Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: Killer Husband Brian Walshe Twists in Court as Wife's Lover Takes the Stand, Jury Brings Down the Hammer

Date: January 24, 2026
Host: Nancy Grace
Notable Guests: Bob Ward, Tom Ruskin, Julie Lewis, David Stoddard, Karen Stark, Dr. Kendall Crowns

Overview

In this gripping episode, Nancy Grace and her panel of experts dissect every shocking detail of the Brian Walshe trial, where Walshe stands accused—and ultimately convicted—of murdering and dismembering his wife, Anna Walsh. The episode delves into the evidence, the critical role of Anna’s lover in court, the digital and forensic trail, and ends with the emotional toll on Anna’s three young sons. With her signature prosecutorial zeal, Grace walks listeners through the twists and turns of the investigation and trial, highlighting how digital forensics, damning Google searches, and physical evidence led the jury to a swift and decisive verdict.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Case Introduction & Trial Drama (02:26)

• Brian Walshe, a Massachusetts father of three and convicted art fraudster, faces trial for the alleged murder and dismemberment of his wife, Anna Walsh.
• The courtroom is riveted as Anna’s lover, William Fastow, takes the stand, revealing intimate details about Anna’s state of mind and her fractured marriage.

Nancy Grace: “Brian Walsh accused of murdering and dismembering his wife Anna, the mother of his children. Got to sit by and listen to her lover on the stand.” (02:35)

2. Background: Anna’s Disappearance & Marriage Dynamics (03:00-05:44)

• Anna was last seen departing for a supposed work trip to D.C. but never boarded her flight; her husband failed to report her missing—her employer did.
• William Fastow testifies that Anna was deeply unhappy, emotionally drained, and shouldered the family’s financial burden while Brian was under house arrest for art fraud.

Fastow via Nancy Grace: "She was deeply upset that she was not in a position to be the mother to her children she wanted to be because of her husband." (04:18)

3. Timeline of Events & Initial Investigation (05:44-12:26)

• Investigators can’t confirm the rideshare or the flight she allegedly took, and all leads hit dead ends.
• Nancy, with guest Bob Ward, emphasizes how odd it is for a high-powered executive’s employer—not family—to initiate the missing persons report.
• Digital and flight records show Anna never left town.

Bob Ward: “Right from the very beginning, this sounded odd because ... this was New Year's Day ... She had a party at her house ... a mother of three who claimed there was an emergency at her realty firm in Washington, D.C.” (07:36)

4. Critical Evidence: The Digital Trail (18:04-24:58)

• Brian claims he lost his way to his mother’s house (citing a “pirate ship” landmark) because he didn't have his phone—expert guests express extreme skepticism.
• Surveillance and phone data places Brian discarding heavy trash bags at multiple dumpsters across the region, leading up to an incinerator where it’s believed Anna’s remains were destroyed.

Nancy Grace: “When he starts going from one dumpster to the next ... all in a one hour period, that concerns me. And you know who it reminds me of ... Jennifer Doulos, the missing Connecticut mom of five …” (24:58)

5. Forensic Bombshell: Dumpster Evidence (24:58-30:10)

• Trash bags recovered (not incinerated) contained a hatchet, hacksaw, bloody rug, Anna’s purse and boots, and even her COVID-19 vaccine card.
• Without a body, forensic evidence (bloody tools, clothing, and personal effects) proved pivotal.

Bob Ward: “They found a hatchet, a hacksaw ... Anna's Prada purse, the boots she was seen wearing at that New Year's Eve party ... her COVID 19 card. It's absolutely stunning.” (29:51)

6. Digital Forensics: Google Searches of Doom (42:16-47:56)

• Brian’s devastating Google search history, performed on his son’s iPad hours after Anna’s disappearance, included:
  • “How long before a body starts to smell?”
  • “10 ways to dispose of a dead body if you really need to”
  • “How long for someone to be missing to inherit?”
  • “Can you throw away body parts?”
  • “Dismemberment and best ways to dispose of a body”
  • “How to clean blood from wooden floor”
  • “Luminol to detect blood”
• Dr. Kendall Crowns provides medical context for these searches in a chilling “lightning round.”

Nancy Grace: “He goes and he finds his kid's iPad and he's doing these searches within a couple of hours of his wife being there, someone that he loved. And this is what he is doing. … the depravity of this case to me is really just off the charts.” (48:21, 50:53)

7. Domestic Violence, Motive, and the Final Blow (50:53-54:29)

• Prior abuse noted: Anna previously reported that Brian threatened to kill her (2014), and posted images of bruises years before her death; experts agree on a pattern of escalating domestic violence.
• A haunting note found on a champagne box (“2023 is going to be a great year. Love you, Anna”) believed to be Anna’s last written words to Brian.
• Jury finds Brian Walshe guilty of first-degree murder, misleading investigators, and improper disposal of a body. He is sentenced to life without parole.

Bob Ward: “You don't get to this kind of … hatred to, you know, I can understand a moment of passion, of murder, you know, a moment of anger, but this dismemberment and this depravity that we see here in these messages ... It's almost too much.” (54:11)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Digital Evidence:
  “He’s searching ‘how long before a body starts to smell’ at 4:55am … Anna Walsh was alive at 1:00 in the morning and at 4:55am she’s gone and that search is done.” (Bob Ward, 49:10)
• On Cover-up Behavior:
  “Why is it that when a woman goes missing, her husband suddenly turns into a neatnik and he has to throw out the trash?” (Nancy Grace, 24:58)
• On Domestic Violence Escalation:
  “She complained back in 2014, before they were engaged, ... he threatened to kill her in 2014. ... I think there was an escalation of domestic violence.” (Bob Ward, 51:09)
• On Jury Verdict:
  “The jury brings down the hammer, finding Brian Walsh guilty in the murder and dismemberment of his wife, 39 year old Anna Walsh, the mother of their three little boys. He gets life without parole. Brian Walsh rot in hell.” (Nancy Grace, 54:29)

Important Timestamps

| Time | Segment | |--------|------------------------------------------------| | 02:26 | Nancy Grace introduces the case and trial drama | | 05:44 | Timeline: Anna’s last known movements | | 12:26 | Employer reports Anna missing, not Brian | | 18:04 | Lover Fastow testifies – marriage woes & finances| | 24:08 | Surveillance: Brian’s suspicious trips to dumpsters| | 29:51 | Forensic finds: Tools, clothing, and more | | 42:16 | Brian’s damning Google searches revealed | | 47:26 | Dr. Crowns: Forensic explanation of searches | | 50:53 | Domestic violence, last note & motive explored | | 54:29 | Verdict: Guilty, life without parole |

Conclusion

Nancy Grace and her guests meticulously piece together the case against Brian Walshe, expertly walking listeners through the workflow of investigation, the avalanche of digital and physical evidence, and the haunting context of escalating domestic abuse. The episode concludes with the weight of the tragedy Anna’s three children face, and Nancy’s blunt demand for justice.

Nancy Grace’s closing words:
“The jury brings down the hammer ... Brian Walsh rot in hell. Nancy Grace signing off. Goodbye friend.” (54:29)

For more information and true crime updates, tune in to "Crime Stories with Nancy Grace" on iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline.