Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: DNA Evidence Solves 1964 New York Cold Case | Crime Alert 6AM 10.21.25
Date: October 21, 2025

Episode Overview

Nancy Grace delivers the latest breaking crime news in a rapid-fire format, spotlighting three unfolding cases: the suspected murder of a missing Philadelphia woman, a campus shooting at Oklahoma State University during Homecoming, and the search for a missing 15-year-old boy in Pennsylvania. The episode is marked by urgent updates, official statements, and appeals for public assistance, all delivered with Grace’s trademark gravitas and urgency.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Discovery of Human Remains in Philadelphia: Kada Scott Case

• Reporter: Nicole Parton
• Segment Time: 00:00–03:44

Sequence of Events

• Human remains discovered near an abandoned middle school during search for Kada Scott, missing nursing home worker.
• John Stanford, Philadelphia P.D. Deputy Commissioner, detailed how an anonymous tip led authorities to a shallow grave in a wooded area behind Ada Lewis Middle School (Germantown neighborhood).

Official Statements

• The remains are believed to be female, but confirmation awaiting medical examiner’s report.
• Kada Scott last seen October 4th; reported missing by family on October 5th.
• Significant volunteer turnout during searches, indicating widespread community concern.

Suspect Information

• Keon King, 21, apprehended October 14th on kidnapping and reckless endangerment charges.
  • Evidence indicates prior contact with Scott.
  • He is also a suspect in a previous kidnapping case (previously dismissed due to witness nonappearance, now reopened).

Key Procedural Points

• Police previously found items belonging to Scott (iPad case, name card, glasses) in the search area.
• The discovery of remains was directly prompted by a tip submitted anonymously via the police tip line.
• Ongoing investigation into any other possible victims associated with King.

Community/Family Response

• Police statement: "This is a tragic development and our hearts go out to K’s family and friends during this incredible time." (01:31)
• Stanford underscores the vital role of the anonymous tip and ongoing communication with Scott’s family.

Memorable Quotes

• "All indications at this point is that it's a female." — Deputy Commissioner John Stanford (00:50)
• "We are not going to confirm at this point that it is Ms. Kada Scott because that has to be done by the medical examiner's office." — John Stanford (01:13)
• "We are not certain if there are other victims connected to this individual we have in custody." — John Stanford (02:52)
• "We do not know the identity of the tipster, but we are thankful for their submission that directed us there." — John Stanford (03:37)

2. Oklahoma State University Dorm Shooting

• Reporter: Nicole Parton
• Segment Time: 04:55–07:44

Incident Summary

• Active shooter at East Residential Hall, OSU Stillwater, during Homecoming weekend.
• At least three injured, one confirmed student hospitalized; injuries treated in Oklahoma City and Tulsa.

Timeline & Details

• Shooting occurred around 3:40 AM; police dispatched immediately.
• Shooting linked to an earlier large, private off-campus party.
• Chaotic student response: "students fleeing from the building, even jumping from a balcony" (05:59).

Official Response

• Law enforcement assures no ongoing threat to campus as investigation continues.
• Suspect status undisclosed; no confirmation if any injured were suspects.

Policy and Safety Reminder

• OSU’s strict weapons ban emphasized: “students, faculty and staff... can best learn, work and live in an environment free from dangers... which can arise upon unauthorized weapons...” (07:26).
• Students advised to avoid the East Residential area unless residing there.

3. Missing Juvenile: Dominic Caesar Case (Pennsylvania)

• Reporter: Nicole Parton
• Segment Time: 07:26–07:44

Case Details

• Dominic Caesar, 15, last seen running away from brother at Pen Hills Park, State College Township.
• Description: 5’7”, 175 lbs, wearing black sweatpants, gray sweatshirt, black/gray sneakers.
• Family "extremely worried" per Facebook post.

Appeal to Public

• Police urge anyone with information to contact the State College Police Department: 814-234-7150.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Anonymous Community Involvement:
  "We do not know the identity of the tipster, but we are thankful for their submission that directed us there."
  — John Stanford (03:37)

• On Possible Additional Victims:
  "We are not certain if there are other victims connected to this individual we have in custody."
  — John Stanford (02:52)

• Student Reactions to Campus Shooting:
  "A student residing in east heard multiple gunshots early Sunday morning and observed students fleeing from the building, even jumping from a balcony."
  — Nicole Parton (05:59)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Philadelphia Remains Discovery – Nicole Parton & John Stanford: 00:00–03:44
• Oklahoma State University Dorm Shooting: 04:55–07:26
• Missing 15-Year-Old in PA: 07:26–07:44

Episode Tone & Style

• Urgent, Compassionate, and Direct: Nancy Grace and correspondents maintain a tone of urgency, authority, and compassion for victims and their families.
• Emphasis on Public Engagement: Strong appeals for information and community support are woven throughout.
• Straightforward Reporting: Each story is delivered with minimal speculation, grounded in verified statements and facts.

For more updates and to assist ongoing investigations, listeners are encouraged to visit CrimeOnline.com.

Nancy closes with her signature call to action:
"We do our best to find missing people, especially children, and help solve unsolved homicides." (07:44)