Loading summary
Jake Halpern
Foreign.
Amazon Pharmacy Voiceover
The last thing you want to do when you're sick is go to the pharmacy to pick up a prescription because then you're standing in a long line with a whole bunch of sick people and everyone is sick of being sick around other people who are sick. Amazon Pharmacy will deliver right to you fast so you can get meds without congregating among the contagious. Healthcare just got less painful. Amazon Pharmacy and now two pigeons who.
Jake Halpern
Can'T believe how good humans have it with DirecTV. These humans are hopping from streaming apps to live sports without batting a wing, all from the DirecTV home screen. With just one click, you could be watching a baseball game, a movie on Netflix, or a critically acclaimed documentary. You watch documentaries? I love the ones that leave you with a quote. Question, what exactly? Directv A better way to watch whatever you want to watch.
Ryan Seacrest
Visit directv.com Internet connected Gemini device, separate Netflix membership and additional paid subscriptions required.
Jake Halpern
For third party apps.
Amy Brown
Hey, it's Amy Brown from the Bobby Bone Show. Join me in supporting St. Jude Children's Research Hospital for a chance to win a trip to meet Megan Maroney at the 2025 iHeart Country Festival in Austin, Texas on May 3rd. Hosted by Bobby Bones. Going to hook you up with tickets, flights, hotel, food credits and a meet and greet with Megan Maroney. Take action now to support St. Jude and help cure childhood cancer. And you're going to be entered for a chance to win. Visit iheartcountrytrip.com to learn more.
Jake Halpern
Previously on Deep Cover. Craig, you gotta. I can't just call a prosecutor over here and waste his time. You gotta tell us what is it we're asking the prosecutor to come for? And that's when he says, I'm not the shooter and I want immunity.
Mike Farrell
And so he starts telling us how it went down. That basically that he and Tommy decided one night to go and find a black man to kill that black man so that they could get their spiderweb tattoos as skinheads.
Jake Halpern
It was definitely a different type of case. You know, a skinhead coming to Philadelphia to kill somebody. A cowardly act.
Tyrone Wood
The family and I thought that this would be good if we found at least what happened to him. Can't do nothing about it. Can't bring them back. But at least we'll find out the truth.
Jake Halpern
Aron Wood was murdered in the spring of 1989. The case had been cold for almost 20 years until 2008. That's when Tom Gibisson was put on trial. He stood accused of four ethnic intimidation, carrying a Firearm without a license, conspiracy to commit murder, and murder in the first degree. So far, I'd heard a great deal about the prosecution's case against him, and I wanted to hear the defense's case directly from the man who made it himself.
Mike Farrell
He's scared to death, Jake. They're taking away his life.
Jake Halpern
This is Mike Farrell. He was Tom Gibisson's lawyer. And he was quick to tell me just how precarious his client's situation was.
Mike Farrell
And at the time, he's facing life without parole, and the only comfort he has that he's got this crooked Irish kid who's trying to help him.
Jake Halpern
Crooked Irish kid being you?
Mike Farrell
Correct.
Jake Halpern
Why do you call yourself a crooked Irish kid?
Mike Farrell
Well, I have a crooked face, Jake.
Jake Halpern
He means that quite literally, by the way. When he was just a baby, Mike had an operation. And as a result, the left side of his face is paralyzed. It's not apparent immediately unless he smiles and then you notice because it's really only a half smile. When I arrived at Mike's house in Philadelphia, he was prepared to retry this case. And I'm being serious here. He had his opening remarks printed and laid out on the dining room table. He'd retrieved all the files from this case, boxes of it. And after a brief introduction, you know, explaining his crooked face, as he called it, he launched right into his opening arguments.
Mike Farrell
I believe Tom Gibson is innocent.
Jake Halpern
Tom Gibson is innocent, he told me. Is as if the trial were going on right now in his dining room.
Mike Farrell
They had no physical evidence. They had no gun. They had nothing but the ear witnesses of scorned girlfriends and Craig Peterson, who had been made an offer he couldn't refuse to. To escape prosecution in return for full immunity.
Jake Halpern
Mike got worked up. Red in the face, raised voice, leaning in close to me. At one point, he actually apologized for getting so animated, Said he couldn't help it. I learned that over the course of his career, Mike had carved out a niche for himself, defending what Mike calls unpopular persons, people who might alienate a jury. He represented a bunch of skinheads, but also guys like Mumia Abu Jamal, a black activist who was convicted of murdering a white Philadelphia cop. Mike was on his legal team, too.
Mike Farrell
At cocktail parties, criminal defense attorneys are always asked, you know, how do you represent people who are accused of doing horrible things? My answer was, because I'm a sinner.
Jake Halpern
When you say you're a sinner, though, what exactly do you mean by that? Do you mean that in a way that we're all sinners, or are you speaking Specifically, yes, we're all sinners.
Mike Farrell
I'm a sinner, and ultimately no one is the worst thing that they've done in their life.
Jake Halpern
One more thing that I should mention about Mike. Years after he defended Tom, he was convicted of money laundering and attempted witness tampering in another case involving marijuana dealers. It's safe to say Mike's entire career, start to finish, defies convention. One of Mike's challenges in this case was to keep the jury from jumping to conclusions about his client, Tom Gibisson. The whole skinhead thing was potentially a liability. It threatened to bias the jury against Tom from the start. To counter this, Mike described Tom in a very specific way. You might recall Tom once told a local newspaper that he was at one time a certain type of skinhead, a blue collar skinhead. Mike claimed that this was a very important distinction.
Mike Farrell
Tom Gibson was a blue collar skinhead, and a blue collar skinhead did not advocate racism. He advocated, frankly, not unlike our current maga, which is America first, blue collar skinheads do not advocate racism.
Jake Halpern
I had read that he had a Hitler tattoo, though, on his body.
Mike Farrell
He did, and at some point in his younger life, that was part of his ideology, but it was not his ideology when I represented him.
Jake Halpern
I haven't been able to speak with Tom directly about this. He never responded to my requests for an interview. But based on the court records, Tom got the Hitler tattoo after the alleged murder. I know this because before the trial even started, his lawyer, Mike, argued that the jury did not need to know about that tattoo. And the judge agreed it was a win for the defense. Even so, it would be easy for a jury to make some snap judgments about who Tom Gibson was and what he believed. It was Mike's job to preempt these judgments. Mike hoped that he could focus the jury's attention instead on what he saw as the problems with the prosecution's case.
Mike Farrell
This was a case that was absolutely backwards. Ordinarily, you have a murder and law enforcement searches for the murderer. In this case, they started with a murderer and searched for a murder.
Jake Halpern
In other words, the feds had taken the rumor of a killing, linked it to a cold case, and blamed his client. That was the argument. Anyhow. Mike didn't have to offer any answers. He didn't have to identify the, quote, real killer. All he had to do was create reasonable doubt, poke just enough holes in the prosecution's argument that jurors might start scratching their heads. And the thing about Mike is he's really good at poking holes. This became apparent to me the minute I set foot in his dining room. But of course, it wasn't me he needed to convince. It was a jury of 12 Philadelphians back in 2008. His adversary was the legendary prosecutor Roger King. His audience was a courtroom packed with spectators. They included lawyers who'd come to witness this showdown, a Ron woods family who was praying for justice. And of course, the press was there, too, because this trial would make headlines. How could it not? A cold case almost two decades old had been resuscitated in rather epic fashion. And if the prosecution was to be believed, Haight itself was on trial. I'm Jake Halpern, and this is deep cover. Season 4 the Nameless Man Episode 5 the Trial.
Amazon Pharmacy Voiceover
The last thing you want to do when you're sick is go to the pharmacy to pick up a prescription, because then you're standing in a long line with a whole bunch of sick people and everyone is sick of being sick around other people who are sick. Amazon Pharmacy will deliver right to you fast so you can get meds without congregating among the contagious. Healthcare just got less painful. Amazon Pharmacy.
Amy Brown
Hey, it's Amy Brown from the Bobbi Bones Show. Join me in supporting St. Jude Children's Research Hospital for a chance to win a trip to meet Megan Maroney at the 2025 I Heart Country Festival in Austin, Texas on May 3rd. Hosted by Bobby Bones. We're going to hook you up with tickets, flights, hotel, food credits, and a meet and greet with Megan Maroney. Take action now to support St. Jude and help cure childhood cancer. And you're going to be entered for a chance to win. Visit iheartcountrytrip.com to learn more. You know, when the world gets a little crazy and everything is moving too fast, don't you just wish you could get away from all of it for a while? Well, that's exactly what the all new 2025 Nissan Murano can do for you. And to be clear, you don't even have to go anywhere. The Murano is the getaway. It was designed from the ground up to be a refuge from the daily grind. I mean, it has a Bose premium sound system which can play your favorite, most relaxing music. And there's nothing like a world class audio system to just transport you to a better headspace. Then there's the Murano's massaging leather appointed seats. Yeah, massaging seats. Talk about melting away your stress. So could getting stuck in traffic become your happy place? I don't know. It sounds like it could. In the all new Murano you should probably check one out for yourself. You gotta drive the all new 2025 Nissan Murano today. Bows and massaging leather. Appointed seats are optional features.
Jake Halpern
The prosecutor in this case was Roger King, a legendary figure. A distant cousin of Martin Luther King Jr. He spoke with the cadence and the charisma of a big church pastor. Roger often made the papers. He tried high profile cases. Back in the spring of 2008, the city's criminal justice center was buzzing with the news that Roger King was trying his very last case. This drew a bunch of spectators, and one of them was another prosecutor named Carlos Vega. Carlos says he just had to be there.
Carlos Vega
It's almost like saying goodbye. You know, it's a level of respect you're giving him, but also you're watching one of the greats do his last performance.
Jake Halpern
Carlos, like so many prosecutors in Philadelphia, had been mentored by King as a baby da.
Carlos Vega
When you first came to the office, he was a legend. He had tried these really complicated murders, you know, that were in the front front page and, you know, they go, that's Roger King.
Jake Halpern
Eventually, Carlos ended up getting involved in this case as a prosecutor. But initially he was just a spectator sitting in the gallery watching Roger King's last performance. As he put it, Roger died back in 2016. The headline to his obituary read, Roger King, 72, larger than life. And I should tell you, his legacy was complicated. In a number of other murder cases that he tried, his convictions were later overturned. There were allegations that he hid evidence, manipulated witnesses, or otherwise broke the rules. Carlos told me Roger was not the kind of guy who would have been intimidated by anyone, that he was tough and that he was always ready for anything.
Carlos Vega
A lot of homicide prosecutors are armed. So, you know, Roger always carried two guns.
Jake Halpern
Why two?
Carlos Vega
Because Roger is Roger.
Jake Halpern
And then there was Roger's opponent, Mike Farrell. Carlos remembers how Mike carried himself in the courtroom.
Carlos Vega
He was very, very intense. He's not a bully because he's very gentle, but he looks like he'd run up and punch you. Like he really. You see the veins popping in his neck and everything like that.
Jake Halpern
So that was the scene in the courtroom, larger than life. Roger King, who liked to carry his two guns, and the self proclaimed crooked face Irishman, veins ready to pop out of his neck. Two impassioned lawyers getting ready, prelude to an epic standoff. The trial would hinge on two fundamental questions. Number one, did it really happen? In other words, do you believe that in 1989, Tom Gibson went to Philadelphia and murdered a complete stranger? The answer to this question would depend on the credibility of three star witnesses. There were the two ex girlfriends, both of whom claimed that Tom had confessed to them. And there was the old friend, Craig Peterson, who claimed to be the accomplice. These witnesses would have to convince the jury that Tom had committed murder back in 1989. Then there was question number two. Was this the correct victim? In other words, was there enough evidence to convict Tom Gibson specifically for the murder of Iron Wood? And the answer to this question would focus on the detective work performed by Scott Duffy, Terry Mortimer, and the Philadelphia PD the burden of proof was on the prosecution. And this was a point that Mike made both in his opening arguments and in the little reenactment that he did for me.
Mike Farrell
Now, in a criminal case, it's very interesting in the sense that the prosecution side of the story, they have to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. As to the defense side of the story, we just have to create reasonable doubt. But we did way more than that.
Jake Halpern
Ultimately, Mike would present his own theory on how and why Iron Wood was killed. But his main job was simply to poke holes in the prosecution's case, starting with the credibility of its three star witnesses. Let's start by talking about the testimony of the two ex girlfriends. If you recall, one of them was from high school. Her name was Jen. Tom was her prom date. And when she took the witness stand, she testified that Tom had shown off his spiderweb tattoo on a number of occasions, including at the prom, and that Tom had been very clear. This tattoo was a badge of honor for killing a black man. Jen also claimed that Tom kept a newspaper article covering the man's death and boasted that this was his doing, his murder. Jen testified, Quote, he told me that he was driving aimlessly, and a man just walked out between two parked cars and he shot him in the head. Jen said her relationship with Tom ended because he was abusive. The other ex girlfriend was Patricia. She was Tom's girlfriend when he was older, in his 20s. Patricia also testified to the fact that Tom liked to show off his tattoo and brag about the murder that he'd committed. She also talked about the newspaper article that Tom supposedly kept. She also alleged Tom had abused her in a brutal manner. I'm not going to get into all the details here, but the allegations were graphic, specific, and disturbing. Carlos Vega, who you heard from earlier and who eventually got involved in this case as a prosecutor, said that Jen and Patricia showed real courage, not only for taking the stand, but for risking the potential consequences.
Carlos Vega
Think of it. If they were Intimate with him. They know who he is, they know what he is. People don't understand. It's not TV that it's cut and everybody's happy. There is a life after a case, and people have to live the rest of their lives dealing with the murderer. His family, his friends, his associates. They're going to have to look behind their back for the rest of their lives.
Jake Halpern
Mike, the defense lawyer, argued that both of these women had been cast aside by Tom, that they were, quote, scorned girlfriends. In particular, Mike attacked Patricia's credibility, noted that she'd struggled with substance abuse for years, and pointed out that Tom had cheated on her repeatedly.
Mike Farrell
You know, he was not a faithful boyfriend, but he was not a murderer.
Jake Halpern
Mike maintained that both ex girlfriends were lying on the stand. To get back at Tom in cross examination, Mike did his best to poke holes in the ex girlfriend's stories by pointing out inconsistencies. Over the preceding years, Jen and Patricia had told their stories multiple times to investigators and court officials, and there were some discrepancies. Patricia and Jen both testified at trial about seeing Tom's spiderweb tattoo. But years earlier, Patricia had originally told investigators the tattoo that Tom got for the murder was a teardrop within a spiderweb.
Mike Farrell
Well, the theory of the girlfriends, the theory that, that began this whole snowball rolling down the side of a snow covered hill was not to earn the web tattoo, but to earn a red teardrop within the web tattoo.
Jake Halpern
For the record, Tom did have a web tattoo, but there was no teardrop in it. Mike found things like this, small inconsistencies and hammered away at them. In my mind, the most confounding issue that Mike raised involved a newspaper article about the murder, the one that Tom allegedly kept. This article was important because in theory, if Iran Wood was the victim, then this article would have Iran's name in it. Right, because it would be about Iran. But no one, not the feds or the police or the prosecutors was able to find such an article. Not at Tom's house or the library or anywhere. It's a loose end that remains unexplained. And according to Mike Farrell, this was another hole in the prosecution's. More on the prosecution after the break.
Amazon Pharmacy Voiceover
The last thing you want to do when you're sick is go to the pharmacy to pick up a prescription, because then you're standing in a long line with a whole bunch of sick people. And everyone is sick of being sick around other people who are sick. Amazon pharmacy will deliver right to you fast. So you can get meds without congregating among the contagious. Healthcare just got less painful. Amazon Pharmacy.
Amy Brown
Hey, it's Amy Brown from the Bobbi Bones Show. Join me in supporting St. Jude Children's Research Hospital for a chance to win a trip to meet Megan Maroney at the 2025 I Heart Country Festival in Austin, Texas on May 3rd. Hosted by Bobby Bones. We're going to hook you up with tickets, flights, hotel, food credits, and a meet and greet with Megan Maroney. Take action now to support St. Jude and help cure childhood cancer. And you're going to be entered for a chance to win. Visit iheartcountrytrip.com to learn more. You know, when the world gets a little crazy and everything is moving too fast, don't you just wish you could get away from all of it for a while? Well, that's exactly what the all new 2025 Nissan Murano can do for you. And to be clear, you don't even have to go anywhere. The Murano is the getaway. It was designed from the ground up to be a refuge from the daily grind. I mean, it has a Bose premium sound system which can play your favorite, most relaxing music. And there's nothing like a world class audio system to just transport you to a better headspace. Then there's the Murano's massaging leather appointed seats. Yeah, massaging seats. Talk about melting away your stress. So could getting stuck in traffic become your happy place? I don't know. It sounds like it could in the all new Murano. You should probably check one out for yourself. You gotta drive the all new 2025 Nissan Murano today. Bows and massaging leather appointed seats are optional features.
Jake Halpern
By far the most important witness was Craig Peterson, the supposed accomplice. He was really the linchpin to the prosecution's case. When Craig finally walked into the courtroom, it was a dramatic moment. Craig and Tom had been friends since the fourth grade. They knew each other's families. They'd grown up alongside one another in Delaware. And if Craig was to be believed, they'd finished out their adolescence by committing murder together. Now, almost two decades later, the former friends were in their late 30s. One was the defendant, possibly facing life in prison. The other, the star witness, who had a get out of jail free card. When he took the stand, Craig described the night of the murder in detail, just as he had done with Scott and Terry, the two federal agents, two years prior. It was the same story. That he had helped to kill a man, all because of the color of his skin. And that he had watched as Tom Guybusson shot him in the head. And then as Craig told the jury, he, quote, slowly drove off like nothing happened and just kept going.
Mike Farrell
Craig Peterson was a liar. He was a corrupt source, frankly, he was given an offer that no one could refuse.
Jake Halpern
This is the argument that the defense made at trial that Craig lied to the federal agents Scott and Terry to save his own skin.
Mike Farrell
If in fact their theory was that, that he was the driver of Tom Givison to Philadelphia from Wilmington to kill a black man. He's a co conspirator of first degree murder, life without parole.
Jake Halpern
So your contention is that they explicitly threatened him or said, you're going to go away from murder if you don't cooperate with us.
Mike Farrell
It's not my theory, Jake. It's the truth. It's exactly what happened. You know, Mr. Peterson, you know, didn't Tom Garbison. Didn't you drive Tom Garbison to Philadelphia to kill Blackman? No. Second time. Didn't you drive Tom Gibson to Philadelphia to kill Backman? No. Third time. Well, look, you know, you're facing life without parole, first degree murder, co conspirator. But we'll let you go scot free with total immunity if you essentially tell us what we want to hear.
Jake Halpern
It is true that initially Craig denied taking part in this murder when Scott and Terry made that trip to Vermont. But it's also true that once he confessed, his story with all its many details, remained consistent in the courtroom under cross examination, Craig held his own. At one point, Mike asked him pointedly, you decided to tell them what they want to hear, that you'd get immunity and not have to worry about prosecution. Correct, Craig replied, I didn't tell them what they wanted to hear. I told them what happened. It's impossible to underscore just how important Craig was as a witness. In order to convict Tom Gibisson, the jury would not only have to believe that Craig was credible, they would also have to believe that Craig's memory was reliable. Because all the details that connected this murder to Iron Wood came from Craig's confession. Scott, Terry and Luby, the detective from the Philippe PD all testified for the prosecution. They walked the jury through the years of work they'd done to bring this cold case out of the basement, literally and into the courtroom. Talked about how several key facts from Craig's confession, the general location, the type of weapon, the nature of the wound, and the timeframe spring of 89 led them to a single match, Iron Wood. But in the end, it would all come down to a gut feeling about Craig. The prosecution presented him as someone with a checkered past who'd finally redeemed himself and told the truth. The defense was calling him a liar and an opportunist. It would be up to the jury to decide. After the prosecution rested, Mike Farrell had an opportunity to present his own witnesses to build out an alternate theory of how Iron Wood died, to suggest that Tom wasn't the one who killed him. His counter narrative is a bit spotty. Not all of it connects, but I'm going to walk you through it.
Mike Farrell
Aaron Wood, who was supposedly the victim, Tom Givison, didn't kill him. Drugs and guns killed him.
Jake Halpern
Mike called a bunch of witnesses to build out his theory that Aram was murdered over a drug debt. One of these witnesses was an old girlfriend of Iran's. She testified that Aran sold drugs and that she'd once received a threatening phone call from a guy who was looking for Iran. In response, Roger King pointed out that this call occurred more than a year before the murder. So he argued, connecting these two events was a real stretch. Mike brought in other witnesses too, including a bartender who'd seen Aran on the night of the murder in an agitated state.
Mike Farrell
We proved that Aaron Wood was in a bar, nervous, afraid, indicating that he may never come back.
Jake Halpern
The bartender recalled Aran saying, you probably won't be seeing me no more, man, after today. It went on like this. Mike brought in someone who had been interviewed by the police back in 1989 at the scene of the crime.
Mike Farrell
And we have an eyewitness of heard the gunshot and saw three black males in hoods running from the scene of the gunshot.
Jake Halpern
On cross examination, Roger asked this witness if he thought the three men in hoods running away were involved in the crime. No, said the witness. This man also admitted in a moment of absurdity that he had no idea why he was being called to testify because he knew nothing about this murder. Okay, at this point, if you're scratching your head trying to keep all this straight, I hear you. Information overload. That, however, seemed to be part of the defense's strategy here. Mike wasn't offering complete answers or a counternarrative. That made total sense, and he didn't have to. He was just trying to see doubts in the jurors minds. I should mention Tom Gibisson never took the witness stand. He waived his right to testify, so the jury never heard from him. The trial would last for 12 days, and as the lawyers sparred and the witnesses testified, one man in the gallery watched on silently. He was there every day from start till finish, taking it all in. That man was Tyrone Wood, Iran's youngest brother.
Tyrone Wood
I felt like I had to go to trial every day, and I felt like I had to find truth for not only for the family, for my mom, because she said, should I go? And I said, no, no, because he.
Jake Halpern
Didn'T want her hearing all the details, reliving the whole nightmare. So he went instead, though it was no easy task for him either. In the lead up to the trial, kind of amazingly, no one had shared any details with him. The whole story about Tom and Craig and the prom and the tattoos, that was all news to him. Tyrone intently listened to all the witnesses, especially Craig, and he found him credible. It was a torturous situation. On the one hand, Craig's testimony is what made this whole trial possible. He was the key to the family shot at justice or at least at closure. On the other hand, Craig was also the man who supposedly helped kill Iran, the man who drove away, quote, like nothing happened. I asked Tyrone how he felt about Craig testifying.
Tyrone Wood
I was actually thinking that I was glad he did, at least for my family and for my mother mainly, so at least they can close their eyes knowing that they knew who did it. And that's the way I look at it also. I just thank God for that. I knew who did it.
Jake Halpern
Occasionally during the trial, Tyrone found himself looking right at Tom Gibson. Looking and thinking.
Tyrone Wood
I said, I'm not gonna let him win. I just wanted you to be convicted of my brother's death. You did it. You know, you did it, so. And I felt like he was a coward, you know? Cause you didn't face no man. You went up and just shot a man just because. For sport. I don't hate. But I was kind of hating for a little bit. And then at the same token, I thought to myself, I can't let this guy overtake me again. So I'm thinking that we gonna get justice, and then everything will be okay.
Jake Halpern
His family's hopes, just like Tom's fate, were now in the hands of 12 Philadelphians. It was their call. They had to sort through the witnesses testimonies, the narrative, the counter narrative, the lofty rhetoric of Roger King, the doubts sowed by Mike Farrell, all in search of the elusive prospect that buried somewhere in this tangled, tragic mess was a verdict that was truly just. Next time on Deep cover. My name is Bob. I'm a Philadelphian, and I was selected to serve on the jury that heard the case of Thomas Gibson. Pressure was growing within the the group to come to a conclusion. There was a feeling of we don't have more to go on. Deep Cover is produced by Amy Gaines, McQuaid and Jacob Smith. It's edited by Karen Shakurji, mastering by Jake Gorski. Our show art was designed by Sean Carney. Original scoring and our theme was composed by Luis Guerra. Fact checking by Arthur Goperts. Our story consultant was James Foreman Jr. Special thanks to Jerry Williams, Sarah Nix, Greta Cohn and Jake Flanagan. I'm Jake Halpern.
Amy Brown
Okay, so we all need to get away from the world sometimes. Well, in the all new 2025 Nissan Murano, you don't even have to go anywhere. The Murano is the getaway. Just picture it. The Bose Premium sound system plays your favorite music as the Murano's massaging leather appointed seats melt away your stress. Yeah, that's a real getaway. Drive the all new 2025 Nissan Murano today. Bose and massaging leather appointed seats are optional features.
Jake Halpern
Stop hitting snooze on new tech Upgrade the whole team@lenovo.com Unlock AI experiences with the ThinkPad X1 Carbon powered by Intel.
Amy Brown
Core Ultra processors so you can work.
Jake Halpern
Create and boost productivity all on one device. Win the Tech Search for Business PCs@lenovo.com.
Ryan Seacrest
Hey, it's Ryan Seacrest for Albertsons and Safeway with the Stock up sale at Safeway and Albertsons. Stock up and earn four times points at your local store when you purchase participating products. Save on Household Essentials from General Mills, Kellogg's, Philadelphia Quaker and Tide. Clip the offer in the app for event savings and look for participating items throughout the store. Shop in store or online. Plus you can even have your groceries delivered or use. Drive up and go to have your groceries brought to your car at the store. Restrictions and exclusions applied. Visit Albertsons or Safeway.com for more details.
Release Date: May 20, 2024
Producer: Amy Gaines McQuade
Host: Jake Halpern
Series: Deep Cover: The Nameless Man (Season Four)
In Episode 5, titled "The Trial," Deep Cover delves into the high-stakes courtroom battle surrounding Tom Gibisson, a former Republican Congressman from New York accused of heinous crimes from his past. Producer Amy Gaines McQuade, hailing from the very district Santos represented, unpacks the intricate web of deception and legal maneuvering that defines this landmark case. The episode provides a gripping narrative of the trial's proceedings, highlighting the clash between the formidable prosecutor Roger King and the tenacious defense attorney Mike Farrell.
Tom Gibisson stands accused of four counts: ethnic intimidation, carrying a firearm without a license, conspiracy to commit murder, and murder in the first degree. The alleged crime dates back to the spring of 1989 when Aron Wood was murdered. The case had remained cold for nearly two decades until renewed investigative efforts in 2008 brought Gibisson to trial.
Notable Quote:
Mike Farrell, Tom Gibisson's lawyer, asserts, "[Tom Gibisson] is innocent." (03:24)
Under the leadership of Roger King, the prosecution's strategy hinged on Craig Peterson's testimony. Peterson, a childhood friend of Gibisson, recounted the night of the murder in vivid detail, claiming that Gibisson sought out Aron Wood solely based on his race.
Notable Quote:
Carlos Vega describes Roger King: "He was tough and always ready for anything." (14:45)
The prosecution emphasized that Gibisson had the motive and opportunity, supported by testimonies from two ex-girlfriends of Gibisson—Jen and Patricia—who alleged his involvement in the murder and recounted abusive behaviors.
Notable Quote:
Patricia testified, "Tom had been abusive, and he showed off his spiderweb tattoo as a badge of honor." (18:00)
Additionally, the prosecution presented forensic evidence linking Gibisson to the crime scene, including the absence of a murder weapon and the supposed possession of a newspaper article by Gibisson detailing the murder.
Mike Farrell's defense centered on creating reasonable doubt regarding both the occurrence of the murder and Gibisson's involvement. Farrell meticulously deconstructed the prosecution's narrative by attacking the credibility of key witnesses and highlighting inconsistencies in their testimonies.
Notable Quote:
Farrell challenges Peterson: "Craig Peterson was a liar. He was a corrupt source." (25:36)
Farrell argued that Craig Peterson was coerced into testifying through promises of immunity, suggesting that Peterson's account was fabricated to secure his own freedom. He pointed out discrepancies in the ex-girlfriends' stories, such as variations in the description of Gibisson's tattoo and the absence of the alleged newspaper article in any public records.
Furthermore, Farrell introduced an alternative theory implicating drug-related motives behind Aron Wood's murder, presenting testimonies from Wood's old girlfriend and a bartender to suggest Gibisson's innocence.
Notable Quote:
Farrell states, "Aaron Wood was killed by drugs and guns, not by Tom Gibisson." (29:05)
Notable Quote:
Tyrone Wood shares his emotions: "I was actually thinking that I was glad he did, at least for my family and for my mother mainly." (32:53)
Prosecution: Leveraged Roger King's reputation to present a compelling case, emphasizing Peterson's testimony and the corroborating accounts of the ex-girlfriends. The prosecution aimed to establish Gibisson's premeditation and racial motive.
Defense: Focused on discrediting the prosecution's witnesses by exposing inconsistencies and suggesting ulterior motives. Farrell sought to redirect the narrative towards alternative suspects and motives, thereby sowing doubt about Gibisson's guilt.
Notable Quote:
Farrell explains the defense tactic: "In a criminal case, the prosecution has to prove beyond a reasonable doubt. We just have to create reasonable doubt." (16:53)
The courtroom was a battleground of contrasting personalities. Roger King, with his charismatic and authoritative presence, contrasted sharply against Mike Farrell's intense and aggressive defense approach. The interplay between the seasoned prosecutor and the unconventional defense attorney underscored the trial's high stakes.
Notable Quote:
Carlos Vega remarks on King’s legacy: "Roger King was not the kind of guy who would have been intimidated by anyone." (14:45)
For Aryon Wood's family, particularly Tyrone Wood, the trial was a quest for closure. Witnessing the proceedings firsthand, Tyrone grappled with his desire for justice against the backdrop of a complex legal battle that questioned the very essence of truth and memory.
Notable Quote:
Tyrone Wood reflects: "I want justice, and then everything will be okay." (33:26)
The jury faced two pivotal questions:
The resolution hinged on the jury's ability to navigate conflicting testimonies, assess witness credibility, and evaluate the effectiveness of the defense's reasonable doubt strategy.
Episode 5 of Deep Cover masterfully unravels the intricate layers of a decades-old murder case resurfaced in a modern courtroom. Through its detailed exploration of both prosecution and defense strategies, the episode sheds light on the complexities of seeking justice within the legal system. As the trial progresses, listeners are left contemplating the elusive nature of truth and the profound impact of past actions on present lives.
Mike Farrell:
Carlos Vega:
Tyrone Wood:
In the next episode of Deep Cover: The Nameless Man, the focus shifts to the jury deliberations, where critical decisions will be made that could alter the lives of everyone involved. Join Jake Halpern as he continues to uncover the layers of deceit and truth in this compelling case.
This summary aims to capture the essence of Episode 5: The Trial, providing an in-depth look into the pivotal moments and key discussions that define the narrative. Whether you're revisiting the episode or exploring it for the first time, this guide serves as a comprehensive overview of the trial that captivates Philadelphia and beyond.