Podcast Summary: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg – Hour 1: LIVE from Colonial Springs Golf Club
Release Date: July 21, 2025
Location and Setting
In the inaugural hour of the "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg" podcast, hosts Don La Greca, Dave Rothenberg, and Bart Scott broadcast live from the picturesque Colonial Springs Golf Club in Farmingdale, Long Island. The setting provides a relaxed atmosphere as the trio engages in lively discussions about current sports events, primarily focusing on Major League Baseball (MLB) and the National Football League (NFL).
Introductions and Live Event Coverage
Don La Greca kicks off the episode by describing the live environment:
"Now we're live from our Tee It Up Golf Challenge here at Farmingdale, Long Island, Colonial Springs. Just a gorgeous golf course... Got to see Greg Buttle, got to see Justin Tuck. Rick DiPietro's here."
[00:54]
The hosts mention the presence of various celebrities and sports personalities, setting the stage for candid conversations and insider insights.
Major League Baseball: Mets and Yankees Analysis
A significant portion of the discussion centers around the current state of MLB teams, with particular emphasis on the New York Mets and New York Yankees.
Don La Greca provides a critical analysis of the Mets:
"I'm a Met fan, but I'm also no apologist for my team watching... Over the last 61 games... they're a team that got up to a hot start... but now it's kind of petered out."
[04:20]
Dave Rothenberg echoes similar sentiments, highlighting the Mets' struggles:
"They don't hit with runners in scoring position at all. Their bullpen... is probably subpar."
[04:45]
The hosts discuss the imminent trade deadline, debating the necessity for both teams to make strategic moves to contend for the championship. La Greca emphasizes the importance of adequate bullpen depth:
"They're going to have to need a couple because I don't trust Stanic... at least two arms in the bullpen to make this thing salvageable."
[07:54]
Rothenberg focuses on specific player performances, criticizing the team's pitching inconsistencies and the inability to capitalize on scoring opportunities.
"And you also don't want... to make any kind of assumption on the base path... And it was a lazy play."
[16:19]
National Football League: Season Expansion and Salary Caps
Transitioning to the NFL, the hosts delve into the controversial topic of expanding the regular season from 16 to 18 games. Bart Scott and Don La Greca present opposing viewpoints:
Scott argues from a player’s perspective:
"Expanding the rosters... will make the product even worse because a lot of these guys are playing on Sundays in March, April... it's impossible to carry more players."
[22:19]
La Greca counters with concerns about game meaningfulness and player health:
"I don't want the NBA-ization of the NFL where you're throwing weeks away... you want all the games to be meaningful."
[22:18]
The discussion highlights potential negative impacts on player performance, increased injury risks, and the dilution of game significance.
Listener Engagement: Phone Calls and Interactive Discussions
The podcast features interactive segments with listeners calling in to share their thoughts.
Caller Bennett raises questions about MLB salary structures compared to other major sports:
"Do you guys think that a Salary cap is necessary for the player question?"
[37:26]
La Greca and Rothenberg engage in a debate about the fairness and feasibility of implementing a salary cap in baseball, drawing comparisons to the NBA and NFL.
Another caller, Tony, discusses a recent play in a baseball game, prompting La Greca and Rothenberg to critique the players' decisions and coaching strategies.
"But that play's in the corner, right? And it was an unbelievable throw... But at the same time, it was a lazy play."
[44:36]
Celebrity Guests and On-the-Go Commentary
Throughout the episode, the hosts interact with various celebrities present at the golf club, including former athletes like Justin Tuck and Greg Buttle. These interactions provide unique perspectives and add a dynamic element to the conversation.
Bart Scott shares anecdotes about meeting fellow guests and discusses the blend of sports and entertainment within the live event setting.
"I was like, this is really cool. I got to tell you, when you meet one of these people that you're a huge fan of and they're really cool..."
[02:40]
Sports Team Performances and Future Predictions
The trio evaluates the performances of various MLB teams, assessing their chances for the remainder of the season and the playoffs. Discussions include:
- Yankees vs. Blue Jays: The strengths and weaknesses of both teams, with Rothenberg expressing confidence in the Yankees' chances despite recent performance dips.
"The Yankees strike out a lot... it's a bad matchup against the Yankees right now."
[33:05]
- Dodgers and Padres: Analyzing the Dodgers' consistency and the Padres' potential if they maintain their pitching strength.
"The Padres could make a run. When you look at the starting pitching the Giants have..."
[16:19]
- Other Teams: Brief mentions of teams like the Detroit Tigers, Chicago White Sox, and Pittsburgh Pirates, discussing their current standings and prospects.
Debate on Competitive Balance in MLB
A heated debate unfolds regarding the competitive balance within MLB, specifically addressing the disparity caused by teams with higher payrolls like the Yankees, Mets, and Dodgers having an "unfair advantage."
La Greca critiques the lack of parity and the challenges faced by smaller market teams:
"But it's still unfair that he actually... Does that seem fair that the Padres, a small market team, has a dying owner who's a billionaire..."
[39:48]
Rothenberg concurs, labeling baseball as "broken" due to these systemic issues.
"No, baseball is broken."
[40:23]
Closing Remarks and Upcoming Content
As the episode winds down, the hosts hint at upcoming segments and invite listeners to engage further.
Don La Greca encourages listeners to call in with their thoughts:
"1-800-919-3776. Your thoughts?"
[26:52]
Alan Hahn, another host, reminds listeners to subscribe and catch future episodes on-demand.
"Catch the show on demand whenever you want. Just subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts."
[29:08]
The episode concludes with a teaser for a "30 for 30" podcast series on basketball, hinting at upcoming in-depth discussions on the evolution of the game.
"30 for 30 podcast presents a brand new original series, Chasing basketball heaven, available July 22."
[50:20]
Key Takeaways
-
MLB Team Dynamics: The Mets and Yankees are under scrutiny for their current performance and payroll advantages, with calls for strategic trades to bolster competitiveness.
-
NFL Season Expansion: There's a divided opinion on expanding the NFL season to 18 games, weighing player well-being against increased revenue and game frequency.
-
Salary Cap Debate: The absence of a salary cap in baseball is deemed unfair by hosts, highlighting disparities between high-spending teams and smaller market franchises.
-
Interactive Engagement: Listener calls add depth to the discussions, bringing in diverse viewpoints and real-time sports analysis.
-
Celebrity Insights: Presence of sports celebrities enriches the podcast, offering unique behind-the-scenes perspectives.
-
Future Content: The podcast promises more engaging sports discussions and deep dives into sports history and evolution.
Notable Quotes:
-
Don La Greca:
"We're doing well. We're living the life... it's a really nice place."
[02:15] -
Dave Rothenberg:
"I don't think it's gonna happen. But you know, get swept, you can't get swept."
[11:59] -
Bart Scott:
"The expansion of the rosters... is going to make the product even worse."
[22:19] -
Caller Bennett:
"Do you guys think that a Salary cap is necessary for the player question?"
[37:26]
This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the first hour of "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg," highlighting the hosts' insightful analysis, engaging debates, and interactive segments that make the podcast a must-listen for sports enthusiasts.