Don, Hahn & Rosenberg Podcast Summary: Hour 2: Analytics & The List
Release Date: July 2, 2025

In this engaging episode of the "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg" podcast, hosts Don La Greca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the intricacies of Major League Baseball analytics, focusing on the New York Yankees and Mets. Later in the episode, they pivot to a lighter segment, presenting their curated list of the top five American rock bands. Below is a detailed summary capturing all key discussions, insights, and notable quotes.

1. MLB Analytics: Yankees and Mets Under the Microscope

A. Mets' Recent Struggles and Bullpen Woes

The episode kicks off with a recap of the Mets' disappointing 7-2 loss to the Brewers. Peter Rosenberg laments the team's inability to maintain leads, highlighting starter Clay Holmes' respectable five innings pitched but critiquing the bullpen's collapse:

Peter Rosenberg [01:20]: "Holmes got that. But then they go immediately to the bullpen and it all goes to crap..."

B. Comparative Analysis: Mets and Yankees

Rosenberg and Hahn discuss the broader landscape of MLB, noting a trend of parity where even historically strong teams like the Yankees and Mets exhibit significant flaws. They question whether this is indicative of a systemic issue within the league:

Peter Rosenberg [04:58]: "As much as the Mets and Yankees are not playing great, they're going to stay in this thing because that's because they added the extra wild card."

C. Roster Construction Critiques

A significant portion of the conversation centers on the Yankees' roster decisions, particularly the utilization of DJ LeMahieu. Rosenberg argues that playing players out of position undermines team performance:

Peter Rosenberg [08:51]: "To justify his salary. Well, is that ego? Is that what's best for the team?"

Hahn echoes these sentiments, emphasizing concerns over the effectiveness of the Yankees' substantial payroll:

Don Hahn [09:12]: "Is his money being spent wisely? Is his money being spent effectively?"

D. Offensive Inefficiencies

The hosts delve into the Yankees' offensive challenges, especially their inability to capitalize on scoring opportunities with runners in scoring positions:

Don Hahn [12:57]: "If that's a problem at some point, don't you change the approach?"

E. Defensive Alignments and Managerial Decisions

Discussions also touch upon defensive alignments under Yankees' manager Aaron Boone, with Rosenberg criticizing the reliance on analytics over on-field performance:

Peter Rosenberg [14:20]: "Aaron Boone... is blind because he's looking at the stupid numbers instead of his eyeballs."

2. The List: Top Five American Rock Bands

Transitioning from sports, the podcast segues into their much-anticipated "List" segment, where Hahn and Rosenberg debate and finalize their top five American rock bands. The criteria focus on bands formed in the U.S. with significant influence and enduring popularity.

A. #5: Aerosmith

Selected for their longevity and classic hits, Aerosmith garners a spot despite mixed personal preferences:

Peter Rosenberg [26:20]: "Even though I'm not a huge fan of them, it's hard not to have Aerosmith in the top five."

B. #4: Chicago

Chicago is praised for their extensive catalog and ability to evolve over decades:

Don Hahn [29:43]: "Chicago. Good one, three."

C. #3: Van Halen

Honored for their dynamic sound and influential presence in the rock scene, Van Halen's versatility and hit tracks secure their place:

Peter Rosenberg [29:50]: "I'm gonna go with you, Allen. I'm sorry. Van Halen."

D. #2: Beach Boys

The Beach Boys are celebrated for their iconic status and timeless music that continues to resonate across generations:

Don Hahn [27:06]: "They have two greatest hits albums. Yeah."

E. #1: Eagles

Topping the list, the Eagles are recognized as a quintessential American band with unmatched success and influence in rock music:

Peter Rosenberg [31:26]: "The Eagles, that's a quintessential American band."

F. Honorable Mentions

Several bands receive honorable mentions for their contributions, including Pearl Jam, REM, Metallica, Grand Funk Railroad, and Kiss, each noted for their unique impact and legacy.

3. Listener Interaction and Final Thoughts

The hosts engage with audience feedback, debating potential additions to the list and acknowledging the subjective nature of such rankings. They encourage listeners to share their opinions, emphasizing the diversity of musical tastes.

Don Hahn [35:03]: "You guys Mentioned Beach Boys at one, Chicago at four, and Aerosmith at five."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Peter Rosenberg [08:36]: "But every year we have the same conversation with the Yankees. You know, who's playing left field."
• Don Hahn [09:12]: "Is his money being spent wisely? Is his money being spent effectively?"
• Peter Rosenberg [14:20]: "Aaron Boone... is blind because he's looking at the stupid numbers instead of his eyeballs."
• Peter Rosenberg [26:20]: "Even though I'm not a huge fan of them, it's hard not to have Aerosmith in the top five."
• Peter Rosenberg [31:26]: "The Eagles, that's a quintessential American band."

Conclusion

This episode masterfully balances analytical discourse on baseball team strategies and performance with a passionate exploration of American rock music. Listeners gain insightful perspectives on MLB team dynamics and enjoy a well-argued list of America's top rock bands, complete with engaging debates and relatable commentary.

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the essence of the "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg" podcast episode, providing a clear and detailed overview for those who haven't tuned in.