Disgraceland: The Who Pt 2 - A Crowd Crush, a Death Trap, and a Tragedy in Cincinnati

Episode Release Date: June 17, 2025

Introduction

In this gripping episode of Disgraceland, hosted by Jake Brennan and produced by Double Elvis Productions, the focus shifts to one of rock and roll's most harrowing tragedies—the 1979 concert disaster involving The Who in Cincinnati. This episode delves deep into the events leading up to the tragedy, the immediate aftermath, and the long-term repercussions for the band and the community.

Event Overview

The narrative centers around a sold-out Who concert at the Riverfront Coliseum in Cincinnati on December 3, 1979. Despite the venue's previous experience with a near-riot during a Led Zeppelin concert, the organizers implemented strict entry protocols to prevent a repeat of past chaos. However, unforeseen circumstances led to a catastrophic crowd crush.

Joanie, a 17-year-old first-time concert-goer, and her friend Gene epitomize the typical young fans eager to experience the raw energy of a Who performance. Despite the frigid temperatures and the massive influx of 18,000 attendees, excitement quickly turns to panic as overcrowding ensues.

At [12:51], Jake Brennan introduces the scene:

"Joanie was stoked. This is her first show ever and it was about time. She was 17, for Christ's sakes."

As the concert begins, a premature sound check—or possibly a test screening of the Quadrophenia movie—triggers the crowd's imagination that the show has officially started, leading to a frenzied surge toward the entrance. This misunderstanding becomes the catalyst for tragedy.

Impact on The Who

The episode intricately explores the profound impact of the tragedy on The Who, particularly focusing on guitarist and lead songwriter Pete Townshend. The loss of drummer Keith Moon in 1978 had already left a void within the band, and the Cincinnati incident further strained their dynamic.

Pete Townsend's internal struggle is poignantly depicted:

"Pete was on a self-imposed break from The Who... Pete was on a self imposed break from the who. One during which the band's manager, Bill, curbishly strongly advised Pete against drinking and drugging."

The tragedy not only affected the band's morale but also ignited legal battles and public scrutiny, forcing them to confront the darker side of their rock and roll lifestyle.

Aftermath and Legal Consequences

In the wake of the crowd crush, legal actions ensued against multiple parties, including the venue, promoters, and the band itself. The episode highlights the complexities of assigning blame and the financial ramifications that followed.

At [22:35], Jake Brennan summarizes the legal fallout:

"The families of the victims received about $150,000 each, which left $750,000 to be split between 23 others who had been badly injured."

The settlement process was fraught with tension, especially as some victims' families sought trials, leading to prolonged legal battles that echoed the initial chaos of the concert.

Personal Struggles and Redemption

Pete Townshend's personal journey is a central theme of this episode. Grappling with guilt, substance abuse, and the pressures of fame, Pete's story serves as a cautionary tale of the destructive nature of rock and roll excesses.

A notable quote at [22:37] captures Pete's turmoil:

"Pete Townshend was transported freebasing. Cocaine was Pete Townshend's ticket to a fantasyland."

However, the episode also sheds light on his path to redemption. By 1982, Pete sought help and began the arduous process of overcoming his addictions, culminating in a successful stint at an electroacupuncture clinic in San Diego. This period of healing coincided with the release of The Who's 10th studio album, "It's Hard," which featured the introspective single "Eminence Front."

Conclusion

The Cincinnati tragedy remains a pivotal moment in rock history, illustrating the fine line between exhilarating performance and uncontrollable chaos. Disgraceland masterfully narrates this event, weaving together personal stories, band dynamics, and the broader implications for the music industry.

As the episode concludes, it reflects on the enduring legacy of The Who and the lessons learned from a night that forever changed the lives of thousands.

Jake Brennan wraps up the episode with a thought-provoking question:

"Was the Riverfront Coliseum tragedy the worst tragedy in rock and roll history?"

Listeners are encouraged to engage and share their thoughts, fostering a community dialogue around the event's significance.

Notable Quotes:

• Jake Brennan at [12:51]: "Joanie was stoked. This is her first show ever and it was about time. She was 17, for Christ's sakes."

• Jake Brennan at [22:35]: "The families of the victims received about $150,000 each, which left $750,000 to be split between 23 others who had been badly injured."

• Co-host at [22:37]: "Pete Townshend was transported freebasing. Cocaine was Pete Townshend's ticket to a fantasyland."

• Jake Brennan in Conclusion: "Was the Riverfront Coliseum tragedy the worst tragedy in rock and roll history?"

Final Thoughts

This episode of Disgraceland serves as a poignant reminder of the volatile nature of live performances and the profound impact they can have on both performers and fans. By intertwining factual events with dramatic storytelling, the podcast offers a comprehensive exploration of one of rock's most tragic nights, inviting listeners to reflect on the cost of entertainment and the humanity behind the legends.