Rosemarie’s Story

Summary

Deep Cover: Episode Summary – "Rosemarie’s Story"

Release Date: June 23, 2025

In the gripping episode titled "Rosemarie’s Story," part of Season 6 of Deep Cover: The Truth About Sarah, Pulitzer Prize-winning journalist Jake Halpern and investigative journalist Jess McHugh delve deep into the intricate web of deception spun by Sarah Kavanaugh. This episode uncovers the profound impact of Sarah's double life on those around her, particularly focusing on Rosemarie, Sarah's dedicated community support specialist.

---

Introduction to Rosemarie and Her Connection to Sarah

The episode opens with Jake Halpern introducing Rosemarie, a recently retired community support specialist who dedicated years to assisting veterans in their most vulnerable moments. Rosemarie recounts her first meeting with Sarah Kavanaugh:

Rosemarie (02:05): "Oh, he's gonna bark at the mailman like all good dogs do."

Rosemarie portrays Sarah as a struggling veteran battling traumatic injuries and cancer, painting a picture of a woman in dire need of support.

---

Building Trust: Rosemarie’s Role in Sarah’s Life

Rosemarie details her professional relationship with Sarah, highlighting the challenges faced in assisting someone with traumatic brain injury, a prosthetic hip, and PTSD:

Rosemarie (03:11): "What did you understand her physical injuries to be? She had the traumatic brain injury. She had a prosthetic hip, supposedly, and she was also going through cancer treatment."

She emphasizes the personalized approach required in her work:

Rosemarie (08:36): "So there isn't a set blueprint for working with someone with brain injury. It's different in the sense of each person's injury manifests itself in different ways."

Through her compassionate support, Rosemarie becomes a pillar in Sarah's life, assisting with daily tasks and emotional support.

---

Unraveling the Deception: Signs of a Double Life

As Rosemarie spends more time with Sarah, discrepancies begin to surface. Rosemarie notices inconsistencies between Sarah's public persona and her private struggles:

Rosemarie (10:56): "She was in tears. Wow. She was anxious. She was worked up. There was things that had happened."

A pivotal moment occurs when Sarah desperately attempts to return her Purple Heart license plates, a symbol of her fabricated military heroism:

Rosemarie (14:03): "We have to go to the DMV. I have to return these plates. They're causing so much problems. I just want to get rid of them."

This act raises red flags, hinting at the unraveling of Sarah's constructed identity.

---

The Revelation: Discovering the Truth

In early 2022, Rosemarie stumbles upon an article exposing Sarah's fraudulent claims. Shocked and devastated, Rosemarie confronts Sarah:

Rosemarie (15:09): "Are you okay?"

Sarah's evasive response confirms the depth of her deception, leading Rosemarie to realize she has been deceived for years:

Rosemarie (16:30): "John, I've been deceived for years. I knew Sarah so intimately, but in other ways, I didn't know her at all."

---

Investigations and Unanswered Questions

The episode introduces Tom Donnelly, an investigator from the VA's Office of Inspector General, who sheds light on the elusive figure "Ivy," a supposed social worker involved in Sarah's care. Rosemarie recalls conference calls where Ivy provided updates, but discrepancies suggest someone else was impersonating Ivy using Sarah's VA-issued phone:

Tom Donnelly (22:44): "We could never prove that another person was involved, but it's evidence that leads me to believe that 100% somebody else was involved."

The true identity of this accomplice remains a mystery, deepening the intrigue surrounding Sarah's double life.

---

Aftermath: Emotional and Psychological Impact

Rosemarie reflects on the broader implications of Sarah's actions, expressing regret and questioning the ripple effects of her own involvement:

Rosemarie (27:28): "So many people got scammed. ... I just wish I could have saved some grief for people."

The episode poignantly captures Rosemarie's internal struggle with guilt and the profound sense of loss stemming from Sarah's betrayal.

---

Unresolved Tensions and Lingering Doubts

In the episode's closing moments, Rosemarie shares her fears about Sarah's future actions post-sentencing, highlighting the enduring uncertainty:

Rosemarie (29:47): "What she's going to do after, because how do you come out of jail and having done this and have some kind of a normal life?"

Jake Halpern concludes by emphasizing the haunting nature of unresolved questions, leaving listeners contemplating the complexities of human deceit and trust.

---

Conclusion

"Rosemarie’s Story" masterfully weaves personal narratives with investigative journalism, exposing the intricate layers of deception orchestrated by Sarah Kavanaugh. Through Rosemarie's eyes, listeners witness the profound impact of living a double life, the challenges of uncovering the truth, and the emotional toll on those who care deeply. This episode underscores Deep Cover's commitment to unveiling hidden truths and exploring the human stories behind acts of deception.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Rosemarie (08:36): "So there isn't a set blueprint for working with someone with brain injury. It's different in the sense of each person's injury manifests itself in different ways."

• Tom Donnelly (22:44): "We could never prove that another person was involved, but it's evidence that leads me to believe that 100% somebody else was involved."

• Rosemarie (27:28): "So many people got scammed. I mean, that's where I stopped beating myself up was people smarter than me got scammed..."

• Rosemarie (29:47): "What she's going to do after, because how do you come out of jail and having done this and have some kind of a normal life?"

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the essence of "Rosemarie’s Story," offering insightful perspectives into the profound themes of deception, trust, and the human condition explored in Deep Cover.

Transcript

[Ryan Seacrest]

This is an iHeart podcast.

[Justin Richmond]

This is Justin Richmond from Broken Record. The three things I love about summer are pool days, blaring, all the new summer songs that come out, and endless refreshing iced drinks from Starbucks. Even better, my favorite summer drink has returned to Starbucks. The Summer Berry Refresher is available now. A mix of berry flavors shaken with ice and poured over raspberry flavored pearls and it's light, vibrant and just as refreshing as the summer fun you'll be having. So queue up your playlist and head over to Starbucks to check out their summer menu. There's something for everyone. From creamy cold brews to ice cold refreshers. Your Summer Berry Refresher is ready at Starbucks.

[Unknown]

In golf, precision is everything on and off the course. PGA of America chose advanced 5G solutions from T Mobile for Business for smooth operations and seamless transactions. Together they enhance ticketing and concessions for better fan experiences from gate to green. This is pro level efficiency. This is PJ of America with T Mobile for Business. Take your business further@t mobile.com now this.

[Justin Richmond]

Is a vehicle that looks tough because it is tough. The Defender 110. Built for the modern explorer with an exterior designed for optimum durability and a raised hood and sculpted grille that give it a modern edge. Inside capability meets comfort with luxury materials and seating for five or up to seven. Naturally capable expedition ready. This is the Defender 110. Explore the Defender 110 at land roverusa.com.

[Jake Halpern]

Pushkin One morning last December, my co host Jess McHugh and our producer Amy Gaines McQuaid traveled to Rhode island to sit down with a woman named Rosemary Coffee.

[Rosemarie]

Oh, he's gonna bark at the mailman like all good dogs do.

[Jake Halpern]

Boo.

[Rosemarie]

Leave Frank alone.

[Jake Halpern]

That's Rosemary talking to her dog Boo. When Jess and Amy arrived, Rosemarie had pastries from a local bakery waiting for them. And Rosemarie, she likes to take care of people like this. She's 60 years old and recently retired, but before that, she spent her career supporting people when they're at their most vulnerable. She worked as a community support specialist and for a time, Rosemarie took care of Sarah Kavanaugh.

[Rosemarie]

Well, I worked with her, I'm guessing three years. Wow. So. And up to the end. So it would have been right. Exactly to the point.

[Jake Halpern]

Sarah enrolled in the Wounded Warrior Independence program. It's designed for veterans with life changing injuries and it was through this program that Wounded Warrior paid for Rosemarie's services.

[Rosemarie]

What did you understand her physical injuries to be? She had the traumatic brain injury. She had a prosthetic hip, supposedly, and she was also going through cancer treatment. The prosthetic, the brain injury and the PTSD were the primary challenges.

[Jake Halpern]

She still remembers the first time that she showed up to Sarah's house.

[Rosemarie]

At the time, Sarah was like curled up in a blanket on the couch in front of the window, just looking out the window, all forlorn and shy and withdrawn. And according to the case manager, she wasn't getting adjusted to the community and she really needed a lot of support. If you can just picture that person that's just not been able to do anything, you know, or go anywhere, you know, really struggling, you know, that was, that was the Persona that she put out there.

[Jake Halpern]

Throughout our reporting, Jess and I had heard these stories about Sarah running down mountain trails and competing in epic workout challenges. But, but this, this was an entirely different Sarah we were hearing about. Rosemarie worked with Sarah right up until Sarah's double life came crashing down. Throughout all that time, Sarah let Rosemarie into her home, into her life. And we wondered, what did Rosemarie see? Turns out she saw and heard an awful lot. Some of which has major implications for our story. It suggests that there may have been someone else helping Sarah with her deception. A possible accomplice.

[Tom Donnelly]

I couldn't even tell you a name. I couldn't even tell you necessarily who I suspected. But there were a couple incidents when somebody had to call Sarah's caseworker at the va and Sarah's standing in the room. So it wasn't Sarah. So who's on the other end of the phone?

[Jake Halpern]

Welcome back to deep cover Season 6 the Truth About Sarah. This is Rosemarie's story.

[Rosemarie]

Foreign.

[Unknown]

Together T Mobile for business and industry leaders are innovating with our advanced 5G solutions. For Walt Disney Studios, they transformed moviemaking by syncing teams in California with a remote production hub in Hawaii, enabling Picture Perfect collaboration to help bring Lilo and Stitch to theaters this summer. For PGA of America, they deliver pro level efficiency with connected security and ticketless entry. For smoother operations, seamless transactions and better fan experiences from gate to green. And for tractor Supply, they put 5G business Internet to work across 2,200 stores, cultivating AI driven customer experiences to keep things running seamlessly and inside curbside and countryside. T Mobile for business is helping industries redefine what's possible. Because with a partner that's as committed to your business as you are, there are no limits. Discover how T Mobile Advanced 5G solutions can take your business further. @t mobile.com.

[Justin Richmond]

Now, for those who push past the pavement and chase what's just beyond the map, there's the Defender 110. Purpose built and courage driven, it offers the perfect balance of on road presence and off road prowess. Inside, the Defender 110 transforms every journey. Five seats with the option for seven. Luxury appointments and rich materials mean every mile feels earned, but never uncomfortable. And with cutting edge technology, you stay aware and in control. 3D surround cameras with Clearsight ground view let you see under the vehicle. Clearsight rear view ensures nothing blocks your line of sight. And the next generation PIVI Pro infotainment system keeps your world connected. This is more than a vehicle, it's a machine built for an adventure with the endurance. To take you Further, design your Defender 110 today at Land RoverUSA.com the best.

[Unknown]

AI assistant isn't one that knows the whole world. It's one that knows your world. A custom assistant built on WatsonX with IBM's granite models can leverage your trusted data, be easily trained on your workflows, and integrate with your apps. It can be tuned to do just what you need. Because the more AI knows about your world, the more it can help you do. Learn [e-mail] productivity IBM let's create.

[Jake Halpern]

Rosemarie has worked with people living with disabilities for decades. And if there's one thing she's learned, it's that every case is different.

[Rosemarie]

So there isn't a set blueprint for working with someone with brain injury. It's different in the sense of each person's injury manifests itself in different ways.

[Jake Halpern]

Rose Marie told us that most of the people that she works with have had their worlds turned upside down and they're still trying to find their footing.

[Rosemarie]

So they've had pretty much a normal life leading up to this injury. And then they may have had a car accident, a stroke, a brain tumor. And then everything changes, including personality changes. So that's part of it that you wouldn't see with other disabilities necessarily.

[Jake Halpern]

Her job, helping people get back into the world, running errands, doing chores, the simple stuff, which is no longer so simple. That's where Rosemarie comes in. That's what she started doing for Sarah.

[Rosemarie]

At the time I met her, supposedly she couldn't even go into a store. She couldn't go to a Target, she couldn't go grocery shopping. She couldn't, you know, take care of her household.

[Jake Halpern]

Rosemarie believed Sarah was dealing with ptsd. So she tried to break things down, make simple tasks eat even simpler.

[Rosemarie]

Okay, your first task is to try to just go into target, you know, get one item and go through the register, and that's a success. Or we go, you know, make a grocery list. Like, what do I need? How. What am I going to eat this week?

[Jake Halpern]

And Rosemarie was told certain things were going to be hard for Sarah.

[Rosemarie]

Okay, These are things, emotionally she needs to address. You know, going out in the community, like the DMV would have been a big trigger for her, you know, to do that by herself.

[Jake Halpern]

So Rose Marie went with her to the DMV to get special purple heart plates for her car. You might remember Sarah claimed she earned a purple heart in combat. Somehow she had the paperwork to back that claim up, and she got the plates without even realizing it or meaning to. Rose Marie had played a small role in helping Sarah deepen her deception. As they spent more time together, Rosemarie and Sarah began to form a bond.

[Rosemarie]

So I was supporting her. And of course, when you're doing that, you want to build a rapport. You want to have the person be comfortable. So you're. You're. I mean, I was willing to do the things with her. Let's say she knows she's got to do laundry. Well, I'm not just going to stand there with a clipboard, you know, and talk at her.

[Jake Halpern]

Instead, Rosemarie said, let's chat as we fold the clothes. And over time, Rosemarie became a sounding board for Sarah.

[Rosemarie]

She talked about things that bothered her. She talked about relationships. She talked about family. She was always talking about financial troubles that was weighing on her.

[Jake Halpern]

The version of Sarah that we kept hearing about from other people was tough, unbreakable, Always smiling through the pain. The kind of person people held up as a hero. But Rose Marie saw something else, Something that seemed more tender and fragile.

[Rosemarie]

I would say about 99% of the time. When I arrived at her home, she was in tears. Wow. She was anxious. She was worked up. There was things that had happened. And then, you know, we would talk, and she would calm down, and then we'd say, okay, what's the plan? And we would, you know, be able to move on to an activity that she orchestrated that we should do.

[Jake Halpern]

One of these things was physical therapy.

[Rosemarie]

She wanted to start physical therapy, and the organization was paying for it. Wounded warrior. And so she was nervous about going to the first visit, so I took her to her first visit with Sam.

[Jake Halpern]

Yep. Rosemarie says she took Sarah to her very first appointment with Sam, the physical therapist she went on to become romantically involved with. At first Nothing stood out to Rosemarie. But over time, she came to understand that Sarah's relationship with Sam had evolved.

[Rosemarie]

It took a long time before I saw evidence there was something else with Sam. And I'm trying to be professional. I'm not going to delve into, like, obviously she'd just gotten married, you know, not long before.

[Jake Halpern]

Rosemarie knew Nicole, Sarah's wife at the time. She spent many hours in the home that they shared, and she did her best to stay out of this whole mess and just stick to her job. Being a community support specialist. Well, it's tricky work. You get pulled into people's lives. The mess, the chaos. Rosemarie kept her focus. Help the person in front of you. What she didn't know was just how messy it really was. In early 2022, as Sarah's lies were falling apart, Rosemarie arrived at Sarah's house to help with an errand. The moment she got there, she sensed it. An unsettling tension in the air, like everything was on edge.

[Rosemarie]

I show up, she's outside. She's not even in the house. She's outside. She's, like, anxious. She's got the plates in her hand, she's got the paperwork. She was just like, we have to go to the dmv. I have to return these plates. They're causing so much problems. I just want to get rid of them.

[Jake Halpern]

Sarah was desperate to return those Purple Heart license plates. It was a request that seemed to baffle the DMV staff, but Sarah just wanted those plates gone.

[Rosemarie]

The staff at the DMV were like, so nice, and they were trying to get at what was going on. Like, why? Why do you want to return these? Is somebody harassing you? Like, because we can help you. You know, we'll contact whoever we need to to help you with this. If, you know, you should feel like you earned these. And she's like, no, no, I just have to get rid of it. I don't want to talk about it.

[Jake Halpern]

Soon after this, reports about Sarah's fraud started circulating. Rosemarie was at home when her husband showed her an article that revealed Sarah's deception.

[Rosemarie]

My husband came to me and said, is this Sarah? Sarah in the news? He's showing me on his phone. I was just like, oh, my God. They really have, you know, gone out of their way to. To hurt her. Oh, my God, poor Sarah was my first response. I was like, reaching out to her and be like, are you okay? But so initially, it sounds like your reaction is disbelief. Oh, yes. Yeah. I Had no reason to doubt her. And I was just like, what are these people doing to her? Oh, my God, is she okay? You know, call her right away. And I just said to her, are you okay? And she's like, well, no. And I said, well, if it's not true, you have to defend yourself, Sarah, you know, and she's like, I can't. She said, I can't. I was like, what do you mean? She's like, I. I can't defend myself. And then I was like, well, tell me what's going on. And she's like, I can't talk. I'll call you right back. I'm getting another call. And then she hung up. And that was it.

[Jake Halpern]

Rosemarie soon learned about the investigation into Sarah's fraud and what the feds had begun to discover. And she came to the unsettling realization that. That she had been deceived for years. In some ways, Rosemarie knew Sarah so intimately, but in other ways, she didn't know her at all. We asked Rosemarie if she knew whether Sarah had a job, and turns out she had no idea. Sarah was a social worker at the VA in Providence. Now, granted, she did only work for Sarah part time, roughly six hours a week. She knew that Sarah visited the VA pretty often. And she knew this because sometimes she drove Sarah there.

[Rosemarie]

I've taken her to the va, so I mean, I have no idea what I took her to, but, you know, definitely dropped her off and waited in the car and that kind of thing.

[Jake Halpern]

Part of what made Sarah's story so convincing to Rosemarie and others we interviewed was the fact that someone from Sarah's healthcare team was in contact with them. This person's name was Ivy. Supposedly, Ivy was a social worker at the VA assigned to managing Sarah's care.

[Rosemarie]

She had a lot of talks about the social worker, Ivy at the va, so that's what I thought was going on.

[Jake Halpern]

But what was really going on with Ivy was, well, that's something we're all still trying to figure out. More on that after the break.

[Unknown]

Together. T Mobile for business and industry leaders are innovating with our advanced 5G solutions. For Walt Disney Studios, they transformed moviemaking by syncing teams in California with a remote production hub in Hawaii, enabling Picture Perfect collaboration to help bring Lilo and Stitch to theaters this summer. For PGA of America, they deliver pro level efficiency with connected security and ticketless entry for smoother operations, seamless transactions, and better fan experiences from gate to green. And for tractor Supply, they put 5G business Internet to work across 2,200 stores cultivating AI driven customer experiences to keep things running seamlessly inside curbside and countryside. T Mobile for business is helping industries redefine what's possible. Because with a partner that's as committed to your business as you are, there are no limits. Discover how T Mobile Advanced 5G solutions can take your business further@t mobile.com now.

Your business deploys AI pilots everywhere. But are they going anywhere or are they stuck in silos, exhausting resources, unable to scale? Maybe you don't need hundreds of AI pilots, you need a holistic strategy. IBM has 65,000 consultants with Gen AI expertise who can help you design, design, integrate and optimize AI solutions. So you're not just deploying AI, you're scaling it across your business. Learn more at IBM.com consulting IBM let's.

[Justin Richmond]

Create this is Justin Richmond from Broken Record. What's summer without new music? And what's the hottest new summer song without a refreshing iced coffee in hand? Especially the new iced Horchata Oat Milk Shaken Espresso available now at Starbucks. A blonde espresso combined with rich horchata syrup that delivers a wonderful hint of cinnamon, vanilla and rice flavors. Topped with oat milk, it delivers a flavor inspired by the Mexican style horchata. For a refreshing and creamy, pick me up. As an LA native, I've had my fair share of horchata and this blend is delicious. Not only does it taste like authentic horchata, but you still get a great coffee flavor. It's perfectly balanced, a little something for everyone. You can savor your coffee at the same time you kick out your summer jams this year thanks to Starbucks new summer menu featuring everything from creamy cold brews to ice cold refreshers. Your Iced Horchata Oat Milk Shaken espresso is ready at Starbucks.

[Jake Halpern]

A few people we've interviewed, including Rosemarie, say they spoke with someone claiming to be Ivy. Rosemarie told us about one conference call in particular. It was a check in with Sarah's healthcare team. Rosemarie was on the line as was a case manager from the Wounded Warrior Project. And then there was Ivy from the VA offering updates on Sarah's care.

[Rosemarie]

So she would go on and talk about her medical situation, the cancer, what they were trying to do there. So I'd be there with Sarah and just. And then the other two were on conference call and so Sarah was in the room with you?

[Jake Halpern]

Yes.

[Rosemarie]

So she couldn't have been the one on the phone. Right? Right. And that was the case as well. Another time some other woman was speaking. And as Ivy.

[Jake Halpern]

The question that now comes up, the one that Rose Marie still thinks about and the one that we still think about a lot is this. Who is on the phone pretending to be Ivy, offering these made up details about how Sarah's treatment was going. It wasn't Sarah, because on that particular call, Sarah was sitting in the room with Rosemarie. So it had to be someone else, someone who was complicit in Sarah's lies.

[Rosemarie]

So there had to be other people involved. There absolutely had to be, because I clearly remember at least two times when Ivy was on the phone. But yeah, there had to be another person.

[Jake Halpern]

We talked to Tom Donnelly about this, if you recall. He's the in house investigator at the VA's Office of Inspector General. Donnelly's thought about this a lot.

[Tom Donnelly]

We could never prove that another person was involved, but it's evidence that leads me to believe that 100% somebody else was involved.

[Jake Halpern]

Donnelly told us there really is someone named Ivy who works for the Providence va. But investigators had interviewed her over the course of their investigation and they felt convinced that she was not in on this in any way. We actually got in touch with the real Ivy and she told us, I knew Sarah from the time she was a social work intern. We would eat lunch together and. And although she never pretended to be a veteran with me or other co workers, she would tell us story after story about her large military family. I was shocked to learn that they never existed and was appalled when I was questioned by federal agents investigating whether or not I was involved in her schemes. She went on to say, more appalling than her using my name was the grift that she had been running for years, duping many organizations and betraying the trust of so many veterans like the ones that she was receiving a salary to help. All of this has led investigators to believe there had to have been someone else, someone impersonating Ivy on a series of phone calls.

[Tom Donnelly]

Like we figured out who Ivy's phone number was. Ivy's phone number was Sarah's VA issued government cell phone. So I don't know where that phone was or who had it, but we do know that it was used.

[Jake Halpern]

In other words, Donnelly thinks someone was using Sarah's work phone to fake the whole thing. Calling people, pretending to be Ivy. But if it wasn't Sarah, well then who was it? That question has yet to be answered. Maybe one day we'll find out. Before Rosemarie learned about Sarah's lies, she says she was never really suspicious. She felt nothing but empathy for Sarah.

[Rosemarie]

You see, this person has been an imperfect, and her life has been so impaired, and she's so young. I mean, it really pulled on your heart. There's no question about it. Everybody who met her felt sorry for her every time. Everyone wanted to help her.

[Jake Halpern]

Rosemarie became so attached to Sarah that even after retiring in 2021, she continued to help her, volunteering her time for free.

[Rosemarie]

I just knew I had to be there for her. Like, I felt when she reacted that she wasn't going to have my contact. And she felt so lost, and there was just so much going on that I wanted to be there for her. I wanted to be able to say, you can call me anytime. I'm here for you. And she was like, great, okay. You know, never said, oh, you don't have to do that, or, you know, I don't want, you know, she definitely let me do it. It's really generous of you. I don't know. I mean, you can't work in this career, in this field and not care, you know what? You can't. That's just, you know, it doesn't make me any kind of a special person. It's just that's where I was at, you know, at the time.

[Jake Halpern]

The last time Rosemarie saw Sarah was on the day of the sentencing in March of 2023. Rosemarie was there in the courtroom surrounded by people who were angry and demanding justice.

[Rosemarie]

You know, by that time, you know, sympathy had worn off, and everybody just wanted to see her be held accountable, you know, so basically it was Sarah and her attorney and then a whole bunch of other people just, you know, rooting for her to go to jail.

[Jake Halpern]

At sentencing, Rosemarie connected with many other people in Sarah's orbit, like Michelle, the gym buddy, and Dave, the VFW commander. Rosemarie had felt hurt and embarrassed that she'd fallen for Sarah's schemes. But when she looked around, she started to see the bigger picture, and it put things into perspective.

[Rosemarie]

So many people got scammed. I mean, that's where I stopped beating myself up was people smarter than me got scammed, you know, in a lot larger ways. All the times all of us could have intersected somehow. We didn't, you know, and then. But it just didn't happen. God, I just wish I could have saved some grief for people.

[Jake Halpern]

I just wish I could have saved some grief for people. It felt like Rosemarie was basically saying, if only I had figured this out, maybe we could have avoided this whole mess. The fallout from Sarah's actions was far reaching. But one of the cruelest outcomes is that someone like Rose Marie would be left feeling even a little bit responsible, blaming herself for her own generosity, wondering if that very kindness did more harm than good. Of course she's not to blame, but sometimes it's not so easy for her to see it this way. At the very end of this interview, our producer Amy asked Rosemarie a final question about Sarah.

[Rosemarie]

Is there anything that you would want to ask her? Or, like, do you think that you'll connect with her after she's gone? No, I think everybody just probably wants to know why, but you'd never get an answer that you could trust. If I asked her why, I wouldn't get a real honest, you know, so what would I really ask, you know, just part of my past and time to move on.

[Jake Halpern]

So many people in this story were deceived. Rosemarie saw this for herself at the sentencing hearing. But the human mind, it's a curious thing. It's not always governed by rationality or self love. Our friends may tell us we did no wrong. We may yearn to believe them, and perhaps we should. But in quiet moments late at night, the mind often wrestles with guilt, regret and recriminations. Feelings that defy logic. But hard as we may try, prove impossible to quiet. And in this way, Sarah's story lives on.

[Rosemarie]

I don't think it ends. That's what I worry about. I guess the biggest thing I wonder is like, what she's going to do after, because how do you come out of jail and having done this and have some kind of a normal life? She's going to have to create another set of lies. She's not going to just come out and say, yeah, I just went to prison because I scammed all these people and I stole valor. And, you know, so I don't think it stops. That's what I'm afraid of.

[Jake Halpern]

These last words, they've stayed with me. I find them haunting. As storytellers, we're always chasing after the elusive perfect endings, looking for that final note of closure. But as long as people remember and as long as they're willing to ask that most human of questions, what if? Then there is no end. Not really. Only more questions that spin into the night. This episode was produced by Amy Gaines McQuaid, Jess McHugh, Tali Emlyn and Sonia Gerwitt. It was edited by Karen Shakurji. Our executive producer. Producer is Jacob Smith. Original music from Luis Guerra. Mastering by Sarah Bruger. Special thanks to Owen Miller, Lucy Sullivan, Jake Flanagan, Sarah Nix and Greta Cohn. I'm Jake Halpern.

[Rosemarie]

Foreign.

[Ryan Seacrest]

It is Ryan Seacrest here. There was a recent social media trend which consisted of flying on a plane with no music, no movies, no entertainment. But a better trend would be going to chumbacasino.com it's like having a mini social casino in your pocket. Chumba casino has over 100 online casino style games all absolutely free. It's the most fun you can have online and on a plane. So grab your free welcome bonus [e-mail] sponsored by Chumba Casino.

[Justin Richmond]

No purchase necessary.

[Jake Halpern]

VGW Group Void where prohibited by law 21 terms and conditions apply.

[Unknown]

Does friendly have a taste? If it does, it's probably like hello's Peppermint flavored anti plaque and Whitening toothpaste. Brush away plaque, show tartar who's boss and remove surface stains to naturally whiten. Hello's thoughtful and flavor forward products make brushing your teeth feel like a confetti filled bathroom dance party. So say hello to hello with the always cruelty free never tested on animals toothpaste that's made to spread smiles. Visit helloproducts.com and let hello add some everyday yay into your life.

[Justin Richmond]

Clorox Santiva Smells like grapefruit, cleans like Clorox.

[Jake Halpern]

It feels like yay.

[Rosemarie]

Okay, we could be here all day. Try Clorox Scentiva for a trusted clean with long lasting freshness. Also available in lavender and coconut. News as directed this is an I Heart podcast.