Criminal Attorney: Episode 5 - "A Few Good Men"

Release Date: October 14, 2024
Host/Author: Wondery
Title: Criminal Attorney

Introduction

In the gripping fifth installment of Wondery's Criminal Attorney series, titled "A Few Good Men," listeners delve deeper into the intricate web surrounding Paul Bergren, a renowned criminal defense attorney in Newark, New Jersey. As Paul's reputation for securing client acquittals soars, so do the suspicions regarding his involvement in illicit activities. This episode unravels the complex dynamics between Paul, his clients, the FBI, and those who stand in between.

The Suspicious Incident

The episode opens with John Edwards Tiffany recounting a peculiar encounter in Paul’s office. While heading home, John realized he forgot something and decided to retrieve it, only to find a man rummaging through legal files with a flashlight in Paul's office.

John Edwards Tiffany (00:59): "I startled the shit out. What are you doing?"

The paralegal hastily exited, leaving John unsettled. This unusual behavior hinted at the unconventional and possibly covert operations within Paul's legal practice.

Paul Bergren and Will Hunsaker

The narrative shifts to Will Hunsaker, a dedicated soldier who finds himself wrongfully detained alongside three other soldiers accused of murdering three unarmed Iraqi detainees. Paul Bergren steps in pro bono to defend them, showcasing his relentless drive to challenge authority and expose corruption.

Paul Bergren (06:54): "I guess you could say if the light was to light up every little dark corner in that, there'd be a lot of cockroaches scattering."

Paul's strategy focuses on holding higher-ranking officials accountable, particularly the colonel who allegedly ordered the killings, despite the colonel receiving immunity.

Arrest and Investigation

As Paul's investigative prowess intensifies, he simultaneously manages illegal enterprises, including an escort agency and money laundering operations. His dual life attracts the attention of FBI Agent Shawn Brokos, who perceives Paul as a formidable adversary.

Paul's apparent downfall begins when he is unexpectedly arrested for multiple felonies, including money laundering and conspiracy to promote prostitution. This arrest leaves his clients and associates bewildered, fearing that Paul's legal maneuvering might jeopardize ongoing cases.

Paul Bergren (07:21): "It was kind of challenging the status quo... trying to bring to light, look, this is what it is."

Legal Maneuvers

Larry Lustberg, a respected criminal defense attorney and Paul's cousin, steps in to represent Paul. Despite initial reservations about the daunting case, Larry recognizes the significance and complexities involved. Their longstanding professional respect adds depth to the portrayal of legal battles.

Will Hunsaker (25:21): "If he was convicted of murdering a witness, Paul could face a death penalty."

Larry meticulously dissects the prosecution's case, aiming to dismantle the evidence linking Paul directly to the crimes. However, Paul's decision to represent himself adds unpredictability to the trial, highlighting his confidence and legal acumen.

The Trial

Paul's courtroom appearance is a dramatic spectacle. Dressed in a pinstripe suit despite being in chains, he passionately defends himself against the charges. His opening argument successfully persuades the judge to sever the murder charge from the other felonies, narrowing the scope of the trial.

Paul Bergren (29:57): "But."

This strategic win forces the trial to focus solely on the murder charge, undermining the comprehensive prosecution's narrative. Despite extensive efforts, Shawn Brokos faces setbacks as the jury declares a mistrial, leaving Paul unconvicted but the case far from resolved.

Conclusion

The episode culminates with Agent Shawn Brokos reflecting on the mistrial, expressing her exhaustion and desire to move on from the case. However, the unresolved verdict sets the stage for continued conflict, with the prosecution poised to pursue Paul relentlessly in future trials.

Shawn Brokos (32:11): "FBI always gets its man."

As the episode draws to a close, the tension remains palpable, indicating that Paul's battle with the law is far from over. Listeners are left anticipating the final installment, where the pursuit reaches its climax.

Key Takeaways

• Paul Bergren's Dual Life: Paul adeptly balances his high-profile legal cases with illicit activities, making him a complex and elusive character.

• Agent Shawn Brokos' Determination: Shawn's relentless pursuit of Paul showcases her commitment to justice, despite personal and professional challenges.

• Legal Strategy and Tactics: The trial underscores the intricacies of legal maneuvers, highlighting how strategic decisions can sway high-stakes cases.

• Moral Ambiguities: The episode delves into ethical dilemmas, questioning the boundaries between lawful defense and unlawful actions.

Notable Quotes

• John Edwards Tiffany (00:59): "I startled the shit out. What are you doing?"

• Paul Bergren (06:54): "I guess you could say if the light was to light up every little dark corner in that, there'd be a lot of cockroaches scattering."

• Paul Bergren (07:21): "It was kind of challenging the status quo... trying to bring to light, look, this is what it is."

• Will Hunsaker (25:21): "If he was convicted of murdering a witness, Paul could face a death penalty."

• Paul Bergren (29:57): "But."

• Shawn Brokos (32:11): "FBI always gets its man."

Stay Tuned: As the battle between Paul Bergren and Agent Shawn Brokos intensifies, the final episode promises to deliver a riveting conclusion to this legal thriller. Follow Criminal Attorney on the Wondery App, Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or wherever you get your podcasts to continue the journey.