Crime Stories with Nancy Grace: "POLICE: MOM'S CHILLING COMMENT AFTER BABY DIES FROM MALNUTRITION, DEHYDRATION | CRIME ALERT RECAP SATURDAY 12.06.25"
Episode Date: December 6, 2025
Podcast by: iHeartPodcasts & CrimeOnline

Episode Overview

This Crime Alert Recap episode delivers a sobering roundup of recent headline-making criminal cases, focusing on the tragic death of an 18-month-old due to malnutrition and dehydration, the shocking murder and fetal abduction of a pregnant woman in Michigan, a dramatic fire rescue in Massachusetts, and an update on an ongoing Kentucky murder case involving a former sheriff. The tone reflects the podcast's trademark blend of urgency, compassion for victims, and relentless focus on accountability.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Utah Infant Death; Parental Neglect and a Mother’s Chilling Comment

Segment Starts: [02:09]

• Case Summary:
  Dave Mack reports on the death of 18-month-old Ruby in Utah. Her parents, Carrie and Mitchell Murray, have been charged with murder and child abuse after Ruby was found dead in her crib surrounded by sippy cups and waffles.
• Details of Neglect:
  The parents described themselves as "not table people," saying Ruby ate in her crib, disliked being fed by others, and primarily consumed food while isolated.
  Over the four days prior to her death, baby monitor footage revealed Ruby was only taken out of her crib for a total of six hours and spent less than an hour with others.
• Chilling Parental Statement:
  During questioning, Carrie reportedly said, “It was her time.” ([02:28], paraphrased by Dave Mack)
• Cause of Death:
  Investigators determined Ruby died from dehydration and malnutrition.
• Call to Action:
  Information is offered for the Child Help national abuse hotline.

Memorable Quote:
“Carrie says it was her time.” — Dave Mack ([02:28])

2. Michigan Fetal Abduction and Family Betrayal

Segment Starts: [03:32]

• Case Summary:
  Jennifer Gould covers the horrific case of 22-year-old Rebecca Park, eight months pregnant and lured by her mother and stepfather into the woods where she was stabbed, and her unborn baby violently cut from her womb.
• Details of Crime:
  Rebecca was missing for three weeks before her mutilated body was discovered near her mother’s property. The infant’s remains have not been found.
• Investigation:
  Prosecutors reveal the crime was meticulously planned. The Bartholomews, Rebecca's mother and stepfather, researched “fetal extraction methods” and remote disposal sites.
• Possible Motive:
  Motive remains unclear but may involve a recent inheritance or resentment over the pregnancy. It’s noted that the accused couple previously struggled with fertility.
• Complicity and Charges:
  Rebecca’s sister and her sister’s fiancé are also charged for covering up evidence and tampering with the scene.
• Prosecution’s Remark:
  Wexford County Prosecutor Joanna Carey described the plot as, “frankly evil personified.” ([04:11])
• Court Update:
  All four suspects remain jailed; the Bartholomews face first-degree murder and conspiracy charges. Investigation for the missing infant continues.

Memorable Quote:
“These two individuals created a plan, conducted research … [and] forced her to the ground while they cut her baby out and ultimately caused her death and the death of the baby.” — Jennifer Gould, relaying prosecutor’s statement ([05:53])

3. Heroic Rescue in a Somerville Fire

Segment Starts: [10:32]

• Incident Summary:
  Erin Levine narrates the story of a woman rescued from a burning building by a bucket-truck operator from Eversource, who intervened before firefighters arrived.
• Details:
  The worker noticed smoke, drove his cherry picker close, and pulled the woman to safety from a window awning seconds before flames overtook her escape route.
• Authorities’ Praise:
  Fire Chief Charles Breen lauded the utility worker: “He did a hell of a job. Definitely saved the woman's life.” ([11:16])
• Aftermath:
  The rescued woman suffered smoke inhalation; her dog, unfortunately, perished. All residents of the six-unit building were displaced.
• Eyewitness Account:
  Neighbor Al Yanick described the confusion and urgency he witnessed as rescue unfolded.

Memorable Quote:
“She had climbed out a window onto the front porch under heavy smoke and fire conditions … the worker drove his bucket truck to the front of the building … and got her to safety.” — Fire Chief Charles Breen ([11:09])

4. Kentucky Judge Shooting: Dismissal Motion Rejected, Trial to Proceed

Segment Starts: [12:40]

• Case Summary:
  Nicole Parton covers former Letcher County Sheriff Sean Stein's unsuccessful motion to dismiss his indictment for the fatal shooting of District Judge Kevin Mullins.
• Legal Arguments:
  The defense alleges prosecutorial misconduct and points to Stein's severe mental health issues at the time of the shooting, citing acute stress diagnoses and psychotic episodes.
• Judicial Response:
  The presiding judge ruled that the prosecution's presentation did not mislead the grand jury and that there was sufficient evidence for probable cause.
• Upcoming Trial:
  Stein, who could face the death penalty, will proceed to trial as the court denied the move to dismiss.

Notable Moment:
“The judge concluded that the prosecution met its burden … any alleged misrepresentations or omissions would not have altered the grand jury's decision.” — Nicole Parton ([13:55])

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Parental Neglect in Child’s Death:
  “Ruby is only taken out of her crib for a total of six hours … when questioned about the baby's death, Carrie says it was her time.” — Dave Mack ([02:28])
• On the Nature of the Michigan Crime:
  “This is frankly evil personified.” — Prosecutor Joanna Carey, quoted by Jennifer Gould ([04:11])
• On the Utility Worker’s Heroism:
  “He did a hell of a job. Definitely saved the woman's life. She was in severe danger at the time.” — Fire Chief Charles Breen ([11:16])
• On the Grand Jury’s Decision:
  “The judge concluded that the prosecution met its burden of providing sufficient evidence for probable cause.” — Nicole Parton ([13:55])

Timestamps for Key Segments

• [02:09] — Utah parents charged in malnutrition death of an 18-month-old
• [03:32] — Michigan woman’s murder and fetal abduction by her own mother & stepfather
• [10:32] — Fire rescue: Utility worker saves woman with bucket truck in Massachusetts
• [12:40] — Kentucky ex-sheriff’s failed motion after shooting a district judge

Tone & Style

The episode conveys urgency, outrage, and empathy, particularly in cases involving vulnerable victims. The reporting style is direct, highlighting hard realities and underscoring societal responsibilities, while also commending acts of heroism and the diligence of investigators and prosecutors.

Summary for New Listeners

This Crime Stories with Nancy Grace episode shines a spotlight on recent serious crimes, with day-of updates and strong criticism of systemic failings. Listeners are confronted with the devastation of parental neglect, the horrifying reality of premeditated familial violence, moments of selfless heroism, and the complex search for justice in high-profile murder cases. Each segment is loaded with details and sharp commentary, offering enough context for those new to each story, and underlining the dire importance of vigilance, community action, and the rule of law.