Podcast Summary: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg – Hour 2: Giants Sign Winston

Release Date: March 24, 2025

Hosts:

• Don La Greca – ESPN New York and New Jersey Legend
• Alan Hahn – Long-time Sportswriter and New York Knicks Broadcaster
• Peter Rosenberg – Highly Opinionated Hip Hop Vet and WWE Personality

I. Introduction to the Episode

The episode begins with casual banter among the hosts, seamlessly transitioning into the primary topic of discussion: the New York Giants' recent signing of quarterback Jameis Winston. The conversation is lively, reflecting the hosts' deep engagement with current sports events.

II. New York Giants Sign Jameis Winston

Alan Hahn initiates the main discussion by highlighting the significance of the Giants signing Jameis Winston amidst the ongoing NFL draft chaos.

• [05:23] Alan Hahn: "Listen, we just wanted to look because baseball season's about to start and there's a lot of questions. I don't know what's going to happen."

Peter Rosenberg expresses skepticism about Winston's long-term impact on the Giants.

• [07:21] Peter Rosenberg: "Let me explain this to people. ... For $4 million a year, guys, it's a no brainer and it doesn't change the landscape at all because they needed another body in the room."

Alan Hahn discusses the Giants' quarterback strategy, emphasizing that Winston serves as a temporary solution while the team awaits potential draft picks or other veteran signings.

• [09:23] Alan Hahn: "Why are you laughing, Peter?"

Peter Rosenberg elaborates on the financial and strategic benefits of signing Winston, despite his mixed performance statistics.

• [09:36] Peter Rosenberg: "Honestly, it's calling at this point, Alan, for that price. My ... Jameis Winston's going to make four."

Jordan Renan, a guest analyst, adds depth to the conversation by outlining the Giants' multifaceted quarterback strategies, including mentorship and veteran support.

• [30:10] Jordan Renan: "They're going to add as many bodies at the position as possible. That's the conclusion that I've come to here."

Chris Canty, another guest, offers insights into Winston's role as a mentor for younger quarterbacks within the team.

• [29:34] Chris Canty: "Jameis Winston is the pace guard for whatever quarterback that they draft."

III. NFL Draft and Giants’ Quarterback Strategy

The discussion delves into the complexities of the NFL draft, particularly how it affects the Giants' quarterback decisions.

Alan Hahn critiques the unpredictability of the draft and the challenges it poses for the Giants.

• [15:07] Alan Hahn: "It's the biggest sham going is the NFL draft and the NBA draft."

Peter Rosenberg shares his frustrations with the draft process, emphasizing the inconsistency between player performance and draft expectations.

• [15:32] Peter Rosenberg: "They are now reaching the point where the BS is being filtered out and the reality is setting in."

Caller Dave from Westchester voices his skepticism about the Giants drafting Shador Sanders, fearing it won't address the team's immediate needs.

• [19:56] Caller Dave: "I just don't want to get into over on the radio. I just, I don't want to. I don't think he's all that great."

Alan Hahn responds by highlighting the long-term benefits of drafting players like Sanders, even if it doesn't yield immediate results.

• [21:10] Alan Hahn: "Well, you're not going to win. You're not going to win right away, Dave."

IV. Callers’ Perspectives on the Giants’ Quarterback Situation

Engaging with the audience, the hosts take calls that provide diverse viewpoints on the Giants' quarterback decisions.

Caller Dave is critical of Shador Sanders, questioning his abilities and suitability for the Giants.

• [20:20] Caller Dave: "I just don't think he's all that great. I'd rather get the quarterback next year and take Abdul."

Caller C.J. from Brooklyn supports the Giants' strategy, believing that Shador Sanders fits well within the team's quarterback-centric approach.

• [45:06] Caller C.J.: "I think they would do well to get him ahead of the Giants."

V. Strategic Analysis and Future Prospects

The hosts analyze the Giants' current strategies and speculate on future moves, considering various scenarios based on draft outcomes and player performances.

Alan Hahn and Peter Rosenberg debate whether the Giants are truly committed to finding a long-term quarterback solution or merely buying time through temporary signings.

• [35:16] Alan Hahn: "Don, that's not on the table. That's not."
• [35:19] Peter Rosenberg: "But I know, I don't think it is either."

Jordan Renan reinforces the idea that the Giants are focusing on multiple fronts, signing veterans and accumulating talent to strengthen their roster.

• [32:38] Jordan Renan: "That seems to be the plan here at the quarterback."

VI. Additional Sports Discussions

While the primary focus remains on the Giants, the episode touches upon other sports topics, including NBA games and player performances.

Alan Hahn discusses Anthony Davis' return to the court, reflecting on his significance for the Lakers.

• [41:38] Peter Rosenberg: "Anthony Davis plans to play tonight."
• [41:48] Peter Rosenberg: "It's his first since February 8th."

The hosts also reminisce about past sports strategies and slogans, adding a nostalgic touch to the episode.

VII. Conclusion and Final Thoughts

As the episode wraps up, the hosts summarize their thoughts on the Giants' quarterback situation, emphasizing the importance of strategic planning and adaptability.

Alan Hahn concludes that the Giants' lack of a clear plan entering the offseason may lead to further complications in their quarterback endeavors.

• [39:44] Alan Hahn: "The lack of plan going into this offseason that we're starting to see unravel might be the bigger story."

Peter Rosenberg agrees, stressing the uncertainty surrounding the draft and its impact on the Giants' future.

• [39:35] Peter Rosenberg: "I don't think they're going to take a quarterback. That's why I'm dubious on the whole."

Jordan Renan reiterates the necessity for the Giants to build their roster meticulously to secure a successful future.

• [32:50] Jordan Renan: "That seems to be the plan here at the quarterback."

Notable Quotes with Timestamps

• Alan Hahn [05:23]: "But no one wants to hear it, it's still waiting for Aaron Rodgers."
• Peter Rosenberg [07:21]: "For $4 million a year, guys, it's a no brainer."
• Peter Rosenberg [09:36]: "Honestly, it's calling at this point, Alan, for that price."
• Chris Canty [29:46]: "Jameis Winston is the pace guard for whatever quarterback that they draft."
• Caller Dave [20:20]: "I just don't think he's all that great. I'd rather get the quarterback next year and take Abdul."
• Caller C.J. [45:06]: "I think they would do well to get him ahead of the Giants."
• Alan Hahn [39:44]: "The lack of plan going into this offseason might be the bigger story."
• Peter Rosenberg [35:16]: "But I know, I don't think it is either."

Episode Highlights

• Giants' Strategy: The signing of Jameis Winston serves as a stopgap measure while the team navigates the complexities of the NFL draft.
• Draft Uncertainty: The unpredictability of the draft makes it challenging for the Giants to formulate a long-term quarterback plan.
• Audience Engagement: Diverse caller opinions reflect the community's varied perspectives on the Giants' decisions.
• Future Projections: Hosts and guests speculate on potential outcomes based on draft scenarios and player performances.
• Broader Sports Context: Discussions extend beyond football, touching upon significant NBA events and player returns.

Conclusion

This episode of "Don, Hahn & Rosenberg" offers a comprehensive analysis of the New York Giants' quarterback situation amidst a tumultuous NFL draft period. Through insightful discussions, guest contributions, and engaging audience interactions, the hosts provide listeners with a nuanced understanding of the challenges and possibilities facing the Giants. The episode underscores the importance of strategic planning and adaptability in professional sports, making it a valuable listen for fans seeking in-depth sports analysis.