How Empathy Can Change Your Decision Making

Summary

---

Podcast Summary: The Dr. Laura Podcast

Episode: “How Empathy Can Change Your Decision Making”
Host: Dr. Laura Schlessinger
Date: November 22, 2025

---

Main Theme Overview

This episode centers on the role of empathy in human decision making, questioning whether people truly act as rational, utility-driven beings or whether compassion and emotional responses are hardwired into human nature. Dr. Laura reads and responds to a thought-provoking listener letter that explores these dilemmas through the lens of a personal experience involving a rat infestation. The discussion moves into deeper philosophical and psychological territory, covering the interplay between rationality and empathy, the evolutionary importance of compassion, and how empathy sometimes overrides pragmatic decisions.

---

Key Discussion Points & Insights

The Listener’s Letter: Rationality vs Compassion

[03:00 - 08:00]

• The Catalyst:
  • The listener describes a rat infestation plaguing their home and their initial reaction:
    • “My response, Dr. Laura, was pragmatic, perhaps even ruthlessly so, the application of chemical agents ... The goal was simple eradication.” (03:40)
• A Shift in Perspective:
  • One night, faced with a sickly, unmoving rodent, the listener feels a moment of deep empathy and remorse:
    • “He wasn’t skittish ... he seemed at that moment not merely a pest, but something profoundly vulnerable. And in that split second ... a most peculiar and utterly unexpected reaction occurred.” (04:30)
• Self-Examination:
  • The letter-writer questions their own response:
    • “If man is, as some contend, a purely rational maximizer of utility, why did my brain override the simple economic solution?”
    • “It is the capacity to feel pity for such a creature that is ... an anomaly.” (05:30-06:00)
  • References Thomas Sowell and explores whether empathy is innate or learned.

Dr. Laura’s Reflections

[09:04 - 10:45]

• Human Nature: Practical and Emotional
  • Dr. Laura challenges the notion that humans are primarily rational utility maximizers or “robotic,” asserting:
    • “Some people overdo the compassion. Some people clearly underdo the compassion. But that we’re capable of pragmatic utility and compassion is the human condition anyway, the capacity.” (09:10)
• Political and Philosophical Overtones
  • She notes that the idea of pure utilitarianism aligns more with collectivist ideologies:
    • “I would say that's a communist, socialist way of looking at people.” (09:40)
• Empathy as an Evolutionary Tool
  • Dr. Laura disagrees with the idea that empathy is a “costly, inefficient piece of psychological hardware”:
    • “Having compassion is a very useful way of assessing whether utilitarianism is the best solution in a particular situation. Sometimes compassion has to be put aside, like in self defense.” (09:55)
• Innate Emotional Code
  • She agrees that empathy is “preloaded,” a genetic and historical inheritance that can override logic:
    • “We carry within us a genetic memory of feeling, a historical inheritance that can, without warning, interrupt the most carefully constructed logic of self interest.” (10:22)

Key Takeaways

• Humans are not strictly rational; emotional responses shape real-life decisions, often for the better.
• Empathy is not a “flaw” but an adaptive trait that informs and sometimes appropriately tempers pure self-interest.
• Dr. Laura encourages listeners to recognize both utilitarian logic and sentimental compassion as intrinsic—and often necessary—parts of decision making.

---

Notable Quotes & Memorable Moments

• Listener:
  • “The years of accumulated frustration, the sleep deprivation and the cold rational decision to poison an entire population vanished. In its place was a sharp, undeniable surge of remorse.” (04:50)
  • “Whence comes this inherited empathy? If man is, as some contend, a purely rational maximizer of utility, why did my brain override the simple economic solution?” (05:35)
• Dr. Laura:
  • “If anybody suggests that’s true, that’s stupid. It’s not. Looking at the truth and reality, some people overdo the compassion. Some people clearly underdo the compassion. But that we’re capable of pragmatic utility and compassion is the human condition anyway.” (09:07)
  • “Having compassion is a very useful way of assessing whether utilitarianism is the best solution in a particular situation.” (09:58)
  • “We carry within us a genetic memory of feeling, a historical inheritance that can, without warning, interrupt the most carefully constructed logic of self-interest.” (10:22)

---

Timestamps for Key Segments

• 03:00 – Listener’s Rat Infestation Story Begins
• 04:30 – Pivotal Moment of Empathy Toward the Rat
• 05:30 – Philosophical Questions on Human Nature and Utility
• 09:04 – Dr. Laura’s Direct Response: Humans as Both Practical and Emotional
• 09:55 – Empathy as Evolution’s Solution, Not a Flaw
• 10:22 – Genetic Memory and Empathy in Human Nature
• 10:50 – Closing Reflections and Dr. Laura Invites Listener Feedback

---

Episode Flow & Tone

The episode maintains Dr. Laura’s signature style—blunt, insightful, and somewhat playful. There is a balance of humor, critique, and philosophical inquiry, making the discussion accessible and relatable for listeners grappling with the intersection of reason and feeling in their own lives.

---

For listeners:
This episode offers a nuanced look at empathy and serves as a reminder that sometimes even our smallest moments of compassion can teach us about the deeper wiring of humanity. Dr. Laura not only answers the listener’s question but prompts you to consider how empathy plays a vital role in the choices you make every day.

Transcript

[A]

When you think Dr. Laura a web based store is not what comes to mind. But I have one and my Dr. Laura store, filled with fun, thought provoking merch is powered by Shopify. Shopify is the commerce platform behind millions of businesses, from household names like Mattel and Magic Spoon to brands that are just getting started. Shopify can help you build a beautiful online store to match your brand style. Their AI tools can assist you with product descriptions and page headlines. And of course, Shopify has world class expertise in everything from managing inventory to international shipping to processing returns and beyond. If you're ready to sell, you're ready for Shopify. Turn your big business idea into With Shopify on your side, sign up for your $1 per month trial and start selling today at shopify.com DRLaura go to shopify.com DrLora shopify.com DRLaura the who's down.

[B]

And who Newville were making their list, but some didn't know Walmart has the best brands for their gifts. What about toys?

[A]

Do they have brands kids have been wanting all year?

[B]

Yep, Barbie, Tonys and Lego.

[C]

Gifts that will make them all cheer.

[A]

Do you mean they have all the brands I adore?

[B]

They have Nintendo, Nespresso, Apple and more. What about so the who answered questions from friends till they were blue? Each one listened and shouted Friends from Walmart? Who knew Shop Kiss from top brands for everyone on your list in the Walmart app.

[A]

Thank you for listening to my morning monologue brought to you by Vibrance Super C Serum, the skincare product I use twice a day. Visit vibriance.com drlaura to save 37% and get free shipping. Remember, you can hear my radio program daily on Sirius XM Triumph and connect with me 24 [e-mail] this is interesting. It was on empathy. I got this the other day and I've been holding it and I'd like to read it to you now and frankly, any opinion you have, thoughts or feelings about it, call me. But first hear it out. I write to you from a position of intellectual curiosity through the immediate catalyst. Though the immediate catalyst for this correspondence is a rather decidedly less lofty a rat infestation. For several weeks now, my humble dwelling has been, to put it mildly, an acoustic nightmare courtesy of a nocturnal scuttling horde. Their incessant scratching, and I can only assume, general rodent revelry have made a proper night's sleep an increasingly scarce commodity. Yes, dramatic writing. Love it. Though my response, Dr. Laura was pragmatic, perhaps even Ruthlessly so, the application of chemical agents for days. The goal was simple eradication. I saw them not as creatures, but as a problem, a negative externality imposed upon my peace and quiet. The objective was the termination of the disruption. And the method, I confess, was unburdened by sentimentality. This, one might argue, is the rational calculus of self interest. The cost of a few vermin is rightly exchanged for the benefit of human repose. Yet this past evening, the tidy lodger of my calculated self interest was thoroughly smudged. I found one of these tormentors, a sickly small creature, perhaps half grown, sitting quite literally in the middle of my living room floor. He wasn't skittish. There was none of the usual frantic dash for the shadows. He sat there brazenly, as if in a state of terminal resignation. Well then he wasn't sitting there brazenly. It's one or the other. Just saying. I walked toward him, my foot raised to end the matter, a simple final solution to a weeks long ordeal. But he didn't move. He seemed at that moment not merely a pest, but something profoundly vulnerable. And in that split second pause before the descent of my heel, a most peculiar and utterly unexpected reaction occurred. The years of accumulated frustration, the sleep deprivation and the cold rational decision to poison an entire population vanished. In its place was a sharp, undeniable surge of remorse. Not just for this small doomed creature, but for the countless others that had suffered in the dark and for the sheer brutality of my calculated campaign. I felt sorry for the rat. Dr. Laura, this is where the Thomas Sowellian question, if you would permit the invocation of that great mind, arises. Whence comes this inherited empathy? If man is, as some contend, a purely rational maximizer of utility, why did my brain override the simple economic solution? I'm going to read that sentence again because I think this is where it goes amiss. If man is, as some contend, a purely rational maximizer of utility, that's not the case or there wouldn't be compassion.

[C]

My uncontrollable movements called TD tardive dyskinesia felt embarrassing. I felt like disconnecting. I asked my doctor about treating my TD and learned about in a prescription medicine clinically proven for reducing TD in adults. That's always one capsule once daily and number one prescribed people taking in can stay on most mental health meds in.

[D]

Can cause depression, suicidal thoughts or actions in patients with Huntington's disease. Call your doctor if you become depressed, have sudden behavior or mood changes, or suicidal thoughts. Don't take in if allergic Serious side effects may include allergic reactions like sudden, potentially fatal swelling in hives as sleepiness, the most common side effect, and heart rhythm problems. Know how in Greza affects you. Before operating a car or dangerous machinery, report fever, stiff muscles or problems, thinking as these might be life threatening. Shaking, stiffness, drooling and trouble with moving or balance may occur.

[C]

Take control by asking your doctor about Ingrezza.

[D]

Learn [e-mail] that's I n g r.

[C]

E z z a.infunny movie night just got easier with Fandango. Reserve seats in advance, skip the lines and even cancel if plans change. Plus with Fandango's fan club Save on every trip to the movies. Want to stay in with Fandango at home? You can stream your family favorites right from the couch. Whether it's a weekend outing or a cozy night in Fandango makes movie magic simple for the whole family. Download the Fandango and Fandango at Home app today. Holidays feeling hectic? Pillsbury is here to lend a hand. Roll out some magic with cookies, crescents, crusts and more fresh from the oven. Tis the season for big smiles and easy wins with Pillsbury.

[B]

Tis the season of gifting and hauls to deck and the who's in Whoville were in love with new tech. Where can we find Sonos and Samsung and Nintendo? They shouted. Could they find it in one place? This they questioned and doubted when suddenly a who yelled, walmart's the place to start. And D2 added headphones, TVs and games to their carts. With Walmart, their shopping was done in a flurry. They cried out, who knew? And ordered their gifts in a hurry. Shop the latest tech gifts in the Walmart app.

[E]

It's never too early for Lowe's Black Friday deals. Snag some of our biggest savings of the season right now, like 25% off select pre lit artificial Christmas trees and man, get yourself free. Select dewalt Cobalt or Craftsman tools when you buy a select battery or combo kit before the Black Friday rush. Because everyone loves free stuff, right? Lowe's we help you save valid through 123 while supplies last selection varies by location.

[A]

So if anybody suggests that's true, that's stupid. It's not. Looking at the truth and reality, Some people overdo the compassion. Some people clearly underdo the compassion. But that we're capable of pragmatic utility and compassion is the human condition anyway, the capacity. Okay, wait a minute. Why did my brain override the simple economic solution? No rat. More sleep with an emotional cost. The rat is a non contributor to society. It is a vector of disease and a destroyer of property. From a purely instrumental viewpoint, its suffering is not a ledger entry. And yet it is the capacity to feel pity for such a creature that is by definition one's enemy is an anomaly. It's not an anomaly. You see, I really loved this until he got into that notion that we're robotic, that we're only utilitarian. I would say that's a communist socialist way of looking at people. I would grant you that. But in reality, human beings, practical and emotional. That's just a fact. It's not a theory. It is a costly, insufficient piece of psychological hardware. Inefficient piece of psychological hardware. I disagree with that. Having compassion is a very useful way of assessing whether utilitarianism is the best solution in a particular situation. Sometimes compassion has to be put aside, like in self defense. Mm, got me. Okay. This kind of sudden profound remorse suggests that human nature is not a blank slate, but is preloaded with an emotional code. That's true. That is often anti rational in the narrow economic sense. It suggests that the inheritance of our species includes a deep, perhaps burdensome capacity for shared suffering. I was taught a lesson by that doomed rat in the center of my room. The lesson was that sentiment is often more durable than strategy. I don't know about that either. We carry within us a genetic memory of feeling, a historical inheritance that can, without warning, interrupt the most carefully constructed logic of self interest. That's true. The rat died, of course. But the question remains, why didn't I suddenly feel like a poor man after the cost of the transaction was simply the removal of a pest. I look forward to your thoughts, Doctor, because you're a decent human being. That's $250. That's my fee for answering that. My number one, 800-375-2872. If you like this podcast, be sure to rate it on Apple podcasts or your favorite place to listen to my podcast of I'd love if you gave me five stars. And be sure to share this podcast with a friend on Facebook or your preferred social media platform.

[B]

Tis the season of gifting and holes to Deck and the who's in Whoville were in love with new tech. Where can we find Sonos and Samsung and Nintendo? They shouted. Would they find it in one place? This they questioned and doubted we when suddenly a who yelled Walmart's the place to start. And each who added headphones, TVs and games to their carts. With Walmart, their shopping was done in a flurry, they cried out, who knew? And ordered their gifts in a hurry shop. The latest tech gifts in the Walmart app.