Dark Downeast: The Murder of John Evers Robinson (Connecticut) Release Date: December 19, 2024
Introduction In this compelling episode of Dark Downeast, investigative journalist Kylie Lowe delves into the unsolved murder of John Evers Robinson, a 24-year-old musician from New Haven, Connecticut. Nearly 35 years after his brutal death, Robinson's sister, Jocelyn Jackson, spearheads efforts to bring new attention and justice to her brother's case. This detailed summary captures the key discussions, insights, and conclusions presented in the episode.
Background: John Evers Robinson On the morning of March 14, 1990, John Evers Robinson was discovered dead in his music studio at 178 Temple Street, New Haven. Robinson was an active member of the local punk scene, playing bass for the band Sold on Murder (S.O.M.), also known as Rockhead. His passion for music was evident, and his dedication extended beyond performing; he managed the band's logistics, including using his job at Ashley's Ice Cream to support their gigs.
Discovery and Initial Investigation At approximately 8:30 AM, firefighters responded to reports of a strong foul odor emanating from room 208. Upon entry, they found Robinson lying face down with severe head trauma. The room was minimally furnished, and the condition of the body suggested a violent and possibly prolonged struggle. Detective interviews with the property manager confirmed Robinson as the likely tenant, supported by receipts found on his person.
Personal Reflections: Jocelyn Jackson Jocelyn Jackson, Robinson's sister, provides a heartfelt portrayal of her brother. Reflecting on their childhood, she shares:
"Those memories are almost always there's laughter in them because you know, the hijinks of older brother is just what it is." ([04:21]) Jocelyn emphasizes John's role as a protector and his unwavering commitment to his music, highlighting his adventurous spirit and the lengths he went to pursue his passion.
Life in New Haven's Punk Scene Robinson's immersion in the New Haven punk scene was both his sanctuary and, ultimately, a potential source of conflict. The 1980s punk culture in New Haven was a melting pot of anti-establishment sentiments, rebellious energy, and, unfortunately, elements of white supremacy. Robinson's interactions within this scene, particularly with individuals associated with the skinhead subculture, played a significant role in the investigation.
Potential Motives and Key Players The investigation revealed multiple potential motives behind Robinson's murder:
- Drug Deal Gone Wrong: Robinson had engaged in small-scale drug transactions to fund his music career. On March 12, 1990, he was involved in a plan to purchase several pounds of pot from two individuals known as Cody and Hank. Patrick, a key figure, provided $400 for this deal. The failure of this transaction raised suspicions.
- Conflict with Skinheads: Robinson had previous altercations with members of the skinhead subculture. Accusations arose that he had stolen symbols from their group, leading to tensions that may have culminated in violence.
Patrick's Involvement and Statements Patrick, who had assisted Robinson with back rent and was involved in the drug deal, became a person of interest. His statements revealed inconsistencies:
"He made the choice that he needed to go live with his father in New Haven. And that happened very quickly." ([05:13]) Initially claiming no further information, Patrick later admitted: "At that point, I knew for sure John was dead." ([09:49]) His nervous demeanor during polygraph tests and the discovery of an aluminum baseball bat in his possession deepened suspicions, although no direct evidence linked him conclusively to the murder.
Forensic Evidence and Investigation Challenges The case faced significant hurdles due to limited forensic technology in 1990. Key pieces of evidence included:
- Bloody Footprints: A cardboard piece with partial footprints suggested multiple assailants, but matching them to specific individuals proved challenging.
- Fingerprints: Partial matches were found for Patrick and his friend, but these were deemed innocuous due to their prior presence in the studio.
- Murder Weapon: Despite the medical examiner’s theory of a bat-like object causing fatal injuries, no such weapon was found at the scene. An aluminum baseball bat discovered later was examined but did not yield conclusive links.
Escalating Conflict and Final Confrontation The ongoing tensions within the music community, exacerbated by conflicts with skinheads, set the stage for Robinson’s murder. Witnesses recounted prior threats and physical confrontations, painting a picture of a man embroiled in dangerous liaisons. The final confrontation remains shrouded in mystery, with questions about the motives and the true perpetrators lingering.
Reactivated Investigation and New Evidence Decades later, advancements in forensic technology and new evidence from the FBI reignited the investigation in 2009 and again in 2023. Although Jocelyn and host Kylie Lowe did not have access to recent files, it's clear that fresh eyes and modern techniques may one day uncover the truth.
Jocelyn Jackson's Pursuit of Justice Driven by a desire for closure, Jocelyn launched a three-episode podcast titled Sold on Murder, interviewing family, friends, and those connected to John. She poignantly shares:
"The reason I am pursuing justice in this way... because for 35 years I have not had peace." ([44:57]) Jocelyn’s unwavering commitment underscores the personal toll of losing a loved one to unresolved violence and the enduring hope for justice.
Conclusion: A Call for Information Despite the passage of time, John Evers Robinson’s murder remains unsolved. Jocelyn Jackson continues to seek answers, urging anyone with information to come forward:
"If you have information regarding the 1990 murder of John Evers Robinson in New Haven, Connecticut, please contact the Connecticut Cold Case Unit at 1-866-623-8058 or the New Haven Police Department at 1-866-888-8477." ([45:30])
Final Thoughts This episode of Dark Downeast not only revisits a cold case but also highlights the relentless pursuit of justice by those left behind. Through thorough investigative storytelling and emotional testimonies, Kylie Lowe brings to light the complexities and enduring impact of John Evers Robinson's tragic death.
For those interested in supporting Jocelyn’s efforts or learning more about the case, additional resources and links are available on darkdowneast.com.