
Loading summary
A
This is an I heart podcast, Crime Stories with Nancy Grace. I saw it. You saw it. You heard the evidence, you heard the women on the stand, what they recounted had been done to them. The beatings, the bruises, the and more. But I guess there was one person that wasn't listening. The judge. That's right. In the last hours, the judge has sentenced Sean Combs to a slap on the wrist. 50, not years, 50 months. M O N T H S 50 months behind bars after a grueling eight week trial with women on the stand recounting the worst moments of their lives, showing photos of their bruises, their cuts, their bleeding, their infections, you name it. 50 months. Okay, what does that boil down to? 50 months minus 14 months he's already served while awaiting trial. That brings us down to 36 months. Subtract from that, like the feds love to do for quote, good behavior behind bars. He is going to walk in about, what would you say? Two years. Joining me in all star panel. But first, straight out to Sam Krupen joining us, investigative journalist inside the courtroom for the sentencing. He's been on the case from the very, very beginning and he is the star of Sampson's World on YouTube. What happened? What happened to this judge?
B
I don't know, Nancy. I mean like I said, his tone seem like everybody in the courtroom was like, oh wow, Diddy is going away for a long time. And then it's almost as if like, you know, you're, you're punishing your kid and you're like, I am so angry you did that and I can't believe you stole my car and you took it out and I'm going to ground you for one month, you know, like instead of years. I mean it felt like he was going to lay the hammer down on Diddy, everybody. The family was literally heads down, praying, they thought worst case scenario. But then like you said, with good behavior, with his free ditty game program, he's looking like it's going to. People are saying a year and a half tops that he would serve out of that 50 month sentence.
A
50 months. 5. 0. The max he's looking at is 36. 6 months because he's getting time off for good, for time served. Straight out to Lynn Shaw joining us. She is the founder and director of Lynn's warriors, which is a nonprofit dedicated to stopping sex trafficking and abuse of women and girls. Response.
C
I am so sick and tired of, number one, the justice system not understanding about victims of crimes of abuse, rape, sexual exploitation. I am sick and tired all the time. Of going to court and seeing this over and over again, victim blaming. I am sick and tired of Dirty Diddy. That's exactly what he is. He's a pimp, he's a trafficker, he's a sexual offender. We have seen the pictures. We have heard from the women and some men. And I'm tired of having to explain to vulnerable people. Listen, just be a warrior. Listen, just keep speaking your truth. Listen, it's going to get better because it's not getting better.
A
So until we really address this, keep speaking your truth. You know what? Why bother? That's what victims and abuse victims are thinking tonight. Why bother? Why go through all the hassle of even calling the police, trying the case, reliving all the pain, being cross examined like you're nothing but dirt on the stand for a judge to then give a light sentence? Straight out to Troy Slayton, veteran defense attorney, joining us out of the LA jurisdiction. He's been on Diddy's side since day one. I guess you're happy tonight, right?
D
Nancy, I've never been on the side of Diddy, but what I am on the side of is justice and the rule of law. And what the judge did here was follow the sentencing guidelines. Although he could have been sentenced up to 20 years. In a perfect world for you, he was sentenced based on what he was convicted of, which was just the transportation for the purposes of prosecution.
A
Okay, you can stop right there. Of rape, you can stop right there because you are contorting the law. That is not the law. Sam Krupy joining me outside the courthouse. Sam, just a yes or no from you, please. Sam, Isn't it true that on each count he could have gotten 10 years and run consecutively, that would have been a 20 year sentence?
B
Yes, you are correct, Nancy. Yes.
A
So he was looking at 20 years behind bars, but the judge, in his wisdom, gave him 55, 0 months. Isn't it true that in court the defense was that Diddy, Sean Combs was actually the victim, that he had been, what, high for 24 years and that's why he did the things he did. Voluntary use of drugs or alcohol is not a defense, Sam.
B
No, it never is, Nancy. And I felt that the defense was using that, saying that because he had been a drug addict for over 25 years, that somehow that made beating women okay? You know, I know a lot of people have done drugs in their life and they've never raised a hand to a male or a female. So me personally hearing that, excuse the defense, using it, I mean, and again, he was doing Molly. Molly's supposed to make you loving and positive and all this stuff. Anyway. So obviously his violent, traumatic upbringing is what is really to blame for his disgusting behavior towards women.
A
Right. You're acting like you actually believe that his violent upgrade. He's a multimillionaire, he's living in the lap of luxury, yet he chose to use all of his advantage to hurt other people. And speaking of hurting other people, I want you to listen to what we've learned about the letter Cassie Ventura wrote the judge, which he totally ignored.
E
Cassie pens an emotional three page letter to Judge Subramaniam recalling that the entire world watched footage of Combs kicking and beating her as she tried to run away from a freak off. Though defense attorneys called her relationship with Combs a great modern love story, nothing could be further from the truth. It was a horrific decade stained by abuse, violence, forced sex and degradation from which she still suffers horrific nightmares and flashbacks that require psychological care.
A
Cassie Ventura actually moved out of the state of New York out of fear to a location where she's keeping her family and her children. She's not the only one in fear. Listen.
E
Several of Combs victims have written to the court urging against leniency for the rap mogul. Cassie and her parents, assistants Mia and Capricorn Clark, stylist Deontay Nash and personal chef Jordan Atkinson have all implored the judge to consider their safety. The full measure of Combs harm and Combs troubling lack of accountability as he hands down a sentence.
A
There was a warm and fuzzy video created by the defense team that was played in court. You brought up earlier, Sam, that there was nothing like that for any of the victims. What about the video created by Sean Combs defense team? What was it?
B
I mean, it felt like, I said, like a wedding video or a Nike video or something that you play at a tribute to somebody. A happy Father's Day, a 70th birthday party. But it felt totally inappropriate that they were even allowed to play this. And think about how many of us even have this much footage, this high quality footage shot of us that we could even edit together something like this. And I think you brought up a good point, Nancy. When the cameras are on, Mr. Combs, he knows how to put on that good act. But when he didn't know the cameras were on in that Intercontinental Hotel, I think we were seeing a little bit more of the real Sean Combs.
A
You know what? The dichotomy between what he did to Cassie in that video then paid about $100,000 to keep it quiet, to suppress it. That was the real Sean Combs. I guess the judge forgot about that. Speaking of the video that Sean Combs defense team used in court to snow the judge, here's part of it. Watch if you dare.
F
This is a heart. Because you my heart.
A
All right.
G
Okay.
F
You my heart.
A
Okay.
F
May God bless you and keep you happy and keep you thinking positive. Everything's not gonna be perfect at this time in life. And you. You good. You're a good person that understands reality. So we're gonna. We're gonna accentuate the positives in life. Cause you doing great, girl.
A
Bring me the bar.
H
It starts like any other night. The glass of red, the cozy blanket. Then the drop. The stain so dark, so stubborn, it might as well have been a crime scene. But this isn't your average couch. This is Anna Bay. Fully washable, unspeakably comfortable, and ready for whatever your life, your kids, or your existence rows ahead. And here's the kicker. Starting at just $6.99, you can make sure your sofa isn't part of the problem. Fully washable, stain resistant, and built to hide even the darkest defenses. Right now, get up to 60% off. Because no one should have to live with a stain that won't quit. Annabe the only mystery you won't be losing. Sleepover Shop washablesofas.com today, that's washablesofas.com.
A
Crime stories with Nancy Grace.
F
The heart. Cause you my heart.
A
All right. Okay.
F
You my heart.
A
Okay.
F
May God bless you and keep you happy and keep you thinking positive. Everything's not gonna be perfect at this time in life. And you good. You a good person that understands reality. So we're gonna. We're gonna accentuate the positives in life. Cause you doing great, girl.
A
Bring me the barf bag. Did you see that? Do you want to tell me that Sean Combs. Sean Combs has spent time with the elderly? Not just the elderly. You know who the little old lady is? That's Kim Porter's. Yes. Yes. That's Kim Porter's grandma. Yes. So he's totally using his dead ex lover and her children to get his sorry rear end, which is in a sling, out of jail. He is using the grandma.
B
Yeah. I mean, like I said, Nancy, the video was extremely odd. It was. It felt so inappropriate inside the courtroom. And again, the magic of editing. I think about that video without any music. It's like when we go to a movie and if you just see the actors with no music. But this video it pulls at your heartstrings because literally the orchestrated music is making you feel this emotion of a family man, a father, a hard worker. But again, like the judge said, it can't be overshadowed by the video of Cassie Ventura being stomped on, being kicked on, being dragged by her hair. You know, we can see all the cute wedding videos and editing is amazing. They have some beautiful shots here. But it's not going to get myself or the public, Nancy, to forget what the real crimes committed here were.
A
I don't believe Sean Combs has ever actually married anybody. Did you say wedding video?
B
Yeah, I mean the wedding video for the wedding he never had. But it feels like a wedding video.
A
It's a tribute. It's a tribute video.
B
A tribute video.
A
You know what, and I'm not the church lady. I don't care who marries who or who doesn't marry anybody. That's not a felony. So I really don't care. But speaking of Cassie Ventura, to Sydney Sumner, Joining us, crime stories investigative reporter. Give me a little reality check about what was done to Cassie Ventura.
I
Cassie was exploited, used and put in a box. She had essentially no career because Sean Palmes promised to give her one and then made her have sex with him for days on end. And other Sports giving her UTIs infections, sores, bruises and even cut her face. Just before a movie premiere, Sean Combs brutally attacked Kathy on a regular basis behind closed doors, in public. Prince's own security had to pull Combs off of Cassie at a house party. Everyone knew it was an open secret that Sean Combs was abusing Cassie Ventura for more than a decade. And no one did anything. Cassie threatened suicide at least three times during their relationship. Deontay Nash, her stylist, hid her in a hotel room. But his efforts were dashed when Combs employee showed up to bring Cassie back to him. She threatened to go over the balcony. That's how afraid Cassie was of Sean Combs. This was a waking nightmare for her for nearly 10 years. Years.
A
To Troy Slayton, a defense attorney joining us out of L. A who seems to stand by the judge's decision. The limp wristed judge who sentenced combs to just 50 months, now 36 months behind bars. Troy, this is a yes, no answer. You know what a UTI is? A urinary tract infection. Do you know what that is? Okay, so Cassaventura had so many urinary tract infections, mouth infections, ulcers all over her body that regular antibiotics. And this is because of all the freak offs, the sex acts. She was forced to perform bicombs on video at freakoffs that she didn't want to do. And yes, I know the jury did not come back guilty on sex trafficking, but no one ever cross examined her or impugned her credibility on those issues. So the judge ignored everything that was done to Cassave Ventura. Everything. It didn't amount to a hill of beans to him. Utis ulcers, Nancy.
D
When a jury doesn't convict somebody, that means not that they're innocent, but that they're not guilty of those things. If even one juror determines that, then it's a hung jury. But in this case, they found him not guilty. All 12 jurors agreed that the government failed to meet their burden.
A
But also.
D
What you're not talking about, that's not what I asked. You also imposed another part of the.
A
Sentence, not what I asked.
D
The judge sentenced him to a fine of a half a million dollars. $500,000.
A
He's already made that two times over from behind bars, renting out his private jet. Man, get with it. You know, Nancy, that means nothing to him.
D
Despite all the parade of horribles that you and all your guests have outlined.
A
Why are you calling it a parade of horribles? It was the evidence. I didn't bring it on. The victims brought it on. They testified.
D
Even the pre sentence report. That doesn't favor the prosecution. That doesn't favor the defendants. Came in at about six years. So the judge slightly from that, imposing.
A
You're answering that question. You're giving an answer because you don't like the answer to the question I asked you. Bethany Marshall, let me ask you, do you remember all the UTIs and the busted lips and the video of her getting dragged up and down the hall of Sean Combs and nothing but a towel. He didn't care what anybody thought. The beatings, the stomach ulcers, the mouth ulcers, the urinary tract infections. What the judge forgot about all that. It just happened a few weeks ago.
J
You know what happened in court today, Nancy, is there was a parallel process between how P. Diddy treated his victims and how the court treated the victims. What you have are materialistic, educated, older, powerful people who do not think that the victims deserve anything. Brutality was sanctioned today, just like during wars and other things like that where there's brutality and then all of a sudden it's rationalized or dissociated from as if brutality is. Okay, Nancy, the one thing you missed off the list is he actually smashed her head against. Was it a bed or a table and busted her lip wide open. He tried to stop her career. He gave her things, he took them away. I mean, maybe. What if we just use the word assault, blackmail and kidnapping with the victim hiding in plain sight? Does that make it easier for people to digest the reality?
A
Well, here's what's also confounding. Sam Krupen joining us, star of Samson's World on YouTube. At the very beginning, I had faith that there would be a substantial sentence because the judge said, hey, hey, I get to take into account everything I know about you, even the charges, the claims in the charges on which you were acquitted. But he didn't. He didn't do that. Sam, I want you to see in that video the way Combs used his own children today.
F
Now, I'm a full time dad and I'm going to be there for you. Do everything, all of y'. All. Every Sunday, I gotta slow everything down and do the family ritual. Get the family together. Make sure the girls watching church.
A
There is a definition of grace. What? A full time dad? No. He was all over the world practically every week doing free cough for two or three days. Even the night he got arrested. And he knew he was surrendering himself. He was having a freak off in a five star hotel in New York.
B
Yeah, I mean, Nancy, I think this is kind of illustrates almost the problem with social media. You know, we see people that are able to act like a good parent because you might see an Instagram post or a video of them being a good dad. But to me, the mark of a good father or mother is are you in that child's life every single day? You know, this wedding video we saw, it's a beautiful montage of his moments. I wish somebody could create a video like me to show how great of a father I am like this. But the facts remain. If you want to be a good parent, it's about every single day showing up. It's not about showing up in a video that is nicely put together with high production and great producers and editors. If you're going to be. You have to show up if you're going to be a parent.
H
It starts like any other night. The glass of red, the cozy blanket. Then the drop. The stain. So dark, so stubborn, it might as well have been a crime scene. But this isn't your average couch. This is Anna Bay. Fully washable, unspeakably comfortable, and ready for whatever your life, your kids or your ex throws at it. And here's the kicker. Starting at just $6.99, you can make sure your sofa isn't part of the problem. Fully washable, stain resistant, and built to hide even the darkest defenses. Right now, get up to 60% off because no one should have to live with a stain that won't quit. Anna Bay. The only mystery you won't be losing sleepover shop. Washablesofas.com today, that's Washablesofas.com.
A
Crime stories with Nancy Grace. I do not know what happened to this judge, but I do know this, women all over the world are crushed at this sentence. Hey, guys, I'm hearing in my ear. Joining me right now is Dr. Duane Hendricks, the former warden at MDC. He is the founder of the New Daylight foundation and he's the author of See it, say it, seize it. Dr. Hendricks, thank you for being with us. Tell me about Sean Combs. First night back at the MDC tonight. I understand he's having spaghetti and meatballs, salad and green beans. But guess what, Dr. Hendricks, Diddy doesn't like spaghetti. He's still upset. He wanted to walk free. He even had a speaking engagement set up for Monday in Miami. So tonight he's like, I don't want spaghetti.
G
It's gonna be very lonely. And I can tell you he did not receive a standing ovation when he got back. When he gets back to the jail. I'm not sure if he's back at the facility at this time right now. But I can tell you when he does get back, it's gonna be a cold meal. No matter how warm it is, it's going to taste cold to him. And he's not going to have a standing ovation. He just needs to, I think the euphoria of, you know, not having those other charges go against him, the racketeering and possibly having a life sentence. But his next plane ride, like we discussed in previous shows, his next plane ride is going to be on a Con Air flight with Martin chains and a black box. And it's not going to be on a private jet heading to Miami this weekend to prepare for this teaching engagement for on Monday in Miami. So it's going to be lonely. It's going to be cold. That's going to be a cold night. But hopefully his family will, as he say, he's a family man. So hopefully his family will be visiting with him this weekend and preparing him mentally for what's coming next, which is a three year sentence at a federal prison somewhere close to where he's going to release. And I want to clear something up. I keep hearing something about it. He'll be home in a year and a half. I used to do sentence calculations for a number of years. He is going to serve at least 28 more months in prison. So if he, if he gets his 54 days of good time, he'll get that. And he may spend about three to four months on home confinement as long as he behaves while he's at his next facility. But he will not be coming home in a year and a half. He will.
A
He'll be coming home happy about 28 months. Why do you even say 28 months? We all know that is two years and four months. I'm supposed to be happy about that? You know how many victims I've represented? How many ag assault victims I've represented that have been beaten like pimp beaten by pimps like Sean Combs? More than I can even remember. And it messes them up the rest of their lives. They are never the same. If they're lucky enough to have a family after that, they raise their children in a way that makes them raise their children in a way it never ends. That is what Combs did to these women and many, many more. They're lined up filing civil lawsuits with real evidence. Maybe they'll get a judge that actually listens to the evidence, unlike this. And another thing, Crouppen, if you're still with me, isn't it true Sean Combs had a speaking engagement set up for Monday? He was that arrogant to think he was walking today. Isn't it true he had a speaking engagement? Or as you keep saying, a teaching engagement, whatever, Monday in Miami.
B
I mean, look, it's a teaching engagement, Nancy, not a. There's a big difference between a speaking engagement and a teaching engagement. He was going to go to Miami, go to One Star island maybe, you know, pop a little bubbly and go to a teaching engagement. You know what?
A
I don't care what it is, Krupin. The point is. Hendricks, can you hear me? Dr. Hendricks? You're the warden. The former warden. He was so convinced he had this judge wrapped around his little finger that he was going to walk today. So I guess tonight he is. Over a 36 month sentence to him. That's probably like life behind bars.
G
It is. And it's his. His arrogance just continued to go on and on and on. But now I think reality is going to set in, especially in about a month. And they shouldn't tell him. They're not supposed to tell him where he's going, but he'll be moving. I'm sure they're going to be moving him out of Brooklyn within the next 30 to 45 days to his designated facility. And if he doesn't get the point, I guarantee you when he is shackled and put on that plane for several hours until he gets to where he's going, the reality is going to set in that all this euphoria from coming down off those other charges, not being convicted, he's going to realize that he is now a convicted felon. So there won't be any speaking teaching engagements. I'm sorry. Anytime soon. And I'll tell you this. He's been teaching these entrepreneurship classes, but the true test is going to be.
A
Please stop talking about the classes he's, quote, teaching behind bars are called. It's all about me, Diddy. Enough about me. What do you think about me? I mean, I don't want to hear about what he's teaching behind bars. He and beat these women. He was convicted on two counts of the Mann Act. Each one has a 10 year sentence. He could have gotten 10 on each to run consecutively. That's 20 years. Instead, he will walk, most likely in less than 36 months. 36 months, max. That's what happened in court. That is what happened in the court that tried Sean Combs. Tonight, women all over the country, victims, beating victims, sex trafficking victims, have taken it on the chin again. Thanks, Judge. You had it all right here. You could have sent a message to abusers and rapists, but you didn't. You talk the talk, Judge. Oh, yes, you did. And for a moment, I believed you. But you did not walk the walk. You probably don't want to hear it, but I'm telling you the truth, Judge. You failed. You are the weak link in the judicial system. You and you had the power, just like Combs had all the power, all the advantage, and he squandered it on a life of victimizing women. I want to thank all of our guests for being with us tonight. But first, I want to remember heroes, heroes that come forward and they fight the good fight, even knowing very well they may lose women against all odds that speak out. And I beg you ladies, keep fighting the good fight, because to me, you are the American hero. Nancy Grace signing off for tonight. Good night, friend. This is an I Heart podcast.
Episode: DIDDY SKATES HARD JAIL TIME WITH SLAP ON WRIST, HELL REJOICES
Date: October 5, 2025
Podcast Host: Nancy Grace
Panelists: Sam Krupen, Lynn Shaw, Troy Slayton, Sydney Sumner, Dr. Duane Hendricks, Bethany Marshall
Nancy Grace passionately dissects the outcome of Sean "Diddy" Combs’ criminal trial, focusing on the public outrage following his unexpectedly lenient sentence. The episode spotlights the disparity between the horrific allegations and testimonials presented in court—abuse, violence, forced sex, and psychological trauma—and the comparatively light punishment handed down by the judge. Grace is joined by an all-star panel, including journalists, an anti-trafficking activist, a defense attorney, and a former prison warden, to discuss systemic failings, victims’ continued suffering, and the role of privilege and fame in the justice system.
Nancy Grace opens with disbelief that Diddy received only a 50-month sentence after an “eight-week trial,” where victims vividly testified to systematic abuse:
Sam Krupen, investigative journalist who attended the trial, likens the sentencing to grounding a teenager for a month after a major misdeed—posting:
Lynn Shaw, anti-trafficking activist, expresses exhaustion with victims being let down by the system:
Nancy furthers: "Why go through all the hassle...for a judge to then give a light sentence?" (03:45)
Troy Slayton, defense attorney, tries to justify the judge’s decision by citing guidelines; Nancy and Sam point out that Combs could have legally received up to 20 years.
Defense strategy argued Diddy was a long-term drug addict, not a predator.
Dramatic reading from Cassie Ventura’s letter to the judge, recalling a decade of violence and trauma:
Multiple victims and their families wrote to the court, begging for a real sentence due to fear and trauma.
The defense played a highly produced video in court portraying Combs as a loving family man, which Nancy and Sam describe as manipulative and inappropriate:
Nancy: "He is using the grandma" of his deceased ex-partner in his favor (11:28).
Notable quote:
Sydney Sumner, investigative reporter, paints a devastating picture of the abuse Cassie endured:
Nancy details Cassie's medical trauma (UTIs, ulcers, bruises) as a result of prolonged abuse.
Dr. Duane Hendricks, former warden, describes Combs’ first night post-sentencing as “very lonely” and foresees no royal treatment.
He offers a sentence calculation: Combs will serve "at least 28 more months" (23:58)—a timeline that Nancy still calls insufficient for the scale of the harm.
"[For Diddy,] the max he's looking at is 36 months ... he's going to walk in about, what would you say? Two years."
– Nancy Grace (00:36)
"He's a pimp, he's a trafficker, he's a sexual offender...I'm sick and tired of Dirty Diddy."
– Lynn Shaw (03:13)
"…because he had been a drug addict for over 25 years, that somehow that made beating women okay?"
– Sam Krupen (05:53)
"It was a horrific decade stained by abuse, violence, forced sex..."
– Cassie Ventura (letter, read at 06:58)
"There was a parallel process between how P. Diddy treated his victims and how the court treated the victims. Brutality was sanctioned today..."
– Bethany Marshall (18:07)
"I beg you ladies, keep fighting the good fight, because to me, you are the American hero."
– Nancy Grace (28:44)
| Segment | Timestamp | |------------------------------------------|-------------| | Sentencing Announcement & Breakdown | 00:00–02:41 | | Panel: Systemic Failing & Victim Blaming | 02:41–03:45 | | Legal Arguments, Defense Strategy | 04:30–06:28 | | Victim Impact Letters Read | 06:28–07:57 | | Defense’s Video, Image Management | 07:57–13:17 | | Details of Cassie Ventura’s Abuse | 13:17–16:21 | | Jury Verdict, Moral Implications | 16:21–18:07 | | Family Montage & Parental Imagery | 19:03–21:04 | | Diddy’s First Night in Prison | 22:04–24:44 | | Nancy’s Call to Action/Closer | 27:44–End |
The episode is highly emotional, urgent, and direct—punctuated by Nancy’s characteristic outrage at perceived injustice. The panel’s comments are raw, pointed, and unfiltered, interspersed with both bitter humor and despair at the legal outcome and its implications for survivors.
Nancy Grace’s “Crime Stories” episode delivers a scorching critique of the justice system’s handling of high-profile abusers, using Diddy’s case as a prime example of failed accountability. Despite abundant and compelling victim testimony, Grace and guests lament a culture and judiciary that repeatedly lets abusers "skate," all while women are left to pick up the pieces. The episode captures the emotional devastation of survivors, the defense’s strategic manipulation, and the lasting need for societal and systemic change. Ultimately, Nancy calls listeners—especially women—not to be discouraged, demanding continued courage in the face of injustice.