Don, Hahn & Rosenberg Podcast Summary
Episode: Hour 1: Thibs Haters
Release Date: March 13, 2025
1. Knicks' Thrilling Victory and Mikhail Bridges' Buzzer-Beater
The episode kicks off with a detailed analysis of the New York Knicks' recent game against Portland, highlighting Mikhail Bridges' clutch performance. Bridges secured a season-best buzzer-beater, marking the first Knicks buzzer-beater in over three years.
Peter Rosenberg reflects on the game's intensity:
“A win is a win is a win... It really was the game itself. Portland played hard...” [01:07]
The discussion underscores the significance of Bridges' shot, not only for the win but also for his personal performance amidst previous controversies.
2. Controversy Over Minutes Allocation: Bridges vs. Thibodeau
A major portion of the conversation delves into the controversy surrounding Mikhail Bridges and head coach Tom Thibodeau (Tibbs). The crux of the issue revolves around Bridges' comments on his playing minutes and Tibbs' public denial of any prior conversation.
Caller:
“Did you hear what Tibbs said before the game about when Bridges said that we had this meeting?” [02:00]
Peter Rosenberg elaborates:
“Thibbs was prepared pregame, chapter and verse about minutes... I almost feel like Tibbs needs to do more of this because fans never understand his decision making...” [02:18]
The trio discusses whether there was a miscommunication or misunderstanding between Bridges and Tibbs, questioning the transparency and honesty of the coaching staff.
Alan Rosenberg critiques Tibbs' handling of the situation:
“He can complain all he wants. I do what I want to do. There was no conversation...” [04:19]
3. Analyzing Thibodeau's Coaching Strategy
The hosts examine Thibodeau's approach to player minutes, comparing it to league averages and other coaches' methodologies. They highlight how Thibbs manages player fatigue and matchup strategies, particularly emphasizing star players' consistent playtime.
Peter Rosenberg:
“He explained the matchup thing. And I almost feel like Tibbs needs to do more of this because fans never understand his decision making in rotations...” [02:18]
Alan Rosenberg adds:
“If they don't win, it's not going to be because of this... It's something that's going to be monitored...” [12:11]
The conversation acknowledges the delicate balance coaches must maintain between player health and competitive performance, debating whether the current strategy benefits the team in the long run.
4. Impact of John Feinstein's Passing
The podcast takes a brief but poignant turn to honor the late John Feinstein, a renowned sportswriter known for his extensive coverage of college basketball.
Caller:
“John Feinstein passed away at 69... He had his regular Washington Post column that came out today...” [20:06]
Peter Rosenberg shares personal reflections:
“One of the first books I really dove into as a kid was 'A Season on the Brink'...” [21:06]
The hosts commemorate Feinstein's legacy, recognizing his significant contributions to sports journalism and his influence on fans and aspiring writers alike.
5. Knicks' Road Trip and Upcoming Games
Shifting back to basketball, the discussion covers the Knicks' ongoing road trip, including their strategies and upcoming matchups, notably against the Warriors.
Peter Rosenberg:
“The Knicks get a win last night. They're two and two on this trip...” [27:03]
They analyze the team's resilience and potential performance in future games, considering player injuries and roster changes.
6. Fan Criticism of Coach Thibodeau
A substantial segment of the episode focuses on fan backlash against Coach Thibodeau. The hosts explore various perspectives, including callers expressing dissatisfaction with his coaching decisions and minutes management.
Caller John:
“I'm not having fun. I want to win games. I want to win a championship...” [37:26]
Peter Rosenberg defends Thibbs by highlighting past coaching successes and the players' respect for him:
“He developed bench players like Manuel Quickley and OG Anunoby... What they've turned him into...” [33:17]
Alan Rosenberg draws parallels with other sports teams:
“I understand why Ranger fans lose patience with La Violette... What is the issue?” [34:33]
The dialogue underscores the tension between fan expectations and coaching strategies, debating whether Thibbs is the right fit for leading the team to championship glory.
7. Comparing Thibodeau to Other Coaches
The hosts compare Thibodeau to other notable coaches, particularly Buck Showalter, to contextualize the criticisms and expectations surrounding his tenure.
Peter Rosenberg:
“It's what's so dangerous because they're going back to his time in Chicago and Minnesota...” [35:28]
Alan Rosenberg:
“He'll get you close. He'll get you to the doorstep...” [35:42]
This comparison highlights the skepticism regarding Thibbs' ability to lead the Knicks beyond a certain threshold, emphasizing the pressure to deliver tangible championship results.
8. Light-Hearted Banter: Music Taste Debate
In a humorous detour, the podcast features a playful exchange about music preferences, showcasing the show's camaraderie and willingness to tackle offbeat topics.
Peter Rosenberg and a caller engage in a spirited debate about Counting Crows, culminating in playful jabs about each other's musical tastes.
Peter Rosenberg:
“I love it because it's so good and terrible...” [46:43]
Caller:
“Counting Crows being for white guys who can't get laid is a truly terrible band...” [49:23]
The segment serves as comic relief, demonstrating the hosts' chemistry and ability to engage with listeners on a variety of subjects.
9. Closing Thoughts: Team Resilience and Future Prospects
As the episode nears its end, the hosts reflect on the Knicks' resilience and the potential trajectory of the team under Thibodeau's leadership. They express cautious optimism, recognizing past successes while acknowledging ongoing challenges.
Peter Rosenberg:
“There's something in the core of this team and this coach... He's part of this resiliency...” [29:43]
Alan Rosenberg:
“It's something that's going to fan the fuel of the fans who think that Tibbs plays these guys too much...” [12:11]
The conversation concludes with a reaffirmation of the team's strengths and a look ahead to upcoming games, balancing critique with support for the Knicks' pursuit of success.
Key Takeaways
- Mikhail Bridges' Impact: Bridges' buzzer-beater was pivotal for the Knicks' win, reigniting excitement among fans.
- Coaching Controversy: Ongoing debate about Coach Thibodeau's minutes management and communication with players, particularly Bridges.
- Team Resilience: Despite challenges, the Knicks demonstrate strong team spirit and adaptability.
- Legacy Consideration: Tribute to John Feinstein underscores the importance of sports journalism and its influence.
- Fan Sentiment: Mixed reactions from fans regarding Thibodeau's coaching, highlighting the complex relationship between coaching strategies and fan expectations.
- Humorous Interlude: Light-hearted discussion on music tastes illustrates the hosts' dynamic and engaging style.
Notable Quotes with Timestamps
-
Peter Rosenberg on Bridges' Game-Winner:
“...over three years. So that's a, that's a big one.” [01:59] -
Alan Rosenberg Critiquing Tibbs:
“There was no conversation. Because if there were a conversation, he'd be straightened out.” [04:43] -
Peter Rosenberg on Thibbs' Strategy:
“He explained the matchup thing... pulling out the chalkboard...” [02:18] -
Peter Rosenberg on Team Resilience:
“He developed bench players like Manuel Quickley and OG Anunoby...” [33:17] -
Alan Rosenberg Comparing to Buck Showalter:
“He can set you up, but he can't knock it down.” [35:28]
This comprehensive summary captures the essence of the "Thibs Haters" episode, providing insights into the Knicks' recent performances, coaching controversies, fan perspectives, and lighter moments, making it accessible and informative for both regular listeners and newcomers.