Don, Hahn & Rosenberg: Hour 4 - Nimmo's Big Day

Released April 28, 2025

In the fourth episode of the Don, Hahn & Rosenberg podcast, hosts Don La Greca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg delve deep into the latest happenings in New York sports, with a particular spotlight on baseball and the intricate dynamics within the New York Yankees. Titled "Nimmo's Big Day," the episode offers a comprehensive analysis of standout performances, team strategies, and passionate debates that resonate with fans across the region.

1. Brandon Nimmo's Stellar Performance

The episode kicks off with an exhilarating account of Brandon Nimmo's exceptional performance in the recent game. Alan Hahn sets the stage by highlighting Nimmo's remarkable statistics:

Alan Hahn [00:44]: "How about Nimmo? 4 for 5, 9 RBIs. He's got two home runs, including a grand slam."

Don Hahn chimes in to emphasize the historical significance of such a feat:

Don Hahn [01:28]: "That's a forever day. Like, that's a day. I'm gonna be honest. That's a day that, if you did it, I swear to God, in sixth grade, you would talk about it the rest of your life."

The trio celebrates Nimmo's achievement, discussing how it elevates his batting average and cements his status as a pivotal player for the Mets.

2. The Mets' Season Outlook

Transitioning from individual performance, the hosts analyze the Mets' broader season trajectory. Despite a recent blowout loss where they squandered a 7-1 lead, there's optimism fueled by standout performances:

Alan Hahn [03:58]: "Who else is having a big day? When you get 15 runs, it's a lot."

They discuss the implications of such high-scoring games on the team's morale and standings, highlighting the unpredictability of the season and the Mets' potential to secure a significant number of wins.

3. Devin Williams and Yankee's Closer Conundrum

A substantial portion of the episode is dedicated to the New York Yankees' bullpen dynamics, focusing on pitcher Devin Williams losing his closer role. The hosts dissect the possible reasons behind this shift and its repercussions:

Don Hahn [04:26]: "A franchise record nine RBIs for Brandon Nimmo."

Alan Hahn [04:46]: "I can't believe all these reporters here, like, is that one thing that Brian Cashman's got to do a better job of is just, all right, bring players in. Are they ready for New York?"

Peter Rosenberg adds insight into the psychological pressures associated with being a closer in the high-stakes environment of New York baseball:

Peter Rosenberg [07:01]: "It just means the anxiety of being here and being in the microscope is not for everyone."

The discussion underscores the Yankees' challenges in managing talent under intense media scrutiny and the importance of aligning player psychology with team expectations.

4. Mets vs. Yankees: A Fiery Debate

In a spirited segment, Alan Hahn passionately defends his allegiance to the Mets while critiquing rival teams, notably the Yankees and Phillies. This debate showcases the intense rivalry and deep-seated loyalties that characterize New York sports fandom:

Alan Hahn [12:22]: "If you choose to... you can pick the Yankees. The Mets picked me. Okay. And I'm good. I'll be All Right."

The banter escalates as Alan disparages Mets supporters who prefer other teams, emphasizing the historical successes of the Yankees and diminishing the achievements of their rivals:

Alan Hahn [13:42]: "Even the Flyers won back to back cups. The Sixers, they have their championship."

Don Hahn and Peter Rosenberg engage in the debate, adding humor and camaraderie to the competitive exchanges, reflecting the show's dynamic and entertaining nature.

5. Listener Interaction: Spike's Praise and Game Analysis

The episode features a heartfelt call from a dedicated listener, Spike from St. Pete, who commends the hosts for their insightful commentary and engaging style. Spike also inquires about a specific refereeing call in a recent game:

Spike [19:16]: "I've just done a fantastic job and you're doing color commentary and it goes hand in hand with the Knicks."

The hosts respond by dissecting the controversial shot made by Jokic, analyzing whether it should count based on its trajectory through the rim:

Don Hahn [21:03]: "He had two games in 30 hours and two calls. And he's a good guy."

Peter Rosenberg [21:15]: "If they said no basket, I would have been okay. Like, it's really."

This interaction highlights the show's commitment to listener engagement and its depth in analyzing intricate game moments.

6. Sports Management and Future Forecasts

Towards the end of the episode, the hosts shift focus to sports management, discussing potential moves such as Mike Sullivan's departure from the Pittsburgh Penguins and speculating his next destination:

Peter Rosenberg [21:36]: "How close are we now? Now that he's a free agent, now he's out there. Do you think that's the obvious movement in the mix?"

Alan Hahn [22:34]: "He was an assistant of John Tortorella here with the Rangers. It seems like the logical choice."

The conversation touches upon the importance of coaching chemistry and the strategic considerations teams must evaluate when making such transitions.

7. Closing Remarks and Future Episodes

As the episode wraps up, the hosts tease upcoming content and express gratitude towards their listeners. They hint at future discussions, including playoff broadcasts and game analyses, ensuring that fans stay tuned for more insightful sports commentary.

Notable Quotes:

• Don Hahn [01:28]: "That's a forever day... your friends would be hearing about it till you're 60."

• Alan Hahn [04:46]: "Is that one thing that Brian Cashman's got to do a better job of... Are they ready for New York?"

• Peter Rosenberg [07:01]: "It just means the anxiety of being here and being in the microscope is not for everyone."

• Alan Hahn [12:22]: "You have a choice. You can either be a fan of one of the most storied franchises... or the Mets."

• Spike [19:16]: "You've taught me more, both you guys and Billy and... you've just done a fantastic job."

Conclusion

"Nimmo's Big Day" serves as a testament to the vibrant and dynamic nature of New York sports, capturing the highs and lows that define the season. Don La Greca, Alan Hahn, and Peter Rosenberg adeptly balance statistical analysis with heartfelt opinions, delivering a podcast episode that is both informative and entertaining. Whether you're a die-hard Mets supporter or a Yankees aficionado, this episode provides a rich tapestry of insights that resonate with all sports enthusiasts.