Crime Stories with Nancy Grace
Episode: FL Man Arrested in Cold Case Murder of “Peaches” Once Linked to Gilgo Beach Serial Killings | Crime Alert 6AM 12.07.25
Date: December 8, 2025
Episode Overview
Nancy Grace delves into major breaking crime stories, with a special focus on the long-unsolved 1997 murder of a woman known as “Peaches,” whose remains were once tied to the infamous Gilgo Beach investigation. The episode covers the recent arrest in this cold case, updates on related cases, and moves through other significant crime and justice news.
Key Discussion Points & Insights
1. Major Break in the "Peaches" Cold Case
[00:00–02:15]
-
Nicole Parton's Report:
- The 1997 killing of an unidentified young woman in a Long Island state park remained a cold case. She was known as “Peaches” because the only unique identifier was a tattoo of a peach.
- In 2011, while searching near Gilgo Beach, authorities found additional skeletal remains—including those of her 2-year-old daughter—which became linked to the wider, high-profile Gilgo Beach serial killings.
- Key Development:
- This week, police arrested Andrew Dykes, age 66, in Tampa, Florida, for the murder of Tanya Denise Jackson (previously known only as “Peaches”).
- Dykes is confirmed to be the father of Jackson’s daughter, Tatiana Marie Jackson. He is currently awaiting extradition to Long Island.
- The Nassau County District Attorney's office declined to comment; Dyke's lawyer has not been named.
- New identity confirmation came earlier this year through advanced DNA and genealogy. Jackson was 26 at the time of her murder, a Gulf War veteran originally from Mobile, Alabama, estranged from family, and living in Brooklyn with her daughter.
- Quote:
- “Her body was dismembered, left unidentifiable except for a tattoo of a peach. That changed in 2011 when investigators searching near Gilgo beach uncovered new skeletal fragments and the remains of her two year old daughter.” — Nicole Parton, [00:07]
-
Forensic Expert Adds:
- The crucial legal issue hinges on whether enough evidence exists to classify the infant’s death as murder based on skeletal remains.
- Quote:
- “What it comes down to is was there enough to show from the skeletal remains of the infant that there was a murder? … You have manner of death and cause of death.” — Forensic Expert, [01:37]
-
No Link to Other Killings:
- Police state no apparent link exists between Dykes and Rex Heuermann, the man charged with several Gilgo Beach murders.
- Ten sets of remains were found in the area, suggesting more than one perpetrator may have used these grounds.
- Additional details expected as Dykes is extradited to New York.
- Quote:
- “Officials say there is no apparent link between Dykes and Rex Heuermann, the Long island architect charged in seven of the Gilgo beach murders.” — Nicole Parton, [01:47]
2. Update: Conviction of Trinity Pogue in Child Murder Case
[04:41–06:47]
- Story Recap and Sentencing:
- Trinity Pogue, a former Miss Donaldsonville, was convicted on five charges, including two counts of felony murder, for the killing of a young boy, Romeo Angeles (aka Jaxton Drew), at Georgia Southwestern State University.
- Sentenced to life imprisonment plus 20 years (to run concurrently); parole eligibility in 30 years.
- Judge James Sizemore Jr. commented on the gravity of the sentence.
- Prosecutors alleged Pogue harbored resentment towards the child, wanting a baby with her boyfriend (the child's father), and described the death as involving blunt force trauma.
- Dorm students heard persistent crying from the child, which abruptly stopped.
- Pogue lost her pageant title after being charged.
- Quote:
- “I don't usually elaborate on handing down a sentence. However, the reality is that you will serve a life sentence which is fitting for the crimes you've been found guilty of.” — Judge James Sizemore Jr. (read by Nicole Parton), [04:56]
- “We knew we heard crying and then all of a sudden it stopped. Did a baby die?” — Lily Waterman, student, [06:24]
3. Missing Person: Kimberly Moore
[06:47–07:35]
- Crime Reporter’s Appeal:
- Kimberly Moore disappeared over a year ago after her partner, Vernon Parker, was shot dead in his car in Ringo, Louisiana.
- Moore was last seen at a New Year’s Eve party; police believe she may have witnessed the shooting.
- A call to listeners for information on her whereabouts.
- Quote:
- “Police now believe Kimberly Moore may have witnessed Parker’s shooting and could be in danger or worse. Kimberly Moore now missing over a year.” — Crime Reporter, [07:11]
Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments
-
On the Case’s Breakthrough:
- “Her body was dismembered, left unidentifiable except for a tattoo of a peach.” — Nicole Parton, [00:07]
-
Forensic Doubts Raised:
- “What it comes down to is was there enough to show from the skeletal remains of the infant that there was a murder?” — Forensic Expert, [01:37]
-
Clarity on Suspect Connection:
- “Officials say there is no apparent link between Dykes and Rex Heuermann…” — Nicole Parton, [01:47]
-
On Justice Being Served:
- “You will serve a life sentence which is fitting for the crimes you’ve been found guilty of.” — Judge James Sizemore Jr., [04:56]
-
Student Remembrance:
- “We knew we heard crying and then all of a sudden it stopped. Did a baby die?” — Lily Waterman, [06:24]
Important Segment Timestamps
| Segment | Timestamps | |-----------------------------------------------|-----------------| | Update on “Peaches” Case & [Andrew Dykes] | 00:00–02:15 | | Trinity Pogue Sentencing & Child Murder Case | 04:41–06:47 | | Kimberly Moore Missing Persons Appeal | 06:47–07:35 |
Conclusion
This episode of Crime Stories with Nancy Grace highlights a remarkable step toward resolution in a decades-old murder case, updates listeners on high-profile convictions, and calls for public assistance in ongoing missing person investigations. With the power of new forensic technology and determined investigative work, long-dormant crimes are being brought to light, justice delivered, and the search for the missing continues.