Podcast Summary:

Drop Dead Serious With Ashleigh Banfield
Episode: Mom Arrested After She Gave Birth to Her Daughter’s 14-Year-Old Boyfriend’s Baby?
Date: November 7, 2025
Host: Ashleigh Banfield
Primary Guest: Abby Escobar (“Abby Blabby”)

Overview

This gripping episode of "Drop Dead Serious" delves into an unbelievable true crime case from Washington, Illinois: 43-year-old Robin Polston, a mother and hairdresser, has been arrested after giving birth to a baby whose father is her 14-year-old daughter's ex-boyfriend. As Ashleigh Banfield guides listeners through the unfolding and disturbing details, she brings on podcaster Abby Escobar for further investigation. The episode highlights small-town shock, deception, and a mountain of evidence, raising profound questions about guardianship, predatory relationships, and community reaction.

Key Discussion Points and Timeline

1. Case Introduction & Shocking Allegations (01:05–07:00)

• Robin Polston, 43, arrested for giving birth to a baby whose biological father is a 14-year-old boy.
• The boy was dating Robin’s daughter; the relationship began around the daughter’s 8th grade dance.
• Ashleigh Banfield’s tone: Irreverent, shocked, and outraged.
• Notable Quote:

  “Pour a stiff one for this because the evidence against Robin Polston is piling up.” — Ashleigh Banfield (01:32)

• Police allege that Robin began a secret, illegal relationship with the boy while chaperoning the dance.
• Even as the boy moved with his family—from Illinois to Nevada, then to St. Louis—Robin maintained contact.
• Central Evidence: Maternity photoshoots, baby’s naming details, and sexually explicit material were key for investigators.

2. Discovery and Evidence Mounting (07:00–10:31)

• The boy made repeated trips “to visit a friend” in Illinois, later revealed to be Robin.
• Robin fabricated stories for her family and community about the baby's paternity—claiming the father was an adult military man, “Brian.”
• Investigators zero in on timeline: Her baby was born in January 2025, exactly nine months after one of the boy’s visits.
• Notable Quote:

  “She gave her newborn baby the same middle name and the same last name as her teenage boyfriend.” — Ashleigh Banfield (06:59)

• DNA test conclusively identifies the 14-year-old as the father.
• Robin charged with criminal sexual assault and child pornography.
• Police discover explicit images and videos shot by Robin featuring the boy.

3. Interview: Abby Escobar (“Abby Blabby”) Joins (10:31–20:32)

a. Timeline, Family Dynamics, and Custody (10:31–13:56)

• The boy’s mother had passed away; he lived variously with his father, stepmother, then grandparents.
• Behavioral issues emerged after visits to Robin—he wanted to return to Illinois.
• July 2024: Boy moved in with Robin under the pretense of being “friends with her teenage son.”
• Notable Quote:

  “...after he came back to Illinois to visit that friend, he started having behavior issues. All he wanted to do was get back to Illinois.” — Abby Escobar (11:20)

• Multiple moves enabled Robin to maintain access, as both parents and grandparents allowed visits under misleading circumstances.

b. Concealment, Maternity Photos, and Community Suspicion (13:56–17:57)

• Robin told clients and friends the baby’s father was a military man from St. Louis.
• Her maternity photoshoot included the 14-year-old boy; she claimed to the photographer he was 25 but “just has a baby face.”
• Notable Quote:

  “Who does that? And it almost looks like she has an engagement ring on her finger...I literally cannot believe my eyes.” — Ashleigh Banfield (15:52)

• The baby was publicly baptized with the same middle and last names as the boy.
• Robin left the father line blank on the birth certificate—yet named the baby after her underage partner.

c. Hospital Staff and Family Reactions (16:27–20:09)

• The boy was present for prenatal care and birth, participating in baby routines at the hospital.
• Hospital staff reportedly noticed the boy looked young but did not intervene.
• Robin's sister-in-law became suspicious, compared stories, found the boy’s yearbook photo, and contacted police.
• The family, now aware, expressed public shock—children reportedly “disowned” Robin, and the daughter left angry comments on social media in her defense.
• Notable Quote:

  “...the kids have been extremely disappointed with her and basically disowned her because I believe she was the one who called the police.” — Abby Escobar (18:39)

4. Reflection and Legal Outlook (20:32–End)

• Ashleigh reacts viscerally to the explicit details and poor attempts at concealment.
• She questions whether Robin is “so incredibly stupid that she doesn’t know she’s broken the law” based on the poorly constructed coverups.
• Discussion turns to the failures in the boy’s guardianship—how both parents and grandparents missed red flags.
• Comparison to notorious cases such as Mary Kay Letourneau, with Ashleigh predicting additional charges and a fierce community backlash.
• Notable Quote:

  “If you handed me the DNA test and you handed me the maternity pictures, I'd be like, life, life. No parole.” — Ashleigh Banfield (20:33)

• Concludes with anticipation for the next court hearing on December 4 and a promise to follow up on the case.

Memorable Quotes & Moments with Timestamps

• On the surreal crime:

  “Holy hell, you are not going to believe this one.” — Ashleigh Banfield (01:05)

• On Robin’s alleged carelessness:

  “Who books a maternity shoot to show off your baby bump and your 14 year old boyfriend who's got his hands on your tummy?” — Ashleigh Banfield (02:08)

• Community’s disbelief:

  "When you first launched that TikTok, I fell over and then texted you. I didn't think it was real." — Ashleigh (10:31)

• On the evidence:

  “So, natch. The police ordered up a DNA test which connected the illegal dots once and for all.” — Ashleigh Banfield (07:58)

• On the damning maternity photo:

  “That picture right there will be a nail in her coffin if the DNA report isn’t already.” — Ashleigh Banfield (15:55)

• On family unraveling the truth:

  “Her [estranged] husband’s sister is the one who...pieced it all together...and she has said that the kids have been extremely disappointed with her and basically disowned her...” — Abby Escobar (18:39)

• On public exposure:

  “In August she had the baby baptized and had the baby with his name posted in the church bulletin. I have a copy of it.” — Abby Escobar (17:58)

Important Segment Timestamps

• [01:05] – Ashleigh introduces the case, outlines the gist and shock value.
• [06:59] – The connection between the baby’s name and the underage father is revealed.
• [07:58] – DNA results and discovery of explicit evidence described.
• [10:31] – Start of conversation with Abby Escobar; timeline begins.
• [15:13] – The maternity photos and community reactions described.
• [17:57] – Naming details, birth certificate, and social media exposure.
• [18:39] – Family response and estrangement.
• [20:09] – Wrap-up and prep for upcoming court hearing.

Tone and Style

• Ashleigh Banfield’s tone is a blend of journalistic rigor, exasperated humor, and blunt outrage: “Pour a stiff one for this.”
• Abby Escobar delivers methodical research with a touch of social media savvy, providing inside details and first-hand reactions.

Summary

This episode lays out an incomprehensible and disturbing case of predatory abuse: a mother’s illegal relationship with her teenage daughter’s boyfriend, the web of lies that delayed discovery, and the role of both family and digital sleuths in exposing the truth. The hosts connect listeners with both facts and emotion, painting a chilling portrait of a community shaken by betrayal and criminality. The story is poised to develop further, with a pivotal court hearing scheduled for December 4.

Key Takeaway:
A staggering true crime story with layers of deception, failed guardianship, and community shock—delivered with sharp analysis, memorable quotes, and a promise for continued coverage.

Next Update:
Court hearing scheduled for December 4, 2025; podcast promises to revisit the case as new developments unfold.