Hour 1: Yankees Frustration

Summary

Podcast Title: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg
Episode: Hour 1: Yankees Frustration
Release Date: August 5, 2025

---

Overview

In this episode of Don, Hahn & Rosenberg, hosts Don La Greca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the mounting frustrations surrounding the New York Yankees. Released on a balmy Tuesday afternoon, the conversation primarily centers on the Yankees' recent performances, managerial decisions, and the broader implications for the team's future. Alongside expert analysis, the trio engages with listener calls, offering diverse perspectives on the team's challenges.

---

1. Setting the Stage: Yankees' Recent Struggles

The episode kicks off with Ty Butler expressing excitement about a second chance, setting a hopeful tone despite the team's ongoing issues.

Key Discussion Points:

• Emotional Toll of Recent Losses: Ty shares his disappointment over a heartbreaking walk-off loss, emphasizing the rarity of such moments where he and Peter collaborate on-air.

  Ty Butler [02:06]: "You're forcing me to stay up an hour later just to lose in heartbreak fashion on a walk-off three, one shot."

• Manager Aaron Boone's Decisions: The conversation shifts to Boone's managerial choices, particularly his handling of the pitching staff during critical moments.

  Ty Butler [03:11]: "Aaron Boone is part of the problem... when you hand over a three nothing lead to your ace... it's hard to put that on the manager."

---

2. Analyzing Managerial Accountability

The hosts debate the extent to which Aaron Boone should be held accountable for the Yankees' underperformance.

Notable Quotes:

• Peter Rosenberg [04:07]: "He's part of the fabric of what's been the issue with the Yankees."

• Ty Butler [05:24]: "We watch the games. We don't have to be baseball savants to figure out what's going on. Devin Williams stinks."

Discussion Highlights:

• Devin Williams' Performance: Ty criticizes Williams, the Yankees' ace, for failing to close games despite large leads, arguing that Boone shouldn't bear all the blame.

• Holistic Team Issues: Both hosts agree that the team's problems are multifaceted, encompassing pitching, fielding, and offense, rather than stemming from a single source.

---

3. General Manager Brian Cashman's Role

A significant portion of the discussion focuses on GM Brian Cashman and his long tenure with the Yankees, questioning his effectiveness in the current season.

Key Points:

• Lengthy Tenure vs. Performance: Ty expresses frustration over Cashman's 27-year stint, advocating for fresh leadership to navigate the evolving dynamics of modern baseball.

  Ty Butler [20:35]: "At some point, it's like, all right, enough, enough. We can have a fresh set of eyes."

• Ownership and Accountability: The hosts critique the ownership's reluctance to hold Cashman accountable, likening his role to that of a Steinbrenner, making meaningful changes nearly impossible.

---

4. Listener Engagement: Voices of Frustration

Several listeners call in, each offering unique insights and criticisms regarding the Yankees' current state.

Featured Calls:

• Dave from the Car [14:54]:
  Dave challenges comparisons between the current team and the legendary 1990s Yankees, arguing that despite recent playoff appearances, the team lacks the foundational strength.

  Dave [15:28]: "They're not even close. They have one player."

  Ty counters by emphasizing year-long performance issues, urging Dave to compare the Yankees to their contemporary rivals instead.

• Neil from the Bronx [17:07]:
  Neil attributes the team's struggles primarily to Cashman's ineffective player acquisitions, suggesting that Boone is constrained by the roster.

  Neil [17:53]: "Cashman is not really doing a good job of bringing the players."

  Peter connects with Neil's perspective, reinforcing the notion that Cashman's strategies are at the heart of the Yankees' woes.

• Dominic Mysterio from Long Island [45:19]:
  Dominic echoes sentiments about the lack of accountability among players and managers, stressing the need for leadership and response after significant losses.

  Dominic [45:20]: "The players are the ones that need to be held accountable here."

  Ty and Peter discuss Boone's handling of high-pressure situations, debating whether Boone's decisions contribute to the team's instability.

---

5. Comparing Past and Present Yankees

The hosts draw parallels between the current Yankees and their storied past, highlighting how expectations have evolved.

Key Insights:

• 2009 World Series Impact: Ty posits that reaching the World Series last year has paradoxically set unrealistic expectations, leading to greater dissatisfaction when the team falters.

  Ty Butler [08:17]: "Getting to the World Series might have been the worst thing to happen to this organization."

• Fading Glory: The discussion touches on how recent successes mask underlying issues, with fan bases, especially newer ones, lacking the deep-seated memories of past championships.

  Ty Butler [13:07]: "He's like fresh into, he's like entrenched into his career. And it's like, yo, I don't really have hardcore memories of the last time the Yankees won a championship."

---

6. Player Performance and Leadership

Aaron Judge's pivotal role and perceived lack of leadership are scrutinized, questioning his influence on the team's dynamics.

Notable Quotes:

• Peter Rosenberg [10:06]: "Is it problematic that it is so Aaron Judge dominant and dependent for this team?"

• Ty Butler [38:22]: "Your biggest gripe with Judge... is the lack of, like, conspicuous leadership."

Discussion Highlights:

• Dependence on Aaron Judge: The heavy reliance on Judge for offensive production raises concerns about team balance and resilience.

• Leadership Void: Despite Judge's on-field excellence, his perceived absence in vocal leadership roles is seen as a gap that the team needs to address.

---

7. Future Implications and Solutions

The episode concludes with a contemplation of potential paths forward for the Yankees, balancing immediate fixes with long-term strategies.

Key Points:

• Potential Organizational Changes: Suggestions include reconfiguring Cashman's role or introducing new leadership to bring fresh perspectives.

• Player Accountability: Emphasizing the need for players to take more responsibility on the field, reducing the managerial burden.

• Fan Base Sentiments: Acknowledging the deepening frustration among fans, the hosts ponder how the organization can restore confidence and performance.

---

8. Personal Interludes

Amidst the intense discussions, hosts share personal anecdotes, offering listeners a glimpse into their lives outside the studio.

Highlights:

• Peter Rosenberg's Injury: Peter discusses a knee injury, detailing his treatment plan and the impact on his ability to participate actively.

  Peter Rosenberg [24:47]: "It's day to day... If there's a game Sunday, you know, on the report it says out."

• Family Moments: Brief conversations about Peter’s child and humorous exchanges about family interactions provide a relatable human element to the episode.

---

Conclusion

In Hour 1: Yankees Frustration, Don, Hahn & Rosenberg provide a thorough analysis of the New York Yankees' current struggles, dissecting managerial decisions, organizational accountability, and player performances. Through engaging discussions and insightful listener interactions, the hosts paint a comprehensive picture of a franchise at a crossroads. Balancing expert critique with personal narratives, the episode offers both depth and relatability, making it a must-listen for Yankees fans navigating these turbulent times.

---

Notable Quotes with Timestamps:

• Ty Butler [02:06]: "You're forcing me to stay up an hour later just to lose in heartbreak fashion on a walk-off three, one shot."

• Ty Butler [03:11]: "Aaron Boone is part of the problem... when you hand over a three nothing lead to your ace... it's hard to put that on the manager."

• Peter Rosenberg [04:07]: "He's part of the fabric of what's been the issue with the Yankees."

• Ty Butler [05:24]: "We watch the games. We don't have to be baseball savants to figure out what's going on. Devin Williams stinks."

• Ty Butler [08:17]: "Getting to the World Series might have been the worst thing to happen to this organization."

• Peter Rosenberg [10:06]: "Is it problematic that it is so Aaron Judge dominant and dependent for this team?"

• Ty Butler [13:07]: "He's like fresh into, he's like entrenched into his career. And it's like, yo, I don't really have hardcore memories of the last time the Yankees won a championship."

---

For more insights and detailed discussions, subscribe to Don, Hahn & Rosenberg on the ESPN New York app or wherever you get your podcasts.

Transcript

[Don Hahn]

Are you feeling more fulfilled now that.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You'Re back to work on August 15th?

[Ty Butler]

No, I need a vacation.

[Peter Rosenberg]

See the movie that critics are saying is an awesome look at that crowd pleasing, fist pumping all out brawl of a film.

[Ty Butler]

You're right about that. They're coming after our family. Go fix this.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Oh, my. Nobody 2, rated R, holding in theaters August 15th. Give me a piece of wood, I'll eat it. Han, Peter, the most used sweat is at a buffet. And Rosenberg. I'll be honest, the one thing I miss about having an office is the taste of Steve Hart's nuts. This isn't North Dakota, this is New York. This is Don Hahn and Rosenberg, the.

[Don Hahn]

Best threesome I've ever heard on 880.

[Peter Rosenberg]

ESPN and the ESPN New York app. Oh, you. You're darn tootin'. You bet your ace. As some might say. Welcome to the Show 301 August 5th. Peter Rosenberg, Ty Butler with you on a somewhat balmy Tuesday afternoon. Ty, how you doing, my guy?

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, I had so much fun today, man. I woke up excited that we got a chance at round two.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Really?

[Ty Butler]

Yeah.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I didn't know that you would feel that way. Well, listen, after the night you had.

[Ty Butler]

It'S not often that we. Oh, the baseball. We'll get to that in a moment. But it's not often you and I get to do this. We'll tax. You know, I listen to your shows, but it's not often we get to spend some time together on the air, much to the dismay of some folks we read on social media, but who gives a damn about them? Well, I'm excited.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Right.

[Ty Butler]

This is, this is fun. I enjoy this. We get, we have a lot of different, you know, different subjects that we, you know, like.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Sure.

[Ty Butler]

Share mutually.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yep.

[Ty Butler]

So, Yep. This is fun for me.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You didn't seem. Because you just didn't seem in the best. I guess I'm trying to say is you didn't seem like you were necessarily in the best place last night after the Yankee game.

[Ty Butler]

Well, here's the problem. You're forcing me with the 8 o' clock start. You're forcing me to stay up an hour later just to lose in heartbreak fashion on a. On a walk off three, one shot. That's what we're doing. You can't lose earlier.

[Peter Rosenberg]

And this, and this is what I like about today's show. This is what, this is why we're getting into something exciting, in my opinion, because we're gonna open the phone lines right now. 1-800-919-3776 we're gonna jump into it right now because I think there are a lot of people who have truly hit the. I've lost my mind, there's nothing left to say, I just don't know what to do with my life kind of place. They've. That's where they're at, many of them. And I like that you are ready to defend Aaron Boone, at least on what many people think cost them the game last night. So I'll open the phone lines and pass you the baton. Ty Butler, what is the case for why you're not at least more mad at Aaron Boone today?

[Ty Butler]

Well, listen, I want to make sure the context of this is correct. I think Aaron Boone is part of the problem. He's part of the fabric of what's been the issue with the Yankees. But I can't watch last night and blame him. Because when you hand over a three nothing lead to your ace to a guy who just a few weeks ago was in the Cy Young conversation, it's hard to put that on the manager. I mean, Max Freed's got to be better like that. This is second. Yeah, this is the second time. So Friday night you handed a 6 nothing lead to your second best pitcher. Last night you handed a 3 nothing lead to your best pitcher. And if you're blowing those games, that, to me, speaks to a more holistic issue. Again, Aaron Boone's part of the problem. But I didn't watch last night's game and think, this is on the manager. Freed's just gotta be better.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You're the best pitcher on the team. The intentional walk that set up the game winner, you have no issue there.

[Ty Butler]

It should not have even come down to. That is my point.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Okay, I like this. Well, let's see. Let's see if you continue to defend Aaron Boone when we hear his tone. Because with Boonie, let's be honest, guys, what kind of boonies are we getting? You know, what level of boonies is he speaking? Well, he does say one thing. He says that we know we can't keep losing. We gotta win games. The season's getting shorter in a hurry. No time for excuses and feeling bad.

[Ty Butler]

And I know everyone feels like crap, but we gotta go take it.

[Don Hahn]

Haven't been able to do that on.

[Peter Rosenberg]

This road trip so far, but we gotta do it better now. Here's an opportunity for him to speak. That was fine. That was fine. I don't think I'm gonna be mad at that.

[Ty Butler]

No issue.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Here's an opportunity to truly see. Ty, what kind of boonies my guy is speaking. Is your confidence in Williams wavering at all?

[Ty Butler]

We have really good guys down there.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Devin included, and we gotta be able to close out these games, though. So he's been through some tough moments already this season, and we gotta bounce back from it.

[Ty Butler]

That's not bad.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You're not mad at that?

[Ty Butler]

That's not bad. I mean, he was honest. He didn't. He didn't talk about, you know, he had good pitch quality and like, you know, all the excuses he tends to make, you know, that happens. He didn't. He didn't run.

[Peter Rosenberg]

We like his throwies. We like his throwies. He was giving us ups and downs.

[Ty Butler]

Good pitch action. They make good. We didn't get the alleys.

[Peter Rosenberg]

We like his alleys.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, we didn't get that. So we got truth from him, and that's all Yankee fans are asking for. Yo, we watch the games. We don't have to be baseball savants to figure out what's going on. Devin Williams stinks. And if you want to criticize him for continuing to go to Devin Williams, I'm cool with that. All I'm saying is when your ace has a three nothing lead, you got to be able to close the deal, man. You got to be able to close the deal.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Well. And that's, to me, when you get really worried, like, when you're finding different ways to lose, like, it's not even just point to one thing. Like, on one day, it's one day. It's fielding one day, it's running one day, it's. It's offense. There's just always something. All right, Boonie, is the stress getting to the team at all?

[Ty Butler]

You feel like the stretch is weighing.

[Peter Rosenberg]

On guys in there? Yes. Doesn't matter, though.

[Ty Butler]

Doesn't matter. Weigh on us. Stress.

[Peter Rosenberg]

We got to win, period. We know that. So nobody cares how stressful it is or that's all just noise, excuses, whatever. We got to go play better and we got to win. We know that.

[Ty Butler]

That's fine, right?

[Peter Rosenberg]

All right. I'll be honest. I don't think you hate anything he's saying to the Yankee fans. 1-800-9193776 Are you hating what he's putting down here? Like, is this to you? Same old. Just the exact same. I don't know what you'd want him to do today. Like, would. Would you want it to be screaming? Like, should he just be outright screaming at everyone? I don't know what else he's really going to do. So I don't Have a problem so far with anything that has been said. I'm not mad at this version of boonies. He's not speaking, like a language I don't understand.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, I think most you wanna hear from.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You wanna. From Max Freed, Ty Butler.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, let's go ahead. Let's hear from Max Freed.

[Peter Rosenberg]

It's simple. We just need to get it done, and we haven't been getting it done. And we gotta do something to be able to change that.

[Ty Butler]

Okay. Okay. It's funny. I will say it's kind of funny, right?

[Peter Rosenberg]

Wait, which part?

[Ty Butler]

That we've been hearing the same messaging for weeks. Like, this is a long time, Peter, that the Yankees have been bad since May. So let's just go back since May 29th. I have the stat here. They're 25 and 33. That's a significant part of the season where you've just been an awful baseball team. Which brings me to something I think is going to be controversial, and I'm curious to hear your thoughts on it. All right. Getting to the World Series might have been the worst thing to happen to this organization.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I'm not. I'm not mad at that. I think. I actually think whenever you look at a team that, like, really far, when it wasn't expected, and then particularly when you see a regression the next year. Yeah. I mean, I'm sorry. The. The. The onus would be on someone else to prove you wrong. Like, it. You're clearly. That's clearly what it looks like is that they were falsely giving an indicator that they were right there and they were not.

[Ty Butler]

And that's how I feel. It gave House Steinbrenner a false sense of confidence in the guys running the show. And he could not have been more wrong. Because whether you want to blame the general manager or you want to blame the manager, this team is in third place in the division. It's August 5th. If they go on to lose the next two games of the series, they're on the outside looking in. And the New York Yankees, who are a top three payroll, who did get to the World Series last year. I understand Garrett Cole's out for the season. This team is too damn talented to be on the outside looking in when it comes to the playoff picture. So I think that if you go back, because I, I remember what, what was being said about them last year. The road was easy. Oh, you know, you beat the Royals, you beat the Guardians. How good are you? Then you got spanked by the Dodgers. And now those people who were critical of the ankles who didn't really buy into the hype are being proven correct because this team is bad, man. It's a bad baseball team. And as you said, they're losing games in different ways. There's not one area of the team that you look at and you say, well, I trust that part of the team. Not one.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. You wonder when you look at the stats for the Yankees and you see that number 99 leads every category. In one sense, you're like, wow, that's amazing. I love that. In another sense, you're like, is it problematic that it is so Aaron Judge dominant and dependent for this team? That. That just seems to be the only way this thing goes. I mean, they've gotten. You couldn't hope for much more from Bellinger, Right? Like, that's worked out for you, Todd. You had to be happy about that. Yeah, that's a piece that's. That's worked out. Goldie, as I call him. You're not mad about what you've gotten from, from Goldie, are you?

[Ty Butler]

Well, he fell off for hit the home run last night, but he. After a hot start, he showed his age a bit. But to your.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I mean, also, what were you expecting? You weren't expecting. You weren't expecting to him to be the, the reason you're good. But the bottom line is there are just pieces here that have not been what they thought they were going to be. And obviously the. Right. When I was going on vacation, the Volpe conversation started to get hot and uncomfortable. And that has now continued, Ty, for what, six weeks?

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, it's been, it's been a problem. And you wonder because I brought this up to you yesterday, like, are there Yankee fans out there rooting for this team to miss the playoffs? Because that is your best hope of some significant change. Like if you miss the playoffs again, what would that be? The second time in three years. Shouldn't that send a message to your owner that something ain't right here? And people. Except to your point, yeah, they went to the World Series last year. I get it.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Exactly.

[Ty Butler]

But.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Exactly.

[Ty Butler]

But look how the World Series ended. Like that stuff should matter. How it ended should matter. It shouldn't be a blanket statement. Well, they won the pennant. How did you look against the best team in baseball? You can shine their shoes.

[Peter Rosenberg]

God, it's interesting, right? Like, isn't it crazy that we have one team in the New York Knicks that went seven in the, in the conference finals and got rid of the coach in a year in which that was not expected? I mean, people Expected the Knicks to, you know, be a good baseball, a good basketball team. They expected that. I don't think anyone expected the kind of ride that they got from Tibbs and company. And now Tibbs is gone. Not enough. Now there are some people who don't like that. But it is just so interesting to see the difference in the way the Yankees are operating. And the Yankees and some of their fan base will always rest on their laurels of, well, look at the difference. The Knicks are the New York Knicks. They have not won a championship in 50 years and we are the New York Yankees. But the problem with that logic is, man, 2009 feels like 50 years with the way this baseball team has been.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, it feels like a long time ago. And yesterday we played the audio of, you know, two members of that 2009 team who on and this should not be taken lightly on national television. Pretty much calling out the team as critical as you can possibly be. That's a long time ago. 2009, yo, so I did this, I did the show, what was it last last week. And I'm working with one of the producers at the station, Tom Bauer. Die hard Yankee fans. How crazy is this? He doesn't actually have like vivid memories of that championship. That's how long ago it was. And now he's like fresh into, he's like entrenched into his career. And it's like, yo, I don't really have hardcore memories of, of the last time the Yankees won a championship. That's outrageous. That's something you expect to hear from Knick Fans, not Yankee fans.

[Peter Rosenberg]

1-800-919-3776 it is a talk about it Tuesday. So we're going to give you guys the floor a lot today. And by the way, we do have to spend some time in the New York Mets and also just a horrifying loss. It's like, you know, it's like in the off season, Ty, the Yankees and the Mets were like, yo, man, I'm tired of everyone talking about how bad the jets and Giants are. We could do this. We could also ruin a season for people. Why is it just the football teams who get to be trash talked for 18, 20, 22 weeks straight? So we're going to give you guys the phone lines. Yankee fans met fans today because I do think it's a moment of legit frustration. And this is what we do on let's Talk About It Tuesday. So let's get started first with Dave in the car. Sup, Dave?

[Don Hahn]

Hey, how you guys doing? Just Wanted to say one thing. I mean, at least Ty's not blasting boom like everybody else is blasting him. I mean, Joel Tory was a. Was horrible managing every single team. He came to us until he came to the bomb squad Yankees. I'm waiting for just somebody to tell me, okay, that this team that everybody thinks is they're pretty a good team just because they made it to the World Series. They're just not that good of a team. I'm not going to compare them with the 90s team because they're a bomb squad. I don't know how old you guys are. Compare them with the Reggie Jackson team. I'm not going to go around the infield and give you all the players names. Like, I don't have time for that. You're not going to let me on the phone compare them with that team. They're not even close. They have one player.

[Ty Butler]

Dave, Dave, Dave. The problem.

[Don Hahn]

Hold on, let me just say what.

[Ty Butler]

I want to say. How it worked. Not homie. This is not how it works.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Go ahead.

[Ty Butler]

The problem with what you're doing is you're comparing them to the 90s team. Compare them to their contemporary. Compare them to the teams they're playing against and tell me why. They have been awful since May 29th. That's what we're talking about. We don't have to go through Bernie and Tino. That's cool. We know they are. They are awful against the teams they're playing against right now. Talk to me about that, Dave.

[Don Hahn]

Okay, I'll talk to you about that. Because this is what the problem is. They are not that much better than those teams. The Astros, Detroit, they're not 50 billion times better than those teams. When are you going to figure that out? We have one pitcher who's injured, okay? Freed, he's injured. We have one player who happens to be the best player in the entire league, okay? He's injured. Even if they were both healthy, we still, we're not that much better than they look.

[Ty Butler]

They were bad when Judge was healthy, they were bad when.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Appreciate you, they've been bad. When Freed was healthy, they were bad.

[Ty Butler]

When Judge was healthy, they also at a point this season was 17 games above.500. And everyone's talking about how weak the American League is. So listen, Dave, love him. Great caller. That. That was terrible. Ain't nobody trying to hear that right now. My guy.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Let's go to. Let's go to Neil in the Bronx. What is going on, Neil?

[Don Hahn]

What's going on? Gentlemen, I hear everything. You're saying. But there's enough blame to go around from Boone to how and especially Cashman. Cashman's been there for 27 years. He's the one that's doing the grocery shopping. And Boone has to do as best as he can with the grocery that he's bringing in. So you have to remember this has to fall mostly on cashmere. Boone is doing his best of what he has. Cashman is not really doing a good job of bringing the players. Put it this way, before the trade deadline, the Yankees had like an issue of problems that needed to be resolved. And Cashman, what he does, he puts a band aid on it. And they needed surgery, not a band aid.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You know what, Neil, I don't hate Neil's take there. Because to me, while I think that optically, and I do feel this way, Ty, I think at times optically, Boone is terrible. Like in certain moments when he starts speaking boonies and you're like, my man, please just keep. But the bottom line is that is generally an optics thing. I don't actually believe, and I don't think you do either, that Aaron Boone is the reason they are losing baseball games. If you want to point the finger above the players, and I think at a certain point you have to because the players change and the problems seem to stay the same. I think Cashman is where you have to point the finger. And, and, and I think unfortunately, and this is a frustrating, annoying conversation, he's never leaving. He is a Steinbrenner. I've always said that. Stop thinking of him as a higher general manager. Ty. He's not. He is another Steinbrenner. He's in the family.

[Ty Butler]

But what frustrates me about that take, because I, I a thousand percent agree with it, is how you could be the same guy for all these summers arguing with the Yankee fans about how spoiled they are. And it's not really about them being spoiled. It's about that point that you just made. Regardless of what happens, they could miss the playoffs. They could get spanked in the World Series in a bet in an embarrassing fashion. They could get swept out of the ALCS against the Astros. Regardless of what happens, the main guy responsible for it does not get held accountable. So it's not about all. You guys are used to them winning four championships in five years. It's not about that. We just want to see the person get called to the carpet and the owner refuses to do that.

[Peter Rosenberg]

It's a very, very frustrating situation. And you said, did you say it off the air yesterday? I Think it was off the air when you said.

[Ty Butler]

You're repeated that. That's dangerous.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, no, it wasn't that. When you gave me your suggestion for what they should do about Cashman, I think it was off the air you said that, wasn't it? When you were saying they should just. Just move the role. Like, obviously we know he's not leaving the team, but maybe it is time to sort of make him part of ownership, whatever, but bring in a new set of eyes, a new voice to actually lead this thing. It is possible, guys, people sometimes do. The game changes sometimes, and you may need someone with a different approach. Maybe you can find a place for Cashmen in the organization that is not literally deciding every single thing that affects this team on the field.

[Ty Butler]

My man's been here for three decades. At some point it's like, all right, enough, enough. Like, we can move on. We can have a fresh set of eyes. As the game continues to evolve, as it changes, sometimes it passes you by. And I'm not saying that it has passed him by because the Yankees obviously have had some success, but to the degree of what we've expected, it just hasn't happened. And I think that moving him to some like, senior advisor role, or maybe he might feel disrespected. Rosenberg, and that's just not the play. He's like, nah, y' all not gonna do that to me. Maybe that'll be flagrant disrespect to him. But regardless, this needs to change because it's not working. It's not working. And I fundamentally disagree with this idea that anyone should have a job for life. A general manager. No.

[Peter Rosenberg]

And by the way, you know, you could just make up a new title. When people are this rich, that's all they do. He's head of baseball operations, but there's a new general manager. There's a way to maybe get. We cannot just live in the. It has to be Cashman till what, the day dies. He's going to be 90. Like, at some point it's going to change. And I'm. It's. And I. The point is this. It's not going to end with the headline cashman fired. That's not happening. That's the point I'm trying to make. It's never going to be a big, splashy, catchy tie during the break. You can work on what your made up, trashy New York Post headline would be that they're dreaming of for the bat page. That's not going to happen. But there has to be a moment when they say, you know what? We have to get new eyes on this thing. Because it just seems every year we are having the exact same conversation. This is an ad by BetterHelp. These days it feels like there's a vice for everything. Cold plunges, gratitude journals, screen detoxes. But how do you know what actually works for you? With the Internet and information overload about mental health and wellness, it can be a struggle to know what's true and what actions to take. These days, using trusted resources and talking to live therapists can get you personalized recommendations and help to help you break through the noise. With over 30,000 therapists, BetterHelp is the world's largest online therapy platform, having served over 5 million people globally. And it works with an App store rating of 4.9 out of 5 based on over 1.7 million client reviews. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Talk it out with BetterHelp, our listeners get 10% off their first [e-mail] timeout. That's betterhelp.com timeout.

[Ty Butler]

Hey guys, it's Ceedee Lamb, wide receiver for the Dallas Cowboys. I'm partnering with Abercrombie this season to tell you all about their viral denim. All you need to know is denim should fit like this. My jeans need to check a lot of boxes fit first, trend second.

[Don Hahn]

They need to go with whatever I'm.

[Ty Butler]

Feeling and Abercrombie Denim has it down whether I'm throwing on a tee or putting a whole fit together. Shop Abercrombie Denim in the app online and in store on WhatsApp, no one can see or hear your personal messages. Whether it's a voice call message or sending a password to WhatsApp, it's all just this. So whether you're sharing the streaming password in the family chat or trading those late night voice messages that could basically become a podcast, your personal messages stay between you, your friends and your family. No one else. Not even us. WhatsApp message privately with everyone.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Thanks for listening to the Don Hahn and Rosenberg podcast. I didn't listen to anything you just said. Catch this show on demand whenever you want. Just subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. Right now, Ty is meeting Maya for the first time on camera.

[Ty Butler]

So adorable. So adorable. Maya, I'll tell you this. You look nothing like your daddy.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Everyone says she looks nothing like her daddy. Which is, by the way, exactly what I was hoping for. Big shout out to nyu, fantastic IVF work, obviously accomplished. They managed to somehow pull out any of my DNA, you know what I mean? And making sure she got the highest quality mishattan DNA. But yeah, if you listen to the show yesterday, then you know that I severely hurt my knee region. So we are working from home today because me moving is not an option at this moment. Tomorrow I'm going to Westchester, going to get checked out. You know, go to the sports surgery center and have them take a look at the old knee tie. And listen, we're not willing to make any comments about timeline at this point.

[Ty Butler]

Day to day.

[Peter Rosenberg]

It's day to day. But, you know, it's one of those day to days that if there's a game Sunday, you know, on the report it says out. Yeah, it says out. It's out. It's currently out. It didn't swell overnight. And it actually, I woke up able to walk with putting a little more weight on it than yesterday. So I'm hopeful that were like in sprain and not meanwhile. Meanwhile, I friend, a friend like Ballard, who I think has torn his ACL four times, who is like, it's crazy. No, it's crazy. I think he's had three surgeries.

[Ty Butler]

That's crazy.

[Peter Rosenberg]

It's three or four times. And he hit me and was like, oh, man. But you said the word pop. That's, that's. I said, I think about. I think pop happens a lot, if I'm being honest. I think. I think people often feel pop and it doesn't mean everything was torn to shreds.

[Ty Butler]

So my boy hit me up. My boy Corey, who's listening to the show, he said it sounds like an MCL sprain. He says, Tell Peter, get some CMOs. He'll be. I.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, he didn't say that.

[Ty Butler]

Well, because he's. He's. He's had an MCL sprain and he had to do like, physical therapy. There was no surgery required. But he said to the CMOs, which I'm on too, I take.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Wait, but hold on, hold on. I know CMOS is very good for you, but is that really doing the job if you have like a severe sprain to your leg?

[Ty Butler]

I already have the injury. No, this. This is more preventative.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Well, what is c. What is CMOS supposed to do?

[Ty Butler]

It's to help. It's to help with your joints.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Just in general.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, general help with functionalities and joints.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. Ballard wrote Bro as a guy with 4 ACL tears because we posted a video yesterday. He responded to the video and said, As a guy with four ACL tears, what you're describing sounds familiar. Hoping this isn't what I think it is.

[Ty Butler]

Hmm.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I said. I said, well, when you tore it, did it swell? He said, the first time, a ton. But I also had compression fractures in several bones and tore acl, lcl, mcl. In case you're wondering, he is not an athlete. I believe that one happened when playing with his niece.

[Ty Butler]

But that's. But that. I mean, come on. I like Balor a lot. He's shown me a lot of support on the grammar. That's the last thing you want to hear.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Come on. Yeah, no one wants to. Oh, it sounds like an acl. Does it? Come on, bro.

[Ty Butler]

Sounds like an acl, mcl, pclcl.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, it can't be. It can't be. I'm hoping me and my boy chat GPT. Or girl chat GPT. Whatever. They chat GPT. I'm not sure if we were chatting and. And they. I. I feel like we're leaning towards spraying strain. That's. That's.

[Ty Butler]

Listen, here's my. And I know we got to get to the phone calls. Am I gonna have you for the show tomorrow? Not that I can't host solo, but I would prefer to do the show with you.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, no, I'm. The appointment's 11:30 in Westchester. I'll be home. I'll be good.

[Ty Butler]

But, you know, these Doctors sometimes say 11:30, and then you sit in there, 1:30.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You know what? Listen, if you're concerned, I'll bring the Comrex in the backpack. You know, I'm always prepared.

[Ty Butler]

That shows me you about it. That shows.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, I'm dedicated. I'm about that life.

[Ty Butler]

We've done that before.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah, listen, I've done it from cabs. You. It's all happened before. So beautiful.

[Ty Butler]

Beautiful baby girl, though. I gotta say, man, thank you on the screen.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Well, listen, she is six months.

[Ty Butler]

Wow.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Actually, I guess in 10 days, she'll be seven months.

[Ty Butler]

Wow. See, I'm at the point, Rosenberg now, where I have to watch what I say around my oldest, Noah, which is something you're gonna have to deal with. All I said was. I screamed out loud. I was like, that sucks. And he said. And he said to me, don't say that. That's a bad word. Don't say that. Since I got scolded by my wife, you deal with that at some point.

[Peter Rosenberg]

But now, now, wait till he did. Did he scold you too, or just your wife?

[Ty Butler]

No, he scolded me at first. Good friend to say that.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah, that's a good boy.

[Ty Butler]

You'll hit that at that stage at some point.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. Right now, what I get in trouble for is having her watch wrestling. Natalie's fine with her watching when the actual combat's not happening, but she doesn't want her to see combat yet.

[Ty Butler]

Like, sort of.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. Until we can explain, like, this is play. They're doing a show. They don't. She doesn't want her. You know, we're gonna have her. She's gonna be a smart wrestling fan, unlike her dad, who fell hook, line, and sinker for Seth Rollins.

[Ty Butler]

All right.

[Peter Rosenberg]

By the way, Raw was incredible last night.

[Ty Butler]

That was last night. He said it was great.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, last night's Raw was the best Raw in a while. I truly enjoyed that. All right, back to the phones and the Yankee Talk. 1-800-919-3776. Mike has been on hold for a minute in Hoboken. What's up, Mike?

[Don Hahn]

Hey, what's up, guys? How are you?

[Peter Rosenberg]

Good, good.

[Don Hahn]

Just want to. I just want to call in about, you know, the whole talk about Boone. I've been a Yankee fan since I was a kid, you know, early 70s, and, you know, we recently got rid of Joe Girardi because he had the audacity to call out Gary Sanchez because he was a terrible defensive catcher. So they brought in a new manager. A manager is a little more personable, a little bit better with the players, but very, very, you know, tactical on the. On the analytics side. Right. Michael. Michael Kay says that all the time. They brought in Boone because he listens to the analytical team. So what I want to know is all these chants of fire, Boone, and we got to get rid of Boone, and we got to move on from Boone. Correct me if I'm wrong, but Boone doesn't give up the leads. Boone doesn't get caught off first. He doesn't boot the balls. He doesn't. He doesn't blow the games. He doesn't have, you know, game ending, you know, home runs hit off him. I mean, he only has what he has to use. And I understand that a manager has to get the team prepared to play, but when does it fall on the players? When is it the players who get paid very handsomely to do what they have to do, when does it fall on them to say, we got to be better? Not just we got to fire a Boone, we got. I mean, you know, is there any talk of any other players that we could bring up from the Miners to say, hey, if you can't do this job, we got to a kid who's going to try to do it. I mean, why is it all on Boone? And then they say, well, you know what? He's got to push the right buttons. He pushes the buttons he puts in the relievers when he's supposed to. But it's not his fault that Airbender hasn't been a shade of himself in a year. It's not his fault that the new relievers that we got just got hit a little bit. I don't understand where all the chance of we got to get rid of Boone. What are we going to do when we get rid of Boone? Are we going to bring in another Girardi type?

[Peter Rosenberg]

Listen, your Mike, it's a great call and it's a lazy take when people just go right to get rid of Boone. Now listen, yesterday I sat here on these airwaves and said when people make fundamental mistakes, you should place blame at the feet of the coach or manager. And that is true. But do I really think that when you are dealing with professionals who are being paid this way that balls going under their gloves or getting caught off a baseball, should that be on a manager? No, it should not. These are not high school kids. Some of the stuff that you see that make mistakes with Ty, are not things that honestly, if we're being honest, these are not things that are even being stressed by a manager anyway.

[Ty Butler]

But it should be. But that's the problem.

[Peter Rosenberg]

But they're professionals.

[Ty Butler]

Rosenberg. I understand.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Come on. We have to talk about situational base running when you're 30.

[Ty Butler]

Yes. When you lose a World Series because of that. Yes. We got to do that. That there has to be more of an emphasis on it. And by the way, what was his name? Mike.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah.

[Ty Butler]

It is impossible for him to have. Listen. He was on hold, so he had to have been listening to the conversation. It's impossible for your takeaway to be. Well, we're saying it's all on Boone when we just ripped Cashman.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. We don't think it's all those guys.

[Ty Butler]

And if, if Cashman's going and obviously Boone's got to get out of here too.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Let's keep talking to the people and let's go to Pablo in the Heights. What's up, Pablo?

[Don Hahn]

Peter, what's up? Welcome back, Ty. What up, my brother?

[Ty Butler]

What's good?

[Don Hahn]

So, yeah, listen, the Yankees, honestly speaking, they gotta respond with a win tonight. The, the players are the ones that need to be held accountable here. These guys, they come in every night and it's like there's no fire. I don't know if they have any conversations with each other or whatnot, but it's just the same. And I feel like there needs to be some type of leadership, some type of accountability and that's what's missing in that room. I'm not sure if Judge is that type of vocal leader, like someone that just, you know, tells you what's going on, like day to day, like just base running, whether it's hustle or I just don't know how to really like put it in words, but just some type of fire in there. I don't know if they have any player meetings or whatnot. They have, but there's no. I don't see it. I don't see it. I mean, three games where we've been playing like, like that Friday game where we just lost that seven run lead back to back, all brand new toys and we just lose this league. Like why are we putting these guys into this position? Fine, these are brand new guys. They came into this situation. But what about everyone else? They came back, they gave the three run lead. They get. They came back in the, in the ninth inning, I believe it was. And then Saturday, there's no response to that, that type of game that's at the loss. That's what I'm saying tonight. There has to be a response.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah. Pablo, appreciate the call. Boone was on talking Yanks and with John Boy and Jake and actually acknowledged that he did feel like there was some spillover effect from that Friday night loss. It was so disheartening and you know, those are the types of things that happen when you lose a game like that.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Proud of him for acknowledging that you said what? Proud of him for acknowledging.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, right. He's taking some step. Do you, do you feel like maybe there's some pressure coming from the front office because his, his tone has changed in the last couple of days and maybe it's because of what a Rod and Jeter said on Fox or. I don't know what it is, but it sounds a little bit different.

[Peter Rosenberg]

What would it be? Would it be because of pressure or would it be the opposite? Would it be because they're saying, you know what, go ahead and let loose a little bit. Yeah, like, and not only that, but, but not only that, but like, hey, we're frustrated and we're frustrated with the players, don't feel the need to protect them. Maybe he got a green light more than he feels pressure.

[Ty Butler]

Green light Boone. I'm fascinated to see what that Looks like over the next two months, if he can let loose.

[Peter Rosenberg]

By the way, you know, I know what I'm going to say here is going to sound insane, and I know this would never be done. I wish him and Judge would have, like, a private conversation in which Judge would be like, yo, listen, say something about me. Say something about me. I want them to see that I can get called out, and then I will in turn respond by saying that I need to do better and take ownership.

[Ty Butler]

Okay, so, because. Game. Let's play this. Give me an example of something you would call Judge out for.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Well, that's the problem. He has to do something, so you'd have to just do it. There would, you know, maybe the time would have been after the Red Sox series or something. Right. Like a moment when he's just bad. Like, everyone.

[Ty Butler]

World Series game. Yeah, right now. Bringing that.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I was thinking about the fifth inning. You got to keep your eye on the ball all the way into the glove. What the hell are you doing?

[Don Hahn]

Doing.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Little delayed reaction. But no, if the. If the moment came up, I wish that that could happen. Like, I just want to show everyone. Because if they were to see Judge get called out. You're telling me Jazz Chisholm sees Judge get called out, and all Judge does is say he's. He's right. I got to be better. What does Chisholm then do if he gets called out?

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, I don't know if that plays in baseball, but there it's. It's very telling that. Peter, your biggest. And I don't even want to call it a criticism, because that seems harsh, but your biggest gripe with Judge, if you will, is the lack of, like, conspicuous leadership. Because what that speaks to is there's nothing we can really criticize this dude for on the field. Like, he's doing everything at the plate. You know, he fields his position at a Gold Glove level. You know, he's not. You know, he's not making base running errors. So there's really nothing you can call this dude out for.

[Peter Rosenberg]

What could it possibly be? The only thing that there ever is is that that's the only thing. There's two issues that Yankee fans complain about. Aaron Judge, obviously. Number one is the playoff performance. You know, what he does when we get to the fall. And number two is sometimes he doesn't feel like the leader that people want. How can you argue with the numbers at this point? Oh, and lastly, frustration about availability at times. Fortunately, this year, knock on wood. There was a moment I was on vacation, guys, that was a moment on my vacation. I think I might have been on the beach in Nice and I saw John Boy put up a video like, oh, if Judge needs Tommy John, what's gonna happen? And I'm like, wait a second. I, it actually took me out for a minute. It took me out of the.

[Ty Butler]

You considered re entering the group chat at that moment just to see what the conversation was like.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I was, you know what? I didn't. But I almost considered it. I was like, wait a second. Please don't say, Please don't say. When I go back to work, Aaron Judge is gonna be on the shelf not only for this year, but next year. Please, please.

[Ty Butler]

But that's the scary part. The scary part is he was, he's returning tonight and that's still not off the table. Like something can happen to where you know, he can re aggravate it or experience some type of an issue where.

[Peter Rosenberg]

It takes, man runs into, runs into a wall. You know, you know, things, things happen. Now speaking of tonight, we got game time brought to you by Tullamore Do Irish whiskey. When it's game time, it's Tully time. The Mets, they, they have to continue this series with the Guardians, it seems coverage immediately following us right here on 880 at 6:30 and then the Yankees and the Rangers at 8:10, Liberty in action at 7 as well. Tullamore Dew, the original triple distilled, triple blended and triple cast matured Irish whiskey. Be sure to grab a Tullamore Dew or try the new Tullamore Dew. Honey. During today's action, glasses up to enjoying Tullamore Dew responsibly.

[Ty Butler]

This episode is brought to you by State Farm. Checking off the boxes on your to do list is a great feeling. And when it comes to checking off coverage, a State Farm agent can help you choose an option that's right for you. Whether you prefer talking in person on the phone or using the award winning app, it's nice knowing you have help finding coverage that best fits your needs. Like a good neighbor, State Farm is there. The Jack Welch Management Institute at Strayer University helps you go from I know the way to I've arrived with our top 10 ranked online MBA. Gain skills you can learn today and apply tomorrow. Get ready to go from make it happen to made it happen and keep striving. Visit strayer.edu Jack WelchMBA to learn more. Strayer University is certified to operate in Virginia by Chev and its many campuses including at 2121 15th Street north in Arlington, Virginia. Lowes knows when you're looking for reliability. The right brand makes all the difference. And now Lowes is the exclusive home.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Improvement retailer for the Whirlpool water treatment line, including their WI fi softener under.

[Ty Butler]

Sync filtration system and more.

[Peter Rosenberg]

With Whirlpool's proven performance and our everyday low prices, better tasting, better quality water is within reach. Shop Pro trusted brands like Whirlpool and.

[Ty Butler]

More in store or online Lowe's, we help you save.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Thanks for listening to the Don Hahn and Rosenberg podcast. I didn't listen to anything you just said. Catch the show on demand whenever you want. Just subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. I did have this really lovely return to work this week in the sense that I was gone for so long, getting back into my particular kind of work schedule is a handful to go from zero to a hundred. It's a lot, you know, I mean and I had SummerSlam this weekend. Then you roll, right? So I. Ebro's been off Monday, Tuesday and tomorrow he's off. And then Alan and Don are off. So. Ty. It feels like I got back from Christmas vacation and the first day of school was a substitute teacher. You know what I mean? It's great. It's like an ease in. It's an ease back to my lifestyle.

[Ty Butler]

I just wish we had a better analogy.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Because you don't want to be.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, because that is like a negative connotation for who? Substitute result for me. No, no, the substitute is always like, you know, you can take advantage of them. You don't really gotta pay attention in class. It's all good.

[Peter Rosenberg]

No, see, you're looking, you're making this negative.

[Ty Butler]

Like I'm a soft landing spot.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. Emotionally it's a soft landing. So it's a compliment. It means instead of feeling like right back I'm in the throes of like my everyday work life. It's like, nah, I'm still kind of on vacation. It's not the full on day to day grind. It's me and my boy hanging out. We're just doing a little show together.

[Ty Butler]

All right. I just offense to the substitute teacher. It's like coming back from France and now we go to the beach house. How about that? Is that cool?

[Peter Rosenberg]

Ooh, that sounds good.

[Ty Butler]

That's good. See, that's how, ah, my life fell.

[Peter Rosenberg]

You heard that? That's not what you want.

[Ty Butler]

That drop's gonna somehow make its way into us. Six o'. Clock. Hopefully I didn't, I didn't ruin it, but yeah, I like it, man.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Oh, that was Unfortunate. This light just fell. Let me turn it off so it doesn't burn my house down on top of everything.

[Ty Butler]

And I appreciate because, you know, let people behind the curtain. Yeah. I was hand selected.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Oh yeah. By the God Rosenberg.

[Ty Butler]

The God.

[Peter Rosenberg]

I don't think that's the name I'm not allowed to be called.

[Ty Butler]

So we had, we had people mad at us, man.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yeah. I don't want. If I do any impressions, people might get off.

[Ty Butler]

Could you imagine if I don't want.

[Peter Rosenberg]

People to get myself has to. Yo, that was. I'm gonna tell you guys, listen, I don't want to give too much away, but when I saw the headline that the president and Charlemagne were having beef, it was like for me, it was like the Batman meme. I was like, my dad sent it to me too. I'm sitting at SummerSlam. I get a text from my dad with just an article link and I'm like, what do I make of this?

[Ty Butler]

The crab me. Where you're just like, everything's like going crazy. Like where do. Where do I go here?

[Peter Rosenberg]

Like I don't exactly. Where do I go? I don't know where to land here. Let's get back to the phones. They are completely jammed up. Let me see. I'm gonna reward who's been holding on the longest. Let's go to young Dominic Mysterio. Dominic at Long Island. What's up, Dom? Dominic.

[Don Hahn]

Hello. Hello.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Go for it. Dominic.

[Ty Butler]

What's up, man?

[Don Hahn]

Hey, what's going on? Yo, Ty, you're not a substitute. You're doing a great job, bud.

[Ty Butler]

I appreciate you, man. That was negative energy from my co host here. I appreciate it.

[Don Hahn]

I felt it. I felt it for you. I felt it for you.

[Peter Rosenberg]

So it's the opposite, but go ahead.

[Don Hahn]

I'm a, I believe, orange and orange and blue, but I'm a New York baseball fan through and through. And both teams right now, like you guys are saying before, we're kind of in a position where we got to make moves. The Yankees more so than the Mets, considering where they stand in the standings. And I'm a firm believer bad luck happens. And you're going to, you're going to, you're going to lose games on timely, on poorly timed errors. But fundamentally, like baseball has changed. I think the Yankees are showing a lot of that pain because when you lose a game, fundamentally, and you do that 10 times, 12 times, 15 times in 162 game season, and you guys are now going from comfortably in first place to holding up to that last spot of the playoffs, you can't be doing that. And then on top of that, how do you hold teams accountable when you have guys now that are making Uber money and carry large egos, then statements are getting sent to the press that they. It was a baseball play, they were doing it to win. They're still going to try to make the same play no matter what. It's kind of like a hard spot to stand on. Like, where does Aaron. Boom. Go with that? Like, how do you. How do you go make a judgment call as.

[Peter Rosenberg]

All right. Thanks, Dominic.

[Ty Butler]

What did you do? Don't you feel like that's the. The biggest indictment of Boone? Like, your player screws up in a big spot, and then after the game is telling reporters, basically, I do it again.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Jazz, you know, I'm thinking that one through, right? Because, like, in one sense, I know what he was trying to say. In another sense, it's reading the room so badly. Like, not. Maybe you even do feel like, you know what? That is my approach. I probably would do it that again, but to not read the room that your fan base is really frustrated and whether. However that played out. Jaz, that was a mental mistake. You got it wrong. Now you may say, you know what the logic was, and that's how you approach that. And it was thoughtful. Like, it wasn't sloppy. It was thoughtful. Fine. You were wrong. You got it wrong. I know, because you were out. You were wrong. So then when you have the moment where you're like, yeah, and here's the logic and like, yeah, I'd probably do it again. It's. It's. To me, that is trickle down. That is what this organization reinforces over and over. We don't admit mistakes. You know what? This is something you're seeing all over the place these days. You look around, people just don't want to admit mistakes. They just keep saying, if I keep lying and telling you over and over again it's right, eventually you will believe it. No, that was a mistake. I know because I saw you walk back. I mean, I would have rather see. I want to see Wells try to defend not knowing how many outs there are.

[Ty Butler]

Yo, but fan, there should have been.

[Peter Rosenberg]

There should have been three outs.

[Ty Butler]

Boone took him underneath the duck underneath the dugout and had a conversation with him and you. And you showed up after the game. And to your point, like, even if you felt like the logic made sense, you got to read the room on the season overall, our team has been making a bunch of mistakes. I've got to make this sound better. Than it did. Listen, this is what I intended to do. It did not work out. I regret it. It won't happen again. What's wrong with that?

[Peter Rosenberg]

I got another answer for you. Here you go. I'm going to hedge it a little bit. It could still work. I'm not sure if I would do that next time. I just hope that whatever. Whatever I attempted to do, I make the right decision next time. We can't have outs like that.

[Ty Butler]

See, we just can't.

[Peter Rosenberg]

That's it. Is it that hard?

[Ty Butler]

It also makes. Forget how bad it makes Chisholm look. It makes his manager look bad. And that's the biggest problem.

[Peter Rosenberg]

They've done that to him, by the way. Yo. No. With the exception of basically Judge, who generally makes Boone look good, the amount of players on this team that have accidentally made Boone look bad over the last few years, even though he protects you constantly, is crazy. I don't think they realize how often they've accidentally thrown him under the bus. And by the way, I do want to take this time because I did miss it when I was gone to say how horribly sad I was that it didn't work out for Marcus Stroman here. Oh, man. Couldn't have happened. Couldn't happen to a better guy. Seems like he might be a legendary Yankee. I mean, yesterday they were showing one of his classic performances. Yeah, you talk about something age bad, yo. Marcus Stroman, respectfully, he's from Long island, my man. Between the Mets and the Yankees. Shouldn't even show up to grab a slice of pizza in New York. Like, it didn't work out here, my guy.

[Ty Butler]

It's. It's all good, right? Because he's still getting paid. The biggest story there is Cashmere's still paying him. And that's money that your owner is giving you to field a championship roster, and you're not able to get it done because they released them. Stroman still counts. Again, not a cap, but he's still getting paid his money. So go ahead, get your jokes off. But me, the Yankee fan, I'm mad that that is.

[Peter Rosenberg]

That was money you decided to spend.

[Ty Butler]

Yeah, that's the wrong distribution of financial resources.

[Peter Rosenberg]

And that was actually after Cashman already thought once Stroman's probably not the guy, then desperate times, desperate measures. Well, I'm gonna give him. What was it, $30 million, whatever the number was they gave him. And now you're paying for his Louis Vuitton do rags to put under the next hat one of the worst looks in baseball. I'VE seen in a long time, I would say.

[Ty Butler]

But then you missed it. He posted a picture of him on a private jet or whatever just to show I'm good. I'm chilling.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Always. Always.

[Ty Butler]

He had to. He just had to.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Yo. He. Oh, he has a special kind of annoying dookie that Marcus Stroman ever just whenever you see bad guy. Duke University is not far now. Guys, real quick. I have an ad by BetterHelp. These days it feels like there's a vice on everything. Do cold plunges, gratitude journals, screen detoxes. But how do you know what actually works for you? With the Internet and information overload about mental health and wellness, it can be a struggle to know what's true and what actions to take these days. All right, therapy has been super helpful for me and it could be helpful for you as well. Okay? Trust me now. Therapy can do so many different things. Personal life, professional, just help you relax. And in better Help man, over 30,000 therapists, the world's largest online therapy platform serving over 5 million people globally. Convenient too. You can join a session with a therapist at the click of a button, helping you fit therapy into your busy life, plus switch therapists at any time. As the largest online therapy provider in the world, BetterHelp can provide access to mental health professionals with a diverse variety of expertise. Unwind from work with BetterHelp, our listeners get 10% off their first month at betterhelp.com timeout. That's betterhelp.com timeout. Thanks for listening to the Don Hahn and Rosenberg podcast. I don't want to know how this all messages made, but I just want to know.

[Ty Butler]

It's good.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Hear more of Don Allen and Peter weekday afternoon starting at 3 on 8 80, ESPN, the ESPN New York app and your smart speakers.

[Ty Butler]

This isn't just another ESPN fantasy football season.

[Peter Rosenberg]

It's your shot at greatness.

[Ty Butler]

With a refreshed design, the ESPN Fantasy app is sharper than ever. So you can draft like a pro and dominate your league. And introducing Gridiron Gauntlet, a new game mode where the best compete to be crowned the number one fantasy football player of 2025. One app, one shot, one champion.

[Peter Rosenberg]

Download the ESPN fantasy app and sign.

[Ty Butler]

Up to play ESPN Fantasy Football today.