Dark Downeast – The Murder of Lena Bruce (Massachusetts)

Host: Kylie Low
Podcast: Dark Downeast
Date: September 18, 2025

Episode Overview

In this heart-driven true crime episode, host Kylie Low investigates the 1992 murder of Lena Bruce, a recent Tufts graduate living in Boston’s South End. The episode recounts Lena’s promising life, the details of her murder, the decades-long investigation, and the eventual use of DNA evidence to finally identify and convict her killer. Throughout, Kylie emphasizes Lena’s enduring legacy and the vital role of community, justice, and modern forensic advances in resolving cold cases.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

1. Who Was Lena Bruce?

• Background: Lena Bruce was a 21-year-old Tufts graduate, the first Black woman in her graduating class to earn a bachelor’s degree in electrical engineering.
• Achievements: Described as gifted and driven, Lena had excelled academically (perfect attendance in high school, numerous awards) and was deeply involved in volunteer work.
• Character: Teachers, friends, and family recall Lena’s determination and generosity—she aspired to make a difference in both her family’s life and her community.
• Giving Back: Lena was known for helping others, “Even throughout college, Lena managed to balance schoolwork while volunteering with senior citizens. She also worked with youth at the city's juvenile detention center.” (10:00)

2. Timeline of the Crime (July 10–12, 1992)

• Day of the Incident: Lena saw her roommate Barbara off for the weekend, planning to stay behind to shop for furniture with her first paycheck.
• Discovery: On July 12, 1992, Barbara returns to find the apartment ransacked and Lena dead in her bedroom—partially undressed, bound, and unresponsive. The scene hints at forced entry via a fire escape, with several items (TV, answering machine, stereo) stolen.
• Family Notification: Lena’s family was informed poorly by police, compounding their trauma. “After hanging up the phone with limited information, a pit of dread and a degree of doubt and bewilderment, Lina's father, brother and a few friends got in the car to get to Boston as fast as they safely could, hoping the officer was mistaken…” (19:00)

3. Initial Investigation

• Crime Scene: Physical evidence included a missing answering machine, a discarded wallet in a garden, a beer bottle (though Lena and Barbara didn’t drink beer), and biological samples.
• Early Forensics: Only blood group typing was possible in 1992—insufficient to identify the perpetrator.
• Suspect Pool: The investigation first focused on Lena’s immediate circle, including a former boyfriend and a man she was reportedly dating, but no leads panned out.

4. Stalled Case and Community Activism

• Family and Community Action: Lena’s family and sorority organized remembrance events, letter-writing campaigns, and protests, feeling her case wasn't getting the same attention as others. “Our family thanks the court system by letting everyone know that this black life mattered.” (38:28)
• Unsolved for Years: Items stolen from the scene remained missing; police worked leads but didn’t make progress.

5. Advances in DNA & the Cold Case Break

• 1998–2000: Improved DNA analysis developed a male profile from evidence, but no matches at the time.
• The Impact of Policy: Massachusetts’ participation in the CODIS national DNA database sets the stage for a breakthrough.
• The Match (2015):
  • James Witkowski’s DNA entered CODIS following a parole violation.
  • DNA from Lena’s case matched his, reigniting the investigation.

6. Reinvestigation and Case Against James Witkowski

• Witness Reinterviews: Lena’s friends recall Witkowski and an associate regularly watching Lena’s apartment, sometimes noting her comings and goings with disturbing familiarity.
• Witkowski’s Interview: He claimed not to know Lena but admitted to tying women up during sexual encounters. “He also shared that sometimes he left women tied up.” (26:30)
• Crucial Physical Evidence: A previously untested piece of paper found in a wallet at the scene yielded an intact thumbprint matching Witkowski. (28:33)

7. Court Proceedings & Conviction

• Trial (2017):
  • Prosecution: DNA profile placed Witkowski as Lena’s assailant within a critical time window; circumstantial evidence supported their case.
  • Defense: Claimed the DNA was from consensual sex prior to Lena’s death, undermined by the lack of credible evidence Lena ever knew him.
  • Deliberations: After several days and a 6–6 deadlock, the jury unanimously found Witkowski guilty.
• Sentencing:
  • Life imprisonment without parole. Lena’s sisters’ statement:
    • “Our family thanks the court system by letting everyone know that this black life mattered. We get to enjoy the next passage of our lives while enjoying this victory for our diamond that now has her star shining brightly in the sky.” (38:28)
  • Automatic state Supreme Court review upheld the conviction (2021).
  • Heartbreak: Both of Lena’s parents passed away before the arrest.

8. Broader Implications – DNA Databases

• Policy Power & Critique: The episode reflects on the transformative effect of DNA collection policies in solving cold cases, while acknowledging privacy concerns and the debate over scope.
• Evidence Preservation: “Without well maintained evidence, DNA testing and modern forensic techniques would not be possible.” (39:30)
• Delicate Balance: Raises ethical questions over the trade-off between public safety and personal privacy.

9. Honoring Lena’s Legacy

• Personal Remembrances:

  • Lena’s aunt: “She almost glided down the street with a regal air, her head held high. What do you call it? Young, gifted and black? Well, that was Lena.” (39:56)
  • Sorority sister story: Lena literally gave someone the jacket off her back.
  • Pastor’s words at Lena’s memorial: “She becomes a new model for our young people. May her story become a beacon that penetrates even the hearts of the desperate who place no value on human life.” (40:30)

• Ongoing Scholarships: The Bruce Griffey Leadership and Diversity Internship Fund celebrates students with a passion for public service in memory of Lena and fellow student Anita Griffey.

• Lena’s Own Words:

  • From Lena’s poem, read at the end of the episode (full text at 40:54):

    “You learn to build your roads on today because tomorrow's ground is too uncertain for plans and futures have a way of falling down in mid flight...”

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• On Lena’s Promise:
  "Lena Dolores Bruce dreamed of a better, bigger life for herself and her loved ones than the circumstances she grew up in, and she proved over and over again that the dream was within her grasp...” (08:15)

• On Lena's Generosity:
  “Lina took her jacket off and handed it to Francesca. She quite literally gave people the clothes off her back.” (40:10)

• On the Breakthrough:
  “A new policy...required that DNA samples be taken from those convicted of felonies...his profile was submitted to CODIS. In 2015, there was a hit.” (23:10)

• On Family’s Relief and Sadness:
  “Heartbreakingly, both of Lina's parents passed away before the identification and arrest of her suspected killer. Univie was buried just three days before police called to inform her that they'd identified a suspect.” (37:35)

• On Lena’s Enduring Light:
  "God will not allow the good wrought over 22 years to disappear in a moment of evil." (40:30)

• Lena’s Poem:
  “And you learn and learn and you learn.” (40:57)

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Lena’s Background & Achievements – 03:00 - 10:00
• Discovery of the Crime – 11:30 - 15:30
• Initial Investigation & Forensics – 17:00 - 23:00
• Family Activism and Community Response – 21:00 - 24:00
• DNA Breakthrough & Reopening the Case – 24:30 - 27:50
• Matching Prints and Tying Evidence – 28:33
• Trial, Conviction & Sentencing – 33:30 - 38:40
• Family’s Victim Impact Statement – 38:28
• Reflection on Policy, Privacy, & Evidence – 39:30
• Remembrances and Lena's Legacy – 39:56 - 41:00
• Lena’s Poem – 40:54

Episode Tone & Takeaways

Kylie Low delivers the story in a respectful, heartfelt tone that foregrounds Lena’s humanity and the grief and perseverance of her family and community. This episode not only recounts a tragic crime and its eventual resolution, but also honors Lena’s extraordinary life and the community activism that kept her memory alive, ending with a message of resilience and legacy that transcends tragedy.

For More Information:
Full source material and further reading can be found at darkdowneast.com

Follow: @darkdowneast on Instagram for continued updates on New England true crime and the legacy of the individuals at each story’s heart.