Dateline NBC Podcast: Talking Dateline – "Open Water" Episode Summary

Release Date: August 13, 2025

In this special edition of Talking Dateline, host Blaine Alexander engages in an insightful conversation with esteemed guests Josh Mankiewicz and Dateline producer Michelle Madigan. The trio delves deep into the intricacies of the "Open Water" episode, unraveling the layers of a compelling true-crime mystery that captivated listeners.

1. Introduction to the Episode

Blaine Alexander kicks off the discussion by introducing his guests:

• Josh Mankiewicz: A seasoned journalist with extensive experience in covering intricate true-crime stories.
• Michelle Madigan: A producer with a keen eye for detail, responsible for bringing the "Open Water" narrative to life.

Blaine Alexander sets the stage, highlighting the episode's premise:

"When Lonnie Kakantis invited his wife, Mickey Kanasaki, on a European cruise, she thought it would be a great opportunity to rekindle their relationship. But Mickey never got that opportunity." [01:20]

2. Recap of the "Open Water" Episode

The episode centers on Lonnie Kakantis, a lawyer who orchestrates a European cruise ostensibly to mend his estranged marriage. However, days into the voyage, Mickey disappears under mysterious circumstances. As the investigation unfolds, suspicions fall on Lonnie, prompting his friends Bill and Susan to take matters into their own hands to exonerate him.

Josh Mankiewicz reflects on the emotional complexity of the story:

"This is the mark of a good DATELINE episode... you have an emotional roller coaster." [02:15]

3. Emotional and Narrative Journey

The trio discusses the emotional twists viewers experience, mirroring Blaine's personal reaction:

"About 18 minutes in I thought Lonnie did it. Then I changed my mind at 22 minutes... That's the mark of a good DATELINE episode." [02:15] – Blaine Alexander

Jim Mankiewicz adds depth by characterizing Lonnie as a highly intelligent lawyer, whose professional prestige added layers to his perceived innocence.

4. The Significance of Water as a Setting

A recurring theme in Dateline stories is the setting acting as a character itself. "Open Water" leverages the vast, unpredictable ocean to heighten tension and suspense.

Josh Mankiewicz emphasizes the dual nature of water:

"The beauty of nature. Also savage and dangerous." [04:35]

Blaine shares a personal anecdote about his fear of water, adding relatability to the discussion:

"I'm personally scared of water. I can't swim." [04:50] – Blaine Alexander

5. Unforeseen Challenges During the COVID-19 Pandemic

Originally planned as an on-site investigation off the coast of Naples, the production faced significant hurdles when the pandemic struck. The team had to pivot, relying on local producers to gather necessary footage and interviews, ensuring the story's integrity despite global constraints.

Michelle Madigan elaborates on the logistical shift:

"We started the story before the pandemic. Witnesses from Italy had to pause their testimonies... we ended up not being able to go do this story." [09:45]

Josh Mankiewicz adds a personal touch, expressing regret over missing the on-site experience but commends the local team's efforts:

"The interviews done in Italy were done with local producers... the story came out fine." [10:27]

6. Bill and Susan: Pillars of Integrity

Bill and Susan, Lonnie's friends and former law enforcement investigators, play pivotal roles in the narrative. Their unwavering commitment to uncovering the truth drives the investigation forward.

Blaine Alexander praises their character:

"These are exactly the kind of people you would want defending you if you were wrongly accused." [13:48]

They navigate the murky waters of doubt and loyalty, ultimately confronting Lonnie with undeniable evidence, leading to his downfall.

7. A Glimpse into Bill Price's Personal Life

An unexpected yet heartwarming segment showcases Bill Price's passion for dogs. Through his involvement with the American Kennel Club, Bill reveals a softer side, highlighting his dedication and love for his pets.

Bill Price shares his journey with dogs:

"I never owned a dog myself until about the 1990s... it's unconventional, unconditional love." [17:34]

This personal touch adds depth to Bill's character, juxtaposing his tough investigative demeanor with genuine compassion.

8. Engaging with Listeners: Social Media Insights

The episode transitions into interacting with listeners' comments and questions. Topics range from cruise ship anecdotes to the implications of AI in criminal investigations.

Patricia D. raises a pertinent question:

"How do they tell the difference between a genuine recording and an AI one?" [22:25]

Josh Mankiewicz responds thoughtfully, acknowledging the emerging challenges posed by deepfakes in future investigations:

"I absolutely predict that happening... tracking devices like the Apple air tag are already turning up in all kinds of stories." [23:14]

9. Conclusion and Upcoming Events

Wrapping up, Blaine and Josh highlight the unwavering integrity of Bill and Susan, celebrating their dedication to truth. They also promote an upcoming Dateline Live event in Nashville on September 28th, inviting listeners to engage directly with the team.

Blaine Alexander concludes with enthusiasm:

"If you think that we're fun and all over the place on these Talking Datelines, you ought to see us in person." [26:13]

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Blaine Alexander: "If you have any questions for Talking Dateline, you can leave it for us in a voicemail at 212-413-5252." [26:05]

• Josh Mankiewicz: "This is a fun along the lines of you not knowing how to swim." [05:10]

• Michelle Madigan: "We should have used that line. Come on, we need Helene." [23:53]

Final Thoughts

"Open Water" exemplifies Dateline NBC's prowess in weaving intricate true-crime stories with emotional depth and meticulous investigation. Through engaging discussions with Josh Mankiewicz and Michelle Madigan, this Talking Dateline episode offers listeners a comprehensive understanding of the challenges and triumphs behind producing such a captivating narrative.

For those intrigued by the unraveling of Lonnie Kakantis's mystery and the dedication of friends Bill and Susan, this episode serves as a testament to the relentless pursuit of truth that defines Dateline NBC.