Dateline NBC Podcast Summary: "Talking Dateline: A Walk Through the Woods"

Release Date: February 26, 2025
Host: Blaine Alexander & Andrea Canning

Introduction

In the "Talking Dateline: A Walk Through the Woods" episode, hosts Blaine Alexander and Andrea Canning delve deep into the harrowing true-crime case featured in Dateline NBC's episode titled "A Walk Through the Woods." This summary encapsulates their discussions, key insights, and the emotional journey surrounding the unresolved murders of two Indiana schoolgirls.

Case Overview: Libby German and Abby Williams

The tragic case revolves around the 2017 murders of schoolgirls Libby German and Abby Williams in Delphi, Indiana. The girls were found near an abandoned railway bridge, and the case remained unsolved for years. A pivotal clue emerged from a grainy video and audio recording captured on Libby's phone moments before the murders.

Blaine Alexander provides a succinct recap:

"In 2017, two schoolgirls, Libby German and Abby Williams, were found murdered in the woods of Delphi, Indiana, near an abandoned railway bridge. For years, the case went unsolved with police at a standstill except for one clue, a grainy picture and a grating voice captured on Libby's phone right before the murders. It would turn out to be a very big clue that helped solve the girls' murders."
(00:57)

The Eerie Setting: The Abandoned Railway Bridge

Andrea Canning discusses the ominous location of the crime:

"The bridge is still there. You know, the dangerous ties. People. If you wanted to go out on it, you could. You could find a way."
(03:21)

The bridge, approximately 63 feet high, provided a chilling backdrop for the crime, emphasizing the vulnerability and isolation of the victims.

Impact on the Families

The hosts express profound empathy for the families, especially Libby's grandparents, Mike and Becky.

Andrea Canning shares a heartfelt moment:

"Mike and Becky were so nice, and I commended them because there's a lot of grandparents who end up taking in their grandchildren as their own because of issues going on in the family... They had a Disney World vacation planned... she had to call and take Libby off of the reservation. You know, just broke her when she had to do that."
(04:24)

Investigation Breakthrough: The Phone Recording

A crucial breakthrough came from the recording on Libby's phone. Andrea highlights Libby's bravery:

"Libby helped solve her own crime, you know, and the crime of her best friend... hats off to Libby, who, by the way, was a big fan of crime dramas."
(05:50)

This recording captured both audio and a fragment of video, which eventually led investigators closer to the perpetrator.

Red Herrings: Anthony Schatz and Kegen Klein

The investigation faced significant red herrings, notably involving suspects Anthony Schatz and Kegen Klein. The hosts discuss how these leads ultimately diverted attention but failed to hold.

Blaine Alexander remarks on the deflection:

"That whole episode with Anthony, Schatz, Kegan Klein, I mean, that really was a red herring."
(08:31)

The Trial: Pretrial Challenges and Verdict

The trial of Richard Allen, the accused murderer, was fraught with challenges. A key pretrial ruling prevented the defense from introducing an alternate theory linking the murders to Odinism, severely weakening their case.

Andrea Canning explains:

"The defense team took me out to the woods and demonstrated how the sticks were placed on the bodies and the blood spatter on the tree... they were convinced that it was a ritualistic killing."
(13:34)

Ultimately, despite concerns about a hung jury, the prosecution presented compelling circumstantial evidence leading to Allen's conviction.

Prosecutor Nick McLeland shares his experience:

"It's the culmination of seven years for me, almost eight years for the family of investigating this offense... to come out with a guilty verdict... it's just a huge weight off your shoulders."
(17:05 – 18:08)

Community Impact and Lingering Doubts

The conviction had a profound impact on the tight-knit Delphi community, fostering fear and suspicion among residents. While law enforcement and the families are confident in Allen's guilt, some community members remain uncertain.

Andrea Canning notes:

"There's some people that just, you know, that there's still lingering questions or, you know, the defense truly believes Richard Allen is innocent."
(18:27)

Emotional Toll on the Hosts

Both hosts share the emotional difficulty of covering such a tragic and personal story.

Andrea Canning reflects:

"I was just fighting back tears... how would you feel if someone could do that to two teenage girls."
(19:17 – 20:11)

Blaine Alexander acknowledges:

"I could imagine watching you. I could tell just where your heart was in this story."
(20:32)

Listener Questions and Responses

The hosts address several listener concerns and questions:

1. Delayed Police Action
   Listener Ronnie Brock asks why the police waited five years to follow up on a suspect's confession.
   Andrea Canning responds by highlighting the lack of detective involvement:

   "It goes back to the conservation officer that unfortunately just didn't have that spidey sense that maybe a detective might have."
   (23:25 – 23:50)

2. Bridge Height Clarification
   Jerry Lynn inquires about the bridge's height.
   Andrea Canning provides the exact measurement:

   "63Ft."
   (23:55)

3. Richard Allen’s Criminal Record
   Daniel Welcher questions whether Richard Allen had a prior criminal history.
   Andrea Canning confirms:

   "No. That was what was so strange about the whole thing..."
   (24:23 – 24:31)

4. Motive Behind the Murders
   Gracie Donaldson Cipriano asks about the lack of a clear motive for Richard Allen.
   Andrea Canning acknowledges the ambiguity:

   "That's the million dollar question... it's just bizarre."
   (24:36 – 25:20)

Conclusion

The "Talking Dateline: A Walk Through the Woods" episode offers a comprehensive exploration of the complex and emotionally charged Delphi case. Through insightful discussions and exclusive interviews, Blaine Alexander and Andrea Canning provide listeners with a deeper understanding of the investigation, trial, and lasting community effects. The episode underscores the relentless pursuit of justice and the enduring impact of true-crime stories on those involved.

For those interested in hearing more, visit Dateline Premium for ad-free listening and exclusive content.