Jake Brennan (28:36)
Safely ensconced in his new digs, Rick busied himself with his music. He was always writing, sending demos out to Carole King in la, recording with a new band he was pulling together, picking up side gigs with Tony Conigliero's band, outfielder for the Boston Red Sox and legendary nightclub prowler, and of course, still lending his considerable talent to whatever it was that Van Morrison was cooking up in his head. Their new combo had a name, the Van Morrison Controversy. Rehearsals at the National Express recording studio at 304 Columbus Avenue in Boston's South End were where the band would begin to hone the musical identity for Astral Weeks. The neighborhood at the time was a mix of beauty and grit. Expansive brownstones and back alley cobblestones rubbed up against trash strewn, crime ridden streets that in the daytime bustled with working class Bostonians moving through their daily routines. Beauty, grit, movement. Sentiments that would come to dominate the sound of Astral Weeks. The Van Morrison Controversy brought that sound to the stage on April 20, 1968. The show was held on Boston Common, just across from the apartment Rick Philp had shared with Harvey Alter as part of a festival called Spring Sing with a bunch of other bands whose names sounded like they were invented inside a Hippie Dippy, Mad Libs, Cliche Machine, Third World Raspberry, the Tangerine Zoo. You get the picture. There's a photo from that day of Rick on stage with Van looking at it. You get the vibe of the two men who are standing exactly where they're supposed to be. For a moment anyway, Van would keep searching for that sound and Rick would keep searching for those lost guitars. He'd all but given up until one day he got a call from Harvey. Harvey had told him that he had, quote, unquote, found Rick's guitars. Rick just needed to come by Harvey's apartment to get them. So on May 19, 1969, Rick Philp descended the stairs to Harvey Alter's basement apartment at 233 Beacon street and knocked on the door. Harvey answered excitedly, happy to see his old friend. Rick was in no mood. He was polite but blunt. He wanted his guitars. He didn't even care how Harvey had come upon them. He just wanted them back. Harvey dodged. He was making small talk, acting as if nothing had changed between them since Rick moved out. How are Things going? What's new with your music, how's school, that sort of thing. Rick kept to the point, where are my guitars, Harvey? Harvey lit a joint, clearly stalling. Fine, Rick thought, I'll humor him. Things are good. Harvey. I'm thinking of leaving Boston over break. Kathy is gonna be home from school and it'd be good to be with her for a while. Then after that, who knows, Louisiana maybe. Probably. Maybe New York. All Harvey heard was, I'm leaving Boston. Harvey started whining to Rick. He couldn't leave, he just had to stay in Boston. They had so much to do together. They were just getting started. Rick, I'm in love with you, you know. Rick, of course, knew that the despite the girlfriends, Harvey was gay. But Rick didn't care so long as he didn't come on to him. He politely let Harvey down gently. But all Harvey heard was, I'm leaving Boston. I don't love you, I never loved you. Harvey moved closer to Rick and tried to pull him in. Forget the proclamations. Show him how much you love him. Rick pulled away. This just wasn't his thing, he protested. All Harvey heard was, I'm leaving Boston. I don't love you, I never loved you, you're gay. I'm not. Harvey wasn't taking no for an answer. Rick just needed to be shown how good it could be between them. Now Rick got pissed and angrily pushed Harvey away. Told him to leave him the hell alone and give him his guitars and he'd be out of there. But all Harvey heard was, I'm leaving Boston. I don't love you, I never loved you, you're gay. I'm not. Fuck off. Harvey snapped. Fucking Rick. Who did he think he was? Did he think he could just leave? Just go and be with someone else? Move away? No. If Harvey couldn't have Rick, then nobody could have Rick. Harvey grabbed him. A struggle ensued. Harvey threw Rick back into the short staircase leading out of the apartment. His fall broke the banister. On his way down, Rick clumsily tried getting to his feet. Harvey Grant grabbed one of the banister spindles that had broken off. It was perfect fit perfectly into his hand. Rick was moving for the door. Harvey was blind with rage outside of himself, off on some other trip entirely. Fear, shame, loneliness and sexual excitement all banged violently together inside Harvey's head while Harvey violently brought the banister, spindle banging down under Rick's face head with brute force. When it was over, Harvey came to. What had he done? Rick was hurt badly. Harvey had it together enough to pull Rick into his bed and put him under the covers. But that was about it for three and a half days. While Rick lay mortally wounded in his bed, Harvey slowly lost his mind, pacing the apartment, taking turns mumbling to himself and screaming in horror. Finally, Rick's head wounds, left untreated, proved to be too much, and the young musician with the bright future died. Dead or not, Harvey finally had his man. He'd stopped the young musician Rick Philp, the object of his obsession, from moving. No small feat given that musicians are like sharks. They stop moving and they die. Van Morrison knew this. You can hear it in every note of Astroweeks. Van was searching on a quest, figuratively and literally, moving on from the first phase of his career, moving on from one sound to the next, moving on from the musician he was to the musician he was to become, from the man he was to the man he was to become. Movement equals life, which is why Astral Week sounds so vibrant. There's transience and grace in every note. The album is alive. Rick Philp is dead. When police finally showed up at Harvey Alter's apartment, responding to a neighbor calling in what was described as disturbing sounds coming from the basement, Harvey answered the door and immediately told the police, he's dead. I killed him. I killed Rick. Rick Philp moved in and then out of Van Morrison's life with the quickness, just as many people before and since have done. And Van Morrison keeps moving just as musicians do, making more records, playing more shows, doing what a musician does. Astral Weeks would become Van Morrison's landmark creative statement. It is a masterpiece. Sure, it doesn't have the hits of some of Van's other works, but ask any musician about it and they'll like you, tell you that it's his best album. That is, if you can get one of them to stop moving long enough to talk to you. I'm Jake Brennan and this is Disgrace. Disgraceland was created by yours truly and is produced in partnership with Double Elvis. Credits for this episode can be found on the show notes page@gracelandpod.com if you're listening as a Disgraceland All Access member, thank you for supporting the show. We really appreciate it. And if not, you can become a member right now by going to Disgracelandpod.com Membership members can listen to every episode of Disgraceland ad free. Plus you'll get one brand new exclusive episode every month, Weekly unscripted bonus episodes, special audio collections, and early access to merchandise and events. Visit disgracelandpod.com membership for details, rate and review the show and follow us on Instagram, TikTok, Twitter and Facebook Disgracelandpod and on YouTube@YouTube.com Disgracelandpod Rocka Rolla