Podcast Summary: Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: FBI Hitting AZ Gun Dealers w "Hit List" of Suspects in Search of TODAY Star's Missing Mom | Crime Alert 6AM 02.19.2026
Date: February 19, 2026
Host: Jennifer Gould (Crime Alert segment for Nancy Grace)
Duration of analyzed content: Approx. 00:00–07:56

Main Theme & Episode Overview

This episode delivers a high-intensity, fast-paced breakdown of three major crime stories making headlines. The lead story details a sweeping FBI investigation into the abduction of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, mother of TODAY co-host Savannah Guthrie. It also covers a shocking survival tale of a woman who outwitted her would-be murderer in Oregon and a bizarre, high-speed arrest of a tourist in Florida. The tone is urgent and dramatic, aimed at informing and alarming listeners about the day’s most harrowing and unusual crimes.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. The Kidnapping of Nancy Guthrie – Arizona FBI Dragnet

(00:00–03:22)

• Massive FBI Manhunt:

  • Federal agents are conducting a widespread search across Arizona gun stores.
  • They have distributed a three-page "hit list" with 18-24 potential suspect names and photos, specifically targeting gun dealers.
  • Philip Martin, co-owner of Armor Bearer Arms, recounts the FBI's visit and the process of searching his records:

    "There was probably six or seven names. There was six or seven people per sheet. And so I just went through each sheet, all three sheets and I typed in the last name and nothing popped up." (Philip Martin, 00:38)

• Key Timeline & Evidence:

  • Nancy Guthrie disappeared at 2:28am inside her Tucson estate on February 1.
  • Her pacemaker disconnected from a monitoring app minutes after a NEST camera at her front door was tampered with—indicating a calculated abduction.
  • The armed suspect (described as 5'9"–5'10", average build, with facial hair) was captured on video wearing a black ski mask, zip-up fleece, and carrying an Ozark Trail hiker pack from Walmart.

• Investigative Actions:

  • The FBI is cross-referencing gun shop records and collaborating with retailers like Walmart to trace the purchase of items used by the suspect, including a holster and the distinctive backpack.
  • Despite recovering gloves two miles away from the scene, DNA analysis yielded no matches in the FBI’s national CODIS database, forcing investigators to broaden efforts.
  • They are working with Mexican authorities, fearing a possible border crossing through the Arizona desert.

• Notable Quotes:

  "That might be the only piece of evidence that shows up that can put two and two together. It could be very significant."
  —Bob Krieger, Retired Pima County Lieutenant & SWAT Commander (02:07)

• Urgency & Public Appeal:

  • The investigation remains high-profile with a $200,000 reward for information.
  • Public urged to contact 1-800-CALL-FBI or the Pima County Sheriff’s Department.

2. Oregon Delivery Assault — Survival Through Wit

(04:25–07:05)

• Incident Overview:

  • Daniel Ray Myers, age 62, transformed a routine delivery into a violent, mobile crime scene in Salem, Oregon.
  • Lured an unsuspecting woman, committed sexual assault, and stabbed her multiple times after she resisted.

• Victim’s Ordeal and Clever Escape:

  • Despite grave injuries, the victim convinced Myers to take her to a Walgreens, claiming she needed medical supplies.
  • Upon arrival, store staff noticed her wounds and called 911.
  • Police launched a multi-state manhunt; Myers was ultimately apprehended in California without incident.

• Consequences:

  • Myers faces attempted second-degree murder and multiple sexual assault charges, awaiting extradition back to Oregon.

• Memorable Details:

  "She negotiated with her own executioner. Displaying ice cold composure while suffering from multiple puncture wounds, the victim convinced a delusional Meyers that she needed first aid items..." (Host narration, 04:25)

3. Super Speeder Tourist in Florida

(07:05–07:56)

• Incident Details:

  • Boaz Sinooani, a tourist from Israel, was caught driving 114 mph in a Honda Accord on Interstate 95.
  • When stopped, he explained he was rushing from Miami to New York to catch a flight.

• Law Enforcement’s Response:

  • The deputy reacts incredulously to his excuse:

    "You didn't pull over. You're going 114 miles an hour in and out of traffic. You're going to New York. You're going to be late." (Deputy, 07:05)

  • Sinooani was charged under Florida's “Super Speeder” law and held at Sheriff Perry Hall Inmate Detention Facility.

• Humorous Takeaway:

  "Boaz thought he could turn his rental into a rocket ship, claiming highways back home have no speed limits. He quickly realized, though, that when you're racing for a flight, the law has more turbulence." (Host narration, 07:15)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On FBI Methods:

  "While Martin found no hits in his system, the FBI confirmed to him they are canvassing every weapon dealer in the region to ID the gunman..." (Host, 00:49)

• Retired SWAT Commander on Evidence:

  "That might be the only piece of evidence that shows up that can put two and two together. It could be very significant."
  —Bob Krieger (02:07)

• Survivor’s Resourcefulness:

  "She negotiated with her own executioner... Displaying ice cold composure while suffering from multiple puncture wounds..." (Host, 05:00)

• Humor in Speeding Arrest:

  "Boaz thought he could turn his rental into a rocket ship... He quickly realized, though, that when you're racing for a flight, the law has more turbulence." (Host, 07:15)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 00:00 – FBI launches Arizona gun store dragnet in Guthrie abduction case
• 00:38 – Interview with Philip Martin, gun store co-owner
• 02:07 – Analysis by Bob Krieger, retired SWAT commander
• 03:22 – Kidnapping story wraps, transitions to Salem assault
• 04:25 – The Oregon delivery assault and victim’s survival strategy
• 07:05 – Body cam audio from Florida speeding arrest
• 07:56 – Close of content segment

Summary

This Crime Alert update delivers three chilling, high-alert crime stories: the exhaustive FBI efforts to locate a missing high-profile Arizona grandmother, the harrowing escape of a woman from a determined attacker in Oregon, and the comedic but serious arrest of a tourist speeding through Florida. The episode is rich in detail and urgency, punctuated by expert commentary and moments of both grim determination and unexpected levity.

If you have tips on the Guthrie case, contact 1-800-CALL-FBI or the Pima County Sheriff's Department at 520-351-4900.

For daily in-depth coverage and real-time crime alerts, follow "Crime Stories with Nancy Grace."