Don, Hahn & Rosenberg – Hour 1: Bats & Batman

Release Date: April 1, 2025

In the premiere episode of "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg," hosts Don LaGreca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve into the hotly debated topic of Major League Baseball's (MLB) recent introduction of the torpedo bat, juxtaposed against rule changes in the National Football League (NFL). The episode seamlessly blends sports analysis with pop culture discussions, particularly focusing on the evolution of Batman across various media.

1. The Torpedo Bat Controversy in MLB

Overview of the Torpedo Bat: The conversation kicks off with Alan Hahn posing a critical question: "Which rule or which situation do we think their particular league will get rid of first, the tush push or the torpedo bat?" [00:34]. This sets the stage for an in-depth exploration of MLB's adoption of the torpedo bat and its implications.

Don LaGreca’s Critical Analysis: Don LaGreca provides a scathing critique of MLB's decision, questioning the league's motives and execution. He argues that "Major League Baseball has been handed a gift... They found a legal form to increase the offense" [02:29]. Don further laments the lack of transparency, stating, "Major League Baseball should have got way out in front of this maybe though" [06:47], emphasizing that proper communication could have mitigated the ensuing controversy.

Impact on the Game: The hosts discuss how the torpedo bat has led to a surge in home runs, especially spotlighting players like Anthony De La Cruz. Don contends, "he had a big night because he was using that bat," highlighting how the bat's design provides an unfair advantage that disrupts the game's integrity [04:33].

2. Comparisons with NFL and NHL Rule Changes

NFL's Approach to Rule Changes: Alan Hahn draws parallels with the NFL's handling of rule changes, particularly the "tush push," noting MLB's hesitation to address similar situations promptly. He observes, "baseball did approve its use... that's why this is a controversy," pointing out the inconsistency in MLB's regulatory approach [02:29].

NHL's Proactive Communication: Don contrasts MLB's secrecy with the NHL's transparency post-lockout, where changes like the trapezoid and alterations to rink dimensions were openly communicated to enhance offense [02:29]. This comparison underscores MLB's failure to inform stakeholders, leading to widespread misinformation and backlash.

3. Insights from Aaron Leonard, the Torpedo Bat Inventor

Aaron Leonard’s Explanation: The episode features insights from Aaron Leonard, purportedly the inventor of the torpedo bat. He explains the genesis of the bat: "the eureka moment really was when players pointed to where they were trying to hit the ball and they noticed themselves that that was not the fattest part of the bat" [16:43]. Leonard discusses how the bat's unconventional design was a response to players seeking better performance, leading to its adoption across MLB and minor leagues.

Future Implications: Alan Hahn speculates on the bat's future, suggesting it could become a multimillion-dollar business as its popularity spreads beyond the majors [17:33]. Don warns of potential overuse and the subsequent need for regulatory intervention, saying, "if it does become obnoxious, will there have to be something that will be done about it?" [18:19].

4. Listener Calls and Community Opinions

David and Elizabeth's Perspective: A listener named David applauds the discussion, stating, "this is exactly what baseball wants," highlighting how the controversy has reignited interest in the sport [20:58]. However, Don counters by emphasizing the negative light MLB is in due to perceived impropriety [28:54].

Andre from the Bronx: Andre offers a strategic viewpoint, suggesting that the torpedo bat benefits pitchers by reducing the need for excessive velocity, thereby lessening arm injuries. He posits, "tasking pitchers to just miss the bat", which could restore pitching artistry [31:24].

Javier's Input from Queens: Javier from Queens echoes similar sentiments, appreciating the renewed conversation around baseball and its potential positive impact on the sport's popularity [46:17]. He stresses the unfair focus solely on Yankees players like De La Cruz, arguing that broader recognition of players using the bat would normalize its use without blame [48:30].

5. Pop Culture Interlude: Batman Through the Ages

Evolution of Batman: Shifting gears, the hosts engage in a nostalgic discussion about Batman's various incarnations. Alan Hahn reminisces about watching both Adam West and Michael Keaton's portrayals, highlighting the cultural shift post-Keaton’s performance: "it became what Marvel and everybody else have turned into something different" [14:10].

Preferred Iterations: Don LaGreca expresses a preference for the Adam West version, arguing that his portrayal embodied the essence of Batman without superpowers, much like the traditional roles in sports [15:07]. Peter Rosenberg discusses the animated series of the 90s as his favorite iteration, citing its depth and impact on true fans [46:25].

6. Concluding Thoughts and Future Topics

The episode concludes with the hosts reiterating the significance of transparency in sports regulations and the potential for innovation when leagues communicate effectively with their audience. They also tease upcoming discussions on NFL rule changes, particularly the "tush push," and continue to tease topics in future episodes.

Notable Quotes

• Alan Hahn [01:29]: "We've got rules changes and we've also got one rule in football that everybody wants to stop."

• Don LaGreca [02:29]: "Major League Baseball has been handed a gift... They found a legal form to increase the offense."

• Peter Rosenberg [04:44]: "Now hear me out for a second... Is there a line for that?"

• Aaron Leonard [16:43]: "The eureka moment really was when players pointed to where they were trying to hit the ball and they noticed themselves that that was not the fattest part of the bat."

• Don LaGreca [28:54]: "Major League Baseball should have got way out in front of this maybe though."

• Alan Hahn [31:24]: "So what Andre's trying to suggest is we go beyond power pitching and spin rate and everything else and get back to trying to just miss bats."

Final Thoughts: "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg" successfully navigates the complex interplay between sports innovation and regulatory transparency, enriched by lively banter and diverse perspectives. Whether you're a die-hard baseball fan intrigued by the torpedo bat saga or a pop culture enthusiast reminiscing about Batman's legacy, this episode offers a comprehensive and engaging discourse that sets the tone for the series.