The Idaho student murders: new details. Karen Read's voicemails. And Sean Combs's trial begins.

Summary

Dateline: True Crime Weekly – May 8, 2025

Episode Overview: In this milestone 50th episode of Dateline: True Crime Weekly, NBC News’ Andrea Canning delves into three gripping true crime stories: the latest developments in the Idaho student murders, the explosive voicemails in Karen Reid's retrial, and the high-profile sex trafficking trial of Sean Combs. Joining her are special guests Keith Morrison and producer Shane Bishop, providing in-depth analysis and exclusive insights.

---

1. The Idaho Student Murders: New Details

Timestamp: 02:43 – 08:15

Overview: Andrea Canning introduces viewers to the harrowing case of the four University of Idaho students murdered in 2022. Keith Morrison and producer Shane Bishop share their extensive coverage of the investigation, the subsequent manhunt, and the arrest of criminology student Bryan Kohberger, who has pleaded not guilty. With Kohberger’s trial set to begin in 12 weeks, Morrison and Bishop present never-before-seen security footage and exclusive interviews that shed new light on the case.

Key Points:

• Victims Identified: Maddie Mogan, Kaylee Goncalves, Zanna Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin.
• Focus on Maddie Mogan: Investigative sources believe Maddie was the primary target, evidenced by the killer’s immediate approach to her room.
• Emotional Testimony: An interview with Maddie’s mother reveals the devastating impact of the murders and a last-minute change that likely saved a fifth potential victim.

Notable Quotes:

• Keith Morrison (03:25): “The killer seems to have gone immediately up to Maddie's room. He was familiar with where that girl's room was.”
• Sue Simpson on Maddie’s Mother (04:56): “Imagine this. You've got kids yourself, Andrea. How desperate a mother is to keep her children safe.”

New Evidence:

• Cell Phone Data: Kohberger’s phone pinged near the crime scene 23 times between July 9 and November 7 (05:32).
• Security Footage: Dramatic footage captures a white car resembling Kohberger’s near the scene at the time of the murders (06:24).
• Witness Accounts: Interviews with individuals who interacted with Kohberger reveal his social awkwardness and possible signs of distress (07:03).

Upcoming Feature: The segment “Terrible Night on King Road” will air this Friday, offering a comprehensive look at the case with exclusive content.

---

2. Karen Reid's Voicemails in Court

Timestamp: 09:25 – 17:32

Overview: Karen Reid stands accused of fatally hitting her police officer boyfriend, John O’Keefe, with her SUV during a nor'easter after a night of drinking. In her retrial’s third week, the prosecution unveils Karen’s fiery voicemails, painting a picture of intense animosity. Producer Sue Simpson provides detailed coverage from inside the courtroom, highlighting the contentious evidence collection methods and the emotional testimonies presented.

Key Points:

• Case Background: Reid is accused of abandoning O’Keefe to die in severe weather after allegedly striking him with her vehicle.
• Prosecution’s Focus: Presentation of Karen’s explicit voicemails to O’Keefe, reflecting her anger and possible premeditation.
• Defense’s Argument: Claims that Reid is being framed, suggesting alternative circumstances surrounding O’Keefe’s death.

Notable Quotes:

• Andrea Canning (11:01): “I hit him. I hit him. I hit him.”
• Sue Simpson on Voicemails (16:10): “John, I’m here with your fucking kids and nobody knows what the fuck you are, you fucking pervert.”

Evidence Collection Controversy:

• Unconventional Methods: Use of red Solo cups and leaf blowers to collect blood samples in a snowstorm, raising concerns about evidence integrity (14:37).
• Lie Detector Claims: Police and firefighters recount interactions where Reid allegedly confessed to hitting O’Keefe, though the defense disputes these statements as potential questions rather than admissions (11:48).

Jury Reactions: Jurors remained impassive despite the graphic and emotional nature of the evidence presented, highlighting the gravity of the charges against Reid (16:51).

Conclusion: The case continues to unfold with high tensions as both sides present compelling arguments. Reid’s next court appearances will likely provide further pivotal information.

---

3. Sean Combs's Sex Trafficking Trial Begins

Timestamp: 17:32 – End

Overview: In a landmark trial echoing past high-profile cases like Martha Stewart’s and Bernie Madoff’s, Sean “Diddy” Combs faces charges of racketeering, sex trafficking, and transportation to engage in prostitution. Andrea Canning explores the intricate details of the case with correspondent Shane Bishop, discussing the allegations, defense strategies, and the potential courtroom drama involving one of hip-hop’s most influential figures.

Key Points:

• Charges: Combs is accused of orchestrating a 20-year-long scheme involving the abuse and trafficking of women, utilizing violence and blackmail to maintain control.
• Prosecutors’ Claims: The prosecution alleges non-consensual relationships, drawing parallels to organized crime structures under the RICO statute.
• Victim Accounts: Cassie Ventura, a former partner who filed a civil suit against Combs in 2023, is set to be a key witness, detailing her experiences of abuse and coercion (20:23).

Notable Quotes:

• Shane Bishop (20:18): “New York prosecutors claim that Sean Combs was using this organization to partake in illegal activity and conspired with others who worked for him to carry out that illegal activity.”
• Andrea Canning (23:24): “Combs's defense is saying everything was consensual, that all the charges against him deal with women who were in consensual relationships with him.”

Defense Strategies:

• Consensual Relationships Argument: The defense asserts that all interactions were consensual and characterizes the alleged activities as part of a “lifestyle.”
• Medical Expert Testimony: Allowed to discuss potential drug use by Combs, possibly undermining his responsibility for the alleged crimes (23:53).

Trial Dynamics:

• Jury Selection: Prospective jurors are scrutinized for biases related to high-profile names and perceptions of domestic abuse, with many unfamiliar with the case specifics (24:25).
• Legal Representation: Combs is defended by a team including renowned attorney Mark Garagos and his daughter Tenny, alongside Mark Agnifolo and Brian Steele.
• Emotional Testimonies: Cassie Ventura, currently eight months pregnant, is anticipated to deliver a powerful and emotional account of her ordeal (21:46).

Notable Moments:

• Combs’s Appearance: Showing signs of nervousness, Combs requested a bathroom break early in jury selection, underscoring the trial's high stakes (25:04).

Upcoming Coverage: Andrea announces a new feature where NBC's Chloe Meloss will provide daily updates from the courthouse, enhancing listeners' engagement with the trial's progression.

Notable Quotes:

• Shane Bishop (21:33): “She is the government's star witness. This is going to be explosive next week when she takes the stand.”
• Andrea Canning (25:17): “That's why the DATELINE True Crime Weekly team is trying something new. Starting this Monday, May 12, I'm going to be checking in with Chloe at the end of court every day...”

---

Conclusion: This episode of Dateline: True Crime Weekly masterfully navigates through complex and emotionally charged cases, providing listeners with comprehensive analyses and exclusive insights. From the chilling details of the Idaho student murders to the intense courtroom battles surrounding Karen Reid and Sean Combs, Andrea Canning and her guests deliver a compelling narrative that keeps true crime enthusiasts engaged and informed.

Production Credits: Produced by Franny Kelly and Katie Ferguson, with associate producers Carson Cummins and Caroline Casey. Senior production by Liz Brown Kurloff, and additional support from Kim Florist, Gaynor Veronica Mazeka, Rick Kwan, Jesse McGinty, Bryson Barnes, Paul Ryan, and Liz Kula.

---

Stay tuned for next week's episode, and don't miss the special segments airing throughout the week for deeper dives into these riveting cases.

Transcript

[Charlie]

Looks like a murder happened around here. Maybe I should do a little snooping.

[Andrea]

Red headed alley cat.

[Keith Morrison]

Who even are you?

[Charlie]

She's that freaky little lie detector. My name's Charlie, actually.

[Keith Morrison]

From the mind of Rian Johnson, director and writer of Knives Out.

[Charlie]

I got this thing. I can tell when someone's lying.

[Shane Bishop]

Look me in the eye and tell.

[Charlie]

Me that you didn't kill her.

[Andrea]

I didn't do it. Oh, shoot.

[Charlie]

Oh.

[Andrea]

What the.

[Keith Morrison]

Poker Face New season streaming Thursdays only on Peacock.

[Andrea]

Stick with me and you'll never want for the crazy. Good morning, Jim. How are you? I'm good. You're listening to dateline's morning meeting. They believe the fire was set to destroy evidence. Producers have a lot to talk about. Arrests, courtroom drama and breaking crime news around the country. There's a lot of dirt there.

[Charlie]

The extortion plot with the young couple.

[Andrea]

I mean, it is absolutely War of the Roses in this house. Welcome to DATELINE, True Crime Weekly. It's May 8th, and we've officially hit our 50th episode. Here's what's on our docket. In Dedham, Massachusetts, it's week three in Karen Reed's retrial. We've got the latest on the prosecution's case, including a batch of angry, explicit voicemails from Karen played in court.

[Charlie]

Karen made dozens of calls to John o' Keefe's cell phone and a lot of calls just, you know, went to voicemail. And man, they were fiery.

[Andrea]

Inside a federal courthouse in downtown Manhattan, hundreds of prospective jurors are being narrowed down to the 12 who are who will sit in judgment of a music legend.

[Keith Morrison]

Jury selection is officially underway in the.

[Andrea]

Sex trafficking trial of Sean Diddy Combs. But before all that, we've got two very special guests, Keith Morrison and DATELINE producer Shane Bishop. They're here to tell us about their groundbreaking investigation into a crime that stunned the nation. The murders of four University of Idaho students in 2022. Within days of the tragic discovery that the students had been fatally stabbed in their beds in the college town of Moscow Idah, DATELINE producers were on the ground covering the story. For the next two years, Keith and his team followed the case at every turn, reporting on the manhunt, the arrest of the suspected killer, criminology student Bryan Kohberger, and the family's painful wait for answers. Kohberger's trial is set to begin in 12 weeks, and the judge has entered a not guilty plea on his behalf. Now Keith is back with DATELINE's latest reporting on the case from never before publicly seen security footage to exclusive interviews with Pete, who crossed paths with Kohberger. It's the kind of insight you won't find anywhere else. Keith and Shane, thank you so much for coming on to talk about this.

[Sue Simpson]

Our pleasure, I'm sure.

[Andrea]

Just remind us, who were the students who were killed in the house in those early hours of November 13, 2022?

[Keith Morrison]

So the four students that were murdered were Maddie Mogan, Kaylee Goncalves, Zanna Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin.

[Sue Simpson]

Two of them were about ready to spring into the world, just about almost finished with their studies. Two were not quite so far along, you know, lauded by their families and by their parents as responsible kids who were nevertheless, you know, going to college and having a good time as college students as well.

[Andrea]

Shane, there's always been a question about whether the killer was targeting one of the students in particular. What did you find out about that?

[Keith Morrison]

So we've confirmed with investigative sources that they believe the target that night was Maddie Mogan. One reason they believe that is because the killer seems to have gone immediately up to Maddie's room. So he was familiar in some way with where that. That girl's room was. As we all know by now, the killer found Kaylee with Maddie. These same sources tell us that there was a struggle upstairs in Maddie's room between Maddie, Kaylee and the killer. And the noise of that confrontation, the. The thumping is the words that our source used, got the attention of Zanna on the floor below. So the belief is by these sources that she went up to investigate the thumping upstairs. The killer got interrupted and then chased Zanna downstairs.

[Andrea]

So just awful, awful final moments for these poor students. You found out that there was another girl who was supposed to be there that night. But lucky for her, she had a change of plans. And, Keith, you had a very emotional interview with her mom. Let's take a listen.

[Sue Simpson]

How soon was it that you thought, my God, she was going to be there?

[Charlie]

I didn't think about that right away. All I could think about was the kids.

[Andrea]

But she just cried in her bed.

[Charlie]

She didn't want to talk about it. We just cried together for a long time.

[Sue Simpson]

Makes you sad, too, doesn't it?

[Charlie]

It does.

[Andrea]

Sorry.

[Charlie]

Wow.

[Sue Simpson]

Well, I mean, imagine this. You've got kids yourself, Andrea. And you know what? How desperate a mother is to keep her children safe. Her daughter was intending to go that weekend to spend several days with her best friend, Matty Mogan. And only at the very last minute, she had to stay at home to watch over the Family dog. And if she hadn't, she would have gone to Moscow, Idaho. She would have been in that house when the murders occurred and probably would have been sleeping in that same bedroom where the murders occurred.

[Andrea]

That is chilling. Something else that you learned from court records, which you will go more in depth in the episode. You discovered that Kohberger's phone pinged off a cell tower close to the student's house before the murders.

[Sue Simpson]

Mm.

[Keith Morrison]

So it's been discussed in court documents that the FBI's CAST team, this cellular area survey team, has found 23 instances in which Kohberger's cell phone used a tower that served an area within 100 meters of the murder scene between July 9 and November 7. We have some additional reporting on that that hasn't been out there, some specifics that we'll disclose on Friday.

[Andrea]

So there is some never before publicly seen security video which you'll show. Describe this video for us.

[Sue Simpson]

You have to see it to get a full appreciation of it. But there is certainly some pretty dramatic evidence of a white car in the vicinity of the crime scene right around the time it happened and afterwards.

[Andrea]

And you can't say for sure that it's Bryan Kohberger's car, but he owns a car similar, at least looks similar to what's in that video, Right.

[Keith Morrison]

Well, we know Kohberger owns a white Elantra.

[Andrea]

Your team tracked down people who crossed paths with Kohberger, including some guests at a pool party he attended. What do you. What did you learn from these people?

[Keith Morrison]

We know that Kohberger attended a pool party on July 9th in Moscow, which was about 10 days after he'd arrived in Washington from Pennsylvania. One of the people we talked to was a woman named Holly, who had also at some point been a graduate student far from home. And so she felt some responsibility to, you know, talk to Coburger, try to welcome him to the area.

[Andrea]

He seemed a little awkward, kind of.

[Charlie]

Like you might expect for a PhD student who didn't know anyone at the party and was maybe trying his best to kind of get out there and be social and make friends.

[Keith Morrison]

She told him about a hiking group that she was involved in. They exchanged numbers. The next day, Coburger texted her and said, hey, I'd like to get involved with this hiking group. And then for some reason, she just blew him off. She said. She said, the universe intervened and I never returned that. And still makes her shiver a little. Obviously, in hindsight, there's so much more.

[Andrea]

Reporting that your team did. It is a must see. And it is called the Terrible Night on King Road and it airs this Friday on NBC at 9, 8 Central. Keith and Chains, thank you so much for just sharing all this information that you found.

[Sue Simpson]

Thank you, Andrea.

[Keith Morrison]

Thank you.

[Andrea]

Up next, Karen Reid's voicemails get played in court and the defense has some questions about how police collected evidence. And it involves red solo cups. Hey, everyone, I'm Jenna Bush Hager from the Today show and I'm excited to share my podcast Open Book with Jenna. It is back for season two. Each week, celebrities, experts, friends and authors will share candid stories with me about their lives and new projects. Guests like Rebecca Yarros, Kristin Hannah, Ego Wodom, and more. Like a good book, you'll leave feeling inspired. Inspired and entertained. Join me for my podcast Open Book with Jenna. Listen now on Apple Podcasts. Hey everybody, I'm Al Roker from the Today Show. Let's kick start your wellness journey with the all new Start Today app. Everything you need for a healthier you all in one place, fitness challenges for all levels, meal plans that are easy and delicious and so much more. It's built to fit your lifestyle and our experts will guide you every step of the way. Come on, let's do this.

[Sue Simpson]

To subscribe, download, start today from the.

[Andrea]

App Store on your Apple device now. Terms apply. Cancel anytime through Apple under profile settings In Dedham, Massachusetts, Karen Reid's second trial enters week three. Reed is accused of hitting her police officer boyfriend John o' Keefe with her SUV after a night of drinking and leaving him to die in a nor' easter. Reid has pleaded not guilty. Her defense says she's being framed by law enforcement to cover up what they say is the truth about o' Keefe's death, that Karen dropped him off at an after party at the home of another Boston police officer. There, the defense says he was beaten up, dragged outside and left to die in the cold. This week, the prosecution turned its focus to the day o' Keeffe's body was found and how the criminal investigation began. They also played some of the most explosive audio we've heard over the course of the trial so far. Angry, explicit voicemails Karen left for John o' Keefe. DATELINE producer Sue Simpson is here to fill us in on the latest. Welcome back to the podcast, Sue.

[Charlie]

Happy to be here.

[Andrea]

Okay. And I have to ask, of course, did you win the lottery this week? Did you get a seat in the courtroom?

[Charlie]

I am in the courtroom. It is so exciting.

[Andrea]

Wow. Okay. Wow. This is big. All right, so court was back in Session on Monday, and we heard from some of the law enforcement and emergency personnel at the scene. The prosecution called a firefighter paramedic to the stand, and prosecutor Hank Brennan had her describe what she saw that day.

[Charlie]

That's right. So Brennan asked Katie McLaughlin about seeing Karen Reid at the scene, and McLaughlin testified that one of the firefighters there asked her to gather more information about what had happened. McLaughlin said she noticed Karen and she decided to approach her.

[Andrea]

Did she say to you, in addition to the typical background information that you would try to obtain from somebody? Yes. What did she say? I asked if there had been any significant trauma that happened that preceded this. And she answered with a series of statements that she repeated. I hit him. I hit him. And, sue, that's not the first prosecution witness who has testified that they heard Karen say, I hit him.

[Charlie]

You're absolutely right. And the defense, of course, maintains that what Karen said was, did I hit him or could I have hit him? That she wasn't making a statement. She was asking a question. But, you know, if you wanted to simplify this case, Andrea, and boil it down to a few critical points, this would be one. How will the jury interpret those few words, that handful of words? McLaughlin also testified that after Karen said, I hit him, Jen McCabe, who was standing right beside Karen, told her to calm down, stop talking, calm down.

[Andrea]

You're hysterical. So she repeated, I hit him. And a police officer asked her, said, you what? And she repeated it again, I hit him. And the officer then signaled for his sergeant to come down to the. The defense really pushed back on this in their cross examination. Alan Jackson, you know, star defense attorney from Los Angeles. What did he have to say about it?

[Charlie]

Well, Jackson asked if McLaughlin was sure that Karen wasn't asking a question. And Jackson asked if she was actually admitting to a crime, why didn't they arrest her right then and there?

[Andrea]

So they handcuffed her. No, no, no. Even though she just confessed in front of a police officer, According to you. You. That's what she said. I hit him. I hit him. It's my fault.

[Keith Morrison]

I did it.

[Andrea]

It's my. That's a confession, correct? She said, I hit him. I hit him. I hit him. I hit him. And Officer Serif just stands there and my client walks away, Correct. You'd have to talk to Officer Serif about that. The prosecution next called a witness who spoke to how evidence was collected at the scene. This was Lieutenant Paul Gallagher. He was one of the law enforcement officers who searched the crime scene after John o' Keefe had been Taken to the hospital. What did he have to say?

[Charlie]

So Gallagher testified that he was responsible for trying to preserve the scene in the midst of a snowstorm and that the weather conditions, those awful weather conditions made it difficult. And he actually testified that he didn't know it was a crime scene at the time.

[Andrea]

I decided to process the area where Mr. O' Keefe was found and try to find out why he had the medical episode he was having. If you understood this to be a medical episode and at that point you didn't have any information it was a crime scene, why were you taking the time and effort to process the scene under these conditions? Because that's what we do. I think we had a duty and obligation to check around his. Where he was found and see if there was any explanation to what caused his medical condition. We've heard before about some of the unconventional methods used to collect evidence in the case. Gallagher was asked about those. Can you remind us how they picked up this evidence and what they picked up?

[Charlie]

Yeah, unconventional is a good word for it. I mean, they actually used a leaf blower to reveal blood in the snow and red Solo cups to collect that blood.

[Andrea]

And what was the purpose of using the red Solo cups? They were plastic. They weren't going to leak. My thought was we could collect it, transport it, and transfer it to the crime lab who could extract the DNA however they saw best fit. Sue, the defense obviously seized on this, you know, making a big point about how the evidence was collected.

[Charlie]

Jackson really did push him on that.

[Andrea]

The blood was stored in non sterile Solo cups, correct?

[Shane Bishop]

Correct.

[Andrea]

We've agreed that those cups were not sealed. The cups themselves were not sealed. There was no cap, there was no plastic plasticine, Saran Wrap, nothing put over the cups, correct? That is correct. So they were open? Yes. They were not in an evidence bag. They were in a grocery bag, correct? They were, yes.

[Charlie]

Jackson pointed out that having unsealed an unsecured biological material, his words was not within any normal protocol for securing evidence. They clearly want to show the jury that this evidence could be tainted. And if it's tainted, then how can they trust it, you know? And then that raises the possibility of reasonable doubt, which is exactly what they want to do.

[Andrea]

There was one more moment from the prosecution this week that was really striking. They played some voicemails that longtime listeners might remember from the last trial. Sue, remind us about those voicemails.

[Charlie]

Yeah, you know, they were. They're so powerful, these voicemails. Karen made dozens of calls to John o' Keefe's cell phone after she dropp him off. And a lot of calls just, you know, went to voicemail and man, they were fiery.

[Andrea]

And just a note, those voicemails have some explicit language. John, I'm here with your fucking kids and nobody knows what the fuck you.

[Shane Bishop]

Are, you fucking pervert.

[Charlie]

The prosecutor wants to show the jurors just how angry she was at him. She was calling him a loser.

[Andrea]

You're a fucking loser yourself.

[Charlie]

She was saying, John, I hate.

[Andrea]

And so you were there. Did the jurors visibly react at all?

[Charlie]

You know, the thing about these jurors are they really, for me at least they don't show their emotions, they don't show their feelings. They listen. Their faces are impassive. I didn't notice a reaction there. Startling. I will tell you, they land with a startle because Karen is sitting right in court and these angry, angry words of hers and the swearing and clearly this is a woman who is passionate and has, has lost control of herself. They land in a court with a huge bang. Now the defense decided not to cross examine the investigator who found these voicemails and these calls. They just let her words go and they moved on.

[Andrea]

Well, this case just keeps getting more interesting and I know we will have you back very soon. Sue, thank you so much for joining us again. Thanks, Andrea. Next up, the sex trafficking trial of pop legend Sean Combs is getting underway. We've got news from inside and outside the courtroom. For our final story this week, we're heading to a federal courthouse in New York City, the same courthouse where Martha Stewart was tried. Bernie Madoff pleaded guilty and Sam Bankman Fried was convicted. This week, another celebrity is at the defendants table, Sean Combs. He is the multi millionaire founder of Bad Boy Records and a multi platinum artist himself. For more than 30 years, he was a record label executive who could make or break careers until September of 2024 when he was arrested in a hotel.

[Shane Bishop]

Lobby and charged with racketeering, sex trafficking and transportation to engage in prostitution that could lead up to to life behind bars.

[Andrea]

Prosecutors say they can prove that over a span of 20 years, the 55 year old physically, emotionally and sexually abused his alleged victims and used violence and blackmail to silence them. Combs has denied the allegations and pleaded not guilty to all the charges against him. This isn't the first time Combs has appeared in a New York courtroom. This Sunday, DATELINE will be airing a special episode where Josh Mankiewicz explores the controversies that have dogged Combs over the years and the events that led up to his arrest. Last fall. But we wanted to know what's going on right now as news crews from all over the world gear up for the start of testimony next week. NBC News correspondent Chloe Meloss is here to fill us in from her post on the sidewalk in front of 500 Pearl street in Lower Manhattan. Chloe, you have been on this case from day one.

[Shane Bishop]

Thanks for having me.

[Andrea]

So the top charge against Sean Combs is a charge that was used in the past against mob bosses in New York. That's how Rudy Giuliani made his name. It's what is called RICO or racketeering. What exactly is the state's top attorney alleging Combs did?

[Shane Bishop]

You know, I've been talking to a lot of different criminal defense attorneys and they all told me ahead of this trial to go watch Goodfellas if you really want to understand what RICO is. New York prosecutors claim that Sean Combs, who had bad boy records and he had all of these different businesses, that he was actually using this organization to partake in illegal activity and that he conspired with others who worked for him to carry out that illegal activity.

[Andrea]

Something that got just a lot of attention were these freak offs.

[Shane Bishop]

Yeah, Alleged drug fueled sex parties that he supposedly filmed. He had people who worked for him go and procure sex workers for these parties and potentially flew them across state lines to meet him. And had employees of his allegedly fill his home with what's now gone viral, you know, tons of baby oil.

[Andrea]

The prosecutor has listed four victims in this case. What do we know as far as who they are? Because we don't have their names yet. Right.

[Shane Bishop]

We don't. Other than victim one we know is Cassie Ventura. We know it's Cassie because the indictment so closely mirrors what she had in her civil suit that she filed against Combs in 2023. She says that he forced her to participate in freak offs, that he subjected her to years of physical and emotional abuse. And it's incredibly graphic.

[Andrea]

We know that Combs settled that lawsuit with Cassie for an undisclosed amount of money. And there was no admission of wrongdoing on his part. But according to your reporting, it sounds like she is going to be one of the prosecution's first witnesses.

[Shane Bishop]

We know from a source familiar with the case that she is going to be testifying within the first few days of this trial. She is the government's star witness. I mean, this is going to be explosive next week when she takes the stand.

[Andrea]

And this is a sad story when you think about Cassie Ventura, because this is a woman who had big dreams. You know, to be a singer. And Sean Combs was that guy who was going to help her live out her dream.

[Shane Bishop]

So she was 19 and he was 37 years old when they first met, and she had signed a 10 album record deal with him and they started to date, but she very quickly became known as Mrs. Combs. Essentially. They weren't married, but she was like the first lady of hip hop. They were on every single red carpet together. From the outside, they looked like they were in a perfect relationship. But she really pulled back the curtain with this civil suit. And I can imagine that we're going to hear a lot more when she takes a stand. And I'm sure very emotional. Also, I just want to point out she's actually very pregnant. I think she's about eight months old.

[Andrea]

Pregnant. Yeah. Tell us a little bit about the people in the courtroom, these prosecutors.

[Shane Bishop]

They're all women. And then you have Combs with almost like two tables of attorneys because he's hired so many at this point. So you may have heard of celebrity attorney Mark Garagos. He famously represented Scott Peterson, Michael Jackson, the Menendez brothers. Right now he has actually been in the courtroom and his daughter, Tenny Garagos is one of the lead attorneys on this case. You also have Mark Agnifolo, who's also currently representing Luigi Mangione. And you also have a man by the name of Brian Steele. Brian Steele, he represented young thug in his state RICO case and was successful.

[Andrea]

What are the defense's arguments so far?

[Shane Bishop]

Combs's defense is saying everything was consensual, that all the charges against him deal with women who were in consensual relationships with him. And something that they said at one point was this was a lifestyle, call it swingers or whatever you want. This was Combs life.

[Andrea]

The judge also ruled this week to allow the testimony of a defense medical expert that can talk about drugs Sean Combs may have been taking.

[Shane Bishop]

Right. So what we've heard about these freak offs is that there were a lot of drugs. And so you're gonna potentially hear from people who say that they can't even remember some of things that happened because they were on some sort of mind altering substance. And also, if Diddy took any of these substances, does that make him responsible for the acts committed?

[Andrea]

Jury selection is always important in trials, but it's especially important when you're dealing with such a high profile defendant. What kinds of questions are the prospective jurors being asked?

[Shane Bishop]

Some of the questions are really simple. What are your views on domestic abuse? What do you know about Sean Diddy Combs? What have you heard about the trial? They were given a list called People and Places. It has dozens of names and some of them are celebrities. And so some of the jurors, we've heard them say, I know who Kanye west is, I know who Michael B. Jordan is. I know who Mike Myers is. And some of those names obviously have been really shocking for the public to hear. They haven't been accused of any wrongdoing. Nobody knows the context why these people are being brought up.

[Andrea]

Are we seeing any reaction from, from Sean Combs? Yeah.

[Shane Bishop]

So on day one of jury selection, early in the morning he actually asked the judge for a bathroom break because he said, I'm a little nervous right now. But he is in the fight of his life and he could spend the rest of his life behind bars if convicted on all counts.

[Andrea]

Yeah. Chloe, you will be there from opening statements until the end?

[Shane Bishop]

I will. Eight weeks, maybe more. I think it's going to be the biggest trial of 2025.

[Andrea]

We do too, Chloe. That's why the DATELINE True Crime Weekly team is trying something new. Starting this Monday, May 12, I'm going to be checking in with Chloe at the end of court every day and she is going to bring us the latest developments. We'll drop those conversations as bonus episodes called On Trial in the DATELINE True Crime Weekly feedback. So watch out for that. And remember to check out Josh Mankiewicz's Dateline episode Sean Combs on Trial this Sunday at 10, 9 Central. That's it for this episode of DATELINE True Crime Weekly. Thanks for listening. DATELINE True Crime Weekly is produced by Franny Kelly and Katie Ferguson. Our associate producers are Carson Cummins and Caroline Casey. Our senior producer is Liz Brown Kurloff Production and fact checking help by Kim Florist Gaynor. Veronica Mazeka is our digital producer. Rick Kwan is our sound designer. Original Music by Jesse McGinty. Bryson Barnes is head of audio production. Paul Ryan is executive producer and Liz Kula, senior executive producer of Dateline. Thanks so much, everybody. Bye bye. Hey guys, Willie Geist here, reminding you to check out the Sunday Sit down podcast. On this week's episode, I get together with Lisa Kudrow to talk about her Netflix series no Good Deed and to reflect on her time as one of six friends on one of the most popular and enduring shows in the history of television. You can get our conversation now for free wherever you download your podcasts.