Podcast Summary

Podcast: Deadline: White House
Episode: “Endowed by the founders”
Host: Nicolle Wallace, MSNBC
Date: September 18, 2025

Overview

This episode examines the chilling and rapid decline of free speech in America following a series of unprecedented government interventions against media and comedians critical of President Donald Trump. Nicolle Wallace and guests dissect the forced removal of Jimmy Kimmel from ABC after controversial comments, explore the broader context of censorship and attacks on the press, and discuss the mounting hypocrisy of the current administration regarding the First Amendment. The episode features in-depth analysis and emotional reactions from major media voices and reporters, highlighting how these actions not only threaten the media landscape but the fabric of American democracy itself.

Major Discussion Points & Insights

1. The State of the First Amendment under the Trump Administration

[00:51 – 04:52]

• Nicolle Wallace opens with a somber tone, noting a profound shift in the meaning of the First Amendment.

• The recent government-approved removal of Jimmy Kimmel from ABC, ostensibly for offensive remarks about Charlie Kirk, marks a new low for free speech protections.

• Trump and his administration have openly celebrated media crackdowns, betraying prior claims to defend free speech.

  “It is abundantly clear to everyone... that the First Amendment in the hands of this current administration isn’t what it used to be.”
  — Nicolle Wallace [00:51]

• Chair of the FCC, Brendan Carr, threatened punitive action against Disney/ABC over Kimmel’s comments, underscoring direct government involvement.

2. The Sequence of Crackdowns on Media and Comedians

[05:07 – 13:43]

• Michael Grimbaum details a pattern of multi-pronged attacks on media: lawsuits against the New York Times, suits involving the Wall Street Journal, settlements with ABC/Colbert, and now pressure on late night comedy.

• Brendan Carr’s signaling on right-wing podcasts catalyzed pressure on Disney and local station owners to yank Kimmel.

• Oliver Darcy reveals the behind-the-scenes chaos at Disney; executives and Kimmel himself struggled with how to respond, but business interests and government pressure ultimately prevailed.

  “Donald Trump is abusing the power of government to go after critics. And that’s not something we’re used to in this country.”
  — Oliver Darcy [09:39]

• This attack strategy follows the script of Project 2025, with the administration systematically weaponizing regulatory and legal levers.

• Reports of chilling effects: protests in LA, subscription cancellations, industry-wide anxiety.

  “There is a chill ... Trump today said Jimmy Fallon and Seth Meyer are next. And you don’t think that’s going to land somewhere with people?”
  — Dominic Patton [12:08]

3. Escalation and Erosion: Consequences and Metaphors

[13:43 – 20:05]

• Nicolle Wallace recaps a growing list of media casualties: large legal settlements, canceled shows, significant newsroom overhauls (e.g., Washington Post’s opinion section), new lawsuits.

• Trump’s intimidation of journalists extends internationally, threatening diplomatic consequences for unfavorable coverage.

  “He is seeking to chill journalism around the world as an extortion tactic for good diplomatic relations with their governments.”
  — Nicolle Wallace [15:08]

• Grimbaum highlights how Trump has moved from rhetoric to effective, unchecked use of obscure but powerful regulatory levers.

  “In this term, President Trump has been incredibly efficient… at finding these obscure levers of government to really enact immense pressure on his political enemies.”
  — Michael Grimbaum [15:19]

• Panel notes that the outrage is palpable among press and entertainment but recourse is limited given the administration’s unchecked power.

4. Media’s Surrender and Response Options

[20:05 – 29:56]

• Stephen A. Smith and others draw comparisons to Hungary’s Viktor Orban and Putin’s Russia — warning of how quickly autocratic crackdowns can unravel democracy.
• Discussion of potential pushback: comedians finding new platforms (as Megyn Kelly and Tucker Carlson did), solidarity within the entertainment community, and the limits of corporate compliance.

  “Perhaps don’t fight them where they think the battle is. Create a new battlefield.”
  — Dominic Patton [21:44]

• President Obama’s statement is read: he explicitly calls out the administration for escalating cancel culture to dangerous new levels.
• Hope that “signs of life” (e.g., Jon Stewart’s return to The Daily Show, industry protests) could snowball into meaningful resistance.

5. The Suddenness and Fragility of Democratic Norms

[26:34 – 32:25]

• The acceleration is noted (“it happens all at once”), with even right-wing media figures and some Trump supporters expressing unease.
• Trump’s pattern as a “trampling guy”: deals with the administration earn no lasting protection for anyone, not even close allies.

  “He’s suing Rupert Murdoch, who basically helped put him in office... You’re not gonna get him to be your buddy, for God’s sake.”
  — Stephen A. Smith [29:59]

• Potential for fissures inside the Trump coalition to gum up the crackdown.

6. International Perspectives and Authoritarian Playbook

[36:13 – 38:52]

• Ann Applebaum draws explicit parallels to Putin’s early moves in Russia, especially targeting comedy as a form of resistance.

  “What’s happening here right now... looks a lot more like what Vladimir Putin did when he took power in Russia...” — Ann Applebaum [36:13]

• Wallace and guests agree that “free speech” is now selectively applied, with egregious right-wing rhetoric given a pass (see Brian Kilmeade’s “just kill them” comment on Fox).

7. Media Coverage, Narrative Control, & the Informational Ecosystem

[42:44 – 44:55]

• Oliver Darcy laments major media reluctance to call out bad actors in clear language, resulting in a diluted public understanding of events.

  “I think one of the things I see from just mass media is a reluctance to call things as they are when they’re happening.”
  — Oliver Darcy [42:50]

• The right-wing media ecosystem is recognized as far more robust, influential, and unconstrained by facts than any left-wing equivalent.

  “There is no left wing equivalent of Fox News.”
  — Oliver Darcy [44:19]

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• “The First Amendment in the hands of this current administration isn’t what it used to be... It is diminished today.”
  — Nicolle Wallace [00:51]
• “Donald Trump is abusing the power of government to go after critics. And that’s not something we’re used to in this country.”
  — Oliver Darcy [09:39]
• “This is how a four year old mourns a goldfish.”
  — Commentator/Analyst, about Trump’s response to Charlie Kirk’s death [03:56]
• “Mark Twain is rolling over in his grave, as is Dorothy Parker.”
  — Stephen A. Smith [12:08]
• “Our democracy is being eroded before our eyes. If this was a foreign country, we’d be a lot more clear eyed about what’s going on.”
  — Oliver Darcy [18:22]
• “What’s happening here right now... looks a lot more like what Vladimir Putin did when he took power in Russia.”
  — Ann Applebaum [36:13]
• “There was no Biden government censorship. I mean, this was an entirely fake narrative.”
  — Ann Applebaum [38:52]
• “I think liberals tend to hew to fact based media and that’s not sticky.”
  — Oliver Darcy [44:12]

Key Timestamps

• 00:51: Nicolle Wallace frames the episode's central question—has America’s free speech tradition collapsed?
• 02:00: Trump’s inauguration pledge on ending “government censorship.”
• 04:32: Trump celebrates Jimmy Kimmel’s indefinite suspension.
• 05:07: Oliver Darcy on the government’s posture towards regulating broadcasters.
• 08:12: Behind the scenes at ABC as Kimmel’s fate is decided.
• 12:08: Stephen A. Smith on historic parallels—Smothers Brothers, Bill Maher—and current protests.
• 13:43: The list of recent media casualties under Trump.
• 15:19: Michael Grimbaum on Trump’s efficient deployment of obscure bureaucratic powers.
• 17:06: Wallace and guests on the press as the most vital democratic institution.
• 18:22: Oliver Darcy’s blunt assessment: “Our democracy is being eroded before our eyes.”
• 21:44: Dominic Patton suggests comedians and critics “create a new battlefield.”
• 27:37: Oliver Darcy: “It’s happening all at once.”
• 36:13: Ann Applebaum compares U.S. crackdown to Putin’s Russia and the targeting of satire.
• 38:52: Applebaum debunks the narrative of Biden-era government censorship as “entirely fake.”
• 42:50: Oliver Darcy on media’s reluctance to call out bad actors.
• 44:19: No equivalent to Fox News exists on the left.

Episode Tone and Style

The episode is urgent, direct, and unapologetically critical—with a mix of analysis, informed outrage, and historical context. The language is impassioned and sometimes darkly witty, as panelists express shock, indignation, and resolve.

Closing Thoughts

This episode serves as a stark warning: American free speech and press freedoms are under direct threat, not theoretically, but right now and in plain sight. The consensus among Nicolle Wallace and her guests is that government weaponization against critics—especially comedians and journalists—guarantees a climate of fear, shrinking platforms for dissent. The question is not when these changes may come, but what those committed to truth and free expression will do next in the face of accelerating autocracy.

For more analysis on legal and political developments, subscribe to the Deadline Legal newsletter or tune in to future episodes of Deadline: White House.