Critical Role & Sagas of Sundry: "The Rudest TTRPG Actual Play Ever?!" with Christopher Hastings & Joe Lepore
Release Date: May 28, 2025
Welcome to a detailed summary of the "Critical Role & Sagas of Sundry" episode titled "The Rudest TTRPG Actual Play Ever?!", hosted by Geek & Sundry. This episode features an engaging conversation with Christopher Hastings and Joe Lepore, renowned storytellers from the "Rude Tales of Magic" podcast. Below, we delve into their journeys in tabletop role-playing games (TTRPGs), the creation of their unique campaign, and their insights for aspiring Dungeon Masters (DMs).
1. Introduction
Dan Casey welcomes adventurers to the episode, introducing guests Christopher Hastings and Joe Lepore, the creative minds behind "Rude Tales of Magic." [01:05]
Dan Casey: “Folks, please welcome Joe Lepore and Christopher Hastings. Thank you, Joe. Guys. Chris, Joe, thank you for being here. I really appreciate it.”
2. Early Experiences in TTRPGs
a. Christopher Hastings’ Beginnings
Christopher recounts his introduction to TTRPGs during the late 1990s while working at a Boy Scout camp. His first exposure was through coworkers playing the "Ravenloft Mask of the Red Death" module of Dungeons & Dragons (D&D), which blended Lovecraftian horror with traditional gameplay.
Christopher Hastings: “I had never heard of this thing before... but I got hooked at that point.”
He describes his excitement upon discovering a version of D&D that diverged significantly from the standard rules, incorporating whimsical elements like "space cats in flying convertibles," which captivated his imagination and drew him deeper into the world of tabletop gaming.
b. Joe Lepore’s Journey
Growing up in Hull, Massachusetts, Joe had limited exposure to the nerd culture prevalent in larger cities. His high school had a minimal number of students interested in anime and comic books, making it difficult to find peers to play TTRPGs. Fast forward to 2015, Joe reconnects with Christopher and other friends through improv and sketch comedy in New York City, leading to the formation of their first D&D group.
Joe Lepore: “I was instantly, instantly hooked, baby. I couldn't get enough.”
This newfound camaraderie culminated in the creation of "Rude Tales of Magic," as their enthusiasm and energy propelled them to expand beyond their initial six-episode plan.
3. Developing Characters
a. Christopher Hastings’ First Character
Christopher’s inaugural character was Brother Sebastian, a human cleric of Mystra, the goddess of magic, designed with a min-maxed approach inspired by D&D sourcebooks.
Christopher Hastings: “Brother Sebastian was... able to cast wizard spells, like, one level later than a wizard would have been able to.”
He candidly admits to metagaming—using knowledge outside the game to gain advantages—highlighting his early passion for crafting powerful characters.
b. Joe Lepore’s First Character
Joe shares his first character, Flint Frostbeard, a dwarf fighter who is an academic and scholar yet humorously inept.
Joe Lepore: “He was none the wiser really. But after that first session, I was like... I could have been a fucking wizard.”
Inspired by Christopher’s warlock, Joe transitioned Flint into a spellcasting fighter subclass, showcasing his adaptability and eagerness to explore different character dynamics.
4. The Genesis of Rude Tales of Magic
"Rude Tales of Magic" emerged from the collaborative energy of Christopher and Joe, both seasoned improvisers in New York City's Magnet Theater. Their deep trust and shared comedic sensibilities allowed them to infuse traditional fantasy narratives with a unique blend of humor and heart.
Joe Lepore: “We've got a healthy and loving disrespect of Dungeons and Dragons fantasy... we find that to be the sweet spot of what entertains us.”
This blend of chaos and emotional depth creates a distinctive storytelling experience, making the adventures both entertaining and emotionally resonant.
5. Campaigns and Storytelling
a. Nethermerc Campaign
Their current campaign, Nethermerc, is a creative twist on the classic underdark setting from the Forgotten Realms. Christopher crafted a dark, metallic-themed world filled with whimsical elements reminiscent of "Fraggle Rock," populated by peculiar creatures and menacing slimes.
Christopher Hastings: “It is like navigating the awful caves of a fantasy world where every single monster... has been driven underground and trying to escape that.”
The campaign maintains a mysterious connection to Cordelia, a central setting, hinting at deeper lore yet to be fully revealed.
b. Interconnected Storylines
While "Nethermerc" primarily focuses on the underdark, subtle ties to Cordelia enrich the narrative, allowing for expansive world-building and intertwined storylines that keep players and listeners intrigued.
6. Memorable Moments of Rudeness
Both creators share instances where their characters behaved rudely, adding drama and depth to their campaigns.
Christopher Hastings: “I believe in your world, man. I like to me, I'm like, I know that this will work out... he thinks Chris is quitting the show.”
In one pivotal moment, Christopher's character abruptly exits the game, leading to unexpected plot developments and prolonged story arcs.
Joe Lepore: “And my character... I have to do. I don't have to deal with their bull anymore. I'm free.”
These moments highlight the dynamic and unpredictable nature of their storytelling, where character actions significantly influence the overarching narrative.
7. Advice for Aspiring Dungeon Masters
a. Christopher Hastings’ Tips
Christopher emphasizes the importance of collaborative storytelling and active listening. He advises DMs to engage with players' interests rather than imposing rigid storylines.
Christopher Hastings: “Talk to them and see what they want out of the game. You don't need to come up with some massive story that they just get plunked down into.”
By incorporating players' fears and desires, like Ally Fisher's character fearing the "Light Eater," DMs can create personalized and immersive experiences.
b. Joe Lepore’s Insights
Joe advocates for minimal preparation to foster spontaneity and discovery during gameplay. He warns against over-preparing, which can lead to frustration and limit the evolving story.
Joe Lepore: “If you're the DM, prepare less... allow discovery at the table. That's so much fun for everyone.”
He recommends starting with simple frameworks and expanding organically based on player interactions and interests.
8. Favorite and Underrated TTRPGs
a. Christopher Hastings’ Favorite: Mirkborg
Christopher champions Mirkborg by Free League Publishing, praising its atmospheric depth and rule-light nature.
Christopher Hastings: “Mirkborg is just so metal. It's so dark... it's a gorgeous work of art.”
He appreciates how the game balances heavy thematic elements with engaging gameplay mechanics, fostering a rich storytelling environment.
b. Joe Lepore’s Recommendation: Lasers and Feelings
Joe introduces Lasers and Feelings by John Harper as an excellent gateway game for newcomers seeking simplicity and flexibility.
Joe Lepore: “It's so easy to pick up, it's so easy to learn the mechanics. It's a one-pager, it's a free PDF.”
He highlights its adaptability and accessibility, making it an ideal starting point for groups looking to explore beyond D&D.
9. Game Night Recommendations
The guests share their top game picks for a group setting:
a. Christopher Hastings: Mythic Mischief
Christopher recommends Mythic Mischief, a strategy board game where players control factions of supernatural beings competing to steal books from a forbidden library.
Christopher Hastings: “It's so fun. Better than chess.”
b. Joe Lepore: Diplomacy and Twilight Imperium
Joe expresses a love for Diplomacy and Twilight Imperium, acknowledging their complexity and the deep strategic thinking they demand.
Joe Lepore: “Diplomacy... it's like a World War I war game... everyone has to argue in other rooms and try to convince each other to work together to win.”
10. Conclusion and Where to Find Rude Tales of Magic
Dan Casey wraps up the episode by directing listeners to find "Rude Tales of Magic" online.
Joe Lepore: “Head to rudetalesofmagic.com or find us on all major social media platforms.”
Christopher adds that there’s no brand confusion, ensuring new listeners can easily locate their content.
Christopher Hastings: “You Google that, you DuckDuckGo it, you Bing it. You'll find us.”
Notable Quotes:
- Christopher Hastings [02:16]: “I had never heard of this thing before... but I got hooked at that point.”
- Joe Lepore [10:45]: “I was very much like, I don't actually know how this works.”
- Christopher Hastings [20:35]: “We take the lore and the worlds and the mythology of fantasy games... mix it up and you discover that actually there's quite a lot of sweetheart to it as well.”
- Joe Lepore [39:39]: “If you're the DM, prepare less... allow discovery at the table.”
Final Thoughts
This episode of "Critical Role & Sagas of Sundry" offers valuable insights into the creative process behind "Rude Tales of Magic," emphasizing the importance of collaboration, flexibility, and player engagement in crafting memorable TTRPG experiences. Whether you're a seasoned player or new to the realm of tabletop gaming, Christopher Hastings and Joe Lepore provide inspiration and practical advice to enhance your storytelling adventures.
For more episodes and content, visit Geek & Sundry or tune into their YouTube channel and podcast platforms.