Loading summary
Don Hahn
McDonald's meets the Minecraft universe with one of six collectibles and your choice of a Big Mac or 10 piece McNuggets with spicy nether flame sauce. Now available with a Minecraft movie meal.
Peter Rosenberg
At participating McDonald's for a limited time. A Minecraft movie only in theaters. This is the Don Hahn and Rosenberg podcast.
Don Hahn
That sounds like heaven to me.
Peter Rosenberg
Listen live weekday afternoon starting at 3 on 880 ESPN, the ESPN New York app and your smart speakers. Oh yeah, my blank is blank bigger than yours. Oh boy, that's unfortunate.
Don Hahn
What?
Peter Rosenberg
$50,000 because his blank is bigger than yours. Oh man.
Don Hahn
What was that in reference to what.
Peter Rosenberg
We talked about earlier? This is Michael the other day talking about the Anthony Edwards conversation. My blank is bigger than yours.
Don Hahn
Oh, that was what the caller was referring to.
Peter Rosenberg
That's right.
Don Hahn
That was awkward.
Peter Rosenberg
That's unfortunate. What happened there? Clown show.
Don Hahn
Oh, wait a minute now.
Peter Rosenberg
It's another day, another couple wins, the local baseball teams. And you got to be feeling pretty good right now if you're a fan of either. But particularly New York Mets who are now 18 and 7, 12 and 1 at home. And let's talk to the people, Don. Let's, let's spend this 5 o'clock hour diving in because listen, we really, obviously we have a huge Nick game tomorrow, but we did basically wall to wall Knicks all day yesterday and we're going.
Don Hahn
To do it all day tomorrow and draft tomorrow.
Peter Rosenberg
We got a lot of Knicks, a lot of draft. So today leaning in on the baseball, which is pretty, pretty exciting at this exact moment. Now let's go to Alex who wants to weigh in on the judge Jeter conversation we've been having. What's up, Alex?
Caller Alex
Hey, what's up, guys? Don, how are you?
Don Hahn
Good. How are you, buddy?
Caller Alex
Good. Yeah. I just want to say something, I think people don't respect like your baseball knowledge and how like smart you are about the sport. I think you're 100% right. I think Judge is a way better player than Jeter by a mile. You know what, how many great players were surrounded by Jeter? Like great players. You can name like a dozen, right? How many like great, good, like on the same level. Players that were surrounded by Jeter are surrounded by Aaron Judge. Like not many, you know, and very few. He's, and, and he's like the guy that like we all look to to win a World Series and like bring us there. But like at the end of the.
Caller Carl
Day, like, I hate to say this.
Caller Alex
But I agree with people. If Jeter was on The Royals, nobody would know who he was, sorry to say.
Don Hahn
Well, they'd know who he was, but he wouldn't. He wouldn't have gone into. He wouldn't have been. He would have been underappreciated because he wouldn't have had the grand stage of the postseason to show off. I'm not here to beat up Derek Jeter. He was an amazing hall of Fame player and he was very clutch. Way better in the postseason than Judge has been so far. But the better players, Aaron Judge, and if you're a scout and these two guys were in the draft, you're taking Judge over Jeter. You just are. Guy's got a gun for an arm. He's an A plus defender, hits home runs, gets on base. He does everything exceptionally well. And he's also a very good leader. All right. Derek Jeter played for the Kansas City Royals. You'd know who he was. If you were a die hard baseball fan, you'd appreciate him. He'd have his 3,000 hits, he'd go to the hall of Fame, but he would not have all of the accolades that he has in the postseason because maybe he would never go to the postseason if he was a Pirate, if he was a Royal, if he was a Brewer, the way he went with. He was with the Yankees. But I give him credit, Peter. When he got to the postseason, he raked. He always came up with big hits. He was clutch, no question. I can't argue with that. He's way more clutch than Judges so far. But the better ballplayer.
Peter Rosenberg
Yeah.
Don Hahn
Is that in Judge?
Peter Rosenberg
To me, it's not really close.
Don Hahn
I don't even know why it's an argument, honestly.
Peter Rosenberg
Carl in West Babylon. Hey, Carl.
Caller Carl
Hey.
Don Hahn
How you guys doing? Good, man. Good. Yeah. First with Richard from Manhattan. I mean, I. I can't be the only listener that thinks I'd rather get a root canal from him than have to listen to him on the radio some days because he is painful.
Peter Rosenberg
I disagree. I disagree strongly, but go ahead.
Caller Carl
I'm hearing he has a cult following.
Don Hahn
I'll give you that. But, oh, some of his takes, and they make it people waiting in the room.
Peter Rosenberg
Well, that's a tough one to get up from there.
Don Hahn
There's no defense of that. But the other reason, the extra reason why I was calling this the whole Aaron Judge thing, I mean, it's not even close. Who's the better player again? Who would you want? I guess, you know, bottom of ninth, bases loaded, is going to be Jeter, hands down. 10 out of 10 times.
Caller Alex
But it doesn't make him a better overall player.
Don Hahn
And I. You know, Peter, I think you were real bringing that up. It's. It's, you know, postseason is one thing. I get it. But he's not a better overall player than. But these Yankee fans are all about the chip. And that's what started the conversation of the beginning. Carl, thanks for the call. Is that. Appreciate the greatness of Aaron Judge. But the first thing you want to do is, well, wait till October. And he doesn't have any rings. Like, all right, so I get that. And if you want to beat him up in October, be more than willing to do that. But sitting here in April, turning on a Yankee game, you don't enjoy watching this guy play. And he says all the right things. He doesn't embarrass you, but yet all you're thinking about is the ring. I don't want to say I feel sorry for you because your team does win. And I'm not going to say I feel sorry for somebody because they happen to root for a good team, but I feel sorry for you in the sense of you can't appreciate the moment that it's all about the rings. And then after the ring, Peter. Well, win me another one. I got news for you.
Peter Rosenberg
I know it's not going to end.
Don Hahn
I know Aaron Judge is not going to win five rings. No, he's going to run out of road. All right? He's already 30, what, 2 years old? Whatever he is, he's not going to hang around long enough to get five rings. He may not get one. So he'll never be Derek Jeter in the eyes of those fans. But you can't appreciate the greatness that you're seeing day in and day out.
Peter Rosenberg
Let's go to Richard. Manhattan.
Don Hahn
Oh, there you go. Yeah, this makes sense.
Peter Rosenberg
Richard. Richard.
Don Hahn
Was he taken aback by what was said in the previous call?
Peter Rosenberg
I don't know. Let's go to Fake Richard. How about that?
Don Hahn
Okay. Fake Richard never disappoint.
Peter Rosenberg
Fake Richard of Manhattan. Hey.
Caller Fake Richard
I'll be with you in one. Just wait there. Just. Just wait. Wait and chat. Wait. I'll be right in. I just. I gotta run and do something really quick. Really quick. I'll be. I'll be right back.
Don Hahn
Finish. Peter. Don, you there? Yeah, yeah. Yep. Hey, Richard.
Caller Fake Richard
How's it. How's it going, fellas? How's it going?
Peter Rosenberg
By the way, that's something you got to work on, on your impression. He never asks us how we're doing. Yeah, never. Go ahead.
Don Hahn
There's already 10 times more interaction.
Peter Rosenberg
Go ahead, Richard.
Don Hahn
All right.
Caller Fake Richard
A couple. A couple of sports things and then I got to get to yesterday's. Yesterday's show. First off, okay, Alan gave an interview with Carmelo Anthony during the scheme the other night.
Don Hahn
And.
Caller Fake Richard
And it had me reminiscing about Frost. Nixon. All right. It was the most incredible interview I've ever seen. I only wish you would have asked Carmelo about his new weed venture, though. Would have been great. Two, Don, this is for your father. With the NFL draft tomorrow. The very first draft pick by the end, New York Giants, was art Smith in 1936 out of the University of Ohio, Art Lewis. Sorry about that. Art Lewis, University of Iowa offensive lineman. Now to yesterday first. Never heard of him before. Before yesterday. Gotta tell you, though, went down the rabbit hole. Pun intended. Very interesting stuff. Now, if it was up to me, I think I would make a great squirrel. Think of me with that big, beautiful tail coming off the back. And the best thing about it is Amazon has a squirrel suit. I send you a picture as soon as I get it.
Don Hahn
Oh, see? Referencing the furry moment from yesterday. Richard.
Peter Rosenberg
Are you talking about being a furry Richard?
Caller Fake Richard
Yes. The first and last Bronies. Completely different thing. 2013, I'm at a conference, a dental conference in Philadelphia. There's a BronyCon at the same hotel. Meet a whole bunch of Bronies. Incredible group of men. One of them gifted me a twilight sparkle. Look her up. She's incredible. Anytime I'm feeling unrelaxed and really upset, I sit down and I comb her hat. It's great. You guys should try it. And last thing before I go, if you really want to get into the weeds, Google clapping. All the best sellers. Have a good one.
Don Hahn
I don't know if that get through the firewall.
Peter Rosenberg
Say clopping.
Don Hahn
Clopping.
Peter Rosenberg
Is that. I don't know what that is.
Don Hahn
I don't know. You want to try your phone?
Peter Rosenberg
Well, it can't be that bad. He said it on the radio, right?
Don Hahn
Who knows? You think he cares?
Peter Rosenberg
It's a good point. It's not like he works here or anything. And he is fake. Richard, for God's sake.
Don Hahn
Anything. You're using the computer. Yeah, I don't think we got firewall.
Peter Rosenberg
Goodness. No, no, no, that's not. Yeah, no, I don't. I don't think it's. I don't think it's good. I don't think it's good. It's related to something. Still related to the Brony World. Don's coming over to look over my shoulder. Now it looks like it's a word in erotic My Little Pony fiction. So I guess fake Richard really did the deep dive, huh? He heard the furry and the brony talk, and he went a step further.
Don Hahn
The caller that said that I had. He was asking how big my shoes are for the clown shoes. Yeah, he does that.
Peter Rosenberg
Let's go to Griffin in Connecticut. Hey, Griffin, the Grift's there.
Caller Carl
Hey, guys. By the way, the guy. The guy probably has a bigger head than Michael, and all of it is probably awful hot air. It's nothing smart. Like Michael at least has smart things to say on the radio. That guy just has a bunch of. Of hot air in his head.
Peter Rosenberg
That's right. You know what? Absolutely right, Griffin. Son of a guy.
Caller Carl
I was going to talk about the hockey playoffs and how phenomenal there is, but this Peter and a Aaron Judge conversation is the same thing. I've gotten an argument with Yukon fans up here in Connecticut because I keep saying Paige is better than Rihanna Stewart, and people go, no, no, no, no, no, no, no. Because they're flowing in the rings. They're throwing in the rings. They only throw in rings. You can't have an argument with the. With the thing. If you're gonna say Jeter's better than Judge, you gotta show me something other than the rings. It's the same thing with the Stewie. They're just gonna throw in the four rings that Stewie has. I'm thinking myself, the things Paige can do, Stewie couldn't do. The things such does Jeter can't do.
Don Hahn
It's just, you guys, they gotta have.
Caller Carl
A conversation other than the ranks.
Peter Rosenberg
Yeah, no, I hear you, Griffin. It's not. It's. It's. It's. It's like a lame way to have a sports conversation. It just ultimately is a boy. Listen, if there are two players that are close, is it fair to use playoff performance to give one the lead? Hundred percent. Wouldn't you agree? Yes, but I think what Don is saying, it's not particularly close. Every single season, Aaron judges in the MVP conversation. Every single season, it's, is he the best player in baseball? And I do wonder. I don't want to rewrite history, Don. There may have been years in which Jeter was in that conversation, but it certainly wasn't nearly as often as it is with Judge.
Don Hahn
Let's say the Giants draft Arch Manning next year, and Arch Manning ends up being the next Patrick Mahomes, but doesn't win a Super bowl and actually doesn't perform well in the playoffs, but has 5,000 yard seasons, throws 50 touchdown passes, it's going to waltz into the hall of Fame. Our Giant fans going to still say, well, Eli was better. Now you could say, I'd rather have Eli in a big spot. Okay, if you want to say I'd rather have Derek Jeter in a big spot than Judge, I can understand that. But are you going to tell me that if Patrick Mahomes didn't win, Eli Manning would be a better quarterback because he won two rings and, and this imaginary quarterback that I'm making up that the Giants could draft next year didn't win and then he's out of the conversation like so Ernie Banks can't be a great player. Tony Gwynn can't be a great player.
Peter Rosenberg
Listen, just because a team, just because a player might get more cheered when they come back because they won championship. The bottom line is when you win championships, you give the fans these really happy memories. And as a result of those happy memories, you respond to them more when you see them. I get that part that doesn't make one a better athlete than another.
Don Hahn
The memory is very interesting, is that your memory, when you think of Derek Jeter, is going to go back to all those amazing moments in the postseason. The big hits, the Mr. November, the flip play. They're going to resonate with you. The regular season doesn't resonate as much as the postseason. And when you think of Aaron Judge, instead of thinking about the 62 home runs or thinking about great plays that he made or big hits that he had in the regular season, you're going to think about him dropping the ball in the fifth inning of the World Series. You're going to be thinking of striking out with the bases loaded. That's what your mind's going to go to because that's the post season. Those are the best. You're not going to remember arbitrary games in the middle of April or May. But it still does not take away from my general point that the better player over 162 games and over a career is going to be Aaron Judge. In my opinion. Can't say it now because Judges might not even be halfway through his career yet, but right now he's on a trajectory of being one of the great Yankees of all time, if not the greatest Yankee of all time. Honestly, as much as you love Derek Jeter, is he mantle, is he DiMaggio, is he Garrick, is he Ruth? No, he's not. He's got a ton of range.
Peter Rosenberg
You think he's fifth.
Don Hahn
He's probably fourth or fifth. And let's not forget about Rivera. But it's hard. He's not an everyday player. But honestly, is there anybody in the world that would take Derek jeter over Joe DiMaggio over Ruth Garrick, if you want to say Mantle, because he got hurt, okay. And those guys had a ton of rings too. But I'm just saying is that it's okay. Derek was a great player and he was a clutch player. And if you want to tell me in a big spot, I'd rather have Derek Jeter up than any other Yankee. Okay. Really can't argue with it. But really, who's the better player? Guys, honestly, who's the better player?
Peter Rosenberg
So in the end, Don, the New York Mets get a win and it was a Starling Marte single. And Marte has not been great. That did it sounded like this.
Don Hahn
The one. Oh, Marte. Broken back flare, shallow center, ducks in for a hit. Here comes Alonso. The throw from Stevenson on the way. Not in time. Alonso slides in safely. A Marte Partey RBI single, walk off. Win in the 10th. Four three Mets win. They sweep the homestand. A seven game winning streak. And Marte getting dunked on with water out near shortstop. They're trying to rip that jersey off. Hugs for Marte, who has won it in the 10th.
Peter Rosenberg
The ball player. Yeah, he was struggling.
Don Hahn
Love Keith Ratt. He's amazing. I put him up with any announcer and I'd allow him to watch my kids. Good person.
Peter Rosenberg
Wow.
Don Hahn
I would lose the Marte part. I don't like that. Not a fan, but you can't love everything somebody does. But Marte Parte?
Peter Rosenberg
No, I don't think I.
Don Hahn
You.
Peter Rosenberg
No.
Don Hahn
But great call. And the ripping of the jerseys too. I'm good on that as well. Every time it's got hugs immediately after. What are we doing?
Peter Rosenberg
Here's. Here's Mendoza on Marte's big play.
Caller
Really good. Really good. Especially because of what you're saying right now, you know, not an easy role for him now after being an elite player, you know, in this league for a long time and not getting results because I feel like the at bats have been there. We saw the first at bat today of Alvarado when he smokes a ball and right at the left fielder. And it's not easy, you know, when you're not getting enough playing time or enough at bat and just finding a way to stay ready and knowing that when you're coming into the game you're facing a pretty Pretty tough arm, most likely because it's a high leverage situation. But honestly, you got to give those guys credit because they continue to support him, to continue to have his back. You know, understanding this is a long season, you know, and at some point he's going to contribute. Sure enough, he did it today. It was good to see him come through and, you know, yeah, good to see that.
Peter Rosenberg
Now, how about the significance of beating the Phillies early in the season?
Caller
It's always good to win games, to win series, especially when you're playing within your division. But understanding it's only April and we're going to see those guys a lot more and they're good team, you know, we just happen to be playing really well. But I said it last night, it's going to be a fun summer. You know, the Braves are good, they're good. Like there's a lot of good team overall around the league, but we know we're good. We just gotta continue to take care of business and continue to control the things that we need to control.
Don Hahn
I would embrace the madness a little more. I just hate that it's early. We all know it's early. I got a calendar. I get it. The date's on my phone, it's on my Fitbit. I know it's April 23rd. I know we're only. What is it? They're 18 and 7, so we're not even 30 games into the year. But you know what? These games count, Peter. And if you're going to be in a death march at the end with Philadelphia, these three wins are going to be big because now Philadelphia is going to have to make up for it. They only play the Mets 10 more times. So I'm not apologizing for it to be too early. I don't care how early it is. If you're the best team in baseball, you're the best team in baseball. We all know how early it is. We all know that we're going to find out what this team is worth in the dog days and when we get to October. But right now, you ride this wave, man. It's not too often you're playing it. You're winning 72% of your games and have a five game lead in first place in the division.
Peter Rosenberg
Let's try Richard again. Richard.
Caller Richard
Hi, Peter. Hi, Don. Peter, you know I'm in 100% agreement with you. I don't know what the infatuation is to the NFL draft. I mean, just look at the Giants. They couldn't even figure out two guys in Their own building that they've seen Daniel Jones and Saquon Barkley. How are they going to figure out guys that played in college? I have no trust in any of these guys. It's just how the players develop and how the teams, what situations they go in. I really, I can't understand it, but people love this.
Peter Rosenberg
They love it, they love it.
Caller Richard
I don't understand it. Don Ovechkin, come on, his first overtime goal in the playoffs. That's a big thing. That's like LeBron hitting a game winning shot in the playoffs. So, you know, that's a big, big accomplishment. Two goals and an assist. Three points like that I think is great. Now, fellas, I don't understand the NBA schedule now. The Knicks and Pistons played on Monday night, all right? They go to Detroit. Why do they need two days off? Why are they playing Thursday and then they're in Detroit anyway and they're off Friday and Saturday? Why spread it out this much every day? They should be. You know, Peter, in the old days, if you were in Detroit, now you play back to back, you didn't have a day off. If you were in the city where you're playing the next game, you kept playing. And then you had one day off for travel or maybe California, two days off, but that was it. Why do they spread it out like that, Richard?
Don Hahn
Television. They want to make sure they've got X amount of games every day. So if you condense, and I understand it's frustrating, but if you condense these series, you might end up getting, if a series ends too quick, a dark night. And I'm not talking Batman, I'm talking like TNT or ESPN or ABC not having a game. And the NBA does not want to have that. They want to have at least a game, if not multiple games, every single night. And the way to do that is.
Caller Richard
This assures them of that, Don. That's why they do it this year.
Peter Rosenberg
Yeah, I mean, it stretches out every series. I mean, one last thing.
Don Hahn
Thank you, Don.
Caller Richard
Last thing. You got to tell Dave Maloney this, okay? And this is from a guy who's been watching sports 60 years. The greatest sports commercial ever. Don Maloney, Phil Esposito, Ron Dugay and Anders Hedberg on the Jordache jeans commercial. 1979, 1980. Did you. You've seen the commercial. Oh, la la Sassoon. Wow. Greatest commercial ever. Esposito was so great. Oh, one last thing.
Don Hahn
It was Dave, not Donnie. I think Dave was in.
Caller Richard
Oh, it was Dave. It was Dave. Okay, One last thing. You know, when I was growing up, I watched a lot of soccer and, of course, I watched hockey. And my girlfriend at that time, she. Her father loved soccer and loved hockey, but he hated two guys, both Italian guys, because they stood in front of the goal and never moved. And that's how they sc Phil Esposito and Giorgio Kenaglia. He hated China. He hated Esposito. Esposito never moved from the crease. Kinalia never went after the ball. He always stayed in front of the goaltender, looking to put in a rebounder. They played exactly the same game. Always a pleasure, fellas. Thank you.
Don Hahn
Yeah, the old bumper sticker they'd have in Boston all those years was, Jesus saves. Esposito scores on the rebound. And if you. He scored, like, over 700 goals. If you put all of the. Like, the distance between where he shot and where the goal was together for all 700, I'm not sure it would stretch across the ice. Like, yeah, they were all right in front of the goal. Didn't have to move.
Peter Rosenberg
Hey, guess what? That. That's a big part of winning hockey games. That's. I mean, how much we talk about that. Put the puck on the net, get right in front and jam it in.
Don Hahn
That's what.
Peter Rosenberg
That's what winning hockey looks like. Does it ever feel like you're a.
Don Hahn
Marketing professional just speaking into the Boyd?
Caller Ulysses
Well, with LinkedIn ads, you can know you're reaching the right decision makers.
Don Hahn
You can even target buyers by job title, industry, company, seniority, skills. Wait, did I say job title yet?
Caller Ulysses
Get started today and see how you.
Don Hahn
Can avoid the void and reach the right buyers with LinkedIn ads.
Peter Rosenberg
We'll even give you a $100 credit.
Caller Ulysses
On your next campaign.
Don Hahn
Get started at LinkedIn.com results.
Caller Ulysses
Terms and conditions apply. Lowes knows how to help pros save. That's why the new Milo's Pro Rewards program lets you unlock exclusive member deals on the things you need every day on the job. Plus, Milos Pro Rewards members can get volume discounts on eligible orders through a quote of $2,000 or more. Join for free today. Lowe's we help you save Exclusions. More terms and restrictions apply. Programs subject to terms and conditions. Details@lowe's.com Terms subject to change.
Peter Rosenberg
Hey there, travelers. Kaley Cuoco here. Sorry to interrupt your music, great artist, BT Dubs, but wouldn't you rather be.
Don Hahn
There to hear it live? With Priceline, you can get out of your dreams and into your dream concert. They've got millions of travel deals to.
Peter Rosenberg
Get you to that festival, gig, rave.
Don Hahn
Sound bath, or sonic experience you've been dreaming of.
Peter Rosenberg
Download the Priceline app today and you.
Don Hahn
Can save up to 60% off hotels and up to 50% off flights. So don't just dream about that trip. Book it with Priceline. Happy Price. Price line.
Peter Rosenberg
Thanks for listening to the Don Han and Rosenberg podcast. I didn't listen to anything you just said. Catch the show on demand whenever you want. Just subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. I don't know.
Don Hahn
This is from a movie. I got no idea and I can't think of what movie it's from. Jacob, it's from a movie, right? Night at the Museum was one of.
Caller
The movies it was on.
Don Hahn
Yeah, that's.
Peter Rosenberg
What is it and why? I want to know why.
Don Hahn
I don't know why he played it, but it's from that. At the museum.
Peter Rosenberg
Why?
Don Hahn
No reason at all.
Peter Rosenberg
Just randomly went for a song.
Caller
It just. I forgot why.
Peter Rosenberg
Who's it by?
Don Hahn
Fat Boy Slim. Yeah. This is the video that had what's his name dancing in it. Why am. I don't remember his name?
Peter Rosenberg
Spike Jones. The Spike Jones video that he did for Fat Boy Slim?
Don Hahn
No, the guy from. With the watch in Pulp Fiction.
Peter Rosenberg
Oh, oh, oh, oh, oh. Christopher Walken.
Don Hahn
Yes. He's dancing in the video number. You don't remember that? It was a big deal, I swear. You are. You are a music snob. You are.
Peter Rosenberg
It's not a diss. I didn't think it was a bad song. It just was so random.
Don Hahn
No, but like the things you don't know and because you don't know, I'm sure I'd remember something.
Peter Rosenberg
What part of me said it's not something? I just thought something. For me, there were a few big Fat Boy Slim videos, but I don't even think you're thinking of the right one. Can I be honest? Are you sure it's that one?
Don Hahn
I don't even know. Oh, you know what it is that one. And the reason why I played it because on this day, that song came out. So I just went.
Peter Rosenberg
I'll tell you what. Let me tell you something.
Don Hahn
98. 2001.
Peter Rosenberg
Let me tell you something. Wherever Jacob goes to get his on this day, it can be the most random things in history.
Don Hahn
Now do you think he's trying to forward the show?
Peter Rosenberg
Yeah, I remember this.
Don Hahn
Or is Jacob like, hate this show so much this is the only thing he can do to get through the day. Which one? If you had to pick one of.
Peter Rosenberg
The two and I was right. Spike Jonze did direct the video, by the way.
Don Hahn
That makes sense.
Peter Rosenberg
I think he does it out of love for the show. Okay, now, I do remember this video. And Christopher Walken's man.
Don Hahn
Yeah, it was just out of nowhere.
Peter Rosenberg
It's depressing now to think this is 14 years ago. I don't think Chris Walken's doing this.
Don Hahn
Video 14 years ago.
Peter Rosenberg
That's what it says. You think it's older even?
Don Hahn
Well, if it came out in 2001.
Peter Rosenberg
20Th anniversary. Oh, you're right. It's been 24 years. For some reason, it was uploaded to YouTube 14 years ago.
Don Hahn
How about YouTube's been around for a while, but no, Don, to answer your question, I don't. No, I just. I want you to come up with two options. I believe it's because you really want to forward the show, but I just threw the other option out to just see what possibility.
Peter Rosenberg
I see what you're saying. A few people have been waiting to talk Islanders today, including, of course, Felicia in Mississippi.
Don Hahn
Hi, Felicia.
Peter Rosenberg
What do you got, Felicia?
Caller Felicia
Hey, guys. Yeah, I'm sick to my stomach when I saw the news. Of course, I love Brendan and Butchie, but with my lifestyle, it's super convenient for me to get home and, like, while I'm working the horses. Put the radio on. Like, getting choked up. I'm sorry. Like, just thinking of Don's. Everything he said just. Is everything that I'm thinking in my head, like, what are we? We're just a laughingstock, as usual. It's like, typical Islanders just playing like, we're just a B organization, and they just go and prove it time and time again. It's like, we think we're getting out of it with this gorgeous arena. Like, what a joke. We have this arena that's. It's gotta be making us money, right? Like, seriously.
Don Hahn
And how much money could you really be saving by this decision? Honestly, I'm sure money's being saved, and I'm not gonna laugh at any money being saved post pandemic. But from a reputation standpoint, from a professionalism standpoint, is it worth it? Is it worth a few thousand dollars that you saved on this decision? And my. And the answer is clearly no to me. Come on.
Caller Felicia
Yeah. I mean, it's just. It's a joke, and it's absolutely disgraceful, like you said, to be the only team in New York. I mean, goodness. Not to. Not to disparage the WNBA or our soccer teams, but do they have radio? I mean, I'm just curious. I don't I don't genuinely know, but to be an actual NHL team and we were not going to have radio and listening to a simulcast, like you said, is absolutely not the same. You do not get the picture.
Don Hahn
That's even what they do. I'm not even sure if they're gonna do that. I don't know. They haven't announced anything yet, and I guess we'll see what they decide to do. But, you know, two really good guys are out of a job right now and may not be replaced. And it's just sad to save a few bucks. I killed the Carolina Hurricanes for doing the same thing. Jon Forsaland and Chuck Caton are Hall of Fame broadcasters that went back to their heart for days and now they just simulcast the tv. Los Angeles Kings do the same thing. You know, good people lost jobs because of those decisions and weren't replaced. So I know that money was already being saved because the Islanders didn't travel their radio. So they were saving money there. And I get that. I still think that stinks, but I get it. Certain decisions have to be made. While we're on the hockey subject, Chris Drury was just given an extension. General manager of the Rangers, and I know a lot of people might be upset about that. Dude, he's not going anywhere. And if you want to have stability and you're going to let him make decisions on who your next coach is going to be and reforming this roster, you want the other teams in the league and other players in the league to know that there's stability, and that means he got a contract extension. So the choice to me was fire or extend. That's why I hated what the Giants did with Shane and Dable. They did neither. They kept them and didn't extend them. So they showed no confidence. Chris Drury remained. Peter Laviolette didn't extend Drury. That's the right, logical thing to do.
Peter Rosenberg
So you're not surprised at all.
Don Hahn
But no, it makes sense, right? Why have him hanging? He's got to make all these decisions. There should be confidence to know he still has a job and you can think about the long term. Something that Shane and Dabel may not have the luxury of doing with only one year left on their deal.
Peter Rosenberg
So let's go to Corin in Manasquan.
Caller Alex
Hey, guys.
Peter Rosenberg
Hi, Corinne.
Caller Corin
So, first of all, is it a little too late for can't take it Tuesday? So I'm trying to go home.
Don Hahn
We got you for you.
Caller Corin
So I'm trying to go home from this Mets game. I have my map set up to go on George Washington Bridge so I don't have to pay the congestion pricing. And, you know, a couple detours later, coming out of the city, just in the City Field parking lots and detours, suddenly, Grand Central Parkway west, they put me through Midtown, and I got to pay 13 more dollars eventually.
Don Hahn
You think it's a scam? You think they did that on purpose?
Caller Corin
Honestly, I think it might be.
Don Hahn
You know what? I don't doubt it.
Peter Rosenberg
It's on the table.
Don Hahn
You can't rule it out.
Caller Corin
No, definitely can't. But the subject of my call, I just want to talk about the atmosphere of the Mets game. I mean, it was truly something else. I left more than. With more than enough time to get to the stadium, and suddenly I get on the jet on the GCP to go into the stadium. So much traffic. It's the parking lots packed and the atmosphere inside the place. I mean, for Wednesday day game at 1:10, when people are working. So many people there, everyone's cheering. And also, I did some recon. There were no boos for Soto at all. So anyone who's saying there were, you can't even hear them if there were any.
Don Hahn
No, I mean, the Met fans have been very, very supportive. And why not? Corinth, they're winning. They're 18 and 7. To me, that was all just conjured up by people just trying to create a buzz and social media which is accessible. Oh, they're gonna boost Soto. They don't appreciate Soto. Met fans ripping Soto. Okay, 50,000 people in the building all, you know, serenading him. So stop yourself. You're 18 and 7. Does it matter? Why did you want Juan Soto to help you win games? Right? You're winning games without him, right?
Peter Rosenberg
So does it matter?
Don Hahn
What are you doing?
Peter Rosenberg
So if you.
Don Hahn
If he starts to hit, you might win. You can't win any better than you're winning now. You're playing at a over.700 winning percentage, which is amazing. Can't really get much better than that. But believe me, there can be plenty of times during the summer. Peter, we're going to go. Thank God Juan Soto's here because the hitting is going to go south and he's going to carry him. He's going to win him a few games, believe me. And Met fans know that. Met fans appreciate this.
Peter Rosenberg
Let's go to Ulysses. Ulysses in White Plains. Hey, pal.
Caller Alex
Hey, guys. How you doing? Good afternoon. I'll get straight to the point so you guys can get to it. Listen, Don, I love you as a man. When I do have children. I'm going to model how I raise them based off you. I've been listening to you for over 15 years strong. And I mean that. I've met you in person once. You're a phenomenal guy. But when it comes to this point, with the mess, Yankees hall of Fame, Derek Jeter, Aaron Judge, I think you're biased in a big way. At the end of the day, the playoffs are probably worth 80% of the baseball season. No greater.
Don Hahn
80.
Caller Alex
It's the most important game. 80. 80%. Because that's what we remember 5, 10, 15, 20, 30 years from now in.
Peter Rosenberg
Baseball it's on 162 game season, man.
Don Hahn
Yeah. And still less than half the teams make it. You want to say NHL, you want to say NBA where careers are formulated in the postseason because so many teams make it. But in baseball it's harder to make the playoffs and there's so many rounds. Honestly, 80% seems high to me, but. Go on.
Caller Alex
But like I was saying. I understand what you're saying. You are a Mets fan. But the playoffs and the postseason matter to certain franchises more. And since Aaron Judge cannot perform at the best level when the games count most, I personally would never take Judge in an all time draft of the all time greatest players over Derek Jeter. So I consider Derek Jeter to be a greater player because when he does perform in the postseason, he is a greater and better performer. Just because Aaron Judge has broke some records, I don't think that means that he's better or just because he broke some records, dude.
Peter Rosenberg
But that's that you think it's just because he.
Don Hahn
Are you honestly going to tell me when you watched Aaron Judge play that he's not a better baseball player than Derek Jeter? All right. He may not be as clutch, he may not be as big a winner. Come on. So. So you can't. So Tony Gwynn's a bum.
Caller Alex
In my opinion. I would take Derek Jeter over Tony Gwynn as well because I saw Derek Jeter perform in the highest of the highest. Okay, I have yet to see.
Don Hahn
And I would take Derek Jeter too, but according to your formula that you know guys like George Brett with just one ring, Ted Williams, one of the greatest baseball players of all time. Not to you, because he didn't win a World Series and he played in I think one World Series and was not very good in that series. So to you, Ted Williams can't be in the conversations, one of the great players that Ernie Banks can't be in the Conversation of one of the great players because he didn't win. That Greg Maddox, who, if you look at his stats, not great in the postseason, only one ring. You're going to tell me Greg Maddox isn't one of the greatest pitchers in the history of baseball just because he didn't win, and that Schilling, who's a really good pitcher in the regular season but untouchable in the postseason, then becomes better than Greg Maddox?
Caller Alex
Yes, 100%. Because I'm looking at the all time gods of baseball. If aliens come down, it's going to be an all time draft of the greatest players, not the aver. And sorry, I'm not going to take.
Don Hahn
Ulysses if you're going to tell me that Aaron Judge is average because he has not hit in the postseason, that we can't continue this conversation because if you see anything average about Aaron Judge, I agree with you. In the postseason, he has not been the same player. And I give Derek Jeter credit for that. But if you're putting together a draft and you're not drafting Aaron Judge and you're not drafting Ted Williams and you're not drafting Ernie Banks or Tony Gwynn, I don't know what to tell you, man. I just. That's really sad.
Peter Rosenberg
Could you. I assume that you could accept someone calling up and saying, I think both are really great and yes, I think Judge is more talented, but I'm going to go with Jeter because I value playoffs that much. You could go with that because all.
Don Hahn
I said was I think he's the better player.
Peter Rosenberg
Right.
Don Hahn
And I will stand by that. But if you said I'd rather have Derek Jeter because he's more clutch, if I had to get a hit in a big spot, I would pick Derek Jeter.
Peter Rosenberg
Sure.
Don Hahn
Okay. And you know what? If I had a drive in a Super bowl to win a game, I would take Eli Manning over his brother. But do you think for a second that Eli Manning is in the same stratosphere as his brother as a player? Honestly, now, basketball is different. You control more of the game. Football, quarterbacks control more of the game. But baseball, man, that's tough, man.
Peter Rosenberg
You know what's tough, Don? Losing. That's why you want to go to fanduel where you can win the best place to find all your favorite player props. And now you can make a heads up play with player performance trends. That means whether you want to bet on a player to score 30 points or put up a triple double, you can check out the latest stats and see who's hot without leaving the app. Plus, after the game tips off, you can even combine live prop bets into a same game parlay for a chance to win big. If you don't already have FanDuel playoff time is the perfect time to join. You'll get started with $250 in bonus bets if your first $5 bet wins, so just visit FanDuel.com Peter to join today. Make every moment more with FanDuel official sports betting partner of the NBA 21 and over in Fizzly present New York versus online real money wager only $5 first deposit required. Bonus issued as non withdrawable bonus bets which expire seven days after receipt restrictions. Apply seat terms at sportsbook.fanduel.com for all the gambling problem, call 877-8-Hopeny 467369.
Caller Ulysses
Don'T miss your chance to spring into deals at Lowe's right now get a free 60 volt Toro battery when you purchase a select 60 volt Toro electric mower. Plus buy three 19.3 ounce vegetable and herb Bonnie plants for just $10. It's time to give your yard a grow up Lowe's we help you save. Valid to 423. Selection varies by location while supplies last. Discount taken at time of purchase. Actual plant size and selection varies by location. Excludes Alaska and Hawaii.
Don Hahn
There are people out there all across the country pushing boundaries to grow the game of golf, like champion speed golfer Lauren Kupp, who plays faster than anyone else, and Will Lowry, whose work in the golf community inspires more kids to get into the game as a champion partner of the Masters. Bank of America supports everyone determined to find out what's possible in golf and in life. What would you like the power to do? Bank of America bank of America NA Member FDIC Copyright 2025 bank of America Corporation. All rights reserved. Ryan Reynolds here from Mint Mobile. I don't know if you knew this.
Peter Rosenberg
But anyone can get the same Premium Wireless for $15 a month plan that I've been enjoying. It's not just for celebrities.
Don Hahn
So do like I did and have one of your assistant's assistants switch you to Mint Mobile today.
Peter Rosenberg
I'm told it's super easy to do.
Don Hahn
At mintmobile.com/switch upfront payment of 45 for.
Peter Rosenberg
3 month plan equivalent to 15 per.
Don Hahn
Month required intro rate first 3 months.
Peter Rosenberg
Only, then full price plan options available.
Don Hahn
Taxes and fees, extra fee full terms@mintmobile.com.
Peter Rosenberg
Thanks for listening to the Don Han and Rosenberg podcast. I didn't listen to anything you just said Catch the show on demand whenever you want. Just subscribe to us wherever you get your podcasts. Talking about phones and Don, we've been re watching the Bears Commanders game from this season on the NFL Network.
Don Hahn
It's really been on the entire show.
Peter Rosenberg
Literally the entire show. And this is. This was such a frustrating moment for me. Cause the commanders were sitting at 5 and 2, Don. And I was like, oh, if we lose to the Bears at home, I'd be annoyed. But like, we'll still be 5 and 3. But they'd been winning the whole game. There was no reason. The Bears had never been good. And then all of a sudden, this drive happens, and the Bears are getting close now to taking the lead. And we know what happens after that. This weekend I was watching the office, going to sleep in my hotel.
Don Hahn
Yeah.
Peter Rosenberg
And stupidly, I know this is dumb. Had my Apple laptop on my bed, fell off the bed. Broken. Really brought it in. Oh, no, the screen is broken. They said, good news. It's a simple fix. It's just the screen. Let's see how much that'll cost for you. 499.
Don Hahn
Oh. How much was the laptop?
Peter Rosenberg
It's done. Doesn't matter how much it was. I'm not paying 500. I'm not paying 500 to repair a $1,200 laptop from five years ago. It doesn't make sense. I'm done.
Don Hahn
So it was on your.
Peter Rosenberg
On the bed, not on you? No, laying next to me on the bed.
Don Hahn
But you fell asleep.
Peter Rosenberg
And then like, I pushed it off at some point.
Don Hahn
I told you I had Marco on my chest when he was in infant. Fell asleep, and he slid right off me.
Peter Rosenberg
Yeah, I value the laptop. I value my laptop.
Don Hahn
And I took. And I took Marco and they said, listen, it's gonna take, you know, $4,000 to fix him. And I said, you know what? We'll just make another case.
Peter Rosenberg
Yeah. By the way, that's how they did back in the day.
Don Hahn
Yes. Back in the late 1700s, early 1800s.
Peter Rosenberg
They would have said, don't worry.
Don Hahn
They would have said, you have a something else. Typhoid was gonna come anyway, so what's the difference?
Peter Rosenberg
They'd be a question. Do you guys have a baby disposal bin? We'll just throw it in the b. But I. So now I'm gonna take the laptop, and it still works. So I'll turn it into like a desktop computer. Just won't be a laptop anymore. Attach a monitor to it.
Don Hahn
I can find it.
Peter Rosenberg
But 500. Really? Apple? Yeah.
Don Hahn
500.
Peter Rosenberg
You guys couldn't charge 2. 199 to fix the mod.
Don Hahn
You know what it is?
Peter Rosenberg
They just have to replace the actual thing. 199 wouldn't be enough.
Don Hahn
It's all a scam. It really is. It's really a shame. By the way, Arthur Staple confirms that the Islanders will simulcast television. So that will be your radio vehicle. So welcome to Carolina. Might as well be the Raleigh Islanders. That's disgusting. That's just. I hope all that money is saved. You just. You can wipe yourself with it.
Peter Rosenberg
That is so trash. So trash.
Don Hahn
We saved $500,000. Meanwhile, you're paying players like 12 million. Stop yourself.
Peter Rosenberg
There's no one player's contract that you could look at who's just stunk. Don. And go, you know what? We should probably be adjusting this deal anyway. You willing to work with us on this? Let's save a million here.
Don Hahn
Oh, dear God in heaven.
Peter Rosenberg
It just stinks. It just stinks. Especially because Long island is such a commuter place.
Don Hahn
Right.
Peter Rosenberg
There's so many people who have long drives to get back home.
Don Hahn
I know.
Peter Rosenberg
So, like, listening is a major part if you're an Islanders fan. You work in the city. You have an endless commute home. You always miss the start of the game. You want to listen, and now the only thing you can do. So will they still be on the radio or it'll be on the app or something?
Don Hahn
I'm assuming they'll still be on the Hofstra radio station, and maybe they will be on an app. I'm not sure what the vehicle will be. I brought this up on gameisconduct, where you can get your podcast that when all those goals we played from Ovechkin this year. What did you play?
Peter Rosenberg
The Washington Capitals radio network.
Don Hahn
Right. John Wideman. Waldman. So John Wideman was. Worked with Chris King. That's why it was on my mind. John Walton. You didn't play Joe Biddonotti. Who's the TV guy? Why? Because you want to play the radio call. Because we're on the radio. So. And I don't know what they're gonna do when there's a nationally televised game. Is it not gonna be on the radio? They're not gonna take the national broadcast. So who's gonna do the play by play there? Is Brendan Burke and Butchie gonna do it on radio?
Peter Rosenberg
And by the way, they were already having these guys do it locally when they were traveling.
Don Hahn
Yeah. When they tr. The only place they did on the road was at the Rock and at the Garden. So they didn't travel, so they were already saving.
Peter Rosenberg
So if they were in San Jose, they would just be probably halfway at UBS or something.
Don Hahn
I don't know where they did it. Maybe they did it at Hofstra, I'm not sure.
Peter Rosenberg
Maybe at home, whatever. But they made it.
Don Hahn
I don't know if they did it at home, but they did it off the monitor. Yes. And I get that the Toronto Maple Leafs don't travel. A lot of teams don't travel radio wise post Covid. Because they realize, well, we could save a ton of money. Cuz even when you fly on the charter, the team charter, it costs the team money. They pay for everybody that's on the plane. The lighter the plane, the less expensive the flight. So money is saved by not traveling.
Peter Rosenberg
How much money though? Because you're paying for.
Don Hahn
Overall, I don't like it. But listen, there's a lot of teams that are doing it. Baseball, I don't think the Blue Jays travel post Covid. I can understand saving some money, but those guys didn't lose their jobs. Jobs are being lost, man. And two really good guys, that's. Enjoy it. Enjoy yourself. All right. In case you're wondering, thousands of dollars in savings.
Peter Rosenberg
The Austin Eckler just received the kickoff from the Bears. He returned it to the 23 yard line. 19 seconds left on to you and me.
Don Hahn
You would think that there's not nearly enough time at your own 24, even.
Peter Rosenberg
In this era of. Well, no, you're thinking field goal, right? You think getting the field goal. So first down. That's incomplete, wasn't it? Yeah, he threw to Ertz over the middle. It hits the dirt. Nothing. And I said this earlier to Don Anthony, I know you're in lockstep. The commies black jersey is the best new jersey in football. Agreed.
Don Hahn
I don't like the lines above and under the names on the back, but.
Peter Rosenberg
The overall look is pretty sweet though.
Don Hahn
It is very nice.
Peter Rosenberg
It has the DC flag on the. On the sleeves.
Don Hahn
And I'm not a big fan of the numbers on the helmets. That's too old timey.
Peter Rosenberg
You'd rather have a logo there. Yeah, you know what?
Don Hahn
I agree, but that's a nitpick. It still looks sharp.
Peter Rosenberg
No, just give me the.
Don Hahn
But the jersey looks sharp. You're not buying a helmet. If you're walking around with a helmet, you probably fall down a lot.
Peter Rosenberg
So now it's 18 seconds left. I gotta relive this. This is the greatest moment in the history of my life and probably the moment that put the Name Jaden over the top as Maya's middle name.
Don Hahn
Oh, this is it.
Peter Rosenberg
This is when.
Don Hahn
This is what you're gonna tell her? This moment.
Peter Rosenberg
I believe this was the day. And it was. I actually believe it was before the Hail Mary. We were laying. We were in bed watching this game, and Natalie was, like, in and out of sleep because the game was a total bore up until this. And at some point, we brought up the name Jaden. He goes over the middle to Ertz for a first down. But Don, he's only at the 34 yard line. Yeah, that's a bad. By the way, that was a bad play.
Don Hahn
That's not a good play.
Peter Rosenberg
That was not a good play because they could have been thinking about field goal range, and that doesn't get them anywhere near field goal range. I kind of forgot how dumb a play that was. So now it's six seconds left, and I gave up on the game. I went, oh, well, we lost.
Don Hahn
Yeah, because you figure you're down to one play at this point. They're congratulating Caleb Williams on a job well done.
Peter Rosenberg
And Caleb's doing the old, get everybody off the field. We don't want anyone on the field. And then, oh, they ran another play. All right. He runs another one and gets McLaurin out to their own 48 with two seconds.
Don Hahn
I figured there had to be another play because there's no way he was going to reach the end zone from his own 35. From his own 35. So now there's two seconds left. That got it out to what, like the 46? Yeah, negative 46, by the way.
Peter Rosenberg
Yes, negative. Now, Don, the best thing about this play is that when people say this is luck, the beauty of this play is the how not lucky. The way Jaden sets it up is he drops back to his 35. He gets a lot of time, then he has to scramble to his right, goes all the way back to his left, still scrambling, steps completely into it, right on his own 35. The ball lands at the 2. It gets tipped at the 2, into the end zone for. It's the greatest ever.
Don Hahn
It's. Listen, it's a great individual effort by him, but it was still luck that it just bounced off the scrum. Right?
Peter Rosenberg
But that is supposedly what the. What the design was for having the play behind that. The player behind that scrum. It's supposed to be to get a.
Don Hahn
Tie, but you still are hoping for a break there, and they got it.
Peter Rosenberg
Can you imagine throwing a football 65 yards, though? No, I mean, Don honest to God, right now, how far you think you could throw an NFL football? An NFL football?
Don Hahn
The real full size 30, maybe 35.
Peter Rosenberg
No, I don't think you're getting 35 anymore.
Don Hahn
We got to try this. Come summertime, I don't think you get.
Peter Rosenberg
35 in the like with any accuracy. Or if you hear, oh, I don't.
Don Hahn
Know, a tremendous amount of pain, I'm probably on the ground.
Peter Rosenberg
Right, right.
Don Hahn
Like your arms rotator cuff is at the 40.
Peter Rosenberg
Thanks for listening to the Don Hahn and Rosenberg podcast. I don't want to know how the sausage is made, but I just want to know.
Don Hahn
It's good.
Peter Rosenberg
Hear more of Don Allen and Peter.
Don Hahn
Weekday afternoon nude starting at 3 on.
Peter Rosenberg
8 80, ESPN, the ESPN New York app, and your smart speakers.
Podcast Summary: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg - Hour 3: Mets Win & Judge v Jeter
Introduction In the April 23, 2025 episode of the Don, Hahn & Rosenberg podcast, hosts Don La Greca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve into an engaging discussion centered on the recent performance of the New York Mets and a heated debate comparing baseball legends Aaron Judge and Derek Jeter. The episode also touches on various other sports topics, including broadcasting changes in the NHL and NFL playoff strategies. Skipping over advertisements and non-content segments, the hosts and their callers provide insightful perspectives on these subjects, making the episode a must-listen for sports enthusiasts.
The episode kicks off with a celebration of the New York Mets' impressive start to the season. With a record of 18 wins and only 7 losses, the Mets are on a highly successful trajectory.
Don Hahn highlights the team's dominance, stating, "We're winning 72% of our games and have a five-game lead in first place in the division" (18:00).
Peter Rosenberg adds, "It’s a great time to be a Mets fan. Their performance has been phenomenal, and they're setting the tone early in the season."
Listeners are invited to share their excitement as the hosts discuss the factors contributing to the Mets' success, including standout performances and strategic gameplay.
A significant portion of the episode revolves around the ongoing debate comparing current star Aaron Judge to the legendary Derek Jeter. This discussion is sparked by a call from Alex, who passionately argues in favor of Judge over Jeter.
Caller Alex asserts at 01:52, "I think Judge is a way better player than Jeter by a mile. You can name like a dozen great players surrounded by Jeter, but not as many around Judge."
Don Hahn responds thoughtfully, acknowledging Jeter's postseason prowess while maintaining his stance on Judge's overall talent. At 02:36, he states, "Derek Jeter was an amazing Hall of Fame player and very clutch, especially in the postseason. But Aaron Judge is a better ballplayer over the course of the season."
Peter Rosenberg supports Hahn's view, adding, "To me, it's not really close," reinforcing the idea that Judge's regular-season performance gives him an edge.
Caller Carl from West Babylon interjects, critiquing a fellow caller's perspective and emphasizing Judge's consistent excellence: "Aaron Judge is on the MVP conversation every single season. He's one of the best players in baseball."
Don Hahn further elaborates on the debate, pointing out that while Jeter excelled in high-pressure postseason scenarios, Judge's all-around abilities in regular play make him superior overall: "Guy's got a gun for an arm. He's an A-plus defender, hits home runs, gets on base. He does everything exceptionally well."
The hosts also discuss the emotional and subjective aspects of fan loyalty, particularly among Yankees supporters who value championship rings as a measure of greatness. Don Hahn critiques the overemphasis on postseason success, arguing that it can overshadow a player's regular-season achievements: "The Yankees fans are all about the chip. But I give Derek Jeter credit for being clutch. However, Aaron Judge's consistency is unparalleled."
Throughout the episode, multiple callers weigh in on the Judge vs. Jeter conversation, each bringing unique perspectives:
Caller Alex emphasizes the importance of regular-season performance over postseason accolades, arguing that "just because Aaron Judge has broken some records, it doesn’t make him better overall than Derek Jeter."
Caller Griffin briefly touches on unrelated topics but underscores the frustration some fans feel regarding player comparisons and team performance.
Caller Corin from Manasquan shifts the conversation to discuss the Mets' atmosphere during a game, highlighting the team's supportive fan base and lack of boos for star player Juan Soto: "There were no boos for Soto at all. Met fans ripping Soto? No, 50,000 people serenading him."
The hosts transition to discussing recent changes in NHL broadcasting, particularly how teams are cutting costs by reducing travel for radio broadcasts. Don Hahn expresses his discontent with the Islanders' decision to simulcast television for radio broadcasts, lamenting the loss of beloved broadcasters: "Jon Forsaland and Chuck Caton are Hall of Fame broadcasters who were replaced by simulcasts. It's just sad to see good people lose their jobs for cost savings."
Peter Rosenberg adds, "It's a shame because listening to the games on the radio is a major part of being an Islanders fan, especially for those with long commutes."
The conversation highlights the broader impact of these changes on fan experience and the importance of traditional broadcasting methods in maintaining a strong connection between teams and their supporters.
A segment of the episode delves into NFL playoff strategies, with a particular focus on a pivotal game between the Bears and Commanders. Peter Rosenberg narrates a dramatic moment from the game, expressing frustration over a questionable play decision: "They threw to Ertz over the middle. It hits the dirt. Nothing. Now there's two seconds left, and Caleb's doing something unexpected."
Don Hahn critiques the play, discussing its lack of strategic merit and the reliance on luck: "It's a great individual effort by him, but it was still luck that it just bounced off the scrum."
The hosts examine the implications of such plays on the game's outcome and the overall strategy teams employ during high-pressure moments.
The episode takes a personal turn as Peter Rosenberg shares a story about accidentally breaking his Apple laptop while traveling. This anecdote serves as a humorous interlude amidst the sports discussions, highlighting the hosts' ability to blend personal experiences with their professional insights.
Peter Rosenberg recounts, "I fell asleep with my laptop on the bed, and it broke. The repair cost $500 for a five-year-old device. I'm done with Apple repairs."
Don Hahn empathizes, sharing his own experience with his son Marco sliding off him and damaging his belongings, further adding a relatable human element to the podcast.
As the episode wraps up, the hosts reflect on the passionate discussions and varied topics covered. Don Hahn reiterates his disappointment with broadcasting changes in the NHL and expresses hope that teams will reconsider cost-cutting measures that impact fan engagement.
Peter Rosenberg emphasizes the importance of balancing team performance, broadcasting quality, and fan satisfaction to maintain a vibrant sports community.
The episode closes with the hosts thanking the listeners and encouraging them to subscribe and tune in for future discussions on New York sports and beyond.
Don Hahn: "Derek Jeter was an amazing Hall of Fame player and he was very clutch. Way better in the postseason than Judge has been so far." (02:44)
Peter Rosenberg: "It's like a lame way to have a sports conversation. It just ultimately is a boy." (11:11)
Caller Alex: "Just because Aaron Judge has broken some records, it doesn’t make him better overall than Derek Jeter." (35:45)
Don Hahn: "Are you honestly going to tell me when you watched Aaron Judge play that he's not a better baseball player than Derek Jeter?" (34:17)
Don Hahn: "We saved $500,000. Meanwhile, you're paying players like 12 million." (42:38)
This episode of Don, Hahn & Rosenberg masterfully combines expert analysis with passionate listener interactions, particularly highlighting the debate between Aaron Judge and Derek Jeter. The discussion not only showcases the hosts' deep understanding of baseball but also reflects broader themes in sports broadcasting and fan engagement. Whether you're a Mets fan celebrating the team's early success or a baseball enthusiast interested in player legacies, this episode offers a comprehensive and entertaining exploration of New York sports.