Podcast Summary: Don, Hahn & Rosenberg – Hour 3: Mike Tannenbaum & Peter's Tables

Release Date: August 13, 2025

Introduction

In this spirited episode of the Don, Hahn & Rosenberg podcast, hosts Don La Greca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the world of sports, with a strong focus on football quarterbacks and baseball player comparisons. The episode, titled "Hour 3: Mike Tannenbaum & Peter's Tables," features a dynamic conversation that balances expert analysis with engaging banter, enriched by interactions with live callers.

Football Quarterback Rankings and Jaden Daniels' Inclusion

The core of the episode centers around the hosts' annual quarterback rankings, particularly Peter Rosenberg's unconventional approach of creating "wedding tables" for quarterbacks instead of traditional tiers. Rosenberg introduces a controversial addition to his top tier: Jaden Daniels.

• Peter Rosenberg explains his criteria: "Is there a quarterback who regardless of circumstance can go out there and potentially win a game for you essentially by himself? And to me, that quarterback is Jaden Daniels and I added him to table one." (22:42)

This decision sparks a robust debate, especially when Don Hahn challenges the inclusion by emphasizing the need for consistent performance and higher passing yardage in subsequent seasons.

• Don Hahn states, "He's got to ascend. So if he gave you the exact same numbers, I think I'd be a little disappointed." (34:13)

Discussion with Mike Tannenbaum

The episode introduces a guest appearance by Mike Tannenbaum, a respected figure in football management. Tannenbaum defends his stance on starting Jackson Dart as the quarterback for the Giants over veterans like Russell Wilson and Jameis Winston.

• Mike Tannenbaum argues, "I'm going to give you all that. But he is what he is. Nobody's paying running backs. The Eagles did because they needed to because they don't have a quarterback that's going to throw for 40 or throw for 4,500 yards." (51:18)

He emphasizes the importance of meritocracy in the NFL, advocating for Dart's potential despite being a later draft pick.

• Mike Tannenbaum asserts, "Once they're in the building, to me, guys, you know, it's the ultimate meritocracy who gives us the best chance to win." (18:37)

The conversation highlights differing philosophies on player development and team-building strategies, enriching the discourse around quarterback performance and potential.

Debate on Aaron Judge vs. Darryl Strawberry

Shifting gears, Don and Peter engage in a passionate discussion comparing current Yankees star Aaron Judge to Darryl Strawberry, a legendary figure in the franchise's history. The debate centers on evaluating their performances and contributions to the team.

• Don Hahn emphasizes Strawberry's former prowess: "Daryl Strawberry was a hell of a player all right. He was hitting, you know, 39 home runs when that would, you know that led the league in 1988." (38:21)

Despite acknowledging Strawberry's historical impact, Hahn concedes that Judge surpasses him in several statistical categories.

• Don Hahn concedes, "But Judge is better. But if you want to say that, hey, maybe the numbers would be a lot better had he not got into drugs," (38:35)

Peter Rosenberg counters any undermining of Judge's abilities, reinforcing his status as one of the greatest right-handed hitters in recent decades.

• Peter Rosenberg passionately states, "The man is quite possibly the greatest right-handed hitter of the last 50 plus years in the game of baseball." (37:52)

The debate underscores the nuanced perspectives on player legacies and the impact of off-field issues on athletic performance.

Callers' Interactions and Sports Insights

Throughout the episode, several callers contribute to the discussions, offering diverse viewpoints on football and baseball topics. Notable interactions include:

• Caller Dennis (04:16): Discusses quarterback rankings, questioning the placement of others and defending Jaden Daniels' position.

  "He really does have top five arm accuracy, arm strength. And then his late game decision making is incredible." (04:43)

• Caller Matt (06:22): Challenges Peter Rosenberg on quarterback table placements, specifically comparing Justin Herbert and Tua Tagovailoa.

  "But I'm a Dolphins fan. So my question is why, if Herbert and Tua both don't do anything in the playoffs..." (06:24)

• Caller Griffin (09:03): Adds to the quarterback debate by discussing Trevor Lawrence and his placement among peers.

  "He should be a tribal 4. If anything should be maybe ahead." (09:11)

These interactions enrich the episode, providing real-time fan perspectives and fostering a more comprehensive discussion.

Light-Hearted Banter and Personal Anecdotes

Interspersed with the intense sports analysis, the hosts engage in light-hearted banter and share personal stories, adding a personable and relatable dimension to the podcast.

• Peter Rosenberg shares an amusing anecdote about handling interns and managing relationships, highlighting the challenges of maintaining professionalism amidst personal interactions.

  "They all just walked right out the door and treated me like pure..." (42:10)

• Don Hahn and Peter Rosenberg exchange playful comments about banana pudding from Magnolia Bakery, demonstrating their camaraderie.

  Don Hahn: "I believe that's the best banana pudding I've ever had." (44:31)

  Peter Rosenberg: "This is fabulous. And this is a week old." (44:36)

These moments of levity provide balance to the episode, making the hosts more relatable and the conversation more engaging for listeners.

Conclusion

This episode of Don, Hahn & Rosenberg offers a comprehensive exploration of current debates in football and baseball, enriched by expert insights and interactive discussions with callers. The addition of guest Mike Tannenbaum brings an authoritative perspective on quarterback development, while the passionate debate over player legacies adds depth to the conversation. The hosts' blend of humor and personal anecdotes ensures a well-rounded and engaging listening experience for both avid sports fans and casual listeners alike.

Notable Quotes:

• Peter Rosenberg (22:42): "Is there a quarterback who regardless of circumstance can go out there and potentially win a game for you essentially by himself? And to me, that quarterback is Jaden Daniels and I added him to table one."

• Don Hahn (34:13): "He's got to ascend. So if he gave you the exact same numbers, I think I'd be a little disappointed."

• Mike Tannenbaum (18:37): "Once they're in the building, to me, guys, you know, it's the ultimate meritocracy who gives us the best chance to win."

• Peter Rosenberg (37:52): "The man is quite possibly the greatest right-handed hitter of the last 50 plus years in the game of baseball."

This summary captures the essence of the episode, highlighting key discussions and providing valuable insights while maintaining a natural flow for those who haven't listened to the podcast.