Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: DNA Ties Deceased Suspect to 1991 Texas Yogurt Shop Murders | Crime Alert 6AM 10.28.25
Date: October 28, 2025

Episode Overview

In this episode of Crime Stories, Nancy Grace delivers rapid-fire updates on ongoing and breaking crime stories from across the U.S., emphasizing missing children and recent violent events. The show conveys urgency and emotional depth as it highlights family perspectives and law enforcement statements. While the episode is titled around the Texas Yogurt Shop Murders breakthrough, the transcript mainly covers the high-profile disappearance of Melody Buzzard, a fatal college shooting in Pennsylvania, and a cold case disappearance of Aiden Clune.

Key Discussion Points and Case Breakdowns

1. Update on Missing 9-Year-Old Melody Buzzard

[00:06–02:48]

• Timeline of Disappearance:
  • Missing for weeks before being reported by a school administrator.
  • Last seen October 7, disguised in a wig and hoodie at a rental car agency.
  • Mother, Ashley Buzzard, rented a white Chevy Malibu and embarked on a cross-country trip from California to Nebraska, stopping in Kansas.
  • Returned to California alone on October 10; Melody was not with her.
• Investigation Details:
  • Ashley is uncooperative, providing only outdated photos and scant information.
  • Investigators are focused on a critical three-day window to determine Melody's disappearance.
  • Recent surveillance photos evoke family recognition.
  • Melody's family, including her grandmother and aunt, are emotionally invested, expressing longing and love.
• Family Statements:
  • Grandmother Lily Deans issues a poignant public message urging Melody to reach out.
  • Melody's aunt emotionally recalls her features and connection to her late father.
• Ongoing Search:
  • The FBI and Santa Barbara County Sheriff’s Office are actively soliciting public tips.
  • Melody is described as 4–4’6” tall, 60–100 lbs.
  • The case is entering its second week without leads.

Notable Quotes:

• “If she's listening, we love you. We're here for you... Call me. The numbers are on the TV that you can call and I will come pick you up.” – Lily Deans, Melody's grandmother [01:39]
• “We haven't seen her in four and a half years... But that nose definitely reminds me of her dad's.” – Melody’s aunt [02:03]

2. Lincoln University Homecoming Shooting

[04:29–06:01]

• Incident:
  • Shooting at college homecoming in Pennsylvania outside the International Cultural Center, October 25, 9:30pm.
  • Scene described as chaotic, with at least one dead and six injured.
• Investigation:
  • One suspect arrested with a firearm; charges pending.
  • Potential involvement of multiple shooters is suggested.
  • Authorities currently do not suspect a premeditated mass attack.
• University Response:
  • Counseling offered to students and staff.
  • Campus area cordoned off; investigation ongoing.

Notable Quotes:

• “We're proceeding under the assumption that this was not a deliberate attempt to cause mass harm on a college campus.” – Chester County District Attorney Christopher Sarob [05:27]

3. Cold Case: Missing Teenager Aiden Clune

[06:01–06:45]

• Case Summary:
  • 19-year-old Aiden Clune leaves California for Utah, then to Nevada.
  • Last seen checking out of a Nevada hotel; his truck and belongings later discovered abandoned near Cherry Creek Mountains.
  • Footprints traceable 10 miles into the mountains before weather erased the trail.
• Background:
  • Clune was reportedly struggling with depression amid the pandemic.
  • Disappearance remains unsolved after three years; public tips are encouraged.

Timestamps for Important Segments

• Melody Buzzard Case & Family Appeal: 00:06–02:48
• Lincoln University Homecoming Shooting: 04:29–06:01
• Cold Case – Aiden Clune: 06:01–06:45

Memorable Moments & Quotes

• "If she's listening, we love you. We're here for you. We can help. We want you to be happy. Call me. The numbers are on the TV..." – Lily Deans, [01:39]
• "She...reminds me of her dad's. So yeah, she, it does look like her." – Melody's aunt, [02:03]
• "We're proceeding under the assumption that this was not a deliberate attempt to cause mass harm on a college campus." – DA Christopher Sarob, [05:27]

Summary & Tone

Nancy Grace’s Crime Alert delivers focused, emotionally resonant updates on startling and unresolved criminal cases. The host and correspondents maintain an urgent, compassionate, and advocacy-driven tone, especially when discussing missing children and the impact on families. The episode calls for public engagement and vigilance, highlighting both hope and frustration in the search for answers.

For further details or to provide tips on featured cases, visit crimeonline.com.