Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Crime Alert Recap - November 22, 2025:

INFANT, CHILD AND 2 ADULTS DEAD IN APPARENT OHIO MURDER-SUICIDE

Episode Overview

This episode delivers a rapid-fire rundown of some of the most disturbing and headline-making crimes around the U.S., focusing primarily on a tragic suspected murder-suicide in Ohio that left an infant, a young child, and two adults dead. The episode, through quick investigative reporting and expert commentary, also recaps shocking criminal cases involving gun violence, celebrity crime, domestic betrayal, mental health in the justice system, and bizarre police calls.

Key Stories & Discussion Points

1. Apparent Ohio Murder-Suicide – Four Dead Including Two Children

[02:59–04:13]

• Summary:
  Dave Mack reports a heartbreaking murder-suicide in Tiffin, Ohio. Four are found dead: an infant, a 7-year-old boy, and two adult males (including the shooter, Ryan Egan). The only survivor is a traumatized adult woman and mother of the two children.

• Incident details:

  • The mother was moving out due to ongoing domestic issues.
  • Dustin Willey (father of the 7-year-old) was helping her move.
  • Ryan Egan (father of the infant) allegedly “chased and fired multiple shots at Willey,” then “shot both children before shooting at Willey again and finally killing himself.”
  • The mother tried to save her children, carrying them inside before help arrived.

• Outcomes:

  • Willey and the 7-year-old died at the hospital.
  • The 7-month-old infant and suspect Egan were dead at the scene.
  • The tragedy remains under investigation by Tiffin Police and the Ohio Bureau of Criminal Investigation.

• Notable Quote:

  • “Officers discover four victims suffering from gunshot wounds and an adult female who was physically uninjured but clearly in a state of shock, overwhelmed and visibly traumatized.” — Dave Mack [03:06]

2. New York Self-Defense Shooting: Retired Doorman Faces Prison

[04:13–06:10]

• Summary:
  Drew Nelson covers the legal saga of Charles Foner, a 67-year-old retired doorman who faces four years in prison after firing an unlicensed revolver in a fatal late-night confrontation. Despite claiming self-defense, Foner faced numerous weapons charges due to an unlicensed arsenal in his home.

• Incident details:

  • Victim (Cody Gonzalez), with 15 prior arrests and a history of mental illness, advanced on Foner with what was believed to be a weapon (later, just a pen).
  • Surveillance confirmed the physical threat.
  • Foner had a large collection of unlicensed firearms.
  • Foner’s lawyer, Thomas Kniff, criticized NY state gun laws.

• Notable Quotes:

  • “If this was a state in a city that had its affairs in order, Mr. Foner would be getting a plaque, not a prison sentence.” — Thomas Kniff [06:01]
  • “I pulled the gun out of my pocket. It didn’t go off accidentally. I emptied the revolver.” — Charles Foner, via prosecutors [06:08]

3. Fugees Musician Praz Sentenced for Political Influence Scheme

[06:10–08:55]

• Summary:
  Reporting covers the conviction and 14-year sentence of Pras Michel (of the Fugees) for funneling foreign money into U.S. politics and acting as an unregistered agent. The case featured high-profile figures as witnesses and highlighted international attempts at unlawful U.S. political influence.

• Incident details:

  • Over $100M accepted from Malaysian billionaire Jho Low.
  • Straw donors used to reach Obama’s 2012 campaign.
  • Also involved attempts to influence the Trump administration regarding Jho Low.
  • Pras’s defense team called sentence “completely disproportionate.”
  • Attempted a new trial, alleging use of AI for closing arguments.

• Notable Quote:

  • “[He] betrayed his country for money and lied unapologetically and unrelentingly to carry out his schemes.” — Prosecutors [07:29]

4. Heartwarming Pig Rescue after Albuquerque Highway Chase

[08:55–09:36]

• Summary:
  Amid heavy crime content, a brief lighthearted moment tracks a runaway pig, Boris, rescued by police after interrupting New Mexico traffic and adopted by a loving family.

• Notable Quote:

  • “When we saw him running, we just saw his little spirit and how hard he was working to survive and we just knew that he would fit right in with our pig.” — Catherine Henchman [09:27]

5. Cheerleader's Mysterious Death on Cruise – Suspect Stepbrother

[10:29–11:56]

• Summary:
  Nicole Parton details the death of Anna Kepner, 17, on a cruise ship: strangled via “bar hold,” found hidden under a bed. No arrests yet, but suspicion falls on her 16-year-old stepbrother, noted as having a disturbing obsession and history of menacing behavior.

• Key Details:

  • No sexual assault or substance involvement.
  • Family inner turmoil and custody battles.
  • Her mother prevented from attending funeral.

• Notable Quote:

  • “Her body was discovered hidden under a bed, wrapped in a blanket and covered with life vest.” — Nicole Parton [11:17]

6. Double Homicide: American Idol Music Exec & Husband Slain

[11:56–15:05; 18:51]

• Summary:
  A “drifter” in LA is ruled unfit for trial in the execution-style murders of Emmy-nominated music supervisor Robin K and her husband Thomas DeLuca. The suspect, Raymond Budarian, previously released multiple times despite prior violence.

• Key Details:

  • Victims killed at home after grocery shopping; their bodies undiscovered for days.
  • Suspect contacted police himself, helping track him.
  • Found incompetent, transferred to psychiatric hospital.
  • Potential death penalty; next hearing scheduled.

• Notable Quotes:

  • “For the most part he’s just a kid that’s just dealing with... mental issues.” — Sandy Osuna, neighbor [12:20]
  • “Anytime you have murders that are filed and special circumstances, you know we are dealing with a serious, serious case.” — Prosecutor [13:07]

7. Wrestler Lured to Death by Ex-Wife and Her Lover

[18:51–20:35]

• Summary:
  A pro wrestler, Kevin Nicholl (stage name: Ivan Warsaw), is killed days after his divorce was finalized, allegedly lured to a remote location by his ex-wife (Amanda Penny) and her boyfriend, who then shot him.

• Key Details:

  • Ex-wife is pregnant; both suspects held on high bond.
  • Alleged scheme to lure through fake reconciliation.

• Notable Quote:

  • “You know it doesn’t bring him back, but just knowing that they’re not running around… makes me feel really good.” — Kevin Pendergraff, friend [19:52]

8. Hot Tub Tryst Turns to Assault

[20:35–21:55]

• Summary:
  A domestic incident in Arkansas escalates after a planned ménage à trois ends with Angel Curl allegedly physically assaulting her boyfriend when plans were canceled.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On legal ambiguity and self-defense:
  “If this was a state in a city that had its affairs in order, Mr. Foner would be getting a plaque, not a prison sentence.” — Thomas Kniff (attorney), [06:01]

• On the aftermath of family annihilation:
  “Officers discover four victims suffering from gunshot wounds and an adult female who was physically uninjured but clearly in a state of shock…” — Dave Mack, [03:06]

• Concerning the failed mental health system:
  “For the most part he’s just a kid that’s just dealing with… mental issues.” — Sandy Osuna, neighbor, [12:20]

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Ohio Murder-Suicide: [02:59–04:13]
• NY Retired Doorman Shooting: [04:13–06:10]
• Fugees’ Praz Sentencing: [06:10–08:55]
• Runaway Pig Rescue: [08:55–09:36]
• Cruise Ship Cheerleader Death: [10:29–11:56]
• LA Music Exec Double Homicide: [11:56–15:05]
• Wrestler Lured & Killed by Ex: [18:51–20:35]
• Domestic Battery After Hot Tub Tryst: [20:35–21:55]

Tone and Style

The episode maintains a direct, hard-news reporting tone, moving briskly from case to case with brief but impactful details. Emotional sensibility surfaces in descriptions of victims and affected families, while a moment of levity is provided in the pig rescue story. Analysis and commentary are woven into the reporting, featuring victim and lawyer quotes that highlight broader societal concerns about justice, mental health, and the consequences of violence.

In Summary

This Crime Alert Recap episode offers a fast-paced, detail-rich briefing on headline-grabbing cases, bookended by shocking violence and a rare note of animal rescue warmth. Listeners are left with crucial details on each crime, memorable moments of legal and personal commentary, and a sense of the far-reaching impact of crime in American communities.