Podcast Summary: Dan Snow's History Hit - "Who Owns Greenland?"
Release Date: January 15, 2025
In the episode titled "Who Owns Greenland?" Dan Snow delves into the intricate history of Greenland, exploring its strategic importance, colonial past, and the evolving relationship between Greenland, Denmark, and the United States. Through an engaging dialogue with Professor Robert William Ricks of the University of Copenhagen, Snow unravels the layers of Greenland's ownership and significance from ancient times to the modern era.
1. Introduction: The Geopolitical Significance of Greenland
Dan Snow sets the stage by highlighting Greenland's enduring strategic allure. From the 19th century attempts by the United States to purchase the island to its current role in Arctic geopolitics, Greenland has been a focal point of international interest.
Notable Quote:
“Greenland is important. It matters for its geography. It's a gigantic island with a very teeny tiny population.”
— Dan Snow [00:35]
2. Early Human Settlement: The Paleo-Arctic Presence
The conversation begins with the earliest known human inhabitants of Greenland. Approximately 4,500 years ago, Paleo-Arctic peoples migrated from present-day Canada into Greenland, adopting a nomadic lifestyle dependent on hunting and seasonal movements.
Key Points:
- Introduction of the Dorset and Tule peoples.
- Ancestors of today's Inuit population.
- Nomadic patterns adapting to Greenland's harsh climate.
Notable Quote:
“These were nomads. So they would travel, they would have hunting grounds and they would move from place to place.”
— Robert Ricks [06:43]
3. Norse Discovery and Settlement: Erik the Red's Legacy
Erik the Red, an exiled Icelandic seafarer, is credited with establishing the first Norse settlements in Greenland around the year 986. Despite the island's predominantly icy landscape, Erik named it "Greenland" to attract settlers, successfully initiating a colonial project.
Key Points:
- Erik the Red's exile from Iceland and Norway.
- The establishment of Norse communities in southwest Greenland's fjords.
- Leif Erikson's accidental discovery of North America (Labrador/Newfoundland).
Notable Quote:
“Erik did go west and he arrived in Greenland, which really wasn't that green. In fact, he admitted that he just gave it that name to attract settlers.”
— Dan Snow [08:10]
4. Transition to Danish Rule: The Kalmar Union
In 1397, the Kalmar Union unified Denmark, Norway, and Sweden under a single crown. This union consolidated Danish influence over Greenland, transitioning the island from Norwegian to Danish control. The union's dissolution in 1814 confirmed Denmark's sovereignty over Greenland and other overseas territories.
Key Points:
- Queen Margaret I's formation of the Kalmar Union.
- Transfer of Norwegian overseas colonies to Denmark.
- The Kiel Treaty of 1814, ceding Norway to Sweden while retaining Greenland under Danish rule.
Notable Quote:
“Because what happens in 1397, which is known as the Kalmar Union, is that Queen Margaret the first of Denmark establishes some kind of counter move to the Hanseatic League.”
— Robert Ricks [12:28]
5. Decline of Norse Greenland: Environmental and Societal Factors
By the mid-15th century, Norse settlements in Greenland had dwindled, ceasing communication around 1410. The decline is attributed to several factors, including climatic cooling, resource scarcity, possible conflicts with indigenous populations, and economic challenges exacerbated by Europe's plagues.
Key Points:
- The abrupt end of Norse communication with Greenland post-1410.
- Speculations on the disappearance: climate change, conflicts, overfishing.
- Possible return of settlers to Iceland amidst economic downturns.
Notable Quote:
“This is the idea that bestelling these are the bombastic visions, dystopian visions of all the Norse Greenland is dying from the cold or from starvation. Probably that didn't happen that way.”
— Robert Ricks [14:18]
6. 17th Century Recolonization Attempts: Christian IV's Expeditions
In the early 1600s, Denmark's King Christian IV initiated multiple expeditions to reclaim Greenland, motivated by resource exploitation and to curtail Dutch and British trading activities. These efforts culminated in the successful recolonization of Greenland in 1721, primarily driven by the lucrative whaling industry.
Key Points:
- Motivation: Resource extraction and control over whaling.
- Competition with the Netherlands and Britain for Arctic dominance.
- Establishment of Danish colonies to regulate and profit from Greenland's resources.
Notable Quote:
“Whale blubber is such a commodity that it is something that you really you do anything to gain sort of access to these waters.”
— Robert Ricks [18:17]
7. 19th Century American Interest: The U.S. Pursuit of Greenland
In 1868 and 1910, the United States expressed interest in acquiring Greenland. A notable attempt in 1930 saw Danish Prime Minister rejecting the sale, underscoring Greenland's value. The strategic importance of Greenland during this period was accentuated by its proximity to the Panama Canal and its potential to influence Canadian autonomy.
Key Points:
- U.S. Secretary of State William H. Stewart's attempts to purchase Greenland.
- Strategic reasoning: Surrounding Canada and securing Arctic routes.
- Denmark's firm stance against selling Greenland, even amidst offers.
Notable Quote:
“But at that point it's seen as that Greenland would probably not happen either. So an offer is never really made.”
— Robert Ricks [22:53]
8. World War II and Cryolite: Greenland's Industrial Importance
During World War II, Greenland's cryolite mines became pivotal for aluminum production, essential for aircraft manufacturing. Following Denmark's occupation by Germany in 1940, Danish Ambassador Henry Kaufman clandestinely arranged for U.S. protection of Greenland's strategic assets. This period also saw the notorious "Weather War," with both Allied and German forces establishing weather stations to gain meteorological advantages.
Key Points:
- Cryolite's role in aluminum production for wartime needs.
- U.S. Protectorate status in Greenland to prevent German access.
- Establishment of the Thule Air Base as a critical military installation.
- The "Weather War" involving espionage and meteorological dominance.
Notable Quotes:
“Greenland will be a hub for refueling from at least 10,000 planes.”
— Robert Ricks [28:21]
“This is a podcast that I was not particularly expecting to record in 2025, but actually, once you listen to it, you'll realize that wrangles over Greenland are absolutely nothing new.”
— Dan Snow [04:58]
9. Post-War Dynamics and Modern Governance: Independence Movements
In the aftermath of World War II, the United States maintained a significant military presence in Greenland, integrating it into North American defense structures, particularly within NATO and NORAD frameworks. Denmark, recognizing Greenland's strategic value, gradually granted greater autonomy, culminating in Greenland's self-rule in 2009. Contemporary discussions around Greenland's sovereignty and potential independence are influenced by economic dependencies on Danish grants and the island's rich mineral resources.
Key Points:
- Greenland's integration into NATO and NORAD via the Thule Space Base.
- Denmark's constitutional arrangements, granting Greenland home rule and later self-rule.
- The push for Greenlandic independence, supported by political majorities but hindered by economic dependencies.
- Modern geopolitical tensions, including renewed U.S. interest amidst Arctic melting.
Notable Quotes:
“Selling Greenland would first sort of entail a discussion between Greenland and Denmark about whether there should be independence...”
— Robert Ricks [33:35]
“There's nothing constitutionally to prevent Denmark from having that conversation.”
— Robert Ricks [33:49]
10. Conclusion: The Future of Greenland's Sovereignty
The episode concludes by emphasizing that Greenland's ownership is deeply intertwined with historical, environmental, and geopolitical factors. While Denmark retains sovereignty, Greenland's pathway to full independence remains a complex issue, influenced by economic capabilities and international interests. The ongoing climate changes in the Arctic continue to elevate Greenland's strategic importance, potentially shaping its future role on the global stage.
Notable Quote:
“But the unity of the realm, in 1979, Greenland is granted its home rule and that's expanded in 2009 to become self-rule.”
— Robert Ricks [31:59]
Final Thoughts
Dan Snow's exploration of Greenland's ownership provides a comprehensive understanding of the island's historical significance and its role in contemporary geopolitics. Through Professor Ricks' insights, listeners gain a nuanced perspective on the complexities surrounding Greenland's sovereignty, the enduring legacy of colonial endeavors, and the island's pivotal position in the evolving Arctic landscape.
Additional Information:
- Guest: Professor Robert William Ricks, University of Copenhagen
- Book Mentioned: The Vanished Settlers of Greenland: In Search of a Legend and Its Legacy
For more detailed episodes and historical explorations, subscribe to History Hit at historyhit.com/subscribe.