Siders Rescue: How Did 16 Kids Slip Through the Cracks?

Summary

Criminally Obsessed Podcast Summary

Episode: "Siders Rescue: How Did 16 Kids Slip Through the Cracks?"

Date: July 15, 2026

Host: Anne Emerson

Guest: Kelly Kitley, Licensed Clinical Social Worker

---

Overview

This gripping episode delves into the shocking “Siders Rescue” case, where 16 children—ranging from 18 months to 18 years old—were rescued from appalling, isolated conditions in rural Ohio. Host Anne Emerson seeks to uncover how such extreme neglect could go unnoticed for so long, examining failures in the social safety net, the limits of homeschool checks, and the generational trauma underlying the case. Expert guest Kelly Kitley, a clinical social worker, offers insight on both systemic failures and the lifelong road to recovery for the survivors.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Questioning the Narrative: Did 16 Children Really "Fall Through the Cracks"?

• Anne opens with frustration at official phrasing:

  “Every time I hear someone say that the 16 Siders children just fell through the cracks, I find myself thinking, no, 16 children don't just fall through the cracks, do they?” (00:00)

• Truancy complaints against Elizabeth Siders went unserved because the family “was nowhere to be found” (00:35).
• Conditions of rescue: 16 children (18 years to 18 months) found in a 12x12 room, in squalor described by first responders as “the worst-smelling place imaginable.” (00:35)
• Severe malnutrition: two children hospitalized, others traumatized (00:35).

2. The Role of Isolation & Community Blind Spots

• Social worker Kelly Kitley:

  “This family was living in isolation in a desolate area... There’s no wonder it took so long for people to find out what was going on.” (02:50)

• Lack of exposure: no school attendance, little to no interaction with neighbors, actively avoiding outside contact (03:12).
• Anne: “Have you seen it happen like this?”
• Kelly: “This is an extreme case. Child abuse and neglect is more common than people realize—probably higher because a lot of those go unreported.” (03:59)

3. Generational Trauma & Mental Health

• Kelly highlights multigenerational trauma, speculating that neglect may have been passed down from grandparents to parents (03:59).
• Anne raises the issue of the young mother's (Elizabeth's) age and circumstances—married at 15, perhaps not developmentally an “adult” (07:42).
• Unanswered questions about family’s mental health, possible disabilities, or substance abuse factors influencing neglect (08:04).

4. Systemic Failures: Education, Social Services, and Mobility

• Parents avoided school systems, making discovery difficult. Rural setting exacerbated the lack of oversight (06:11).
• Kelly’s experience: urban cases attract more notice; in rural areas, community is often unaware of residents, especially with high mobility (06:11).
• Movement across counties likely a deliberate tactic to avoid detection:

  “Moving from county to county is how you actually fall through the loopholes, too.” (16:32)

5. Gag Orders, Public Perception, and the Media

• Anne notes law enforcement’s use of language—likening children to “livestock,” calling the situation “pure evil”—suggesting even seasoned officials were shaken (04:46).
• Discussion about “groupthink” among the four adults: no one broke ranks to intervene or expose the abuse (07:07).
• Kelly on public anger: “It is human nature to lash out… but I can only imagine what had happened to the parents of these children” (09:02).

6. Possible Missed Red Flags & Reporting Challenges

• Anecdote from a Dollar General clerk (“Ariel”): witnessed only disheveled adults, terrible odor, but did not know 16 kids lived with them (13:47).
• “He would hold her by her elbow and just guide her around the store.” (Ariel, 13:47)
• Kelly: these were warning signs, but not actionable as abuse reports (14:07).

7. Homeschooling & Limits of Oversight

• Anne references other cases (e.g., Melody Buzzard); asks if homeschooling requirements failed the children (18:04).
• Kelly:

  “If they had no record of some of these children not even existing… there are holes in the system that they fell through that should not have lasted this long.” (18:42)

8. Impact on the Children—Short- and Long-term

• Rehabilitation will be daunting:

  "This is something that's going to take a lifetime to repair for these children." (03:59)

• Communicative and developmental delays significant—children unable to speak or meet basic needs (22:23).
• Success defined as “being able to be in a school setting… probably not a traditional school, but a therapeutic school.” (23:01)
• Acknowledgment that trauma healing is possible, but recovery is unprecedented in severity:

  “I have never seen anything like this in my 25 years… as a social worker.” (22:02)

9. Challenges Ahead: Placement, Resources, and Support

• State of Ohio provided $1 million in emergency funding, but “that’s pennies for the amount of resources... needed.” (23:51)
• Very unlikely all children will be placed together due to high needs and system constraints (19:45).
• Need for “wraparound for each individual child to be successful in life.” (23:51)

10. Community Responsibility & What Comes Next

• Kelly's plea:

  “If you see something, say something, because you never know what's going on behind closed doors.” (24:30) “There is a sense of responsibility in communities to look out for one another.” (24:30)

• Anne closes with a call for sustained public attention to the wellbeing of the rescued children as the news cycle moves on (24:02).

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Anne Emerson (Host):

  “16 children can't just fall through the cracks—not at their school records, not when there are truancy complaints. How did 16 children become practically invisible?” (00:35)

• Kelly Kitley:

  “This is an extreme case. Child abuse and neglect is more common than people realize… This is something that’s going to take a lifetime to repair for these children.” (03:59) “Success… would be that they are able to be in a school setting. Probably not a traditional school, but a therapeutic school.” (23:01) “That’s pennies for the amount of resources that are going to be needed to create a wraparound for each individual child.” (23:51) “If you see something, say something, because you never know what's going on behind closed doors.” (24:30)

• Ariel (Dollar General clerk):

  “When I saw Gary and Elizabeth, let's just say I would have to Lysol before they came in, Lysol while they were in the store and Lysol while they left the store. That's how bad the odor was.” (13:47)

---

Key Timestamps

• 00:00 — Anne’s impassioned introduction; overview of official and social worker reactions.
• 00:35 — Detailed findings from truancy documents and rescue scene.
• 02:50 — Social worker Kelly Kitley joins; discussion of rural isolation.
• 03:59 — Statistics & perspective on extreme neglect cases.
• 06:11 — Systemic failures; rural vs. urban child welfare.
• 07:07 — “Groupthink” and complicity of all adults in the home.
• 13:47 — Interview with clerk Ariel; community contact (or lack thereof).
• 16:32 — Family’s movement across counties as a factor in evading detection.
• 19:45 — Challenges and priorities of placement after rescue.
• 22:02 — The daunting scale of the children’s trauma and path to healing.
• 23:51 — State funding discussed vs. actual needs.
• 24:30 — Kelly’s closing thoughts on community vigilance.

---

Conclusion

This episode offers a sobering look inside a true-crime case of unprecedented scale and neglect, challenging listeners to confront both the failures of multiple systems and their own roles as community members. While it outlines the heartbreaking trajectory of the Siders children’s suffering, it also presses for greater awareness, vigilance, and compassion to ensure such tragedies cannot recur unseen.

Transcript

[A]

Hi everyone, I'm Ann Emerson and this is criminally obsessed. Okay, I need to vent for a second because every time I hear someone say that the 16 Siders children just fell through the cracks, I find myself thinking, no, 16 children don't just fall through the cracks, do they? And I know I'm not the only one asking, how does this happen? Social workers are asking the same question because this is the worst case they've ever, ever seen.

[B]

When you're living in rural towns like this, I mean, people do want to know, where did the system fail this family?

[A]

Well, I have some new documents here from our sister station WSYX in Ohio. They're truancy complaints by a school system against Elizabeth Sers, the mom. They're from an elementary school about an hour away from where the ciders were living before they were arrested. And Here it says six of the children were absent for quote, the entire 2021, 2022 school year. The filed the complaints but weren't able to serve the ciders because they were nowhere to be found. The children were rescued in Hampden, Ohio, and they ranged from 18 years old to 18 months old. They were living in squalid conditions. A 12 by 12 room. First responders said it was full of human waste and bugs. The worst smelling place imaginable. Now their parents, Elizabeth and Gary Seiders Jr. And the grandparents, Christina and Gary Seiders Senior, are all charged with child endangerment. And before the judge issued a gag order in this case, I learned from officials that some of the children were severely malnourished and ended up in the hospital, two in trauma centers. So back to my point here, 16 children can't just fall through the cracks. Not at their school records, not when their truancy complaints. How did 16 children become practically invisible before deputies walked into that house? And if it happened here, could it happen elsewhere? I called a licensed social worker, Kelly Kitley, to help me understand the part of this story that is bothering me the most. Not what happened inside that house, but everything that happened outside of it to allow it to continue. Be sure to like and subscribe and turn on your notifications. We'll be updating this story. Now let's get into it. Kelly. Kelly, thank you so much for coming on the show and talking to us about this. We've been looking to get better perspective on what happened with the sitters children and really why it took so long to rescue these kids. So I appreciate you coming on to, to to give us your take. You know, as a Licensed clinical social worker. I imagine this is not your first rodeo.

[B]

It isn't. You know, this is such a horrific story. This family was living in isolation in a desolate area. And so there's no wonder it took so long for people to find out what was going on.

[A]

I mean, you can't stop thinking about it like, how in the world does this go on for years and years without someone stepping in?

[B]

Well, they weren't exposed, they weren't in the school system, they weren't interacting with neighbors, they weren't having any outside interactions. And so it's very hard to see something that's going on in the home when they are so isolated and they weren't going to school. And they seemingly worked very hard to not let anybody into their world inside

[A]

that house to the point where it's, you know, you have an 18 year old to an 18 month old. That's what we're being told, that we're living in an enclosed space, a small space for possibly years. And I know you're telling me that it happens, it happens. But have you seen it happen? Have you seen it happen like this?

[B]

I mean, this is an extreme case. Child abuse and neglect is more common than people realize. One in seven children experience neglect or child abuse, probably higher because a lot of those go unreported. This is a very extreme case. And so from my perspective, there seems to be a long line of generational family trauma going from the grandparents to the parents and then this being passed on to the kids. And so living in seclusion and not having food or water or having availability to go to the bathroom or communicate with the outside world. I mean, this is something that's going to take a lifetime to repair for these children.

[A]

I know that they want us to stop talking about it because Gary Seiders jr's attorney is concerned that he's not going to get a fair trial based on some of the language that's been used, like the children are, are being kept like livestock. That, that is pure evil. I mean, these are, these are officials coming out, law enforcement officials, authorities. You know, people in this system are saying this out loud. I don't, I don't hear that very often. Whatever they saw was overwhelming is what I'm thinking.

[B]

That's what I was going to say. I would imagine the people who were first on the premises of, of seeing the conditions, just the devil, you know, is the word that comes to mind is just so inhumane to have these children living in these conditions that even grown men in the Police force who are exposed to horrible situations every day were so taken aback by these conditions.

[A]

We're just also trying to understand where the, where the, where the checkpoints failed, I guess. And one thing is, I mean, are you aware of parents being able to keep their kids out of school? Just keep them out of school like they did in this case in Ohio?

[B]

Absolutely. Working in child welfare in Illinois, when I first started out as a social worker, these were cases that we saw all the time. And so the difference is these were in my situation in metropolitan areas. And so people would be more, more privy to kids who weren't going to school, who lived on their block. But when you're living in rural towns like this, I mean, people do want to know, where did the system fail this family? And it's hard to tell. It's multifaceted. And certainly there are many components of these children not being out into the world. So I don't even know if anybody knew how many people living in that home.

[A]

When you first heard about this case, you know, as, as a licensed clinical social worker, what, what made you think this is different?

[B]

Well, the fact that you have four adults and under one roof and that the size of the room that these 16 children were in, I mean, it is heart wrenching to think about the conditions that they were living in. And one would hope that maybe one of the adult break and say, oh my gosh, you know, this child is suffering. We need to take them to the hospital. But the fact that there was this group think mentality is just so damaging for not only how long it went on, but for how many lives were impacted.

[A]

Yeah, I mean, it was four adults. And you know, you've got, you've got two, you've got two grandparents, you've got a set of grandparents and then you have a set of parents. But honestly, I mean, when you look at Elizabeth, and there's a lot of questions surrounding Elizabeth right now because she was only 15, parents signed off on her marriage. Does she even count as one of the adults at this point?

[B]

Oh my gosh. I mean, the, the emotional stuntedness of this situation and the capacity of the parents, I mean, we don't know their iq. We don't know if there were any disabilities, if there was substance abuse involved, untreated mental health issues. I mean, there seems to be a variety of high risk factors that are being played out here.

[A]

You know, these, the, the, the public opinion on this case, the Internet has already, you know, really screamed that these are monsters, that these people that would have done something like this to the children are monsters. Do you think that that is going, you know, it, it, it's, it's human nature to kind of lash out when you see something like that. But, but as far as trying to get back on a road, How does that affect the children?

[B]

Well, I think as hard as it is to have some empathy for how horrific the situation is, and most people don't intend to do harm to children in the general population, but certainly in isolated incidents that we're seeing here is that I can only imagine what had happened to the parents of these children that would then potentially replicate some of the situation of what the children have undergone. So it would be my guess that both of the parents have had somewhat of similar situation in their own upbringing.

[A]

Why would anybody do this to 16 children?

[B]

Because there is potentially some personality disorder and layers of trauma and not being able to make coherent decisions. I don't know what kind of mind we're working with, but obviously there is a lot of, of illness in the mix, mental illness.

[A]

How does this happen? That, that, this, that this, that this family unit could, could separate itself from the world like it has?

[B]

Well, that's a question that I have because I mean the mom needing some maternal care for delivery and prenatal care, perhaps if she was even getting anything, you know, or follow up visits for pediatrician, I mean these kids weren't getting any of that. So you know, what happens from the time they leave the hospital until, you know, that first year. It is so detrimental not having any of those interventions for these young kids.

[A]

Well, and we don't even know if she ever went to the hospital or if there was somebody that came into the home, but that means somebody was there. Unless, unless we don't know. I mean, I've been racking my brain for the last week since we've been working on this story, trying to figure out how this is even possible. Like literally how is it possible? I mean, you've got kids that are 18 months to 18 years old. Nobody knows, nobody knows anything about, about who these kids are, you know, and you know, as, as you're going through it, do you know it? Do you think asking the question how could nobody know? Is that the right question? Are we asking the wrong question right now?

[B]

You know, I think we are so hyper focused on, you know, who we can blame for this or finding out the how or the why is more so what I'm looking at from the lens of a social worker as to what was going on, that this situation continued to multiply child after child and having the lack of resources when somebody's in isolation and they don't want somebody else to find out what's going on, they're going to go to every length to hide that. And they, this family did that. And so, you know, there really isn't any exposure that I can see that somebody would have reported it, which is why, you know, it is so important for the general public to report something if they see something, to say something. But it seems to me that they weren't out in the community.

[A]

So what do you think was going on in that house?

[B]

I can only imagine, you know, from my experience in past cases that I've seen has been malnutrition and potential sexual abuse and you know, children parenting children that have no business doing that. I don't know what was going on for the grandparents and how hands on they were with the children, but certainly having low resources and you know, maybe financial stress and not having ability to pay for food or clothing or hygiene. I mean, it is just endless in terms of the concern of the well being of these children.

[A]

Yeah, I mean you can, you can go to dark places when you think about what's going on in that house. But you know, one thing that we did, we have a couple of, we spoke to the, to the clerk at the Dollar General, we did an interview with Ariel and she shed a little bit of light on it for me. You know, she said she didn't even know those kids, lived with them.

[C]

When I saw Gary and Elizabeth, let's just say I would have to Lysol before they came in, Lysol while they were in the store and Lysol while they left the store. That's how bad the order was. He would hold her by her elbow and just guide her around the store.

[A]

What does that say to you?

[B]

Well, it's bizarre behavior, but it's certainly not something that would be warranted to, to report. I mean, look, the pictures in general, the four adults look very disheveled and unkept. So that would be a potential warning sign for me. But certainly not enough to, to report something.

[A]

No, you're right. And that's why it didn't. I mean, she gave them hygiene products because she said it smelled so bad when they left that she would have to like spray Lysol all over because it was this, the stench was so extreme when they would. But the other thing that was very concerning and I don't really understand why they would do this, but like she said, almost every time they were coming in to buy vegetable oil, and not a big thing of vegetable oil, but like a thing like this, a vegetable oil and water. Have you ever heard of what that vegetable oil would be used for?

[B]

I have not. I have no idea.

[A]

I had heard that that vegetable oil was used in severe malnutrition cases in third. I don't want to say third world countries, but in. In countries or where you see, like, a lot of poverty. So I was just wondering if that was something you had seen in your work or you had heard talked about.

[B]

No.

[A]

Isn't that bizarre? I know. And I mean, I. I didn't want to jump to conclusions, but at the same time, I thought it was interesting that when I did do any kind of research looking for vegetable oil, that's what came up.

[B]

Okay.

[A]

That it was actually used in that way. And we have seen some pictures of, like, rice bags and stuff. But I mean, we've also heard that it was all infested with bugs, human waste. So it just gets worse and worse. I want to know, like, the isolation of this family we're talking about now, if the. If the oldest one is 18 years old, we're talking about at least 18 years where they have been traveling, you know, or living under the radar from county to county. I mean, how do you even move 16 children from house to house without being detected? But do you think that moving from county to county is how you actually fall through the loopholes, too?

[B]

Absolutely, yes. And that was probably done strategically, is my guess, is to not be noticed. And who knows how the transport happened, but certainly not wanting to draw any kind of attention and stay in the same community for too long because this could have been found sooner had they stayed in the same location, I would assume.

[A]

Yeah. And that's what ended up happening, didn't it? From what we understand, they were serving a search warrant on Gary Sers Jr. For public indecency charges. That's when they discovered the kids.

[B]

Right.

[A]

They didn't know that they were even in the house. Now, Elizabeth's attorneys that requested that she gets to leave the. The jail under certain conditions because of her lack of criminality. She's never been charged, but no one's ever seen her. I mean, she's been, you know, in hiding. In hiding or. Or in this house, either on her own behest or. Or because she had to for whatever reason. Yeah, but what's your reaction to that? Do you think that that is appropriate in a case like this when a mom with these kids.

[B]

No. She needs so Much rehabilitation and so many services. I know that there is a lack of resources and that there has been money allotted to the care of the children, but there has to be some serious consequences for the lives of these 16 children that she's completely ruined.

[A]

I worked on a case, Melody Buzzard, a little girl who, her mother is now accused of her murder, but she had kept her in homeschooling. And the reason they were able to find out that Melody was missing in the first place was because the district came forward and said, I have no, we can't find her. She's not. She hasn't come back to register for classes, that sort of thing. So can you explain to me, like, isn't there some checks in homeschooling as well? I mean, if these kids were all being homeschooled, shouldn't the district have known where they were and what was going on? They have to register.

[B]

Sure, absolutely. But if they had no record of some of these children not even existing, I mean, you would hope that somebody would find one of them who was claimed to have been homeschooled but wasn't registered. But yes, there, there are whole cracks in the system that they fell through that should not have lasted this long.

[A]

Do you see patterns in severe neglect cases? Like, are there things that you're hearing in this case that ring bells with other cases you've worked?

[B]

Absolutely. Low socioeconomic status, minimal resources, lack of education, potential untreated mental health issues, substance abuse, substance use disorder, generational traumas. I mean, that's pretty, pretty consistent across most, most cases.

[A]

Is there any way to keep these kids together? Is that something that's going through the mind of the social services group right now? Are they trying to keep them together?

[B]

You know what? These kids are so such high need that it would be very difficult to keep 16 children together in the same home. And I know that there's been an inevitable a flow of people coming forward who want to be foster parents. And I think that keeping 16 kids together who have. Who need so much assistance is not realistic. And I don't think it would be in the best interest of any of these children to keep them all together.

[A]

Is there anything that just makes you angry about this case?

[B]

Yeah. You know, I'm a mom with four children, and I have seen so many situations that have wreaked havoc on families. And what is so heart wrenching is the damage that has been done that will take so many interventions, physically, emotionally, mentally, spiritually in this situation, that these kids have a really long road ahead of Them to even be contributing members of society.

[A]

Well, I mean, and that's, that takes me straight to the point of like, you know, these children have been rescued and that the nightmare is over for them. Out of this 12 by 12 room. They might been rescued, but I feel like this nightmare is continuing just in a different way now.

[B]

Sure. I mean, there was some sense of security that, that I would imagine these kids felt as crazy it is as it is to look at it that way. They didn't know any different, so this was their norm. And as a social worker, we look at the person in environment, so this is the way that they lived for so long. And now we remove these kids from this situation and the increased anxiety and there's a lot of developmental delays and nutritional components that, I mean, just getting these kids to get to a level where they're nourished is going to take so much time before any of the other work can even begin.

[A]

Will they ever live what we would call a normal existence? Do they go to school? What does it look like to be a child like this?

[B]

It's going to take a lot. And I am an eternal optimist and have seen people recover from extreme trauma. I have never seen anything like this in my 25 years, years of work as a social worker.

[A]

When you hear that they couldn't even communicate when they found him, what do you think about that?

[B]

My first thought was the parents and the grandparents weren't even talking to these children. For them to learn the language, that they probably rarely interacted with them, that they were just left to fend for themselves. They don't know how to feed their self. I mean, we're talking about basic needs and basic daily living skills that they're going to need to learn even if they're 10, 12, 14 years old, because none of that was ever taught to them.

[A]

What does success look like for these kids in five to ten years from now?

[B]

My hope would be that they are able to be in a school setting. Probably not a traditional school, but a therapeutic school. The younger children will have more opportunities to practice integrating into life than some of the older kids. I mean, we're going to have to start at, at some of the basics. But I have seen tremendous turnarounds for children who have been neglected or abused.

[A]

The state of Ohio has come forward in a million dollars in emergency funding to Vinton county where this all took place, to try and help them. Will that, will that be enough to get the ball rolling as far as placement medical? Now you're shaking your head. No, no.

[B]

That's pennies for the amount of resources that are going to be needed to create a wraparound for each individual child to be successful in life.

[A]

You know, a lot of people are going to watch this story and they're going to be horrified by what they see. And then in a few days, the news cycle is going to turn over. Something else is going to happen. If you could, like, wave your magic wand and people would remember these 16 children who have been rescued out of this home. In a year from now, in a year from now, what do you want people to be thinking about?

[B]

Well, I think that this case brings up an awareness in our own community. And I think there is a sense of responsibility and community, communities to look out for one another. And if you see something, say something, because you never know what's going on behind closed doors. I mean, certainly they didn't even know these people existed. And, you know, we can all help in, in a little way, whether that is, you know, volunteering time or money, because a lot of children in our country are struggling.

[A]

Drop a comment below. I want to hear your thoughts and I am reading your comments. Thank you so much for all of the responses we've gotten on this story. And be sure to like and subscribe and turn on your notifications. As we update this story, I want you to be the first to know.