Amber Haack (3:40)

Molly, do you mind if I just bring you in here? Because Nick's just laid out some examples there. These accusations that Brooklyn has now put out publicly, they're so specific about the wedding dress being hijacked last minute, about his mother supposedly jumping in on his first dance and acting in a. Appropriately, the fact that it is so specific from a PR perspective, does that make it harder to defend against that? It isn't something vague and general.

Molly McPherson (4:12)

Well, it's certainly difficult when it is a family drama as opposed to two different parties. You know, it's certainly within the family. But proper damage control right now does not look like an Instagram statement. It's about containment. It is likely legal, it is NDAs, it's look looking at contracts line by line. It is not going to be about dismantling the narrative that Brooklyn is putting out there. Victoria and David Beckham right now need to contain the brand, keep their collaboration safe and let everybody know that everything is fine and be a little quiet at the moment. There should be a statement, but it shouldn't match their sons.

Amber Haack (4:56)

And of course there is background to this stuff, right, Nick? Because even though Brooklyn is saying that he has remained silent so far in this statement, there's been a few rumours that have come out over the past year or so that he wasn't happy, for example, about his mum Victoria liking some of his Instagram posts and then subsequently that he'd apparently asked his parents to only communicate with him via lawyers. There is some background to this moment right now, isn't there?

Nick Johnson (5:23)

Yeah, it felt like things were bubbling away to lead up to this very public moment, but I think as well, this sort of. This is all quite relatable, isn't it? It's a family drama and it's a family drama that's air social media. When we use social media with our family members, we're also perhaps one family member might nudge to another and say, well, did you see who liked so and so? Who unfollowed so and so? And this is happening in, in such a. On a much wider scale and perhaps, you know, we'd be forgiven for forgetting that just one click, one unfollow, one like is not seen by, by so many people. But then you look at the Beckhams and those, those brief clicks have such huge ramifications.

Amber Haack (6:03)

So this statement from Brooklyn Beckham on Instagram has got everyone talking, from my friends to my family, it feels like everybody has an opinion on things. But there has been a latest update, hasn't there, Nick from Davos today.

Nick Johnson (6:17)

Yeah, well, the World Economic Forum in Davos, that's a gathering of some of the most powerful people in the world. World leaders are there, world financiers are there. And David Beckham himself is there today at the moment at this resort in the Swiss Alps. And he's been talking to the American broadcaster cnbc. Uh, he's been talking to them about young people and their use of social media and how they can best use social media. And he, he's talked about how there are many dangers of social media, which are well reported, but also the positives of social media. He's talked about how he uses his platform and his following to what he says, try and make positive differences on social media. But this is the interesting thing, he says, I've tried to do the same with my children, to educate them. They make mistakes. Children are allowed to make mistakes. He. That's how they learn. That's what I try to teach my kids. But you have to sometimes let them make those mistakes. So it's important that we're not misleading people. And taking this out of context, he's not directly addressing Brooklyn's social media post here, but he's. It's interesting that only hours after, after his son posted this, he is addressing young people and their use of social media, acknowledging the fact that, that young people across the world make mistakes in their use of social media.

Amber Haack (7:33)

Yeah, it is an interesting response. And social media has played such a big part in this whole supposed feud, hasn't it? The fact that Brooke Lynn has spoken out about his mum liking his post. There's been a lot of public scrutiny, for example, of which family member has blocked who at a certain time and what that means. I mean, it's very indicative of the modern world that we live in, isn't it? Where this gets so scrutinized publicly. How does that play into something for a celebrity in this, Molly, when everyone is Talking about on TikTok, analyzing likes follows, blocks and the rest of it.

Molly McPherson (8:11)

Well, Nick brought up a very important part of it, that this is a family drama. But in my work as a crisis manager, the same family dramas bleed into corporate dramas and brand dramas just like this. This is no different than normal families. But how interesting that David Beckham is coming out with a statement. It is not official, it is not directly discussing his son, but indirectly. That is a PR move. That is a PR statement. The framing is not going to be about dismantling this idea that Victoria is the mother in law from hell. They are going to frame the son as young, making mistakes. And, you know, all kids make mistakes. All kids, you know, can veer off from their family values. They are certainly framing it that the son is the problem, perhaps influence and not David and Victoria. That is very much an indirect direct statement.

Amber Haack (9:09)

And so much of Brooklyn's statement and some of the things that he's accusing his family of is prioritizing public promotion and endorsements above all else. Nick, just paint a picture for us of how huge and global this brand Beckham actually is, because they are a commercial machine that are in so many different sectors.

Nick Johnson (9:32)

They are huge. And it's been argued by, by many in the media and beyond in this country that they are perhaps second only in terms of a family brand in the UK to the Royal Family. They are huge and they've been around for many years. And I think it's important to remember that even before Brooklyn, their eldest was born, obviously Victoria Beckham, she was a Spice Girl, David Beckham, a young footballer. When the two of them got together, they'd managed to forge this huge media personality as a couple very early on. And when Brooklyn was born, that sort of continued and their subsequent children continued even more. And I think in the age of social media now, the fact that we're able to see that family brand play out and in sort of volatile ways, it has done in recent months that that's sort of. We've got a front row seat to that now. And that's something that we wouldn't have done perhaps 30 years ago, 25, 30 years ago when, when David and Victoria got together, even though they were huge celebrities even back then. But I think what Molly said about their very polished brand, and she's right saying that I Think that even though David wasn't addressing the feud in that interview in CNBC, they've been around as a brand for 30 years. I'm sure he knew exactly what he was doing when he was talking about young people and their mistakes on social media.

Amber Haack (10:56)

I mean, it's brought up a lot of feelings for me because I was a young girl growing up in Manchester, huge Manchester United fan, would go all the time with my dad to Old Trafford. And of course, I grew up watching David Beckham. And I remember when he went over to Real Madrid with Victoria, and it was like his brand just took on this whole new weight and meaning around the world. This blonde hair, remember he had it in this ponytail and he became a Galactico. And that name, Beckham has just become a global brand. Talking about brand because it's so central and their name itself to everything that's going on in this story. Molly, David and Victoria Beckham trademarked their children's names back in 2016. Brook Lynn is now alleging that his parents tried to make sign away the rights to his name before the wedding happened. What does an accusation like that tell us?

Molly McPherson (11:49)

Well, the accusation tells us a lot. And really, you went through it yourself, Amber. I mean, you saw the rise of the Beckham name. And certainly what David Beckham and Victoria Beckham have done since the 90s beyond is they understood the power of branding, but they also grew at a time before we really had social media. So these two, they're a couple who understand what it's like to not just brand in the 90s, but certainly into digital and social media and rely on the public. Brooklyn learned from that. What he's doing right now is not leveraging the brand endorsement. He's leveraging the reputation endorsement. He knew when he put up stories on Instagram that those stories, that those statements would have a lot of power, not just in the uk, but in the US as well. The US Right now, people feel like everything is imploding. People are looking for another story to talk about. And this is the story. My messages, my DMs. Everybody wants to know, like, what my thoughts are on this. That doesn't tell me anything about me. It tells me that people are very curious about this. This is absolutely a brand collaboration, Instagram.

Amber Haack (13:06)

Viral story, which is quite incredible, really, because, of course, they are British celebrities. But the weight that they carry in America because of, for example, David Beckham's connection with Inter Miami, you know, it's huge. It so played such a big part in making you obviously call it soccer over there, but, you know, a huge global brand associated with the United States as well. And the language really jumps out to me in this, Molly, because Brooklyn has used some specific terms here. So we said, for example, that his mum chose to dance with him on the wedding, and it was. Was inappropriate. I mean, that word is quite open to interpretation. He's also used the term facade that his parents and their team, they leak and shape the narrative. And the Beckham brand is all a facade in PR terms. Why can language like that be so damaging sometimes?

Molly McPherson (14:02)

You know, let's go to the beginning when. When Nick mentioned, you know, this is a family. You know, family has drama, but they're not a very typical family. They're atypical, but they're acting like a lot of normal families out there. It's. It's somewhat reasonable. Kids grow up and parents disappoint them that they can weaponize or use social media against them. We see that happen all the time. When it comes to the Beckham brand, however, it's as if Brooklyn knew exactly where to pierce the arrow. He knew how to get at his parents and how to hurt them. But it is still heartbreaking that you still have a family that's fractured right now. But I do see a place out for Victoria and David as parents, because a lot of people out there can understand their point of view, how difficult it can be to raise kids in the spotlight. There is a path forward. But what's interesting is they're also doing something that a lot of people at the center of a crisis, or companies or corporations do when they're at the center of the crisis. They blame the Internet. They blame the Internet. And whenever I see someone blame the Internet or blame social media or cancel culture, it usually tells me they want to cover something or they know that there is some blame there, some truth to the matter.

Amber Haack (15:18)

Better all of this, you know, even looking at some of the comments underneath the Instagram post, of course, you get people, and both sides of the camp, so to speak, that some people are saying this is, you know, the eldest child who's grown up with all this trauma around him, finally feeling like he can speak out. But there is also, on the other side, people saying that the Beckhams are real. You know, they're going through something that all families can go through. And actually it sort of humanizes them. Molly's painted a picture there of how the story's being perceived in the States. But, Nick, how huge of a story actually is this?

Nick Johnson (15:52)

Well, it's certainly something that we like to say here that's of interest to the public, but perhaps maybe not entirely in the public interest. I'm just looking on the BBC news website at the moment and it is, yeah, it's up there among the most read stories. Yeah, it is the most read story at the moment and I expect that to remain. I mean, it is a huge deal. I've just spent the first half of the day in the newsroom downstairs and with everything else that's going on in the world at the moment, a bit like how Molly said in the US people feel things are just imploding similarly. So here I think a little bit the news agenda has been bleak perhaps in recent days and weeks. And I think this is really, it's something that a lot of people are talking about and I think one of the reasons that is, is we've talked about family dramas and what have you, but the way Molly said that Brooklyn has gone for this and the points that he's raised in that social media post, I mean, weddings, right? Weddings are high Dr. For everyone at the best of times. There's always an issue at a wedding, who's invited, who isn't invited. Someone wants some gossip coming out of the wedding, whether it's related to the bridegroom and family or not. And the fact that he's gone for those claims about the inappropriate dancing and the lack of a wedding dress, he's really hit the family and hit the gossip where he knows he's going to get it.

Amber Haack (17:09)

Yeah, I think as a story it ticks so many boxes of things that the public are intrigued by. It's things that can feel deeply relatable. We all have families, everybody has tensions, you know, of their own sort of kind. But people feel that it can burst that bubble of celebrity as well, that they are more accessible and real and fractured than we might like to think from a distance. What do we think could happen next then, Molly?

Molly McPherson (17:33)

Well, I'll say the brand Beckham doesn't die here, but it certainly changes. They're a family who've weathered a lot of stories and rumors and they're, they're still intact. So now the brand can be a very relatable, flawed family. You know, the claims of her being this vitriolic mother in law, she's not going to respond to it line by line. You know, we're not going to see it in Instagram, but I, I see something more dignified out of Victoria. I see them doing more indirect type of messaging a la David Beckham. And they'll just get through it like they always do.

Nick Johnson (18:13)

Yeah. Similarly, I think this is not going to harm the brand in the long term. But I think from a news perspective, all of us are waiting for who says what next. Is Brooklyn gonna say something else? Are we gonna get something on camera? Are we gonna get something on social media from David of Victoria or indeed one of the other Beckham children? So I think we're all waiting for who says what and who's going to come next. This is of course just one side of the story. The Beckhams have yet to respond and as ever, with such affairs recollections.

Amber Haack (18:45)

Thank you both so much for unpacking that with me. Definitely on both sides of the Atlantic, people just cannot get enough of this story and it seems everyone has an opinion. So thank you for spending some time getting into it with us.

Nick Johnson (18:57)

Thank you.

Molly McPherson (18:57)

Thanks, Amber.

Amber Haack (19:00)

As always. If you've got any questions, send them to us on social media or you can WhatsApp us on 03306-78111. That's 03306-78114. Don't forget to subscribe. Turn your push notifications on so you make sure you never miss an episode.

Dr. Chris Van Tulleken (19:26)

I'm Dr. Chris Van Tulleken. And I'm Dr. Zand Van Tulleken. Chris, it's that time of year when we set resolutions. It certainly is, Xand. And that is why in January, our four episodes of what's up docs are going to be on on the key themes that feature in resolutions. Alcohol, food, exercise and the whole notion of resolutions themselves. Can we change? Should we change? Well, a lot of us think we should. That's what we're doing the whole month, paying attention or thinking we should pay attention to our health and wellbeing. In addition, we will be dropping a daily dose of expert wisdom from previous episodes because Xand and I have fed and found that we need, we need a reminder, reminding about all the things that we've learned from difficult conversations to how to look after our knees. Protein, the power of nature. Snackable sized episodes every day we've got you covered. And these daily doses are gonna be dropping into the medicine cabinet. That is the WhatsApp docs feed on BBC Sounds.

Grainger Advertisement Voice (20:29)

If you're an H Vac technician and a call comes in, Grainger knows that you need a partner that helps you find the right product fast and hassle free. And you know that when the first problem of the day is a clanking blower motor, there's no need to break a sweat. With Grainger's easy to use website and product details, you're confident you'll soon have everything humming right along. Call 1-800-GRAINGER click granger.com or just stop by Grainger for the ones who get it done.