Dateline Originals: "Murder in the Moonlight - Ep. 5: When It All Falls Apart"

Release Date: April 30, 2025
Host: Keith Morrison
Produced by: Dateline and NBC News

Introduction to the Murders

In the serene rural setting of Murdoch, Nebraska, the tranquil atmosphere was shattered by the brutal murders of Wayne and Charman Stock. The investigation quickly pointed fingers at two cousins, Matt Lyvers and Nick Sampson, who were subsequently arrested and held for months. However, the case took a dramatic turn with the emergence of two Wisconsin teenagers, Greg Fester and Jessica Reed, who confessed to involvement in the murders, casting doubt on the initial arrests.

Initial Arrest and Conflicting Confessions

Keith Morrison sets the stage by recounting the initial suspicion towards Matt Lyvers and Nick Sampson. Their arrest was based on a confession from Matt Lyvers, which, despite his attempts to retract, tied him directly to the crime. Adding to the complexity was a bloodstain found in a car linked to Nick Sampson, believed to be the victim's, Wayne Stock's, which further implicated both suspects.

Jerry Susi, Nick Sampson's lawyer, expressed the emotional turmoil, stating at [01:46], “It's a good feeling to know your client's innocent. It's a bad feeling to know that your client's still in jail.” This highlights the precarious position of the accused as new evidence emerged.

Jessica Reed's Pivotal Testimony

At [02:53], Jessica Reed, a 17-year-old, faced a life-altering decision when offered a plea deal to testify against Matt and Nick. Her lawyer, Tom Olson, emphasized her lack of connection to the cousins, asserting, “She had nothing connected to them. Sure, they weren't friends, family. She had no reason to protect them. And she had every reason to benefit herself.” Ultimately, Reed chose to testify, declaring, “That Lives and Sampson were never at that farmhouse when the killings occurred... it was her and Fester.” Her stance significantly weakened the prosecution's case against Nick, leading to the dropping of charges against him at [06:04].

Legal Maneuvers and Changing Strategies

Despite the dropping of charges against Nick Sampson, Matt Lyvers remained incarcerated. Jerry Susi, at [04:23], described a shift in legal strategy from seeking dismissal to aggressively presenting evidence that pointed to Reed and Fester acting alone. This transition underscored the legal team's determination to secure Matt's release by dismantling the prosecution's case.

Revelations of a False Confession

A turning point in the investigation was the revelation that Matt Lyvers had recanted his confession. Julie Baer, Matt's attorney, identified this as a "textbook false confession" at [16:17]. Initially, Matt had confessed under prolonged interrogation, but a subsequent interview revealed his innocence, stating, “I've been just making things up to satisfy you guys.” This confession recantation posed significant challenges, as the prosecution had heavily relied on Matt's initial statements.

Investigation Flaws and FBI Involvement

The integrity of the investigation came under scrutiny when it was uncovered that CSI Chief David Cofode had likely planted evidence—a bloodstain linking Nick Sampson to the crime scene. The FBI's investigation concluded that Cofode falsified evidence to secure convictions, leading to his indictment on multiple federal charges, including falsifying records and violating civil rights. Cofode maintained his innocence but admitted to procedural errors: “I did make a mistake. I didn't follow procedures...” at [27:30].

Community Impact and Ongoing Uncertainty

The community of Murdoch grappled with the revelations of misconduct and the subsequent release of Nick Sampson. Matt Lyvers, reflecting on his ordeal, shared his struggles with reintegration and the persistent fear for his safety, stating at [07:11], “Constantly looking over my shoulder... I didn't like being alone...” The case left the community divided, with lingering doubts about the true perpetrators and the justice system's handling of the case.

Conclusion and Future Implications

As the episode concludes, the legal ramifications of wrongful convictions and evidence tampering are laid bare. With Matt Lyvers still incarcerated despite exculpatory evidence and Nick Sampson released under shaky grounds, the episode underscores the profound flaws that can occur within criminal investigations and the devastating impact on the lives involved.

Keith Morrison teases the final episode, hinting at unresolved questions and deeper insights into Matt Lyvers' continued imprisonment and the elusive pursuit of the true killer.

Notable Quotes

• Jerry Susi ([01:46]): “It's a good feeling to know your client's innocent. It's a bad feeling to know that your client's still in jail.”

• Tom Olson ([03:32]): “She had nothing connected to them... And she had every reason to benefit herself.”

• Julie Baer ([16:17]): “If you, you know, you look and, and start examining the case in context... It's really a textbook false confession.”

• Matt Lyvers ([07:11]): “Constantly looking over my shoulder... I didn't like being alone...”

• David Cofode ([27:30]): “I did make a mistake. I didn't follow procedures...”

Production Credits

"Murder in the Moonlight" is a production of Dateline and NBC News. The episode was expertly crafted by Producer Shane Bishop, Audio Editors Brian Drew, Kelly Laudeen, Bruce Berger, Marshall Housefeld, and Candace Goldman, Field Producer Brittany Morris, Program Coordinator Leslie Grossman, Co-Executive Producer Adam Gorfin, Executive Producer Paul Ryan, and Senior Executive Producer Liz Cole. Audio mixing was handled by Bob Mallory and Katie Lau, with Bryson Barnes overseeing audio production.

Listen to all episodes of Dateline Originals here or subscribe to Dateline Premium for an ad-free experience.