YOUNG GIRL SADE ROBINSON 'EXCITED' ABOUT DATE WITH SPOILED BRAT KILLER

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

Episode: YOUNG GIRL SADE ROBINSON 'EXCITED' ABOUT DATE WITH SPOILED BRAT KILLER

Date: May 25, 2026
Host: Nancy Grace
Guests: Sheena Scarborough, Carlos Robinson, investigative reporters, legal and forensic experts

---

Episode Overview

This episode centers on the murder of Sade Robinson, a promising Milwaukee teen who was brutally killed after going on a first date with Maxwell Anderson, the son of a local millionaire. Nancy Grace explores the investigation into Sade’s disappearance, details the recovery of her dismembered body, and amplifies the voices of her grieving family, especially her mother and father. The episode investigates the alleged killer’s background, disturbing evidence found at his home, and haunting parallels to historic serial killers. It’s a powerful, emotional deep-dive into a shocking case that has rattled Milwaukee and the nation.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Remembering Sade Robinson

• Academic and Personal Excellence: Sade graduated early with honors and was nearing completion of an associate's degree in criminal justice at Milwaukee Area Technical College. She worked two full-time jobs, lived independently, and had aspirations of joining the Air Force or becoming a lawyer.
  • “She was everything you want your child to be... She had her own bachelorette apartment. She has her own car. She pays all of her own bills.” – Nancy Grace [05:24]
• Family and Community Impact: Sade's murder devastated her close-knit family and the larger Milwaukee community.
  • “This has caused so much emotional effect to my family... everyone has pulled up. This has affected many people in Milwaukee.” – Sheena Scarborough [08:13]

2. Timeline of Events & Discovery of Remains

• Initial Discovery: On April 2, a severed human leg was found by a park goer along Lake Michigan.
  • [03:32–04:05]
• Subsequent Finds: Over the next days, more remains—including a foot with pink nail polish, an arm, and a torso—were found in locations spread miles apart.
  • “Then there's another finding. Then there's another one. 4 total parts human remains.” – Alexis Torres [03:39]
• Identification: Remains matched Sade through DNA and distinctive physical markers.

3. The Last Days and Her Excitement for the Date

• Family’s Last Contact: Sade’s mother last saw her on Easter Sunday.
  • “We spent the Sunday together. This was Easter Sunday... She came by my parent’s home, we spent the Sunday together.” – Sheena Scarborough [12:32]
• First Date with Anderson: Surveillance footage confirmed Sade was excited about her date with Maxwell Anderson, age gap evident (19/20 vs. 33).
  • “Sade Robinson tells a maintenance worker in her building that she’s excited about her first date with 33-year-old Maxwell Anderson.” – Dave Mack [14:47]

4. Investigation and Suspect Profile

• Suspect Background: Anderson is the son of a wealthy insurance executive, former high school football star, and had prior criminal convictions (domestic abuse, disorderly conduct, DUI).
  • “He has been convicted of all three of these things... He is not an upstanding citizen.” – Alexis Torres [24:16]
• Crime Scene Evidence: Evidence at Anderson’s home included blood, gasoline cans (linked to a car fire), sex dungeon with restraints, and dug grave-sized hole.
  • “Blood, gasoline containers, packages addressed to the defendant... blood on a comforter. Blood scattered throughout the home.” – Nancy Grace [24:38]
  • “He planned this.” – Nancy Grace [24:38]

5. Forensics and Suspected Pattern of Behavior

• Dismemberment & DNA: The degree of violence and attempts at body disposal were likened to serial killers; DNA is central to the case.
  • “DNA is going to play a big role in this... her DNA will be found on him and it will be pointing a big accusing finger back at him.” – Joseph Scott Morgan [22:08]
• Possible Additional Victims: Unidentified blood found at the scene, large dugout holes, and sinister dungeon led to speculation this may not be Anderson’s only crime.
  • “Since that blood does not match Sade... are there more victims?” – Nancy Grace [30:33]
• Disturbing Quotes:
  • “This is a 2024 Jeffrey Dahmer.” – Sheena Scarborough [08:13]
  • “Who digs a grave in the backyard and doesn’t use it? What does that say?” – Nancy Grace [32:54]

6. Family’s Grief and Pleas for Justice

• Ongoing Trauma: Both parents vividly describe their agony, inability to lay Sade to rest until all remains are found.
  • “This is probably the hardest part that we’re struggling with right now, trying to find peace, bring my daughter to rest.” – Sheena Scarborough [27:23]
  • “I haven’t been to sleep. I’ve been to the parks, I’ve been all over with flashlights... I just want to find her.” – Carlos Robinson [40:28]
• Demand for Justice: Sade’s family is vocal about holding Anderson and—importantly—others in the community accountable for long-ignored disappearances.
  • “It's justice for Sade, Nancy. It's justice.” – Sheena Scarborough [08:13]
• Enduring Mother’s Love:
  • “I am her voice. I have to speak and advocate through her for others. This is a waking nightmare.” – Sheena Scarborough [45:14]
  • “My baby was my everything. She’s my light. She’s my star.” – Sheena Scarborough [45:13]
• Physical and Emotional Toll:
  • “I can literally feel the symptoms of what this person did to my daughter... I don’t know, Nancy. It’s very challenging.” – Sheena Scarborough [47:03]

7. Emerging Details and Ongoing Investigation

• Dating App Connection: Police are investigating how Sade and Anderson met—possible dating app involvement.
  • “Police are focusing now on various dating apps as to how this teen girl met up with a much, much older man.” – Nancy Grace [48:03]
• Chilling Witness Statement: A confidential informant claims Anderson openly discussed plans to lure and harm Sade.
  • “He was going to lure Sade, take her to the basement, shoot her, and dismember her.” – Nancy Grace [48:54]
• Legal Developments: Anderson’s lawyer requests for jail privileges highlight the privileged background of the accused.
  • “…his lawyer has demanded that he have a laptop behind bars. He can kiss my rear end…” – Nancy Grace [46:25]

---

Notable Quotes & Emotional Moments

On Sade’s Life and Legacy

• “Everything he spoke was exactly what my daughter exerted... I couldn’t have asked for any better daughter.” – Sheena Scarborough [08:13]
• “My baby girl was an amazing person. She was, she was full of love. She was a giver.” – Carlos Robinson [42:10]

On Grief

• “Every day I wake up. I can’t believe what is taking place. I am Sade Robinson’s mother. This is very ongoingly tragic.” – Sheena Scarborough [45:14]
• “You stated that two body parts have not been found. What part of Sade has not been found?” “Her head and one of her arms, sir.” – Nancy Grace and Carlos Robinson [43:24–43:34]

On the Alleged Killer

• “You don’t go from zero to 120 miles per hour in two seconds. There has to be something. Some revving up, up to not only a murder, but a luring…” – Nancy Grace [24:38]
• “It takes a different kind of evil to do something like this.” – Carlos Robinson [44:42]

---

Timestamps for Important Segments

• [03:32] Discovery of Sade's remains begins
• [08:13] Sade’s mother, Sheena Scarborough, speaks powerfully about her daughter and impact
• [14:47] Dave Mack recounts last hours and date with Anderson
• [22:08] Forensic discussion on dismemberment and DNA
• [24:16] Anderson’s criminal history and background
• [27:23] Mother discusses inability to bury Sade and lack of closure
• [31:27] Evidence of sex dungeon and basement described
• [38:41] Sade’s father Carlos Robinson joins, describes agony of the search
• [45:13] Sheena Scarborough describes ongoing grief and coping
• [48:03] Focus shifts to dating apps and new evidence
• [50:11] Mother’s reaction to seeing footage of the horror basement

---

Tone and Style

The episode is raw, emotional, and relentless in its pursuit of both truth and justice. Nancy Grace is direct and empathetic, elevating the voices of Sade’s family throughout. The pain and determination of Sade’s parents is palpable. The discussion is investigative but also deeply human—amplifying the loss, the systemic issues in Milwaukee, and the stakes for all young women.

---

Conclusion

Nancy Grace promises the show’s continued commitment to Sade’s case and to demanding accountability. The episode ends with both grief and resolve, echoing Sade’s mother’s determination and promising that Sade Robinson’s story will not be forgotten.

---

Transcript

[Nancy Grace]

This is an iHeart podcast.

[Mazda CX5 Advertiser]

Guaranteed Human introducing the all new Mazda CX5 featuring more connection hey Google, where's the nearest Pilates class? Safety that has your back? More discovery on the scenic routes, more passion in the details and more control in changing weather. The all new Mazda CX5 more to move every side of you. See it in five films at mazdausa.com fivesides Google is a trademark of Google LLC.

[Nancy Grace]

Sequences shortened and simulated Amazon Health AI presents painful thoughts I I can't stop scratching my downtown. Yeah, but I'm not itching to go downtown and tell a receptionist I'm here to talk about my downtown. Some things you'd rather type than say out loud.

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

There's no question too embarrassing for Amazon Health AI.

[Nancy Grace]

Chat your symptoms and get virtual care 24.

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

7 Healthcare just got less painful

[Nancy Grace]

Crime

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

Stories brought to you by Penn Foster When a student falls behind, the gap doesn't just stay the same, it can grow. Not every student fits in a traditional classroom, and when it's not working, staying on the same path can make things worse. When when that happens, another option matters. Penn Foster High School is an accredited online diploma program built for flexibility. It is self paced. That means students can work on their own schedule, fitting school around jobs, family, sports or other responsibilities. It's a different path, but it's a path forward, one that gives students more control over how they learn. The focus is simple Work toward earning an accredited high school diploma toward what comes next. If you or your family need a change, visit pennfoster. Edu Nancy that's P E N Foster Edu Nancy and learn more. There is an answer. Your family's safety requires your trust. Trust in the security system you've chosen to protect your home. SimpliSafe and has made trust simple 24. 7 affordable professional monitoring with no long term contracts, no lock ins or hidden cancellation fees. Their fully customizable system fits your exact needs with comprehensive sensors and indoor outdoor cameras. Customize a system that's right for you and your [e-mail] and it ships to your door in just a few days. With app guided setup and no drilling required, you can install and arm your system in under an hour. Crime stories listeners get 50% off a new system when signing up for professional monitoring and your first month is free. You just visit simplisafe.com Nancy that's half [e-mail] Nancy first month free. There is no safe like SimpliSafe. Crime stories with Nancy Grace

[Sheena Scarborough]

Shade is

[Nancy Grace]

Beautiful Beautiful Soul Date Turned murder date

[Eric Faddis]

to homicide to dismemberment to scattering human remains.

[Dave Mack]

Park goer reports finding a severed human leg.

[Alexis Torres]

Then there's another finding. Then there's another one. 4 total parts human remains.

[Nancy Grace]

Tonight, into the mind of a human butcher.

[Dave Mack]

5:30pm April 2, Cutahay police respond to a call along Lake Michigan at Warnamont Park, a popular recreation area. A park goer reports finding a severed human leg.

[Unidentified Narrator]

Three days after the Warnamont park discovery, another called to police about a severed body part. 11 miles away from the shores of Lake Michigan, in a Milwaukee west side neighborhood, a body part is found at a playground. Within 24 hours, police respond to another call about the discovery of human remains.

[Nancy Grace]

After a car is found on fire. Paired with a pet tribute blanket found near some of the human remains, police begin to focus on a beautiful young teen girl. Sade. Listen.

[Unidentified Narrator]

Sade Robinson graduates with honors a semester early from Riverside High School. She continues her education at Milwaukee Area Technical College, working towards her associate's degree in criminal justice. In fact, she's only a month away from graduating. But Robinson hasn't been spending all her times in the books. She works through high school and college at the Pizza Shuttle on Milwaukee's Lower east side. She makes such a difference at work that her co workers say Robinson is considered the heart of Pizza Shuttle. Former owner Mark Gold says she is the type of employee who never calls out and is loved by customers and her co workers.

[Nancy Grace]

You know, I just, she's everything you want your child to be. She's this fantastic student. She is working while she's going to school, very close family, tons of relatives in the military. And she is inspired to consider the U.S. air Force. I mean, this is the girl we all want to have. And just look at her. I remember my grandmother, I would give her my school picture every year and she could say, I can just see, see the mischief coming out of your eyes. Look at this girl. Can't you just see the joy, just the love of life crackling smart, just beaming out of her. How in the world did she collide cross paths with an alleged spoiled brat killer? The son of a Milwaukee millionaire, a former ex high school football star, now a 30 something bartender. You know what? I want to get off him and back to Sade. Let me see that beautiful face again, Liz. I want to see that picture of Sade in her. Look at her. I like the one of her in her. She's at home. There's a big cross on the wall behind her and she's got on her, she's getting ready for cap. And get there, there. Oh, my goodness. Joining me is a very special guest along with an all star panel. This is Sade's mother, Ms. Sheena Scarborough. I didn't know you were going to hold that up. And just showing that says it all. It just says it all. You know, Ms. Scarborough, whenever I have to travel for work, my backpack is so heavy because I have all these mementos of the twins I carry with me and set up wherever I am.

[Sheena Scarborough]

No, I hear you talk about these ones a lot, Nancy.

[Nancy Grace]

It's just telling me to think that you have this picture instead of your girl. First of all, tell me about Sade.

[Sheena Scarborough]

Sade is beautiful, beautiful soul. I knew that my kids were very special and different. My parents raised me. They raised us. We are lightworkers. We put out positive energy. We exert. We help others. I'm a community advocate as a personal way of my life, the way I live. I've worked for others. I help others my whole life. I've raised my daughters that way. My daughters have excelled. I have two daughters. This has caused so much emotional effect to my family. Her, her, my parents who love my baby so much. Her grandparents, her uncles, her aunties, the community, everyone has pulled up. This has affected many people in Milwaukee. I'm coming here today. This is the hardest thing I would ever have to do in my life to speak Sade's voice. Sade was a beautiful soul. She was an amazing girl, Nancy. Everything he spoke was exactly what my daughter exerted. I couldn't have asked for any better daughter. There was things my daughter did that many adults were not even able to accomplish in their lifetimes. And I'll be 43 in a week. My birthday is on April 27. Sade's birthday is on May 10. I had her on Mother's Day. The son of a. I'm gonna watch my language on this platform. But this son of a took my daughter from me a month before. She's graduating with her Associate of Arts degree. She works so hard. She's a full time student. She has two full time jobs. She has her own little bachelorette apartment. She doesn't stay in a college dorm campus. She has her own bachelorette apartment. She has her own car. She pays all of her own bills. This is traumatizing, Nancy. I never expected this to pull up on my front door. This isn't normal. This is a 2024 Jeffrey Dahmer. I need him held accountable. I need justice for Sha Dae. There has been A lot of in many black and brown girls that have been gone missing in Milwaukee for a moment and all of them are going to be held accountable now because they put they mess with the wrong family. They mess with the wrong family because we're not going to sit quiet and we're not going to sit still and we're going to call all of them out and we're going to speak for the whole community because I'm not about to sit down and I'm not about to sit still on this one. It's justice for Sade, Nancy. It's justice.

[Nancy Grace]

Ms. Scarborough, I feel like anything, anything I or anybody on this panel could say right now, it pales compared to what you just said. And believe me, Ms. Scarborough, this story of Sade has not just touched people in Milwaukee, it has touched people around the world. And when you say you're not going to sit back, neither are we until there is justice for your girl. And the other missing and murdered girls across Milwaukee, they're not all just missing, they're dead. Many of them are dead

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

guys.

[Nancy Grace]

With me is Sade's mother who is in so much pain. But she is joining us tonight to speak out for shade. What happened? What led up to this night?

[Sheena Scarborough]

Yes, Nancy, this is. Yes, Nancy. The last time I spoke to my daughter was on Easter Sunday. Okay. We seen her, she came by my parents home. We spent the Sunday together. This was Easter Sunday. Okay. I cooked for them, both of my daughters. We all met by my parents house where I'm currently at. We all commute here. All my girls are busy. They're my youngest is 16. They have a lot of activities. They're working, they go to school. I have very successful and independent self sufficient daughters. We harm and hurt nobody. We just put out and help others into the universe.

[Carlos Robinson]

Okay.

[Sheena Scarborough]

So I seen like she, it's just very, it's like she's a 19, 20 year old young lady.

Okay.

We all, at this age, we have a lot of friends. She's not in a relationship. She didn't have a boyfriend. She wasn't tied down to anyone. She's single and she's dating. I knew she hung out with her co workers at Pizza Shuttle. They went out to little bars and hung out sometimes. I'm a very concerned mother. I'm very overprotective. I always would put in Shani's ear, be careful. I don't trust these people around Milwaukee. I'm just that extra type of mom and my daughter's always mom, just sit back. I try to give them space, let them be independent. But I just been having this vibe and intuition and I have been wanting her just to like not hang out and go out to places for some reason and I don't know exactly and I'm still trying to find out the facts. But I know that this type of, this individual and I want to make clarity because there's been a lot of trolls, there's been a lot of media I can't interact and deal with. I'm grieving my daughter right now. I want respect. I need time. They're claiming this was a first date. Like, you know, it's just a first day. I don't just do never. She never mentioned this dude to us. And I agree with you.

[Nancy Grace]

We're learning a little bit about that. We're learning a little bit about that. Take a listen to Dave Mack. Crime Online.

[Dave Mack]

A month away from turning 20, Sade Robinson tells a maintenance worker at her building that she's excited about her first date with 33 year old Maxwell Anderson. Robinson texts Anderson about where to eat and tells him she's feeling seafood. Anderson takes Sade to a place he used to work, the Twisted Fisherman. After dinner, they spend some more time together having drinks at Duke's on water. The couple leaves Duke's together around 9pm

[Nancy Grace]

Straight out to Alexis Toreschuk joining us, crimeonline.com investigative reporter. How do we know that they were together that night they met there?

[Alexis Torres]

There are multiple surveillance cameras outside these restaurants, both of them that show her arriving, walking through the east side of the restaurant. He arrived on the west side. There's such good video footage of this. This is just such a good helpful part of the case. They go there together. He used to work there at the Twisted Fisherman. So the bartender there spoke with police and said they came in, they sat at the bar together, they had a drink. It seemed friendly and casual. Nothing that would alert the bartender to anything that was wrong. He said they just had a few drinks and they left within an hour.

[Nancy Grace]

To Ms. Scarborough, this is Sade's mother. When did somebody realize they needed to call you and ask where's Sade?

[Sheena Scarborough]

Yeah, so it was Wednesday. Nancy. I was at my job. I went to work that morning. I got off as soon as I

got home from work.

I was receiving calls from my, my, my mother, my brother. We were all concerned because we all have the 360 location app. Okay. We all share it as the family. So I have the app shared with me, my mom, both of my daughters, then my daughter also shares Shade My oldest daughter also shares the app with additional friends. Monday morning I seen her getting ready for work. She FaceTimed me. Then she that evening around 3:45 4:00', clock, I got a text message from her asking a cash app for $15. My daughter does not ask me for money like she has. My daughter makes more money than me. Literally. She's that was that boss. Okay so like it wasn't a big deal. I'm just that type of mom. You need something, I'm going to cash app it.

[Nancy Grace]

So you get this test asking for $15 and Sade would never have done that. I mean she could have charged Apple pay, you name it. So you knew right then something was wrong and then this. Take a listen to Chief Jeffrey Norman

[Carlos Robinson]

on Saturday, April 6, MPD continued the search in the area and located additional human remains on the railroad tracks. Later in the Evening on Saturday, April 6, MPD returned to the area when Ms. Robinson's family located her blanket. At this time, detectives located additional human remains.

[Unidentified Narrator]

According to court documents, the remains found Saturday included human flesh and a foot. The foot had pink nail polish, possibly matching the polish on the leg found days earlier.

[Mazda CX5 Advertiser]

Introducing the all new Mazda CX5 featuring more connection hey Google, where's the nearest Pilates class? Safety that has your back? More discovery on the scenic routes, more passion in the details and more control in changing weather. The all new Mazda CX5 more to move every side of you. See it in five films at mazdausa.com fivesides Google is a trademark of Google LLC.

[Nancy Grace]

Sequences shortened and simulated crime stories brought

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

to you by Penn Foster Sometimes things don't go as planned with school. Whether you're looking to go back and finish what you started, or you're the parent of a teen who's falling behind in traditional school, having an alternative can make all the difference. Penn Foster High School is an accredited online diploma program built to be flexible with self paced courses so students can work at their own pace and move forward. Visit Penn Foster Edu Nancy that's P E N N Foster Edu Nancy and learn more. There is an answer. Your family's safety requires your trust. Trust in the security system you've chosen to protect your home. SimpliSafe has made trust simple 24. 7 Affordable professional monitoring with no long term contracts, no lock ins or hidden cancellation fees, their fully customizable system fits your exact needs with comprehensive sensors and indoor outdoor cameras. Customize a system that's right for you and your [e-mail] and it ships to your door in just a few days. With app guided setup and no drilling required, you can install and arm your system in under an hour. Crime stories listeners get 50% off a new system when signing up for professional monitoring and your first month is free. You just visit simplisafe.com Nancy that's half [e-mail] Nancy first month free. There is no safe like SimpliSafe.

[Chelsea Handler]

This is Chelsea Handler from Dear Chelsea. This podcast is sponsored by Veracity. Welcome to an all natural way to slim down, get energized and sharpen your focus. Verasity is revolutionizing health by tackling the root cause of so many issues. With Veracity's drug free, clinically proven and doctor formulated solutions, you can support your body's needs to live your healthiest life. If your goal is weight loss, try Metabolism ignite. The number one doctor recommended GLP1 booster and GLP1 alternative. Metabolism Ignite has sold out 10 times for a reason. No side effects, no allergens. Metabolism Ignite is a natural, safe plant based aid that results in an 85% reduction in hunger and is clinically proven to lose on average nine pounds in 90 days. And metabolism Ignite is safe for everyone, including breastfeeding new moms and women in perimenopause. So before Metabolism Ignite sells out again, make the switch to GLP1s the natural way. Head to VeracityHealth Co and use code iHeart for up to 65% off your order. Once again, that's V E R A C I T Y Health Co for up to 65% off and make sure you use my promo code iheartra crime

[Nancy Grace]

stories with Nancy Grace. Joseph Scott Morgan, renowned professor of forensics, Jacksonville State University. We're talking about a severed leg and a severed arm. And somebody at the medical examiners went, look, the fingernail polish matches. I don't need DNA. A jury's not going to need DNA, but they're going to have it. For why?

[Amazon Health AI Advertiser]

Because every contact, as you mentioned, does in fact leave a trace. We've known that for over 100 years now, and it's coming to fruition here in this, in the world in which we inhabit. DNA is going to play a big role in this. And we're talking about proximity, Nancy with the alleged perpetrator here, he will have had a very intimate contact. Unfortunately, with Sade, just this idea of dismemberment alone is going to leave a trace behind. And it's not necessarily his trace on her as much as it will be her trace on him potentially. And ultimately it could be her Sade that actually brings him to justice. Her DNA will be found on him and it will be pointing a big accusing false finger back at him.

[Nancy Grace]

On Wednesday, April 4, our investigation led to a person of interest, Maxwell Stephen Anderson, who lives in the 3100 block of South 39th street where he was arrested after a traffic stop near the home. A search warrant was conducted. Not only did blood evidence emerge in his home, this guy, this idiot, technical legal term, left a phone trail a mile wide. You know, when you look at his home, you think, wow, beautiful yard, immaculately kept. You know, why? Not because of him. 33 year old, former high school football star. He's a Nepo baby. Nepotism baby. This 33 year old guy, Maxwell Anderson, has a millionaire dad who ran a Milwaukee insurance brokerage firm. Now what do we know about him? Alexis Torres?

[Alexis Torres]

Chuck, he has a rap sheet.

[Sheena Scarborough]

He.

[Alexis Torres]

He has been arrested for domestic. I'm sorry, not just arrested. Convicted for domestic abuse, for disorderly conduct and for drunk driving. This guy has a rap sheet a mile long. He is not an upstanding citizen of the community. And as I said, these are not just arrests. We're waiting to hear from. He has been convicted of all three of these things.

[Nancy Grace]

Let me talk about this guy. Police find a foot, apparently human flesh at a playground. Pink nail polish matching up in the home. They find blood, gasoline containers, packages addressed to the defendant, very important. Blood on a comforter. Blood scattered throughout the home. Let me tell you this, and I'm going to go to you. Fat is with me. High profile trial lawyer, TV legal analyst, founding partner of the Warner Faddis elite legal group. Eric, this isn't his first time at the rodeo. You don't go from zero to 120 miles per hour in two seconds. There has to be something. Some revving up, up to not only a murder, but a luring, luring her onto a day. How many times do you think he watched her come in, have a drink, have dinner, anything like that before he gets the guts up to say, hey, would you like to go to dinner? He planned this. What about it, Eric?

[Eric Faddis]

Yeah, Nancy, it's chilling to think about what was going through Maxwell Anderson's mind, allegedly as he appears to have been preparing for this. You know, the details give rise to a predatory nature here, that there's a huge age gap. Right? And then there's also a friend who says that Maxwell Anderson had a five foot by six foot deep hole. Hole dug in his backyard. And then we look at the rapidity, how quickly this turning from a murder to dismemberment in a like overnight.

[Unidentified Narrator]

A neighbor's security camera shows two figures entering Anderson's backyard at 9:24pm at 12:47am A street camera shows Robinson's car departing Anderson's home. A camera at Cutahay High School shows a car drive toward the pump house at Warnamont Park. At 2:53am a figure is seen walking from the road and climbing down the bluff to the beach several times. At 4:31am the car leaves the park. Three hours later, bus surveillance catches a man carrying a tan backpack walking away from a fire at 30th and Lisbon. At 8:12am Anderson, carrying a tan backpack, is seen boarding a bus heading toward his home. Anderson gets off at 8:35am and enters his backyard eight minutes later.

[Nancy Grace]

Ms. Scarborough, you haven't even been able to have a funeral yet.

[Sheena Scarborough]

Why yes, that's correct.

Nancy this is probably the hardest part

that we're struggling with right now. Trying to find peace, bring my daughter to rest. Yik solace. Let's give her her transition that she deserves because she was taken too soon. My baby was only she didn't even make 20. She was 20 in a few weeks on May 10th. Nancy they don't, they can't even provide us with a death certificate right now. The they don't even know the cause of my daughter's death. They don't know when like they not giving me enough information. NANCY this is so frustrating. There is no closure right now for me and my family.

[Unidentified Narrator]

As volunteer searchers try to locate all of teen girl Sade Robinson's remains. A fourth set of body parts, this time at a remote tree lined stretch of beach along south Michigan. Just after 7am Someone walking along a South Milwaukee waterline discovered an arm and torso. The remains washed ashore about a quarter of a mile from a nearby apartment complex.

[Nancy Grace]

This is the fourth set of remains, this time a torso. What else is missing? Out to Erin Mabin, investigative reporter and anchor for Fox 6 in Milwaukee. Erin, thank you for being with us. There's so, so much happening and so quickly in the Sade Robinson case. But first I want to go to the torso. We have a torso, a female torso that has washed up, so to speak. We have unidentified blood. AARON may BEND this is blood on bedding going up the wall from the basement. And we know that the basement now uncovered was a sex dungeon and blood elsewhere in the home. Blood where it shouldn't be in the normal course of one's routine. So with all of this happening, I can't help but wonder, are there more victims? Since that blood does not match Sade, and we have reason to believe it doesn't match the defendant, the suspect. But back to the torso. Tell me everything.

[Erin Mabin]

Well, you know, this all began with a severed leg at a park in Cudahay. And it just sparked so much mystery. And that's what this case has been, Nancy, a ton of mystery. Where are these body parts first off coming from? And then we later learned that it is Sade Robinson who's been a missing girl. The latest was that arm and torso that washed up on shore. Someone was walking along the beach, Nancy, and they found this arm and torso. Now, let's go back to that severed leg, because these places where they were found, really not close to each other. They're a few miles away, about a 10 minute drive from each other. And police were quickly able to identify that this arm and torso were that of Sade Robinson's.

[Nancy Grace]

There's a very strong possibility that there are other victims. And you know where I'm going with this, Aaron Mabin. If you don't know a horse, look at his track record. Has he put other victims? Specifically, who was that grave dug for in his backyard? Whose blood is that on his wall? Who else had been in that sex torture chamber that he had in his basement? So if he put part of Sade in the water, ergo, has he put other victims in the water? See where I'm going with this?

[Erin Mabin]

We know that right now police are just searching for Sade Robinson in connection to Maxwell Anderson. They swabbed bedding, they swabbed a wall in the basement. We know that that blood was not Sade Robinson's DNA.

[Nancy Grace]

Speaking of searching the home, listen to this.

[Unidentified Narrator]

Maxwell Anderson had a sex dungeon in the basement of his West Milwaukee home. According to a law enforcement source, cops found a sex sling, restraints, and handcuffs. A close friend of Anderson's said that on a visit to Anderson's home last year, he noticed a large hole in the ground that was about 5ft long by 6 foot deep. Anderson said he was working on an underground basement, despite having a large basement in the home already. Neighbors say the basement in the home had small windows that were always covered so you could not see inside.

[Nancy Grace]

Joining us right now, crimeonline.com, investigative reporter Sydney Sumner. Sydney, thank you for being with us. Sydney, what can you tell me about gas cans being found in the suspect's home? And I want to Just ask one more time about the blood, the location of the blood.

[Unidentified Narrator]

Nancy, they found those gas cans and the blood stains on that search warrant from April 4th. Gas cans were found in the garage. And that just further corroborates that Anderson is responsible for that car fire. We remember he was seen entering a bus just after the fire started, carrying a tan backpack matching multiple witness descriptions. And that blood again, was found on bedding, on a comforter, and on the wall of a stairwell leading down to the basement where that sex dungeon apparently is.

[Nancy Grace]

I mean, I guess I need a shrink on this one. Attorney Eric Faddis. But who digs a grave in the backyard and doesn't use it? What does that say? What's that

[Eric Faddis]

exactly? I mean, you don't need a PhD to find out kind of what a person's intention was. It's a 5ft by 6ft grave. It's a human body size.

[Dave Mack]

Footage from inside the unfinished basement that police have called a sex dungeon shows it's in disarray. A large hole has been dug in the concrete floor. A drain in the floor is stuffed with towels. The drain cover marked with evidence numbers. A door without a handle leads to a dark closet. And there are several tables, a chair and exercise equipment. The mattress of a queen bed frame is flipped on its side and bedding is tossed over a table in the corner of the room.

[Nancy Grace]

You are seeing footage that we have managed to obtain of the underground torture chamber as it has been described. But there is more. More than what you're seeing. From a hacksaw to a circular saw to a power drill, a grave dug in the backyard, various sex paraphernalia, all found in this underground bunker belonging to the son of a Milwaukee millionaire. We also learn that he was in fact digging another underground lair. What, if anything, will this reveal?

[Mazda CX5 Advertiser]

Introducing the all new Mazda CX5, featuring more connection. Hey, Google, where's the nearest Pilates class? Safety that has your back. More discovery on the scenic routes. More passion in the details and more control in changing weather. The all new Mazda CX5 more to move every side of you. See it in five films at mazdausa.com fivesides Google is a trademark of Google LLC.

[Nancy Grace]

Sequences shortened and simulated crime stories brought

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

to you by Penn Foster. When a student falls behind, the gap doesn't just stay the same, it can grow. Not every student fits in a traditional classroom. And when it's not working, staying on the same path can make things worse. When that happens, another option matters. Penn Foster High School is an accredited online diploma program built for flexibility, it is self paced. That means students can work on their own schedule, fitting school around jobs, family, sports or other responsibilities. It's a different path, but it's a path forward, one that gives students more control over how they learn. The focus is simple. Work toward earning an accredited high school diploma toward what comes next. If you or your family need a change, visit Penn Foster Edu Nancy that's P E N n Foster Edu Nancy and learn more. There is an answer. Your family's safety requires your trust. Trust in the security system you've chosen to protect your home. SimpliSafe has made trust simple 24. 7 Affordable professional monitoring with no long term contracts, no lock ins or hidden cancellation fees, their fully customizable system fits your exact needs with comprehensive sensors and indoor outdoor cameras. Customize a system that's right for you and your [e-mail] and it ships to your door in just a few days. With app guided setup and no drilling required, you can install and arm your system in under an hour. Crime stories listeners get 50% off a new system when signing up for professional monitoring and your first month is free. You just visit simplisafe.com Nancy that's half [e-mail] Nancy first month free. There is no safe like SimpliSafe.

[Veracity Advertiser]

Let's take a minute to unpack the myths behind GLP1 drugs Myth 1 GLP1 is a long term solution for weight loss True GLP1 can potentially be a long term solution for weight loss. If you want to be on a drug that changes your body's natural instincts, GLP1 can fix your metabolism. False GLP1s fix hunger and this leads to weight loss. But the GLP1s may actually slow down your metabolic rate as your body adjusts to consuming fewer calories. GLP1 leads to a loss of muscle mass True GLP1 can lead to a loss of muscle mass due to losing weight so rapidly that your body is pulling from both fat and muscle to make up for the energy gap from consuming so few calories. If you're looking for a natural GLP1 therapy, you should consider Metabolism Ignite Metabolism Ignite is powered by plants and can help boost your natural GLP 1. Visit VeracityHealth Co to learn more. That's V E R A C I T Y Health Co and type in promo code IHEART for up to 65% off your purchase.

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

Crime Stories with Nancy Grace

[Nancy Grace]

Joining US now is Sade's father, Mr. Carlos Robinson. Mr. Robinson, thank you for being with us.

[Carlos Robinson]

Yes, you're welcome.

[Nancy Grace]

Mr. Robinson, when did you learn that Sade had been killed

[Carlos Robinson]

for sure? When the DNA came back as a match to mine when she was missing, I was hopeful she was still here.

[Nancy Grace]

Up until that point, did you believe that she was just missing, that she would be found?

[Carlos Robinson]

That's what I was praying for, that she would be found, that the body parts wasn't hers and that she was going to be found.

[Nancy Grace]

Mr. Robinson, there was a moment where a volunteer, not police, but a volunteer, discovered, as it's being called, a pet tribute blanket and it was found wet and dirty and filthy in a park area, a park for children area, and nearby were human body parts. When you heard her blanket, her little pet tribute blanket had been found, what went through your mind?

[Carlos Robinson]

All of this is incomprehensible. You know, I don't understand how the community and I appreciate everything that they're doing how they can find a blanket that was already searched by an area that was already searched by the authorities.

[Nancy Grace]

Was it, Mr. Robinson, had that area been thoroughly searched by authorities? Because it's my understanding, volunteers for found body parts as well?

[Carlos Robinson]

Yeah, I, I talked to the police after they, the, the blanket was found and I asked them why they didn't find it because they told me they searched that area previously. I've been here since 11 o' clock last night. I haven't been to sleep. I've been to the parts I've been all over with flashlights, binoculars and I just don't feel like I can sleep. I just need to. I just want to find her, you know, there's only two body parts left we have found and I just want to put her to rest properly. I keep having dreams about it. I just want her to at least rest in peace and I, I can't, can't do that until I have her together. They won't even let me see the body parts they have because they said it's evidence. So I'm, I'm just trying to do what I can do to find, hoping she leads me to it.

[Nancy Grace]

Mr. Robinson, just thank you so much for speaking with us today because I know your heart is breaking and you have been looking through the night out with a flashlight trying to find your daughter, her body parts. Tell me about Sade. In life,

[Carlos Robinson]

my baby girl was an amazing person. She was, she was full of love. She was a giver. She would give you the shirt off her back. She had a very good heart. She was intelligent.

[Nancy Grace]

Mr. Robinson, what did she Want to be. When she got out of college, what did she want to do?

[Carlos Robinson]

Her goal was to be a lawyer. Ultimately, she was graduating for criminal justice, but she was torn between military and being a lawyer. But she always wanted to be a lawyer.

[Nancy Grace]

How proud of her were you going to college, paying her way, working. I mean, this girl did it all.

[Carlos Robinson]

Yeah, she did. She did. She. She was a very independent minded person. She would call me and tell me, you know, dad, I'm doing this or I'm doing that.

[Nancy Grace]

You stated that two body parts have not been found. What part of Sade has not been found?

[Carlos Robinson]

Her head and one of her arms, sir.

[Nancy Grace]

When you learned that she was, quote, excited about her date with this Milwaukee millionaire's son, what goes through your mind?

[Carlos Robinson]

None of it makes sense to me. She did not just seem this guy was not her type at all. I don't know how he got her to come to his house, but that's not something I could see my daughter doing, especially with somebody she didn't know.

[Nancy Grace]

Mr. Robinson, we are learning about this guy underground torture chamber. What goes through your mind when you hear about that? I think my father would just lay down on the ground and cry.

[Carlos Robinson]

It takes a different kind of evil to do something like this.

[Nancy Grace]

Joining me right now is a very special guest, a woman I now consider a friend, Sheena Scarborough. This is Sade's mother. How do you keep putting one foot in front of the other?

[Sheena Scarborough]

Oh, yes, Nancy, this is so challenging.

Daily.

I don't know how I'm doing it. I'm walking in Shoddy's spirit and inner grace. I am her voice. I have to speak and advocate through her for others. This is not something that just like pulled up and happened. I don't know. This is a waking nightmare, Haley. Every day I wake up. I can't believe what is taking place. I am Sade Robinson's mother. This is very ongoingly tragic. My baby was my everything. She's my light. She's my star. She was so independent, self sufficient. She had her whole life ahead of her. She worked two jobs. She was dedicated.

She was strong.

Wrong. The Maxwell Anderson that harmed and hurt my baby, I want that individual and his family held fully accountable. This is unacceptable behavior. My daughter did not.

[Nancy Grace]

Ms. Garb, I just wanted to tell you that in the last days, his lawyer has demanded that he have a laptop behind bars. He can kiss my rear end if he's going to get a private laptop behind bars. Ms. Scarborough, I'm seeing you and you have definitely. You're wasting away. You just. I can look at you, and you have lost so much weight. You're wasting away. How are you managing to go forward?

[Sheena Scarborough]

I can't sleep, Nancy. I can't eat. I'm doing ongoing, you know, therapy along with my youngest daughter. I have symptoms, physical symptoms. I don't mean to get in depth, but I don't share this a lot. But since this has happened, I'm very empathic and I've always been like this. I can literally feel the symptoms of what this person did to my daughter. I literally don't move the same way physically. It's a lot of different layers of things going on with my physical health. I can't describe it, but I don't know, Nancy. It's very challenging.

[Nancy Grace]

We are still on the search for parts of Sade's body, but we are learning in the last days that police are focusing now on various dating apps as to how this teen girl met up with a much, much older man. I don't know what he said to her on this dating app to make her think that it was okay to go with him, but we're not only learning about a date potential dating app connection, but we're also learning about an alleged CI, a confidential informant that claims this guy, Maxwell Anderson, told him the CI, that he was going to lure Sade, take her to the basement, shoot her, and dismember her. Now, who the hey knows something like that and does nothing? But regarding these newly released warrants. Listen.

[Unidentified Narrator]

Eight unsealed warrants are giving new insights into the investigation of Sade Robinson's murder. Newly released surveillance images show Sade meeting Anderson at the Twisted Fisherman for their date. The warrants also reveal police are reviewing employment records and surveillance from Victor's nightclub. Anderson reportedly worked at Victors, a club that one of Sade's co workers says they frequented. Investigators are trying to determine how Sade met Anderson.

[Nancy Grace]

With me is Sade's mother, Sheena Scarborough. I don't know if you have seen the footage of that basement. It's filthy, it's dug up, it's covered in debris. And this defendant picked Sade out of all the women in the area to lure her down to that filthy basement basement to murder her. I just don't understand why her. Have you seen that basement?

[Sheena Scarborough]

It disgusts me, Nancy.

My daughter did not deserve this. This is un. Surreal.

This is freaking unsurrel.

Like, I don't know how we were placed in this nightmare by this demon. Why would you harm my baby?

She hurt nobody. She was angelic she put out good energy. She helped others. She was there for the community. She was there for my, the elders, the young people, her peers. She was constantly giving back. There is something deeper into this, but the truth is going to be told.

[Nancy Grace]

Ms. Scarborough, before we sign off, I just want you to know how much we are praying for you and thinking about you and your whole family. And we will not rest until her killer gets the maximum sentence in that jurisdiction, which is life without parole.

[Sheena Scarborough]

Nancy. Thank you God.

[Nancy Grace]

Please be with Sade's family. Mr. Shanday.

[Sheena Scarborough]

These are her earrings that came in the mail yesterday. Nancy, I don't know if you can see them. I had to go to my baby place for the first time and these came for her. These are her earrings. And I have her earrings on. These are my baby's earrings. This is so.

[Nancy Grace]

You know what's so funny? Look what I've got. My dad's shirt. My dad that passed away. I don't know why. I just feel better having it with me. Like your earrings. Guys, let's just stop for one moment and remember an American hero Police officer Michael Jensen. Just 29 years old. Jensen shot in the line of duty, Syracuse, N.Y. leaving behind his loving parents and sweet sister. American hero Police officer Michael Jensen. Nancy Grace signing off. Goodbye friend.

[Mazda CX5 Advertiser]

Introducing the all new Mazda CX5 featuring more connection. Hey Google, where's the nearest Pilates class? Safety that has your back? More discovery on the scenic routes. More passion in the details and more control in changing weather. The all new Mazda CX5 more to move every side of you. See it in 5 [e-mail] 5 Google

[Veracity Advertiser]

is a trademark of Google LLC.

[Nancy Grace]

Sequences shortened and simulated service opens doors and at American Military University it can open doors for the whole family. If you have a loved one who

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

served in the military, you may qualify for reduced tuition. AMU offers flexible online programs designed to fit your schedule so you can keep moving forward. Forward wherever life takes you.

[Nancy Grace]

Learn [e-mail] edu military open doors to

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

the future for you and your family

[Nancy Grace]

with the help of American Military University.

[Penn Foster / SimpliSafe Advertiser]

Your family's safety requires your trust. Trust in the security system you've chosen to protect your home. Simplisafe has made trust simple 24. 7 Affordable professional monitoring with no long term contracts, no lock ins or hidden cancellation fees. Their fully customizable system fits your exact needs with comprehensive sensors and indoor outdoor cameras. Customize a system that's right for you and your [e-mail] and it ships to your door in just a few days. With app guided setup and no drilling required, you can install and arm your system in under an hour. Crime stories listeners get 50% off a new system when signing up for professional monitoring and your first month is free. You just visit simplisafe.com Nancy that's half [e-mail] Nancy first month free. There is no safe like SimpliSafe.

[Veracity Advertiser]

Let's take a minute to unpack the myths behind GLP1 drugs Myth 1 GLP1 is a long term solution for weight loss True GLP1 can potentially be a long term solution for weight loss if you want to be on a drug that changes your body's natural instincts. Myth number 2 GLP1 can fix your metabolism. False GLP1s fix hunger and this leads to weight loss. But the GLP1s may actually slow down your metabolic rate as your body adjusts to consuming fewer calories. GLP1 leads to a loss of muscle mass True GLP1 can lead to a loss of muscle mass due to losing weight so rapidly that your body is pulling from both fat and muscle to make up for the energy gap from consuming so few calories. If you're looking for a natural GLP1 therapy, you should consider Metabolism Ignite. Metabolism Ignite is powered by plants and can help boost your natural GLP 1. Visit VeracityHealth Co to learn more. That's V E R A C I T Y Health Co and type in promo code iheart for up to 65% off your purchase.

[Nancy Grace]

This is an iheart podcast. Guaranteed human.