Podcast Summary: Dateline NBC – Talking Dateline: The Trouble in Bardstown

Host: Lester Holt
Guests: Andrea Canning (correspondent), Rachel White (producer), Sherry Ballard (Crystal Rogers' mother)
Date: November 12, 2025

Overview

This episode of “Talking Dateline” takes a deep dive into "The Trouble in Bardstown," a multi-year Dateline investigation. The focus is on the 2015 disappearance of Crystal Rogers in Bardstown, Kentucky—a case marked by tragedy, complicated family dynamics, a wave of unsolved crimes, and recently achieved justice through convictions. Correspondent Andrea Canning discusses her reporting process, the tense trial, the impact on Bardstown’s residents, and shares insights from emotional interviews with Crystal’s family. Producer Rachel White later joins for an extended listener Q&A.

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Mystique and Anxiety of Bardstown

• Bardstown is described as "the most beautiful small town in America," emphasizing its charm and close-knit community.
  Andrea Canning:

  “It’s just one of those Americana type towns, you know, a little bit like Mayberry… It is quite the juxtaposition… it’s almost like they don’t fit together.” (02:01)

• Despite the town's idyllic reputation, a string of five murders over four years has deeply unsettled locals. Canning:

  “Of course, it’s just going to set everyone… it’s going to give everyone that uneasy sense.” (02:59)

• The murders have led to widespread fear, distrust of police, and community reticence. Canning:

  “When you’re from a small town, everyone knows each other… So I think that just brings a different element to crimes like this and people being scared. You know, who’s doing this, and if I am speaking out, what will happen to me?” (03:25)

The Ballards vs. The Haucks: Family Tensions

• Crystal’s disappearance and the subsequent murder of her father, Tommy Ballard, caused open hostility between her family and that of Brooks Hauck (the accused). Canning:

  “The Ballards have not been shy about who they believe killed Crystal… They also believe the Hauck family is somehow responsible for Tommy’s death.” (04:02)

• Law enforcement identified certain members of the Hauck family as "unindicted co-conspirators," adding complexity and sensitivity to the story. Canning:

  “That’s the first time I’ve ever, in a story, had unindicted co-conspirators… where they’re publicly naming family members but not arresting them.” (05:11)

Behind the Scenes: Reporting Challenges

• The Dateline team navigated sensitivities around telling both families' stories. Canning:

  “We’re trying to, of course, tell Crystal’s story, which is most important… but at the same time, you also want to give this idea of who’s this other family.” (04:50)

• They encountered the challenge of reporting on a circumstantial case with limited physical evidence.

Inside the Relationship

• Brooks Hauck and Crystal Rogers’ relationship changed, especially after the birth of their son, Eli. Canning shares allegations from Crystal’s daughter Ashley about Brooks’ controlling behavior:

  “Unscrewing light bulbs… turning off the water… unscrewing their doors... It sounded really awful.” (06:00)

Tragedy of the Ballard Family

• The Ballards have suffered repeated losses—Tommy’s sister was murdered in 1979, then Crystal disappeared, and later Tommy himself was killed while investigating Crystal’s case. Canning:

  “Can you imagine? Poor, poor Tommy… history repeats itself with your daughter. It’s awful... She [Sherry] couldn’t even bring herself to, like, cook the dinner she would always cook.” (07:27)

Inside the Courtroom

• The two families sat apart; tension was palpable. Canning:

  “I think it was very much divided… this is some really bad blood here, you know, between these two families.” (10:30)

• The prosecution built a case from hard-to-find and circumstantial evidence, using small details such as suspicious phone calls. Canning:

  “It really took like that drilling down on those details… the FBI just really kind of ran with that." (10:57)

• Police used psychological pressure and emotional appeals when material evidence was lacking. Canning:

  “You’re not going really for the evidence at that point. You’re going for that human response, human emotion.” (11:56)

• Defense argued police molded the narrative to fit their theory due to weak evidence.

• Victory for the prosecution was achieved through piecing together circumstantial evidence and assembling a passionate, close-knit team—including married lead prosecutor Shane Young. Canning:

  “Shane Young… and one of his partners is his wife. So they were just like 24/7, living and breathing this case.” (13:51)

Future Hopes & Continuing Mysteries

• There remains hope Tommy Ballard and Officer Jason Ellis’ murders may be solved. Canning:

  “I definitely think there’s a chance for Tommy’s murder to be solved, and I think there’s a chance for Jason Ellis’s murder to be solved.” (15:01)

• Crystal’s body has never been found:
  Canning:

  “That will take someone to talk. I don’t think that any amount of investigating or searching [will find her body]...” (15:17)

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

On Family Determination Amid Grief

Crystal’s mother, Sherry Ballard, on refusing to let her loved ones be forgotten (16:01):

“My biggest thing for my daughter and husband… that will not be my daughter and husband. I will do everything in my power to keep their name out there. And I think if you do that… you just gotta not let people forget who they are. And you have to push… It’s very hard, but you can’t give up on that.”

Andrea Canning, acknowledging Sherry’s perseverance:

“And you’re proof that it can pay off.” (16:44)

On Patience in Unsolved Cases

Andrea Canning:

“Sometimes you just have to be patient, you know, it just doesn’t happen on your timeline, but it… can happen. Sometimes it’s 20 years later, 30 years later.” (17:18)

Listener Q&A Segment with Rachel White (19:41-26:43)

DNA and Forensic Evidence

• Despite finding two fingerprints and a partial palm print in Crystal’s car, none matched the main suspects. Heavy car use by family complicated DNA as an investigative tool.

Alibi and Phone Records

• Brooks’ brother Nick’s girlfriend testified Nick’s phone was off the night of Crystal’s disappearance—an anomaly given he was a police officer (21:10).

Concealment Theories

• Law enforcement searched Hauk-linked construction sites (including digging up a driveway), but no evidence of Crystal was found (22:01).

The Toll of Unresolved Loss

• Rachel White emphasizes family anguish in not knowing Crystal’s whereabouts or being able to mourn properly:

  “That void of all of this… not being able to have a proper funeral or go to her gravesite or, you know, just not knowing where she is. It’s excruciating.” (22:31)

Ongoing Investigations

• No resolution yet on the murders of Tommy Ballard or Officer Jason Ellis; the death of another mother and daughter is considered isolated from these core cases.

The Fate of Eli

• Crystal’s son Eli is being raised by Brooks’ family. (24:38)

Community Impact

• The case continues to resonate as one of Dateline’s most intense and methodically reported stories—a point underscored by audience feedback (Grumpa Braveheart on X, 26:09).

Timestamps for Key Segments

• Bardstown community & anxiety: 02:01–03:54
• Family tensions & investigation focus: 04:02–05:46
• Relationship dynamics: 06:00–06:42
• Personal stories and Ballard family grief: 07:16–08:26
• Courtroom & investigative tactics: 10:16–13:38
• Prosecutor work and future hopes: 13:51–15:31
• Sherry Ballard interview (memorable quote): 16:01–16:48
• Q&A with Rachel White: 19:41–26:43

Conclusion

This episode is a powerful, empathetic look at the lasting wounds of unsolved crimes in a small town and the fight for justice by determined families. Andrea Canning’s firsthand experience, the Ballard family’s pain and perseverance, and the investigative team’s relentless work are all vividly captured. The legacy of Crystal Rogers and her family’s quest for answers continues to shape Bardstown and the spotlight stays fixed as further developments unfold.

For more details and updates, follow @datelinenbc or submit your questions for future episodes.