Don, Hahn & Rosenberg - Hour 3: Bullpen Confidence (August 1, 2025)

Introduction

In this engaging episode of the Don, Hahn & Rosenberg podcast, hosts Don Hahn, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the intricacies of Major League Baseball’s bullpen dynamics, the perennial Yankees-Mets rivalry, and pivot seamlessly into captivating discussions on music preferences and New York Knicks' latest moves. Listeners are treated to a blend of sports analysis, light-hearted banter, and insightful commentary, making it a must-listen for enthusiasts who thrive on both sports and entertainment.

Bullpen Confidence: Yankees vs. Mets

The episode opens with an in-depth analysis of the Yankees and Mets bullpens, sparked by a listener's observation about the Yankees' bullpen depth compared to the Mets.

Alan Hahn initiates the conversation by referencing a listener’s comment, stating, “Anthony’s more checked out than we are” ([00:56]), reflecting on the initial misprint of game times which hinted at underlying concerns about player performance and team focus.

Peter Rosenberg counters by highlighting the reliability and depth of the Mets bullpen, emphasizing key players like Diaz, Bednar, Duval, and Devin Williams. He asserts, “I think the Mets know they have a closer... He was an All-Star at that position now” ([02:15]). This comment underscores the Mets' strategic confidence in their bullpen strength.

Anthony (Michael) expresses skepticism about Devin Williams’ consistency, questioning his performance under pressure: “he’s walking a tightrope all the freaking time” ([04:32]). This concerns reflect the uncertainty that often shadows bullpen performances, especially in high-stakes games.

The discussion further evolves with Rosenberg exploring the Mets’ bullpen strategy, noting the importance of having multiple reliable arms: “If you have a bullpen that's deep, but I can't have it every night in the regular season, I'm going to wear these guys out” ([13:19]). This highlights the delicate balance teams must maintain between regular season stamina and postseason readiness.

Listener Call: Representing Multiple Teams

A notable segment involves a listener, Alberto, who shares his experience of attending a baseball trip wearing a Yankees jersey while supporting multiple teams. Anthony critiques this behavior, stating, “why are you wearing a Yankees dude?... you’re not saying, hey, I’m a baseball fan” ([29:50]). This sparks a vibrant debate about team loyalty and the perceptions of fans representing teams in regions where they are not playing.

Rosenberg offers a broader perspective, reminiscing about his experiences with other sports teams: “I remember Devil games... people wearing other jerseys” ([32:03]). This anecdote emphasizes how fandom can transcend team rivalries, though it occasionally leads to misunderstandings or perceived disrespect among rival fanbases.

Music Preferences: Country and Reggae

Transitioning from sports, the hosts dive into a spirited debate about music genres, particularly country music. Anthony and Rosenberg engage in a humorous yet critical exchange about the repetitiveness and stereotypical elements of country music.

Rosenberg expresses his disdain, “country music sounds exactly the same” ([22:39]), while Anthony defends its seasonal appeal: “there's a lot of country songs that are perfect for summer vacation” ([22:56]). Their banter highlights the generational and personal taste differences that often surface in casual conversations.

The discussion takes a nostalgic turn as they reminisce about making mixtapes and the evolution of music consumption: “you can go in and... pick like 10 songs and then they would make a mixtape for you” ([26:23]). This segment not only provides entertainment but also connects with listeners through shared memories of pre-digital music eras.

New York Knicks: Mikhail Bridges’ Extension

Returning to sports, the hosts shift focus to the New York Knicks, specifically discussing the recent contract extension of Mikhail Bridges.

Anthony provides a comprehensive overview of the extension: “the extension that Mikhail Bridges agreed to with the Knicks for $150 million for the next four years” ([38:38]). He explains the strategic significance of this move, emphasizing how it secures Bridges within the team's salary cap constraints: “it's not just about keeping DH free for Stanton” ([43:42]).

Rosenberg agrees, highlighting the importance of continuity and stability in the Knicks’ roster: “having him around and having him on this team and the stability of a starting five” ([44:20]). This discussion underscores the broader theme of team building and financial management in professional sports.

Giannis Antetokounmpo Trade Speculations

A significant portion of the episode is dedicated to the ongoing speculations surrounding Giannis Antetokounmpo and his potential trade from the Milwaukee Bucks.

Anthony expresses frustration over the Knicks' inability to secure Giannis: “the Knicks have no shot at getting Giannis” ([44:04]). He elaborates on the contractual and strategic barriers preventing this high-profile trade, noting Giannis’ commitment to Milwaukee through 2028: “Giannis isn't going anywhere for the next two seasons” ([44:17]).

Rosenberg adds depth to the conversation by discussing the dynamics of trade requests and organizational responses: “if he came to them and said, I’m really not happy, I want out...” ([44:07]). This insight provides listeners with an understanding of the complexities involved in trading superstar players and the long-term planning that teams like the Knicks must undertake.

Conclusion

The episode concludes with the hosts reflecting on the various discussions, tying together the themes of sports strategy, fan culture, and personal preferences. Their lively interactions and expert analyses offer listeners a well-rounded perspective on current sports events and cultural topics.

Don Hahn wraps up by encouraging listeners to stay engaged and tune in for more insightful discussions: “Hear more of Don Allen and Peter weekday afternoon starting at 3 on 880, ESPN” ([35:20]).

Notable Quotes

• Anthony on Devin Williams’ Performance: “he’s walking a tightrope all the freaking time” ([04:32])
• Rosenberg on Mets’ Bullpen: “I think the Mets know they have a closer... He was an All-Star at that position now” ([02:15])
• Anthony on Representing Teams: “why are you wearing a Yankees dude?... you’re not saying, hey, I’m a baseball fan” ([29:50])
• Rosenberg on Bulls' Strategy: “if you have a bullpen that's deep, but I can't have it every night in the regular season, I'm going to wear these guys out” ([13:19])
• Anthony on Knicks’ Bridges Extension: “the extension that Mikhail Bridges agreed to with the Knicks for $150 million for the next four years” ([38:38])

Final Thoughts

Don, Hahn & Rosenberg - Hour 3: Bullpen Confidence masterfully balances expert sports analysis with relatable banter, creating a dynamic and informative listening experience. Whether you're a die-hard baseball fan, a Knicks supporter, or simply enjoy lively discussions on music and culture, this episode offers valuable insights and entertainment that resonate well beyond the final whistle.