Drop Dead Serious With Ashleigh Banfield Episode: Amazon’s Idaho Doc Drops Chilling New Bombshells | One Night in Idaho Release Date: July 15, 2025

Introduction to the Episode

In this gripping episode of Drop Dead Serious, host Ashleigh Banfield delves deep into the unsettling revelations presented in Amazon Prime’s new docuseries, One Night in Idaho. This series offers an intimate and raw exploration of the quadruple murder that shook Moscow, Idaho, on November 13, 2022. Banfield promises a comprehensive walkthrough of the fresh insights, unseen moments, and heartfelt accounts that the docuseries unveils, aiming to fill the most significant gaps in this haunting case.

Overview of the "One Night in Idaho" Docuseries

Ashleigh Banfield sets the stage by introducing the essence of the docuseries. She emphasizes that the series goes beyond merely recapping the murders, instead providing a profound look into the immediate aftermath and the emotional turmoil experienced by those left behind.

Ashleigh Banfield [00:49]: "This is not just a recap of the murders. This is a story about what happened right after, right after the murders happened."

The Morning of the Murders

The episode recounts the events leading up to the murders, focusing on the experiences of Hunter Johnson, Emily Allant, and Josie Lotteran—friends who arrived at the crime scene shortly after the tragic event.

• Dylan Mortensen’s Call:

  • Hunter Johnson [insert timestamp]: Describes the chilling moment when Dylan called, expressing fear and confusion about unusual occurrences in the house.

• Arrival at 1122 King Road:

  • Hunter Johnson [insert timestamp]: "It was so unreal that someone I had spent almost every minute of my life with... his voice cracked"

• Immediate Response:

  • Hunter [05:28]: "Get out. Get out. Get out."
  • Emily Allant [insert timestamp]: "Hunter saved all of us extreme trauma by not letting us know anything."

Impact on the Victims' Families and Friends

The personal toll on the victims' families is poignantly highlighted, illustrating the profound grief and confusion they faced.

• Stacy Chapin’s Experience:

  • Stacy Chapin [09:09]: "I was at the grocery store... Hunter just said, 'Ethan's not here.'"
  • Stacy [11:40]: "He's like, 'No, he's not on this earth anymore,' I believe, is what he said to me."

• Jim Chapin on Processing the Loss:

  • Jim Chapin [12:07]: Recounts the difficulty in deciding how to handle Ethan's remains, ultimately choosing to keep him at home to ensure he would never be alone.

The Digital Aftermath: Internet Theories and Accusations

In the wake of the tragedy, the internet became a crucible for rumors, unfounded accusations, and a digital mob targeting innocent individuals.

• Online Vigilantism:

  • Daniel Barakoa: "I was once again fearing for my life, but for a completely different reason."

• Social Media Speculation:

  • Users speculated wildly, accusing fraternity brothers, friends, and even the victims' boyfriends without evidence, exacerbating the trauma for the families.

• Hunter Johnson's Struggle:

  • Hunter [insert timestamp]: "I lost my best friend, and people think I killed him."

Identification and Background of the Killer, Brian Coburger

The docuseries shifts focus to Brian Coburger, the real perpetrator, uncovering his background and the chilling signs that preceded the murders.

• Academic Prowess and Obsessive Nature:

  • Josh Ferraro: "He was obsessed with control and with planning and with precision and with perfection."

• Unusual Behavior:

  • Desales University Students: Recount Coburger’s inability to behave normally and his exceptional yet unsettling skills in forensic psychology exercises.

• The Papa Roger Theory:

  • An enigmatic online commenter, Papa Roger, hinted at crucial details long before they were publicly known, pointing towards Coburger’s involvement.

Papa Roger’s Post [November 30]: Suggested the killer left the knife sheath, a detail only the perpetrator and law enforcement knew.

The Arrest and Legal Proceedings

Six weeks after the murders, Brian Coburger was arrested, bringing a glimmer of closure amidst the chaos. The episode details the legal journey leading to his sentencing.

• Trial Preparations:

  • With sentencing set for July 23, the families have chosen not to attend, seeking solace away from the public eye.

• Stacy Chapin’s Plea:

  • Stacy: "Nothing's going to bring Ethan back. Nothing is going to change anything for my family."

Emotional and Personal Impact on the Families

The profound grief and the arduous path to healing for the victims' families are poignantly portrayed.

• Karen Laramie’s Resilience:

  • Karen [14:19]: "This can't be true... This is ridiculous. This is unbelievable."

• Hunter and Emily's Changed Lives:

  • Hunter [insert timestamp]: "I just want it to go away so I don't have to look at it anymore."
  • Emily Allant: "I had a vision of what I wanted my life to look like, and I've given up some of my goals."

Conclusion

Ashleigh Banfield wraps up the episode with a heartfelt plea to listeners, urging empathy and support for the grieving families navigating their unimaginable loss. She emphasizes the importance of granting them the space to heal without external pressures or judgments.

Ashleigh Banfield [Final Remarks]: "Remember this. The truth is not just serious, it's drop dead serious."

This episode serves as a powerful testament to the enduring impact of true crime on communities and individuals, highlighting the necessity for compassion and understanding in the aftermath of tragedy.

Key Quotes:

• Hunter Johnson [05:28]: "Get out. Get out. Get out."
• Stacy Chapin [09:09]: "I just knew. It was weird."
• Hunter Johnson [08:30]: "It was so unreal that someone I had spent almost every minute of my life with."
• Josh Ferraro: "He was obsessed with control and with planning and with precision and with perfection."
• Ashleigh Banfield [Final Remarks]: "The truth is not just serious, it's drop dead serious."

This comprehensive summary encapsulates the critical discussions, emotional narratives, and investigative breakthroughs presented in the episode, providing a thorough understanding for those who haven't listened to Drop Dead Serious With Ashleigh Banfield.