Summary of "The Clearwater Monster" – Criminal Podcast by Vox Media

Podcast Title: Criminal
Host: Phoebe Judge
Episode: The Clearwater Monster
Release Date: July 4, 2025
Description: Criminal explores stories about people who've done wrong, been wronged, or found themselves caught in between. In "The Clearwater Monster," listener Jeff Signorini delves into a decades-old local legend intertwined with a heartwarming family secret.

Introduction to the Clearwater Monster Phenomenon

In the early hours of July 1948, Clearwater Beach, Florida, was the stage for an unusual event that would captivate the small community and eventually attract national attention.

Phoebe Judge narrates:

"One morning in 1948, a phone call woke up the police chief in the small beach town of Clearwater, Florida. It was 3 am..." ([00:00])

A mysterious caller reported seeing a large, "blowing and spouting" entity emerging from the water, standing nearly 10 feet tall. The eerie sight was accompanied by a request to borrow a high-powered rifle to shoot the creature. The caller's anonymity deepened the intrigue, and shortly after, peculiar footprints appeared on the beach, sparking widespread speculation.

Emergence of the Legend

Local reporter Jeff Klinkenberg, with nearly four decades of experience covering Florida's mysteries, provides firsthand insights into the initial reactions:

"It was like something that didn't exist, like some kind of dinosaur from the Jurassic age." ([02:18])

The footprints were extraordinary—14 inches long, 11 inches wide, with a narrow heel and three prominent toes, resembling something out of a children's show rather than a natural creature. The fear and curiosity among residents grew as theories ranged from sea turtles to crocodiles, none of which matched the evidence.

Judge elaborates:

"Plans were made to send photographs of the tracks to the Smithsonian to be studied. But the rumor was already circulating that Clearwater beach had a sea monster." ([04:11])

The story quickly gained national traction, with letters pouring in from scientists and enthusiasts alike, fueling the monster's legend.

Ivan Sanderson's Involvement

Enter Ivan Sanderson, a charismatic self-zoologist and pioneer of cryptozoology, known for his enthusiastic pursuit of mythical creatures.

Jeff Klinkenberg describes Sanderson:

"He was sort of like Douglas Fairbanks, you know, slick black hair, pencil-thin mustache... a ham." ([07:54])

Sanderson saw the Clearwater footprints as a potential groundbreaking discovery. Equipped with basic tools and his trusty aircraft, he embarked on an investigation, ultimately concluding that the tracks belonged to giant penguins—a hypothesis that added a whimsical twist to the mystery.

"He concluded that the creature was probably generally unhappy, based on its wandering path." ([10:44])

Despite his efforts, no substantial evidence of giant penguins surfaced, and Sanderson eventually returned to New York, leaving the Clearwater Monster mystery unresolved.

The Secret Behind the Legend

The true story behind the Clearwater Monster was a playful secret kept within a family for decades. Jeff Signorini, the grandson of the man who would become known as the monster, reveals the heartfelt prank:

Jeff Signorini shares:

"My father and Al Williams came up with the idea for a prank that would top them all." ([18:18])

In collaboration with his friend Al Williams, Jeff's father, Tony Signorini, fabricated the monster's footprints using cast iron feet and high-top sneakers. Over ten years, they meticulously created the illusion of a sea monster traversing the beach, delighting in the community's reactions.

"They'd go out in a rowboat... put the feet on and step overboard, walking up onto the sand to create tracks." ([21:00])

The pranks were harmless, intended to bring joy and wonder to an otherwise quiet town. The secret remained within the family until years later when Tony decided to reveal the truth, sharing the hefty cast-iron feet with a reporter and unmasking the legendary monster.

Legacy and Reflection

Tony Signorini’s obituary highlighted his multifaceted life, including his service in World War II and his long-standing reputation as the Clearwater Monster. His son, Jeff, reflects on his father's legacy:

"It was part of him, and it had to be part of his story." ([29:28])

Today, Jeff cherishes the monstrous feet as a family heirloom and symbol of his father's playful spirit. The revelation of the Clearwater Monster serves as a testament to the enduring power of community legends and the simple joys of creative pranks.

Jeff Klinkenberg concludes:

"Pranks are fun. They give people some excitement... It's the stuff that makes life worth living." ([31:31])

Notable Quotes

• Phoebe Judge:
  "I can't imagine. This must have been pretty exciting news." ([05:30])

• Jeff Signorini:
  "Anything that's done, that's the... he became the guidance to things in that way." ([29:53])

• Alyssa Shimco (Tony's Granddaughter):
  "It was just the joy of them thinking maybe they could get a rise out of someone." ([30:18])

Conclusion

"The Clearwater Monster" intertwines local folklore, family bonds, and the universal love for mystery and storytelling. Through playful deception, Tony Signorini and Al Williams not only entertained their community but also created a lasting legend that continues to inspire curiosity and wonder.

Support and Further Listening

For those intrigued by the blend of true crime and human stories, Criminal offers a rich array of episodes that delve deep into the complexities of right and wrong. Subscribe to stay updated with the latest stories that challenge and enlighten.