Dark Downeast Podcast Summary: The Murder of Pamela Webb (Maine)

Episode Release Date: May 29, 2025

Background: Who Was Pamela Webb

Pamela Webb, a 32-year-old resident of Winthrop, Maine, led a life marked by community involvement and personal passions. She graduated from Winthrop High School and pursued music and voice studies at the University of Maine at Augusta for two years. Pamela worked as a quality control inspector at Digital Equipment Corp., a job she initially intended to hold short-term but remained with for nearly twelve years. Her commitment to family was evident as she frequently hosted nieces and nephews, often organizing sleepovers filled with ice cream sundaes and memorable activities (00:05).

The Night of July 1, 1989

On the first Saturday of July 1989, Pamela prepared for a sleepover at her home, nestled on a 10-acre plot near her parents, Virginia and Kenneth Webb. After ensuring her nieces and nephews were settled, she made a phone call to her boyfriend, Josh, informing him she was leaving for his place and expected to arrive by 1 a.m. At approximately 9:03 p.m., Kenneth Webb observed Pamela driving past their home in her less-reliable blue 1981 Chevrolet C10 pickup, accompanied by her dog, Thumper ([00:05]).

Discovery of Pamela's Abandoned Truck and Evidence

Later that night, Pamela's truck was found abandoned on the Augusta toll booth (Exit 15) at 9:52 p.m. The vehicle showed signs of a slow flat tire with the spare leaning against the bumper. Inside, Thumper was unharmed, and Pamela's personal items, including her purse and Bible, remained untouched. However, investigators discovered two pools of blood near the passenger side and a pair of earrings embedded in the gravel. The lack of missing funds suggested robbery was not the motive, leading authorities to suspect abduction (Transcript Segment).

Initial Investigation and Leads

Police treated the truck and surrounding area as a crime scene, collecting blood samples and footprints for analysis. Witnesses assisted the investigation by reporting sightings of the truck, some noting that emergency lights were flashing. By narrowing the abduction window to between 11 p.m. and 12:30 a.m., authorities expanded their search radius and intensified efforts, including aerial surveillance and the involvement of game wardens and Naval Air Station personnel. Despite these measures, only minor items unrelated to Pamela were found (Transcript Segment).

Arrest of Randolph Jacobitz and Ruling Out

In July 1989, Randolph B. Jacobitz was arrested for kidnapping a woman in Vermont. Initial suspicions linked him to Pamela's case due to a matching necklace description. However, alibis confirmed his presence in New York and Canada during Pamela's abduction timeframe, effectively ruling him out as a suspect in her murder. Jacobitz was later convicted for his Vermont crime and faced subsequent legal troubles, though his connection to other cases remained tenuous (Transcript Segment).

Discovery of Pamela's Remains

On July 18, 1989, construction workers in Franconia, New Hampshire, discovered Pamela's severely decomposed body in the White Mountain National Forest. The remains were identified through dental records, although the cause of death remained undetermined due to decomposition. The location, approximately 110 miles from where her truck was found, heightened the mystery surrounding her abduction and murder (Transcript Segment).

Jeffrey Haas's Misconduct

A pivotal moment in the investigation involved Trooper Jeffrey Haas, who initially reported seeing Pamela's truck at 2 a.m. However, discrepancies emerged when it was revealed he had previously stated seeing it at 11:35 p.m. in his patrol records. Upon further investigation, Haas admitted to falsifying reports and lying about the timing. Although a polygraph later cleared him as a suspect, his actions compromised the investigation and led to his dismissal from the Maine State Police. The Webb family filed a lawsuit against Haas, arguing his negligence contributed to Pamela's death. Ultimately, in 1999, the Maine Supreme Court ruled against the Webb family, stating there was insufficient evidence to link Haas's actions directly to Pamela's murder (Transcript Segment).

Legal Proceedings and Civil Suit

The Webb family pursued a civil lawsuit against Jeffrey Haas, initially including the Maine State Police and Main Turnpike Authority. Over nearly a decade, the suit faced multiple appeals. In 1999, the Maine Supreme Court denied the family's claims, stating that Haas's failure to act did not constitute a direct cause of Pamela's death. The court emphasized the speculative nature of linking Haas's inaction to her abduction, ultimately dismissing the case (Transcript Segment).

Other Suspects Explored Over the Years

Investigators explored various leads, including James Robert Cruz Jr. and Sean Patrick Goble, both convicted of separate homicides. While Cruz was considered due to his criminal history, his alibi placed him away from the scene during Pamela's disappearance. Goble's modus operandi involved targeting women along highways, but his activities were primarily in the southern states and did not align closely with Pamela's case. Both remain potential but unconfirmed suspects (Transcript Segment).

Connection to Connecticut River Valley Killer

Jennifer Amell, host of Audio Chuck's Dark Valley podcast, delves into the theory connecting Pamela Webb's murder to the Connecticut River Valley Killer (CRVK). The CRVK is attributed to eight unsolved homicides characterized by opportunistic attacks on women, typically involving knife murders with a frenzied stab pattern. Although Pamela's cause of death remains undetermined, her abduction's circumstances—victim of opportunity and body disposal in a remote area—align with the CRVK's profile. However, no forensic evidence directly links her case to the CRVK, and law enforcement found no substantial evidence to confirm this connection (40:33 – 44:37).

Current Investigation and Detective's Insights

Detective Chad Lindsey of the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit emphasizes that Pamela Webb's case remains active, with ongoing efforts to re-examine evidence using contemporary technologies. Despite the challenges posed by aging witnesses and fragmented evidence, there is a renewed commitment within the state police to resolve cold cases. Detective Lindsey dismisses the notion of Pamela's case being a straightforward "whodunit," highlighting the complexity and genuine uncertainty surrounding her murder (45:19 – 48:44).

Legacy and Impact

Pamela Webb's father, Kenneth Webb, passed away in 2004 without receiving closure regarding his daughter's death. The Webb family established a scholarship in her name at Winthrop High School, awarding funds to students embodying Pamela's hard work and compassionate spirit. The community continues to remember Pamela as a caring individual with a tender heart, striving to keep her memory alive through ongoing public interest and investigative efforts. Reverend Glenn Metzler recalled Pamela's forgiving nature, illustrating her enduring legacy (49:18 – End).

Conclusion

The murder of Pamela Webb remains one of Maine's enduring mysteries. Despite extensive investigations, legal battles, and numerous leads, the truth behind her abduction and death is still elusive. The case highlights the profound impact on her family and community, as well as the challenges faced by law enforcement in solving cold cases. Dark Downeast honors Pamela's memory by shedding light on her story, urging anyone with information to come forward and contribute to the pursuit of justice.

Call to Action

If you have information that could help close this case, please contact the Maine State Police Major Crimes Unit at 207-624-7076, extension 9, or leave a tip via the form in the episode description. Your assistance could be pivotal in bringing closure to Pamela Webb's family.

For more information and to follow the case updates, visit darkdowneast.com and follow @darkdowneast on Instagram.