Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: Police Arrest Suspect in Miami Beach Stabbing That Left Man Critically Injured
Date: January 27, 2026
Podcast: Crime Stories with Nancy Grace (iHeartPodcasts and CrimeOnline)
Host: Nancy Grace

Episode Overview

In this “Crime Alert” edition, Nancy Grace and correspondent John Laemmle cover the breaking arrest of a suspect in a Miami Beach stabbing that left a man critically injured, offering details on the investigation, the suspect’s capture, and current legal proceedings. The episode also reviews additional major crime and justice headlines, including a controversial law enforcement shooting in Minnesota, a double homicide case in Ohio involving a physician, and developments in a decades-old Florida murder case scheduled for execution.

Main Story: Miami Beach Stabbing Arrest

Background & Incident Details:

• Suspect: Jack Daniel Gutierrez, 24.
• Incident: Gutierrez walked Miami Beach, approached a man to ask for a cigarette and to borrow a cell phone. Upon being refused, he attacked the man, slashing his neck “ear to ear.”
• Aftermath: Gutierrez fled and was on the run for weeks. Victim suffered life-threatening injuries but survived.
• Arrest: Police apprehended Gutierrez in Miami Beach after a month-long search. He now faces multiple felony charges, including aggravated battery and attempted murder.
• Motivation and Victim Connection: No motive publicly identified; unclear if suspect and victim knew each other.

Key Points & Investigative Insights

• Police Response: Law enforcement released surveillance footage and asked the public for help, warning that Gutierrez was armed and dangerous.
• How He Was Found: Police relied on public tips, video evidence, and follow-up interviews to locate Gutierrez.
• Current Status: The suspect was arrested without incident. The victim continues to recover. More charges may follow.

“Jack Daniel Gutierrez...stops to bum a cigarette and borrow a cell phone. When he didn’t get either one, he attacks the man who said no, slicing his neck ear to ear.”
— Nancy Grace (00:02)

“Authorities say tips from the public combined with video evidence and follow-up interviews ultimately led officers to the suspect’s location.”
— John Laemmle (01:22)

Other Notable Crime and Justice News

[03:04] Minnesota Law Enforcement Shooting

• Victim: Alexander “Alex” Pretty, 37, Minneapolis nurse.
• Incident: Fatally shot by federal immigration agents on January 24th.
• Controversy: Officials claimed Pretty was armed; bystander video appears to show him only holding a cell phone.
• Family Statement: Pretty was attempting to help a woman when agents intervened.
• Aftermath: Family and officials call for independent investigation and evidence preservation. Homeland Security claims self-defense but reviews are ongoing.
• Public Response: Protests and demands for greater transparency in Minneapolis.

“Bystander video reviewed by news organizations appears to show [Pretty] holding a cell phone, not a weapon, in the moments before agents restrained him.”
— John Laemmle (03:17)

[04:12] Ohio Double Homicide: Physician Pleads Not Guilty

• Suspect: Dr. Michael David McKee, 39.
• Charges: Four counts of aggravated murder and aggravated burglary for the December 30th shooting deaths of his ex-wife, Monique Teep (39), and her husband, Dr. Spencer Tepe (37), in Columbus, Ohio.
• Circumstances: The couple’s two children were present but unharmed. McKee was arrested in Rockford, Illinois, after video and vehicle data led authorities to him. Evidence from his car and residence link him to the crime.
• Legal Status: McKee remains detained without bail; if convicted, faces life imprisonment.

[05:08] Florida Execution Scheduled in 1986 Murder Case

• Condemned: Melvin Trotter, 65.
• Crime: Murder of Virgie Langford, a grocery store owner, in Manatee County during a robbery (1986).
• Timeline: Convicted and sentenced to death in 1987; resentenced in 1993 after a sentencing error.
• Legal History: Numerous appeals challenging the sentence have been unsuccessful.
• Current Status: Execution scheduled for February 24 at Florida State Prison.

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Nancy Grace’s vivid summary of the Miami Beach stabbing:

  “When he didn’t get either one, he attacks the man who said no, slicing his neck ear to ear.” (00:07)

• John Laemmle detailing community role in the arrest:

  “Authorities say tips from the public combined with video evidence and follow-up interviews ultimately led officers to the suspect’s location.” (01:22)

• On the controversy over the Minnesota shooting:

  “[Alex Pretty] was attempting to help a woman when agents approached. The footage has prompted calls...for an independent investigation and for all evidence to be preserved.” (03:25)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [00:01] — Miami Beach stabbing incident and suspect arrest
• [00:27] — Details on the police search and public involvement
• [03:04] — Minnesota accidental officer-involved shooting
• [04:12] — Ohio double homicide and physician suspect arraignment
• [05:08] — Florida execution date set for 1986 murder
• [05:57] — Closing remarks and further resources

Conclusion

This episode of Crime Stories delivers concise but impactful coverage of a high-profile violent crime in Miami Beach, offering insight into the investigation and community assistance that led to a critical arrest. It also highlights current high-stakes cases in Minnesota, Ohio, and Florida, reflecting Nancy Grace’s commitment to exposing injustice and advocating for victims.
For continuous updates, listeners are encouraged to visit CrimeOnline.com and join the “Crime Stories” podcast daily.