Podcast Summary: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg – "Hour 3: Alonso the Forever Met?"

Released on June 11, 2025

In this engaging episode of the Don, Hahn & Rosenberg podcast, hosts Don Hahn, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the New York Mets' current season, focusing primarily on superstar Pete Alonso and his potential to become a "Forever Met." The conversation is rich with insights, debates, and fan perspectives, making it a must-listen for Mets enthusiasts and baseball aficionados alike.

Mets' Current Performance and Standings

The episode kicks off with a detailed analysis of the Mets' recent performance. Peter Rosenberg provides a comprehensive breakdown of the latest game against the Nationals, highlighting key moments and player contributions.

Peter Rosenberg [01:05]: "The big hit from Alonzo scores. Soto with a tying run. And then they get the McNeil RBI single in the bottom half of the 10th inning."

Rosenberg emphasizes the Mets' standing in the National League, noting their significant lead over the Phillies and the struggling Nationals and Braves.

Peter Rosenberg [02:37]: "The Mets have the best record in the National League."

Pete Alonso's Performance and Contract Discussions

A significant portion of the discussion centers around Pete Alonso's exceptional performance and the Mets' considerations for his future with the team. The hosts debate whether the Mets should secure Alonso with a long-term contract to ensure he remains a cornerstone of the franchise.

Caller Pete [08:01]: "Do the Mets try to sign him now to a contract and lock them up, just like the Yankees should have tried to do with Soto because, you know, once he went to free agency, was going to be a free for all."

Peter Rosenberg argues in favor of Alonso staying with the Mets, drawing parallels to beloved Mets legends and the importance of having a "forever" player.

Peter Rosenberg [12:23]: "He is for us because of what he brings. Especially if this team competes for a championship or wins the championship."

Alan Hahn echoes this sentiment, emphasizing Alonso's role and the perfect timing for his potential contract extension.

Alan Hahn [27:44]: "He should get the opportunity to be here forever."

Comparisons with Past Mets Legends

The hosts compare Alonso to past Mets legends like Andre Dawson and David Wright, discussing the qualities that make a player a beloved "forever Met." They explore how Alonso's connection with the fans and his on-field performance position him to surpass previous icons.

Peter Rosenberg [25:19]: "He will go down as the greatest everyday Met of all time."

They also reflect on the Mets' history of losing key players to free agency and trades, underlining the missed opportunities and the lasting impact on the fanbase.

Peter Rosenberg [15:31]: "But one of the biggest mistakes the Mets ever made was letting Ray Knight go."

Fan Perspectives and Caller Inputs

Throughout the episode, fans call in to share their views on Alonso's future and the Mets' potential strategies. These interactions add depth to the discussion, showcasing diverse opinions within the fanbase.

Caller Evan [31:00]: "If Pete Alonso were to leave, it would give me the same feeling as when Daniel Murphy walked after his big playoff run."

Another caller, Sonny, expresses skepticism about Alonso fitting into other teams, highlighting his unique connection with the Mets.

Caller Sonny [43:39]: "I absolutely hate the thought of Alonso coming here. I think his personality is a little bit weird. I don't know if he's gonna fit with the guys."

Other Topics: All-Star Selections and NBA Updates

While the primary focus remains on Pete Alonso, the hosts briefly touch upon other subjects, including All-Star Game selections and potential coaching moves in the NBA. They discuss the Mets' prospects for All-Star honors and the Knicks' interest in NBA coach Quinn Snyder.

Peter Rosenberg [33:07]: "Edwin Diaz, Bodhi Regrett, Francisco Alonso. Now, it's always dicey when you get to relievers..."

Additionally, the conversation shifts to speculative NBA trades involving Kevin Durant, with callers debating the potential impact on the Knicks' roster and championship aspirations.

Caller Adam [42:10]: "I think it would be a disaster to trade for Durant. He hasn’t led a team to the next level since Golden State."

Conclusion

As the episode wraps up, the hosts reiterate the significance of securing Pete Alonso's future with the Mets to maintain team continuity and fan loyalty. They emphasize the balance between financial considerations and emotional investments that define franchise decisions.

Peter Rosenberg [14:07]: "Are you really going to nickel and dime and play the stupid analytics game? Are you going to say, you know what, he's special and he is going to end his career as my first baseman."

The episode concludes with a reminder of upcoming events and promotions, encouraging listeners to stay engaged with the team and the podcast.

Key Takeaways:

• Pete Alonso's Impact: Alonso is central to the Mets' success this season, with discussions on his performance and the necessity of a long-term contract to make him a "Forever Met."

• Team Standings: The Mets lead the National League with a significant gap over competitors, positioning them as strong contenders for the postseason.

• Fan Engagement: Caller insights highlight the passionate and diverse opinions within the Mets' fanbase regarding team management and player retention.

• Historical Context: Comparisons to past Mets legends underscore the importance of building a lasting legacy through player loyalty and strategic decisions.

This episode offers a thorough exploration of the Mets' current trajectory, the pivotal role of Pete Alonso, and the intricate balance between business decisions and fan loyalty. Whether you're a die-hard Mets fan or a casual baseball enthusiast, "Hour 3: Alonso the Forever Met?" provides valuable insights and spirited discussions that resonate with the heart of New York sports culture.