Don, Hahn & Rosenberg Podcast Summary
Episode: Hour 4: Last Call Crew
Release Date: May 29, 2025

Overview

In the "Last Call Crew" episode of the Don, Hahn & Rosenberg podcast, hosts Don Hahn and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the New York Knicks' pivotal playoff series against the Indiana Pacers. As the Knicks face a daunting 3-1 deficit, the hosts analyze the team's prospects, key player performances, coaching strategies, and listener perspectives to forecast the potential outcomes of this high-stakes matchup.

Knicks Playoff Series Analysis

The central focus of the episode is the Knicks' current playoff standing, trailing 3-1 against the Pacers. Don and Peter assess the historical context and the team's resilience. Don Hahn expresses cautious optimism, stating, "I feel good about tonight. I do. I feel good about them tonight." (01:26), acknowledging the team's energy despite mixed signals from others.

Peter Rosenberg counters by emphasizing the rarity of such comebacks: "I just can't imagine a team that won 51 games, Peter. A team that is right now one of three teams left in the NBA playoffs are going out three and six at home." (02:20). He highlights the Knicks' strong home advantage and passionate fan base as critical factors that could influence the series' outcome.

Key Players Discussion

A significant portion of the discussion revolves around comparing Jalen Brunson and Carmelo Anthony's impact on the team. Don Hahn posits, "if Jalen Brunson kept up what he's done in his first two years, the way he's impacted that team over eight seasons, you would think he was a better Knick than Carmelo Anthony." (08:35). This statement sparks a debate on player contributions and legacy within the franchise.

Peter Rosenberg defends Brunson's current performance, arguing that his postseason scoring surpasses what Anthony achieved, thereby supporting the notion that Brunson could be the catalyst for the Knicks' resurgence: "Carmelo Anthony was one of the great scorers of all time... But, you know, Brunson's making the shots. They're winning games, they're winning playoff series." (04:59).

Coaching Strategies

The hosts also delve into the strategic aspects of the series, focusing on the coaching decisions by Knicks' head coach Jay Williamson (referred to as Tibbs). A caller, Trey, underscores the importance of coaching in pivotal moments: "I think it's going to come down to coaching. Thibodell brought, started Robinson and then Carlisle. He brought in Brian Matherence." (13:59).

Don Hahn responds by emphasizing the need for adaptive strategies: "When you need it, get a rebound. That would be... when you need it, get a rebound." (20:45). Both hosts agree that coaching adjustments will play a crucial role in the Knicks' ability to turn the series around.

Caller Insights

Engaging with their audience, Don and Peter field calls from Knicks fans offering diverse perspectives. Trey from Long Island criticizes the current team's composition compared to past Knicks teams, questioning the reliance on players like Brunson over legends like Carmelo: "Brunson is not the best player in 25 years." (03:05).

Another caller, Dan from Queens, emphasizes the necessity of strong coaching and player execution: "It comes down to coaching always. They got the players." (13:59). These interactions highlight the passionate and divided opinions among the Knicks' fan base regarding the team's future.

Final Thoughts

As the episode wraps up, Don Hahn and Peter Rosenberg reiterate the high stakes of the upcoming Game 5 and the slim but possible path to forcing a Game 6. Don summarizes the Knicks' qualities, "They are more than talented, more than having a great offense or defense, more than anything. This is a gutsy, gritty, back against the wall fight back team." (15:16).

Peter emphasizes realism in their expectations, stressing that while the Knicks have the heart and potential, the odds are stacked against them in overcoming a 3-1 deficit: "It takes a lot out of you to do that. That's why you were so spot on early about getting off to a good start." (15:26).

The hosts conclude with a balanced outlook, acknowledging the Knicks' strengths and the formidable challenge ahead, leaving listeners with a nuanced understanding of the team's playoff journey.

Notable Quotes

• Peter Rosenberg: "I just can't imagine a team that won 51 games... going out three and six at home." (02:20)

• Don Hahn: "They are a gutsy, gritty, back against the wall fight back team." (15:16)

• Peter Rosenberg: "Carmelo Anthony was one of the great scorers of all time... But Brunson's making the shots." (04:59)

• Caller Trey: "Brunson is not the best player in 25 years." (03:05)

This episode offers a comprehensive analysis of the Knicks' playoff scenario, blending expert insights with passionate fan opinions to provide listeners with a thorough understanding of the team's challenges and potential pathways to success.