance told James that the policies could not be paid without official verification that he was not considered a suspect in his wife's death. And in response, James Coffman sued the company, charging breach of contract for not paying out the two policies, which have no clause relating to homicide. It also said there is no state requirement that the copy of the police report be submitted in such cases as the company requested. But Transamerica countered that it could not pay out the policy without assurance that James wasn't involved. And it suggested the secondary beneficiary, Kimberly, should be included in the suit. So the legal team got to work and started to dig deeper into Jim Kaufman's background. Jim Kaufman liked to show the world that he had a tough exterior, referring to his experience with the elite Green Beret army unit and two tours of duty in Vietnam. He would sometimes show up in army fatigues and a beret while supporting April's veteran advocacy programs. And he occasionally filled in on or co hosted her radio show, telling detailed stories about how his unit had come under vicious attack by the Viet Cong and about how he had been one of the few to survive licking water off leaves as he struggled to make his way out of the jungle. But what Kimberly's legal team uncovered was that there was no record that he had ever served in the US Military at all. All of his stories of hardships were lies. And for Kimberly, who thought her stepfather was a war hero, was disgusted at these findings, wondering what else he could be hiding. Through her attorneys at Darcy Johnson Day, Kimberly formally stepped into the fight to protect her rights and challenge what she believed was deeply wrong. And at the same time, her legal team began conducting their own large scale investigation independent of law enforcement. They even issued a public call to the community asking anyone with information about April's murder to come forward through a dedicated tip line. Alongside that legal action, Kimberly made a public statement, one that made her position extremely clear. She said that not a day goes by when she does not think about her mother, miss her terribly, and wish that charges were filed against the individual responsible. Being brought into the lawsuit by her stepfather left her with no choice but to speak out, and she could no longer sit back in silence. She felt a responsibility to both herself and her mother, who wouldn't have wanted her to be silent any longer.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
Kimberly acknowledged the public support, thanking members of the community for the love they had shown her family. But she also asked that all future questions be directed to her attorneys while the case was ongoing. She hoped that one day criminal justice would be served, and everyone else hoped for that too.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
May of 2014. It marked two years of injustice, and April's friends and family still weren't staying quiet. They held vigils and they invited people to bring a new toy or a gift card to benefit local veteran families. In true April spirit. Meanwhile, prosecutors from the Atlantic County Prosecutor's office were filing motions to prevent the release of specific investigative documents to Kimberly's legal team. They were particularly concerned about protecting the identities of confidential informants and witnesses who had provided information about the case so far. The state argued that if witness names or informant details were released, it would make other people afraid to come forward in what was already a high pressure, high profile investigation involving potential organized crime ties through the Pagan motorcycle club. But the fight continued on. Kimberly wasn't willing to keep going without answers. A 24 year old burning alive inside his own apartment. Police waited outside for 38 minutes. Was this an accident? A suicide? A specific section on both wrists unburned. Hours earlier, he would tell his parents that if his wife found out he was leaving, she would go ballistic. That's our episode. She'd go ballistic. The suspicious death of David Elmquist. This is Crime Salad. I'm Ashley.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
I'm Ricky.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Search for Crime Salad wherever you listen.
Rebel Girls Podcast Host
Hi listeners. We want to tell you about a podcast we love. It's called Rebel Girls, formerly known as Goodnight Stories for Rebel Girls. It's about real life women who are changing the world with their courage, creativity and big bold ideas. Want to know how Taylor Swift became a superstar? Or hear how Simone Biles became the greatest athlete of all time? From immersive stories to heartfelt interviews to super smart advice, Rebel Girls brings you stories that will get you fired up to become your best self. There are over 400 episodes for you to explore with new episodes every week. So check it out. Listen to Rebel Girls wherever you get your podcasts and find us on YouTube.com rebelgirls and whatever you do, stay rebel.
Roxanne and Chantel Podcast Hosts
Reality TV is messy, pop culture is louder than ever and the Internet completely unhinged. Welcome to Roxanne and Chantel, the podcast where cousins Roxanne and Chantal break down reality tv, celebrity drama and the stories everyone's texting about. We recap the shows, spill the headlines, and sit down with the stars themselves. No filter, no boring, takes just the tea. New episodes every week. If it's trending, we're talking about it. This is Roxanne and Chantel. Let's get into it.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
About three years since April was murdered, the organizer of the justice for April Facebook page started a petition to demand the Atlantic county prosecutor and the State of New Jersey to actively investigate and charge her killer with the murder of their beloved friend and Advocate. Pressuring then Governor Chris Christine, Atlantic County Prosecutor James McLean, and the new Jersey Division of Criminal Justice Director ellie Hoenig. By 2017, the legal battle over the life insurance policy marched on between Kimberly and Jim Kaufman as Kimberly's mother's home went up for auction with still no answers in the criminal investigation. And although police determined early that it was not a random killing, their expectations of making a fast arrest never happened. The investigation grew cold until a new prosecutor, Damon Tyner, sworn into the office early in 2017, began looking at old unsolved murder case files, and he almost immediately filed a demand that Dr. Kaufman submit his DNA for use in the probe.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
According to ABC News, there was little left from the original 2012 investigation and the new prosecutor ordered a top to bottom review from the ground up. This was a huge relief to Kimberly and the veteran community who had been so affected by April's death, excited that the case was finally being treated with the urgency that it deserved.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
And that urgency paid off. It was on June 13, 2017. This is five years after April's murder. A combined task force of FBI agents, Atlantic county prosecutors, detectives and local police executed search warrants at Dr. Kaufman's medical office in Egg Harbor Township and also at his home. And when detectives arrived at his endocrinology practice, Dr. Kaufman brandished a 9 millimeter Ruger handgun, pointing the gun at himself and shouting that he wasn't going to jail. So what originally was meant to be a simple search warrant execution turned into a lengthy standoff as authorities were forced to bring in a hostage negotiator and establish a perimeter around the office while keeping their weapons drawn. After being talked down by a negotiator, Kaufman surrendered peacefully and he was initially taken to a psychiatric intervention facility. So during the raid, investigators discovered that James was an extensive gun collector, legally owning approximately 100 firearms. However, he was charged with several weapons offenses related to that, including possession of hollow point bullets.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
Hollow point bullets are designed to expand upon impact, which increases the surface area of the bullet and causes massive tissue damage. It also stops the bullet's forward momentum. Since New Jersey has some of the strictest ammunition laws in the country, you can legally buy hollow points and keep them in your home or transport them to a shooting range. But it's a crime to possess them under circumstances not manifestly appropriate. If you're caught carrying them in public, in a concealed weapon, or in Dr. Kaufman's case, during the commission of another crime, like obstructing justice or standoff, they become illegal.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Prosecutors also found a large amount of cash inside the doctor's office. Some records state that it was over a couple hundred thousand dollars. However, the specific warrant details were sealed at the time of the arrest. The prosecutor, Damon Tyner, stated that the search warrants were unrelated to the 2012 homicide. But it didn't take long before the details of the case came to light. Jim was actually being accused of medical fraud, allegedly ordering unnecessary blood tests, prescribing unnecessary compounded medications, ordering heart testing, and accepting thousands of dollars every month in kickbacks, which is a form of negotiated bribery where someone pays a commission for facilitating a false transaction or service. Since he was arrested for a weapons violation, investigators were able to access his phone records. And from there, everything changed when they saw that Jim Kaufman was in contact with leadership of the Pagans Motorcycle Club, the same club that James originally pointed police to right after April's death. Police determined from there that Jim was part of a drug ring, allegedly supplying OxyContin to members of the Pagans so they could sell it on the street immediately. This gave another motive for April's murder. She uncovered her husband's double life and threatened him with divorce and exposure, giving both Jim and the Pagans motive to end her life. When Jim realized that investigators were finally onto him, according to reporting from the Press of Atlantic City, he tried to cooperate with authorities, providing information that pointed back toward the Pagans. Members of the club then came forward to say that Jim was supplying them with drugs and wanted his wife murdered. In the years following April's murder, it appeared to the public that nothing was happening. But behind the scenes, Kimberly Pack and her legal team were quietly building a case against James Kaufman. They weren't just defending Kimberly's rights in the life insurance case. They were actively investigating April's murder, filing a wrongful death lawsuit against James Kaufman. And through the civil justice system. They conducted interviews, reviewed hundreds of pages of phone records, text messages, emails, photographs, and documents, and they even carried out videotape Depositions, including one from James Kaufman himself. Their investigation was extensive and exhausting as they were engaged in a prolonged battle with the county prosecutor's office over access to investigative materials. And all the while, Kimberly kept pushing, asking questions and demanding answers for her mother. The teams said that as they uncovered information, they turned it over to law enforcement, but according to them, it seemed to fall on deaf ears. But they kept going. According to their findings, April and Jim's relationship was extremely volatile, describing greed as a major factor in Jim's personality. They also reinforced that Jim was not afraid to lie, including to decorate himself as a Green beret despite never having served in the military at all. But one of the most significant discoveries came from phone records revealing hundreds of calls between Dr. Kaufman and a burner phone. These calls went on for eight months and then suddenly stopped the evening before April was murdered. Their investigation also uncovered the strange relationship between Dr. Kaufman and the Pagans motorcycle club, including the sale of opioid prescriptions for cash. So as authorities combined these findings with their medical malpractice suspicions, and the search warrants continued. One of those locations was a luxury condo in Philadelphia, co owned by Jim and the home of his mother. Looking for financial records, cash, or additional weapons that may have been stored outside his primary residence. And in response to all of this, the New Jersey state board of medical examiners issued an emergency order to suspend Dr. James Coffman's license to practice medicine and surgery. The board cited the standoff at his office as the primary reason, arguing that his behavior demonstrated that he was incapable of safely practicing medicine, imposed a clear and imminent danger to the public.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
The suspension was temporary, pending a full hearing, but it effectively shuttered his endocrinology practice immediately. It also stripped him of his ability to prescribe medications, which was significant given the investigation into his pill mill operations with the Pagans.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
At this time, Jim's attorney argued that the suspension was premature. He said the standoff was the result of extraordinary stress, not a reflection of Jim's medical competence. The argument didn't slow anything down. The fight continued. On January 9th of 2018, Atlanta County Prosecutor Damon Tyner, he stood in front of reporters and announced that Dr. James Kaufman had been charged, along with Ferdinand Augello and six others who were in connection with April's murder and an underlying drug enterprise. Eight people in total. And according to prosecutors, this wasn't a random act of violence. This was murder for hire. And the person who ordered it was April's own husband. It all started in 2011. Jim Kaufman was running an Opioid pipeline out of his Egg Harbor Township medical practice alongside members of the Pagans motorcycle club. And at some point that year, April found out, and she told him she wanted a divorce. She told him she planned to spend every dollar she could get her hands on until it was finalized. She also threatened to expose the drug operation.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
So from Jim's perspective, he's looking at losing his marriage, his money, and his medical license all at once.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Prosecutors identified Ferdinand Augello as the leader of the drug network. This was a former Pagans chapter president. And according to their findings, Jim and Augello started looking for someone to kill April. Tyner said that Jim's own words were that he would rather kill April than go through a divorce, quote, and lose
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
half of his empire.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
And it took nearly a year to find someone willing to do it. That person was Francis Mulholland, a local man, a heroin addict, and an associate of the drug ring. The plan was simple. Jim would leave the door unlocked when he left for work. Mulholland would be driven to the house, walk in, and shoot April while she was asleep in her bedroom. Now, according to Tyner, Mulholland was paid at least $20,000 in cash, though investigators believed that real number was higher.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
And Francis Mulholland never faced charges for any of this. He died of what was ruled an accidental overdose In October of 2013, about 18 months after the murder, years before anyone was arrested. Jim, meanwhile, kept the drug operation running for five more years. It only ended when he was arrested in June of 2017 on those weapons charges.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
So on January 9th of 2018, Jim was charged. He moved two days later from the Atlanta County Jail to the Hudson County Jail in Kearney. Prosecutor Tyner said that the transfer was for Jim's safety, because Augello, who was being held in Atlanta county, had allegedly already begun plotting to have Jim killed in jail before he could talk. But Jim never did talk, and he never stood trial, because on January 26th of 2008, 17 days after being charged, Jim Kaufman was found dead in his cell, hanged with a strip of bed sheet. Authorities called it a carefully planned suicide and even left behind a six page letter addressing to his third wife and his attorneys. And in it, he denied killing April. He claimed Augello had approached him three years after the murder and confessed that he, Mulholland and a driver had done it. And he signed the note JMK md Even though Jim was a doctor of osteopathy ado, not an md A title he had used correctly for his entire
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
career, which, depending who you ask, was Either a mistake from a man in crisis or a detail worth paying attention to.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Now for April's daughter, Kimberly Pack, she would never get to sit across from her stepfather in a courtroom. She would never get to hear him answer for what prosecutors said he did. The man she had spent six years accusing had taken that away from her, too.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
As the family tried to make sense of a closure that was stolen from them, questions kept surfacing about the original investigation, about what they had found, what had been missed and what had been quietly set aside.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
And the clearest example of this came from Reporting by Breaking AC in 2018, just days after April's murder in 2012, the Atlanta County Prosecutor's Office quietly reached out to Dr. Michael Baden for context. Baden is one of the most high profile medical examiners in the country. He's the former chief medical examiner of New York City. He reviewed autopsies of JFK and Martin Luther King Jr. And more recently, George Floyd and Jeffrey Epstein. And he also hosted the HBO series Autopsy. When he weighs in on a case, people listen.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
So the question becomes, what were they asking him to look at? And why didn't anyone know about it until six years later?
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
On June 15, 2012, Bailey Baden sent his reply. He had reviewed the evidence. The body stiffness, the blood pooling, a body temperature of 86 degrees when April was first examined at 1:10 in the afternoon, an elevated potassium level in her eye fluids, an empty stomach and bladder. At Autopsy. To a reasonable degree of medical certainty, Baden concluded that April died at approximately 2:10 in the morning. Now, what's interesting about that? Jim Kaufman told investigators that he left the house for work at around 5:30 that morning. This was his routine every weekday. The two mile drive to Shore Medical center in Summers Point. Ricky's part. Yeah. And Baden sent this letter to John Mayer. This would be the chief assistant prosecutor overseeing the investigation. And Mayer, in his own affidavit wrote that Baden's findings clearly contradict Mr. Kaufman's statement that he saw April sleeping as he left their home at around 5:30am so the prosecutor's office had it in writing from one of the country's most respected pathologists, documented internally by their own chief assistant prosecutor, that the husband's story did not line up with the science.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
And then for the next six years, nothing.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Now, the prosecutor's office never publicly acknowledged that Baden had been consulted. They never acknowledged his conclusion. The letter only surfaced when a breaking AC reporter filed an open records request in 2018.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
And when breaking AC filed that request, the office confirmed that the letter existed, but no contract, no invoice, no record of payment. On paper, Baden was never officially retained at all.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Which leaves an uncomfortable question hanging. Why would one of the highest profile pathologists in the country weigh in on a local murder case, deliver a conclusion that placed the victim's death inside the home while the husband was still there, and then disappear from the record for six years? Technically, this case is closed. Ferdinand augello is serving 30 years for April's murder, plus a life sentence on federal drug charges. The five other co defendants from the drug ring took plea deals. Francis Mahaland, the man who pulled the trigger, died of an overdose before he could ever be charged. And Jim Kaufman, the husband prosecutors said orchestrated the whole thing, died in a jail cell before he ever stood trial. So, on paper, the people responsible for what happened to April on May 10, 2012, have been accounted for. But if you ask Kimberly Pack, April's daughter, if that feels like justice, the answer is complicated. Because six years went by while Atlanta County Prosecutor's office sat on a letter from one of the country's most respected pathologists. Six years while Kimberly and her attorneys ran their own investigation out of a civil courtroom because the criminal one had gone quiet. Six years of being told that the case was active while a document that directly contradicted her stepfather's alibi sat in a file somewhere. And then, after the convictions, three employees of the same prosecutor's office filed a formal complaint accusing the prosecutor who brought the charges of hiding evidence, protecting friends and looking the other way when detectives on the case were accused of misconduct.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
The people who killed April have been named. That part's done. But the question of who else failed her and whether they'll ever answer for it, that one's still open.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Kimberly has taken what happened to her mother and turned it into advocacy work, helping other victims navigate the system she spent six years fighting against. April's friends and the veterans she championed still gather every year at American Legion Post 352 in Summers Point for the April Christine Kaufman Veterans Advocate Award. The justice for April Kaufman community is still active online, and the website her family runs, April kaufman.net is still up because the people who loved April understood something early on. The legal system was going to do what it was going to do on its own timeline for its own reasons. But keeping her name alive, keeping her work alive, that part was up to them.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
If you want to follow along with the ongoing work in April's name, check out the justice for April Kaufman Facebook page and aprilcoffman.net and if you're in Atlanta county and want to support the veterans organizations April spent her life fighting for. American Legion Post 352 is a good place to start.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
And if you would like to support Crime Salad, the best way is to head over to patreon.com crimesaladpodcast where you can get ad free listens and be a part of our community. And you can also grab some merch at crime salad podcast.dashery.com we'll have the links in our description.
Co-Narrator (Crime Salad Co-Host Ricky)
Thank you guys so much for listening.
Narrator (Crime Salad Host)
Stay safe everyone. Until next time.
M
For eight years, we've been asking the same question over and over again. How did this happen? My name's Mandy.
Moms and Mysteries Hosts Melissa and Mandy
And I'm Melissa. And we're the host of Moms and Mysteries, the true crime podcast. With over 55 million downloads, we're two
M
Florida moms who are obsessed with mysteries. Each week we do deep dives into fascinating true crime stories.
Moms and Mysteries Hosts Melissa and Mandy
We cover everything from infamous cases like
M
Casey Anthony to the bizarre and complex crimes right here in our home state, like the shocking murder of FSU professor Dan Markel.
Moms and Mysteries Hosts Melissa and Mandy
We bring you the facts, but with warmth and width you'd only get from two friends who have been hooked on mysteries since childhood.
M
Join us for new episodes of Moms and Mysteries every Tuesday and Thursday.
Moms and Mysteries Hosts Melissa and Mandy
Listen to Moms and Mysteries on Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcast.
Ozark Promo Voice
Ever open up your podcast app. Scroll forever and still not know what to listen to. And there are millions of podcasts and most of them, they just don't grab you. That's why I created Something you should know. Every episode is built around surprising, useful and fascinating ideas. We're consistently ranked in Apple's top 200 with thousands of five star reviews. But more importantly, people come back because they learn something interesting every time. If you're tired of searching and you just want something good to listen to, try one episode of Something you should know right here on the platform you're listening on right now.
Woodbine Podcast Narrator
There are vampires out there. They walk among you, shoulder to shoulder in the dark. Heading to work, heading home. Going to the bar. It's a life just like anyone else's, and I have grown used to it. To the darkness, to the moon. To the taste of blood on my tongue. But vampires are dying out. We are a fading kind, and I am the first one created in so long. And that is a dangerous thing to be. Those who came before me, elders of all stripes, they do not want to see our kind gone. And they will do anything to keep their power and for myself and for Grace, who created me. That is a sword that hangs above our heads. And the worst person of all carries our secret. And he will use it however he sees fit. Who do you look to when things are at their darkest? From the creators of Parkdale Haunt comes Woodbine, a podcast about monsters, dreams and changes, those you want and those you never saw. Coming Season 2 arrives September 24th. Distributed by Realm.
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
Oh please, not that music. That music gives me nightmares from my childhood.
I Think Not Podcast Host Joey Taranto
Could we get something a little bit lighter? Some lighter music here?
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
Are you a fan of true crime TV shows?
I Think Not Podcast Host Joey Taranto
And what about Unsolved Mysteries, the show that jump started all of our love of true crime?
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
I'm Ellen Martin.
I Think Not Podcast Host Joey Taranto
And I'm Joey Taranto.
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
And we host I Think Not, a true crime comedy podcast covering some of the wildest stories from your favorite true crime campy TV shows all the way to Unsolved Mysteries.
I Think Not Podcast Host Joey Taranto
Baby, you will laugh, you will cry. You'll think about true crime in a whole new way. And you'll also ask yourself, who gave these people mics?
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
New episodes of I Think not are released every Wednesday, with bonus episodes out every Thursday on Patreon.
I Think Not Podcast Host Joey Taranto
And every Monday you can listen to to our True Crime rundown where we go over the top true crime headlines of the week.
I Think Not Podcast Host Ellen Martin
So come and join us wherever you listen to your podcasts.
Date: April 24, 2026
Hosts: Ashley and Ricky (husband and wife duo)
Podcast Theme: Uncovering the facts behind true crime cases, centering victims and accountability over sensationalism.
This episode examines the murder of April Kauffman, a prominent community advocate in Egg Harbor Township, New Jersey, whose death revealed a tangled web of betrayal, organized crime, and systemic failings. Through precise research and first-person accounts, Ashley and Ricky recount April’s life, the investigation into her murder, the long fight for justice by her daughter Kimberly, and the layers of failures and corruption that kept the case unsolved for years.
Early Life and Community Roots
Entrepreneurial and Social Impact
Charity and Advocacy
May 10, 2012: The Crime
Community Shock
Early Theories
Case Stalls
Allegations Against Jim
Exposure of Jim’s Stolen Valor
Kimberly’s Persistence
Ongoing Community Vigilance
2017: New Prosecutor, New Focus
Unveiling Medical Fraud and Drug Ties
Civil Team Breaks New Ground
January 2018: Charges Announced
Contracted Hit
Aftermath for Perpetrators
Jim’s Suicide
Investigation Failures: The Baden Letter
Convictions
Ongoing Advocacy
Open Questions Remain
On April’s Personality:
“April could definitely piss people off, and she had a knack for telling people to go to hell and make them look forward to the trip. Somehow, that honestly didn't push them away, but drew them in.” (05:46, Ashley)
On the Case Going Cold:
“Despite the public pressure, the media coverage, and the community demanding answers, the case had gone cold.” (20:37, Ashley)
On Jim Kaufman's Exposure as a Fraud:
“There was no record that he had ever served in the US Military at all. All of his stories of hardships were lies.” (25:18, Ashley)
On April’s Legacy:
“Keeping her name alive, keeping her work alive, that part was up to them.” (49:32, Ashley)
On Institutional Failures:
“Six years of being told that the case was active while a document that directly contradicted her stepfather's alibi sat in a file somewhere.” (47:00, Ashley)
This episode offers a deeply researched, compassionate examination of April Kauffman’s life and death, focusing on the long road to justice amid systemic barriers and personal betrayals. Ashley and Ricky foreground the strength and persistence of April and her daughter, and raise important questions about institutional accountability that linger even after convictions.
Resources for listeners: