Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: Sister and Fiancé Arrested After Body of Missing Mich Pregnant Woman Was Found | Crime Alert 6AM 12.01.25
Date: December 1, 2025

Overview

In this episode, Nancy Grace and correspondent Nicole Parton provide updates on the tragic case of Rebecca K. Park, a pregnant 22-year-old Michigan woman found dead after weeks of being missing. The episode covers the emotional discovery of Rebecca’s body, developments in the investigation—including the stunning arrests of her fiancé and sister—and additional significant crime news from across the country.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Disappearance and Discovery of Rebecca K. Park

• [00:06] Nicole Parton reports that authorities in Michigan have discovered a body matching the description of Rebecca Park. She had been missing for over three weeks after last being seen leaving a family member’s home on November 3. Rebecca was 38 weeks pregnant at the time.
• Citizen searchers located the body in the Manistee National Forest — an area previously searched — which heightened the urgency and sorrow surrounding the case.
• [00:38] Citizen Searcher describes the emotional moment of discovery:

  "The son or the young boy or the 20 year old did not want the dad to go up and asked if I could go up and see if it was a mask or if it was really somebody and it was Rebecca."

• Positive identification is pending an autopsy, and authorities have not confirmed the condition of the remains or whether the body was recently moved.

Family Involvement and Arrests

• [01:10] Nicole Parton explains that Park’s disappearance triggered a massive search effort involving law enforcement, volunteers, canine units, and drones. Her fiancé Richard Feylor, 43, and her younger sister, Kimberly Park, 21, had both made public appeals for her return.
• Surveillance and witness reports last placed Rebecca willingly entering a car outside a family member’s home; her phone was later found abandoned nearby.
• In a dramatic development, custody records reveal both Richard Feylor and Kimberly Park were arrested and booked into Wexford County Jail within hours of each other (Richard at 7:30pm, Kimberly near midnight).
• Authorities have not confirmed the reason for the arrests or if they are connected to Rebecca’s death, but speculation is high.
• During a press conference, Sheriff Trent Taylor declined to answer specific questions on the scene, including the clothing found or the condition/timing of the body.

The Ongoing Investigation

• The Michigan State Police and Wexford County Sheriff’s Office are leading the investigation.
• Anyone with information is urged to contact authorities.
• [02:53] Nicole Parton:

  "The investigation continues, led by the Michigan State Police and the Wexford County Sheriff’s Office. Anyone with information is urged to contact authorities."

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• [00:38] Citizen Searcher:

  “And it was Rebecca."

  • A raw, emotional moment at the scene.

• [01:10] Nicole Parton:

  “Her family made public appeals for help, including her fiancé, Richard Feylor, and her youngest sister, Kimberly.”

  • Frankly underscoring the shocking twist of their subsequent arrests.

• [01:49] Nicole Parton:

  “…record show that her fiancé, Richard Feylor, 43, was booked into the Wexford County Jail at 7:30pm Tuesday. Just hours later...Kimberly Park, 21, her sister, was booked into the same jail.”

• [01:59] Nicole Parton:

  "Sheriff Trent Taylor declined to answer questions about the clothing found on the body, whether investigators believe the remains were moved or how long the person had been dead."

  • Illustrating the guarded approach by law enforcement.

Timestamps for Important Segments

• 00:06 – 01:10 Nicole Parton details Rebecca Park’s disappearance, pregnancy, and discovery by citizen searchers.
• 01:10 – 02:39 Discussion of investigation developments, public appeals by family, facts about the night Rebecca vanished, and the surprise arrests.
• 02:53 Call to the public for information.
• 05:46 – 07:26 Nicole Parton reports on New York City murder case involving Nicholas McGee.
• 07:26 – 08:10 Brief coverage of the Aiden Clune missing person case.

Additional Crime News

• New York City Dismemberment Case ([05:46])

  • Nicholas McGee (48) sentenced to life without parole for murdering and dismembering Cain Gelser (38) in their Brooklyn apartment, hiding remains in a refrigerator and freezer.
  • Discovery followed an anonymous Crime Stoppers tip; the case ended after McGee confessed to NYPD detectives.

• Aiden Clune Missing Case ([07:26])

  • A brief update on Aiden Clune (19), missing for three years after last being seen in Nevada. His belongings were found in his abandoned truck; the family mentions his struggles with depression.

Tone & Language

The episode is urgent and somber, with a focus on facts and emotional responses from those involved in the search and investigation. Nicole Parton delivers updates in a straightforward journalistic style, while citizen input adds immediacy and personal impact. Nancy Grace maintains her signature tone of advocacy and determination to seek justice.

Summary

This episode centers around breaking developments in the disappearance and death of Rebecca K. Park, a pregnant Michigan woman found dead three weeks after vanishing. In a shocking turn, both her fiancé and younger sister—who publicly pleaded for her return—have been arrested. The investigation is ongoing, and authorities are withholding many details as speculation intensifies. The podcast also covers a gruesome murder and dismemberment in New York and highlights a longstanding missing person case, all contributing to the show’s focus on crime awareness and the pursuit of answers.